Join Lauren Johnson Matthias (Hidden True Crime), Megan Conner (Lori Vallow’s cousin), Mindy Caldwell, and John Dehlin as they dive deep into Shari Franke’s explosive new book, The House of My Mother: A Daughter’s Quest for Freedom. As the eldest daughter of Ruby Franke—the controversial mother behind 8 Passengers—Shari Franke offers a raw and unfiltered look at her family’s dark reality, her mother’s relationship with Jodi Hildebrandt, and the complex role of the Mormon Church in shaping her upbringing.
In this gripping discussion, we unpack shocking revelations from Shari Franke’s memoir, including Ruby’s history of emotional and physical abuse, the influence of Jodi Hildebrandt’s extreme ideology, and Kevin Franke’s role—or lack thereof—in protecting his children. We explore how religious teachings on obedience, gender roles, and authority primed Ruby for manipulation and enabled a culture of control. Was Ruby always abusive, or did Jodi push her over the edge? How much responsibility does Kevin bear?
Our panelists share their own experiences with faith, parenting, and the impact of Mormonism’s rigid expectations. Megan Conner opens up about seeing herself in Ruby’s strict, fear-based parenting, while Mindy Caldwell brings her extensive research to the table, questioning the church’s silence on abusive figures like Jodi. We also examine the psychological toll on Shari Franke, from religious scrupulosity to her coerced separation from mental health care.
The conversation takes a deep dive into 8 Passengers, family vlogging culture, and the ethical concerns of monetizing children’s private lives. Shari Franke’s painful experiences—being denied therapy, forced to endure religious discipline, and ultimately severed from her family—mirror larger patterns of coercive control within Mormonism. We also discuss her shocking account of sexual assault, her struggle to break free, and her courageous decision to share her truth.
With connections to Visions of Glory, the Daybell/Vallow case, and the systemic failures within the LDS Church, this discussion highlights the broader implications of Shari Franke’s story. How did figures like Jodi Hildebrandt gain unchecked power? What does this say about institutional accountability?
Join us for this eye-opening conversation as we seek to understand the forces that shaped Shari Franke’s harrowing journey and celebrate her resilience in reclaiming her voice.
Episode Transcript
Full text · 52,400 words · 23 chaptersHost: John Dehlin · Guests: Lauren Johnson Matthias, Megan Conner, Mindy CaldwellRead transcriptHide transcript
This transcript is machine-generated and lightly edited for readability. The audio is authoritative. Please excuse occasional errors in names and spelling.
Welcome and Guest Introductions
John Dehlin [00:00:01] Hello, everyone, and welcome to another edition of Mormon Stories podcast. I'm your host, John Dehlin. It is January 10, 2025. Happy New Year. I am over the moon, excited, thrilled to have the band back together. We're getting the band back together. We have Lauren Johnson, Matthias. Did I get the order right of your name?
Lauren Johnson Matthias [00:00:22] You did. You got it right.
John Dehlin [00:00:23] Lauren Johnson, Matthias. From Hidden True Crime, we've got Megan Connor. Hey, Megan.
Megan Conner [00:00:28] Hi.
John Dehlin [00:00:28] From third verse Midlife. What? Resolution. Midlife Revolution. And we've got Binder Mom. Dear friend, Mindy Caldwell.
Mindy Caldwell [00:00:38] Hi, everybody.
John Dehlin [00:00:39] And today we are going to be covering the brand spanking new book that just hit the bookshelves, the House of My Mother, A Daughter's Quest for Freedom, Sheri Franke. And of course, Sheri Franke is the daughter of Ruby and Kevin Franke. And this is an amazing, powerful book. I'm just going to start off at the top high recommend. Everyone needs to go buy this book right now. I went in a little bit skeptic, wondering whether it was going to be a good book. Lauren, do you agree?
Lauren Johnson Matthias [00:01:20] I agree. I agree. I didn't know either. I went in with a very open mind and I couldn't put it down, which is, I think why we're all able to do this today. Because it just came out like two days ago and we have all read
Megan Conner [00:01:30] it cover to cover.
John Dehlin [00:01:31] I think. Megan, I think you bought your airfare like yesterday, right?
Megan Conner [00:01:33] I literally bought my airfare yesterday morning.
Mindy Caldwell [00:01:36] Yes.
John Dehlin [00:01:36] And flew here. Yeah. And then, Mindy, is this thumbs up for you?
Mindy Caldwell [00:01:41] Oh, absolutely. Flew through it. I was like you. I was. I wasn't quite sure what to expect. But I'm very, very proud of Sherry for writing this book. I think it's important for her to take her power back and write the story and. Highly recommended.
John Dehlin [00:01:54] Yeah, absolutely. So go buy this book. That's the first thing we want to say. Thank you, Sheri Franke, for writing such a great book. And it's not just Sherry. Let me just give a couple disclaimers right off the top because I think it's good. First of all, trigger warning. Right, Mindy, that was your idea.
Mindy Caldwell [00:02:13] Yeah, yeah. Megan list.
John Dehlin [00:02:15] Do you want to say why or anything about that?
Mindy Caldwell [00:02:17] I mean, I think if anyone's familiar with the Frankie case, there's, there's talk of abuse and, and neglect and. Yeah. And then there's, there's other parts of the book that I think we weren't aware of before this book came out that there's a trigger warning for. For most of the topics in the book. I believe so.
John Dehlin [00:02:34] Yeah.
Mindy Caldwell [00:02:35] Yeah.
John Dehlin [00:02:35] There's a major storyline.
Mindy Caldwell [00:02:38] Yeah.
John Dehlin [00:02:39] That none of us I think anticipated.
Megan Conner [00:02:41] No.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [00:02:41] Sherry shares a story of hers. Sherry shares a personal story of hers that none of us were aware of until this book came out. And I think people need to be aware of coercive control and sexual assault and grooming of. And grooming of.
John Dehlin [00:02:56] Under of minors. I think.
Megan Conner [00:02:58] Yes.
John Dehlin [00:02:59] In sexual ways.
Megan Conner [00:03:00] A vulnerable person at the very least.
John Dehlin [00:03:03] Yeah. So a couple just disclaimers that a spoiler alerts. We're going to be talking about this book in depth. So if you don't want any spoilers, go, go buy the book, go read the book and then come back over and check us out.
John Dehlin [00:03:17] Margi wrote a couple extra notes. We want to honor Sherry for. For writing this memoir. It was co written by Caroline Writer, so I can tell it's just so well written. I couldn't write a book like this alone. So anyway, Carolyn Ryder, a credit to her.
John Dehlin [00:03:37] Yeah. And we're gonna just be digging in, kind of going chronologically. Let me just take a minute to welcome all of you who are joining us on the live stream. Thank you so much for joining us. And I'm gonna ask Julia and Maven if she ends up joining us to it if possible, when possible to.
John Dehlin [00:03:57] To star any questions or comments. If you guys happen to share your questions or comments as super chats, I can promise you we'll make sure and include them. That's just a way you ask a question. With a little bit of a monetary donation on YouTube. We want to thank all of our donors on Mormon stories that make this episode possible. Of course.
John Dehlin [00:04:20] And yeah, we look forward to the interaction with our live audience. We also welcome our asynchronous audience as well. Those of you who are listening later, not live either audio only or video, please like and subscribe to this episode to this channel that really helps with the algorithms. It helps us stay alive. So Please subscribe on YouTube and Facebook and Instagram and Tick Tock and wherever, but mostly YouTube. So without any further ado, let me reintroduce or have my illustrious co panelists introduce themselves. So Lauren, tell us, remind us how awesome you are.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [00:05:00] I don't know if I'll do that,
John Dehlin [00:05:01] but can I just say your channel is now officially like a hundred thousand subscribers bigger than Mormon stories, which I'm thrilled about.
Mindy Caldwell [00:05:09] True.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [00:05:09] I don't think that's true.
John Dehlin [00:05:10] I think I'm still in the 200, 270, 280.
Mindy Caldwell [00:05:13] I'm.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [00:05:13] No. Then you know you have more, you
John Dehlin [00:05:15] have more subscribers, we're about to say, but we're about the same.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [00:05:17] Yes.
Megan Conner [00:05:18] Yes.
John Dehlin [00:05:18] Tell people how awesome you are or
Lauren Johnson Matthias [00:05:20] I will, I'll skip that question. But I, I'll share who I am. I, I am the host or co host of the Hidden True crime podcast and YouTube channel. We cover, as our channel says, true crime. And we've I'm always grateful to collaborate with Mormon stories as we've covered in depth the Ruby Frankie and Jody Hildebrandt case. We've covered in depth the the Chad Chad Daybell and Lori Valow case and continue to cover that. The band, as you explained, that's back together. We went deep into the book Visions of Glory, which, you know, a little foreshadowing, therefore foreshadowing. Put a pin in that. There's going to be a moment of like we told you so, you know, and we did.
John Dehlin [00:06:09] We told you so.
Megan Conner [00:06:10] We literally did.
John Dehlin [00:06:11] She even mentions Tom Harrison.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [00:06:13] She mentions Tom Harrison. Let's, you know. So I, I know we, I think, should be proud of your work there and all of us should be when it comes to putting something that ties all of these crimes together. And we have delved deep in our podcast as well on Tim Ballard as well as the Shannon Gardner case in several other cases that actually do are part of this sort of lds. I don't know, is there an LDS crime genre now? Yeah, True crime mtc.
John Dehlin [00:06:45] Right. Mindy Mormon true crime.
Mindy Caldwell [00:06:47] You made that up, John. Yeah.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [00:06:49] But this is a case, you know, we care greatly about. Like I said, we've covered in depth. And so I was looking forward so much to reading Sherry Frankie's book and I'm so grateful to just discuss it with with friends today. So, yes, hidden true crime YouTube channel
Panelists Share Their True Crime Backgrounds
John Dehlin [00:07:05] and podcast and some of the big cases you've been covering lately or have covered historically just to give people a flavor.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [00:07:10] Yeah, we cover beyond LDS crimes. We cover, we cover all crimes. We don't just specifically cover those that have an LDS tie in. I just got back from Adelaide, Indiana, where I covered the entire trial of Richard Allen. Many know that Abigail Williams and Libby German, two best friends that were teenagers, were brutally murdered in 2017 and their killer was just convicted. And I spent every day going to that trial. I also covered both the Chad Daybel and Lori Valo trial. I've covered the Alec Baldwin trial. We have several trials we're about to cover this year, including the James Craig trial, who was also that also unfortunately was an an LDS family hit with tragedy.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [00:07:53] But we just, we care about justice, we care about being victim centric on our podcast, and we care about understanding. We always say we're not a. We're not a whodunit channel. We're a why done it channel. That's what we're interested in. And my husband is a clinical and forensic psychologist, and so we delve deep into the whys behind the crime and criminals.
John Dehlin [00:08:13] Love it. All right, well. And you have a TV journalist background, right?
Lauren Johnson Matthias [00:08:20] I was a TV reporter for 10
John Dehlin [00:08:22] years and then in like, Idaho and Utah. Right?
Lauren Johnson Matthias [00:08:25] Idaho. All over Idaho and Utah. Yes. Yeah. And couldn't put it away, obviously. I quit to stay home and then here I am.
John Dehlin [00:08:33] What's more fun, TV journalism or doing a cool YouTube channel?
Lauren Johnson Matthias [00:08:37] Definitely this, because I get to choose what cases we cover every day and I get to delve deep into them. When you're, when you're a TV journalist, every day you're on a different case. And when you care about something and there's other, you know, local crime you have to cover, you have to put that one aside. And so to be able to finally dig deep and be a real investigative journalist and then say, this is what I care about. This is what I need to focus on, it's been a bit of. I'm very grateful for that.
John Dehlin [00:09:05] Yeah. Well, so thrilled to have you. So thanks for coming, Lauren, and shout out to if there are any hidden true cran. To hidden true crime viewers or fans out there. Welcome to our channel. Thanks for. Thanks for joining us. Megan, you're next. Megan Connor, tell us about you again. Remind us about your awesomeness.
Megan Conner [00:09:22] Oh, I just like hanging out with you guys.
John Dehlin [00:09:25] Friends of Lauren, basically.
Megan Conner [00:09:27] Yeah. Just doing book reviews and, you know, changing the world. No, I've got a podcast as well. My podcast is called the Midlife Revolution. It just launched this past April. April of 2024. So I mainly talk about making small changes that end up becoming revolutionary. And most of it is about healing and about being kinder to yourself, loving yourself better, and just starting to question things that, you know, maybe I shouldn't do things this way. Maybe I should do them a different way. So it's all about investigating new ideas and new things, and I'm having a lot of fun with that. But I'm also covering, unfortunately, the case of my crazy cousin, Lori Val.
Megan Conner [00:10:10] She's about to go on trial at the end of March, and she's been having some hearings and motions. Unfortunately, she's representing herself, which makes. Adds another level of crazy to the whole thing. So I've been covering that. And I will also be at the trial. Lauren and I will have to hang out, but that's, that's what else is going on. And I also just launched an E course that, the first module just launched last Tuesday. It's an eight module course on how to recognize manipulation and control and how to defend against it. And that's one of the things I'm most passionate about. And the reason why I keep talking about Lori and her cases is because I always said that Lori had this veneer that she put on in public, and not everybody could tell that she was not really like that in private.
Megan Conner [00:11:00] And that's not who she really was. She was a master manipulator, and she's still manipulating people. And I think the more people who can learn to identify those tactics and defend against them, the less people are going to be victimized. And I think we just are seeing a rise in people who are exhibiting manipulative behaviors, narcissism, and it's in this book. In this book, too, throughout the entire book. So I think the more aware people can become, the more healthy we can become as a society, the better our relationships will be. So that's what my E course is about. And people who want to take the course can email me@askmeganmail.com Megan with two E's.
John Dehlin [00:11:47] Excellent. All right. And of course, last but not least, we have our dear friend Mindy Caldwell.
Mindy Caldwell [00:11:54] Hey, Mindy. Hi, John.
John Dehlin [00:11:56] Yeah. Tell us about you.
Mindy Caldwell [00:11:58] Oh, I'm happy to be here. I've been on the podcast a few times. I'm grateful to be back with these lovely ladies. I. It's always, I always have mixed, mixed feelings because the topics that we're discussing are usually, you know, around crime and around people who have been hurt or harmed. And so there's mixed feelings about saying that. I'm excited to be here, but I am happy to be with my friends that I've met through following these stories. And I did not follow the Frankie family before the news broke of the children being rescued. And I didn't watch their.
Mindy Caldwell [00:12:38] Their YouTube channel, but of course, I've gone back and, and tried to catch up on some of those things. But I do have an interest in true crime and in particularly ones that have an LDS tie. And this, this story certainly does. So I loved Sher's book. I'm very happy to be here and promoting her book. And it's an important story, so thank you for having me.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [00:13:02] I want to say something about Mindy really quickly. What. What people can't see and that we often joke about. We call her binder Mindy is what people can show them.
John Dehlin [00:13:10] The binder Mindy.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [00:13:10] She has a big binder in her lap right now. We joke about it, but it's actually special brain. Yeah, it's incredible. And of course, clearly, we all read this book very quickly. Again, you can't put it down. We recommend everyone reading it, but not only did we all have to just quickly read it, you know, to understand, she has an entire binder with notes and sent all of us this incredible outline. So she's Mindy's brilliant. And.
Mindy Caldwell [00:13:37] And so we.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [00:13:39] We can't do this without her. I just want to say that, like, so we joke this binder Mindy thing, but it's real, and we are very grateful.
Mindy Caldwell [00:13:46] Thank you, Laura.
Megan Conner [00:13:47] I second it. For sure. We couldn't do it without you.
Mindy Caldwell [00:13:49] Thanks, ladies.
John Dehlin [00:13:50] If Mindy weren't mom and a bunch of young kids, she would have her own YouTube channel more successful than I was.
Mindy Caldwell [00:13:55] My kids aren't that young, but, yeah, I still have a busy, busy house. But, yeah, happy to contribute in this way. And outlining things with my brain helps me to stay organized and to not, hopefully not miss anything important that I think needs to be discussed today. So I'm happy about that.
First Impressions of the Memoir
John Dehlin [00:14:12] All right, well, let's dig in. So many questions that I was going into this book wanting to know. I'll just share a couple, and then y' all can also share any. Any things you were excited to learn about the ones that I had.
John Dehlin [00:14:27] I don't know if y' all ever saw Grapes of Wrath or Red Grapes of Wrath, but there's this point where the farmers are, like, out with their guns, ready to kill because they're being evicted from their land. And there's this moment in the book where one of the farmers has a gun, and he's like, well, who do we shoot? And he wants to shoot, you know, the person that evicted him from the land. But someone explains to him, well, the bankers, you know, and. Okay, how to shoot the bankers. Well, it's not the bankers. It's Congress. Well, let me shoot Congress. Well, it's also the president, you know, who do we shoot?
John Dehlin [00:14:56] Like, is this. Is this pure Jody Hildebrandt? How much is Ruby complicit in this? How much does the Mormon Church play a role? What's. You know, Kevin's. You know, what was going on with Kevin? How complicit is Kevin? Like, where. Where. To what extent do we Distribute sort of causality. That's. That's the main question that always comes up for me. And because this is Mormon stories, I'm always thinking about systems more than individuals. And so I just want to know, is there any way the Mormon Church could improve to make it so stuff like this doesn't happen?
John Dehlin [00:15:35] But also, you know, was Ruby abusive before she ever met Jody? That was a question that Margi had. You know, again, how does Sherry view Kevin's complicity in the abuse and, or the neglect? And to what extent does Sherry hold Kevin responsible?
John Dehlin [00:15:59] What is the nature of Ruby and Jody's relationship? Of course, there's a lot of people who want, wanted and still want to know to what extent was that relationship as, as Sherry says, in such a Mormon way, intimate right, which is Mormon code for sexual. Right.
John Dehlin [00:16:17] And, and then, you know, to what extent are Sherry and Ruby even going to have a relationship in the future? Those are some of the questions that Margi had going into this book. Any other ones you all want to add in terms of anticipatory questions that were really on your mind or did we kind of COVID it?
Megan Conner [00:16:34] I, for me personally, I never watched Eight Passengers and so the first that I heard of this case was when. When the children were found. And so for me, I had a lot of questions about how the channel came to be and how widespread it was and how in depth they really did get. And, you know, how was it for the kids. And so even though I knew that Sherry was the oldest daughter, I didn't really know how much her involvement was. And so for me, the question was more about how the kids were being treated during the Eight Passengers time and what that was like growing up as a YouTube kid.
Megan Conner [00:17:12] And, you know, how did that lend to this whole situation? Because I did know that the channel sort of lost, you know, a lot of its notoriety when Jody came into the picture. So I also wanted to know how that happened and what the dynamics like that were as, as well as a lot of the same questions you had, John.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [00:17:32] I think for me, I was very curious about the belief system. There was clearly a belief system in the back of all of this, right there. There was storage, there was prepping. And as someone that's delved deep into the. Someone that's delved deep into the extreme belief stemming from the LDS faith, the ones that seem to be growing. It's sort of like my hyper focus and something we've covered a lot in all of the crimes and cases we've covered. I think I was really Interested to learn about Jody and Ruby's belief system and what exactly they were believing about demons, about prepping, about the apocalypse. And I think that Sherry did shine light on that as well.
John Dehlin [00:18:15] Absolutely. Yeah. Very good, Mindy. Any final anticipatory things?
Mindy Caldwell [00:18:20] I was just curious to hear just how this story evolved. And to be frank, no pun intended at the outset. And on paper, I probably saw myself a little bit in Ruby. You know, I. I have the kind of classic Mormon upbringing. Married young. I had six children myself. And, you know, my parenting style, I'm, you know, I'm proud that it's. It's not like rubies, and, and. And I learned more about that in the book. But so I, I immediate or initially related to Ruby and the model of her life that she had developed with these children and having them young. And so I was curious to see how it could all go so bad and so wrong. And I just was, you know, grateful for Sherry for telling the story of how, you know, problems started right away in her childhood. But, of course, when Jodi comes on the scene, everything escalates.
John Dehlin [00:19:27] Yeah. Well, let's. Should we dive in? Anything else? All right, so let's dive in. So the first section that I have to talk about is just kind of like Ruby and Kevin's, you know, formation of their relationship and kind of the early family life. And we're just going to go through kind of in different periods and just give everyone a chance to share their comments. So let's start with kind of Ruby's, Ruby and Kevin, before they started having kids. Anything surprising or interesting there that y' all want to mention?
Ruby and Kevin's Family of Origin
Lauren Johnson Matthias [00:20:01] I'm always interested in the family of origin. I mean, we are on hidden true crime, actually. John is always like, we need to learn about the family of origin. That would probably be actually another thing that was interesting to me. How was Ruby herself raised? At what point did this idea of the strict authoritarian parent model come from? And I think we did learn a little bit more that she also had strict parents herself, that she was raised to be perfect, the oldest daughter of a brood of kids, to be the example, to help raise her siblings, to be the perfect Mormon LDS daughter to.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [00:20:41] And that she wanted more than anything else to be a mother. She wanted to be a mother because that was her. Her role and how she saw herself to emulate. There was one interesting part, actually. I remember I underlined it where Sherry said, and I'm paraphrasing, that her mom essentially wanted more than anything to be a mother, because as she raised as she helped raise her siblings, she maybe couldn't wait for a time to be able to say, this is how I'm going to do it. And now it's my turn to do it. I'm going to have this control. Let me try to find the exact quote, because it's really interesting that the reason she wanted to be a mother is she wanted the ability to have control and say, this is how I'm going to do it.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [00:21:27] I'm going to do it best. Because it is interesting to think of this woman that's now in prison for, you know, abusing her children, wanted children so bad and wanted to be a mother so bad. But clearly it's what she was taught. It's how she was raised, and she wanted that control. And to say, look, I'm going to be the best of the best.
John Dehlin [00:21:46] Yeah.
Mindy Caldwell [00:21:46] Sherry says Ruby's entire self worth was built on exceptionalism. And I don't know if that's the quote that you're referring to, but that's how she describes her mom's goals of not just having the family, but kind of having the perfect family. So.
John Dehlin [00:22:00] And I can't help but. But think about the church when I think about exceptionalism, because obviously the way the Mormon Church rebranded in the 20th century, it was all about families. It was Donny Marie Osmond. It was those, those commercials, those Mormon commercials that was like, family, isn't it about time? And so, and just the traditional gender roles, like stay at home mom, like Mormon moms, that's. That's their main goal in life, is to be great moms. Right. And so. But then also the Mormon Church claims to be the one true church, you know, and so all of that exceptionalism feels kind of Mormonish to me. It's a lot of pressure, but it felt very Mormon, you know?
Megan Conner [00:22:48] Yeah.
John Dehlin [00:22:49] What do y'. All. What did y' all make of. So. So Sherry and Kevin both go to Utah State University. I'm an Aggie, so go Aggies.
Mindy Caldwell [00:22:59] Ruby. Ruby and Kevin.
John Dehlin [00:23:01] Sorry, I bet you said she doing that, so thank you for correcting me. So Ruby and Kevin both go to Utah State University. And there's this. There's this scene where they're courting and they're holding hands under a blanket, and Ruby is holding Kevin's hand, but she's also holding the hand of another boy on the other side. Now, that offends my ego sensitivities, but what is that? Is that a big deal or is that not a big deal?
Megan Conner [00:23:30] You know, I was going to mention the same exact story, because I think. I think it's a big deal. But I can also see how somebody like Ruby growing up, you know, in this sort of Mormon exceptionalism, as we're talking about here, trying to find a husband, when finding a husband is the ultimate goal. And that's what she's focused on more than anything else. She seems like a person who wants to keep her options open, you know, and. And I don't think it's that unusual. Looking back at my own, you know, adolescence, thinking about sort of the dating scene in Mormon culture was very different from the dating scene, I think, outside of Utah, because I listened to my cousins, you know, on my mom's side, who all lived in Utah, talking about, you know, going on dates with multiple people.
Megan Conner [00:24:22] And where I was growing up in Connecticut, that was not a thing that was done. It was like you were dating one person and that one person was who you're going to go out with. You don't go out with somebody on Friday and then somebody else on Tuesday and then someone else the next Friday. You know, that was really seen as kind of playing the field. But I think my cousin, my Mormon cousins, talking about their dating experience, that was absolutely what they did. So, I don't know, maybe you guys can help me understand that better.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [00:24:48] I mean, yeah, I put her age into context to 18. I'm like, you know, it is odd, but to put another perspective. And of course, maybe this isn't Ruby, though, because she definitely has some narcissism that, that Sherry talks about in the book. But I think that being lds, being an LDS woman who dated for many years, it's very hard to learn how to reject men, too, because we are taught to. To please and to make them feel good and to make sure we don't hurt their feelings and so nice. I remember, you know, myself at one point in my life having two guys like me and we were in the same group and they're both and feeling like this anxiety.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [00:25:28] I probably doubt that that's what Sherry was. Or, sorry, I'm going to do it too, John. That Ruby was thinking, but just to give that perspective, that it can be hard to. If it's happening and you don't know how to say no. But it's also. I just. Also thought it was just very byu, right? It was just very. Or they weren't BYU as Utah State, but it was very, I guess, young LDS dating. She was 18, right?
Mindy Caldwell [00:25:54] Yeah. But dating in Utah, kind of going to what you were saying, Megan, about Dating one person. It was, it was highly encouraged in my upbringing in the 80s in Utah to not steady date because then you're going to get in trouble, you know, with the law of chastity. And so it was very encouraged to maybe have dates in between. I had friends, I didn't have this role myself, but I had cousins and friends who couldn't go on a date with the same person until they had seen somebody else in between.
Mindy Caldwell [00:26:26] Just I think to prevent steady date. Steady dating, pre college times. And then I find it so interesting that she goes to Utah State and she is on a mission. And Sherry says in the book that she has a color coded vision board of the requirements that she's looking for in a husband. And very specific height and occupation and car paid off. And handsome. And it was funny because Kevin checks all the boxes.
Mindy Caldwell [00:26:53] But I also thought that the hand holding story was interesting. I think she's keeping her options open and, and he's. Poor Kevin, he's like tenderly talking about how nice it is to feel Ruby's hand as they're holding hands. And then he realizes that she's holding hands with another guy on the other side. It just felt so Mormon and just like so innocent. Like he's 22 and she's 18 and it just feels very innocent. But then they go on to a very quick engagement. Two weeks till engagement and three months to marriage, which probably sounds crazy, you know, to people outside of the church, but if you've been following Mormonism, that's actually not, not super uncommon for a quick engagement in marriage.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [00:27:35] That was pretty crazy to read though.
John Dehlin [00:27:36] I was like, wow, yeah, pretty typical Mormon to be engaged within a few weeks to a month or two and married within three to four months.
Megan Conner [00:27:45] Right. And I think it's. I think it's to prevent law of chastity issues, as they call them, you know, it's to prevent young couples from having sex too soon before they're married. I think a lot of people do that engagement, quick marriage thing because they want to make sure that they get to the temple because that's the ultimate goal, right? And if they have sex before they're married, they can't go to the temple or they have to wait a year before they can go to the temple. And that's embarrassing. It's shameful for families, it's shameful for the couple. And so to avoid all that shame and embarrassment, we just get married really quickly and, and probably a lot of times get into relationships where we don't know our partner well enough because it was such a quick whirlwind kind of
John Dehlin [00:28:26] thing, now that I think about it. Let's turn to 291. This is a quote that I'm sure all of you wanted to read from the book. And normally I wouldn't jump to a quote at the very end of the book, but I think this is a really useful time to bring it up and I think y' all will all know what quote I'm talking about. Let me just set it up though, if you think about it. So if you. So here's a question. Was Ruby in some ways set up at a disadvantage by, by traditional Mormon gender roles? And here's what I mean, she wouldn't have been allowed to date seriously in high school.
John Dehlin [00:29:05] She would have been allowed, let's just say that there is some sexual ambiguity in terms of her sexual orientation. She would have never had a chance to explore that. Right. She would have never even been able to have normal dating practices in high school because in Utah, Mormons are discouraged from dating. So then she's at college. And then as I understand BYU and Utah State and other places to be, it's like this meat market where you're, you're an 18 year old young woman and you're trying to get the hot return missionary guy before some other girl snatches him. So you're. And you've got your checklist that you've been filling out of the perfect Mormon boy and young women's for like six or eight years prior.
John Dehlin [00:29:47] So you've got that checklist locked and loaded. You get there and you're on the hunt to nab your return missionary before someone else nabs it. Because that's the whole reason you're in college. You're not in college to build a career. You're in college to find your boy. Right. And so I could see her not only jumping into a marriage way too fast, which we've already talked about, but just literally wanting to like feeling the pressure to hurry and get married, but also wanting to keep as many options open until you can pull the trigger. Because what if Kevin were to dump her? Then at least she would have some backup.
John Dehlin [00:30:20] So that's my best attempt at a charitable interpretation of a story you've probably already spent too much time on. But how could you all resonate with that at all?
Lauren Johnson Matthias [00:30:29] Or I put more charity on Kevin in this situation that he was maybe, you know, he could have had some more time himself.
John Dehlin [00:30:38] Absolutely.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [00:30:38] Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Megan Conner [00:30:40] I think that's, it's super short For Kevin as well, you know, but he's a returned missionary, and so he's under a lot of pressure to get married right away as well. Because that is literally something that the prophets and apostles have talked about from the pulpit, that once you get home from your mission, you shouldn't be waiting too long before you find a spouse, take her to the temple and, you know, start a family. That's. That's the goal.
John Dehlin [00:31:04] Yeah. Well, Mindy, why don't we. Have you read that quote
Mindy Caldwell [00:31:11] I'm gonna 291?
John Dehlin [00:31:13] Yeah. Well, you do you know the quote I'm talking about?
Mindy Caldwell [00:31:14] Sometimes I find myself.
John Dehlin [00:31:16] Yeah, I think so. Yeah. Yep.
Mindy Caldwell [00:31:19] That. That whole paragraph.
John Dehlin [00:31:20] Yeah.
Mindy Caldwell [00:31:21] Sometimes I find myself tumbling down the rabbit hole of what ifs. What if Ruby hadn't felt like motherhood was the only path to fulfillment? What if she'd been encouraged to explore all facets of herself beyond what her family told her was right for someone born a woman? Maybe if she'd had the chance to pour herself into a high powered career in banking or physics, fields where empathy isn't exactly a priority, she wouldn't have seen her kids as employees and extensions of herself. Or maybe she wouldn't have had kids at all. It's impossible to know.
John Dehlin [00:31:52] Do you all resonate with them?
Mindy Caldwell [00:31:53] Yeah, absolutely.
Megan Conner [00:31:54] Totally. There have been so many times since I left the church that I have wondered about what my life would have looked like if I hadn't been under so much pressure to get married and have kids. And I love, of course, I love all six of my children. I love being a mother. But I also mourn for the things that I couldn't give them because there were so many of them. And I think one of the main things that I look back on as a mom and think my kids were deprived of was one on one time with me. Very rarely did my kids get the chance to tell me how they were really feeling about a situation or have an in depth conversation about something.
Megan Conner [00:32:36] It was like, okay, let's quickly talk about this in the car on the way to practice because I have 16 other things I have to do in the next half hour and I just don't. I look at, you know, large families and I think that's the biggest detriment is that one on one time with the trusted adult in your life is so pivotal and important that, you know, I wish that I would have had maybe somebody older, wiser, talk to me about the, the spacing of my children and the size of my family in that way. In the way of, like, what can you provide for your children if you only have a few, rather than having a ton?
Megan Conner [00:33:12] Because the only messaging I was getting was, when is the next baby coming? It was like, you're going to be a lot more acceptable if you have more kids in Mormonism because you're bringing spirit children into a true and righteous household. And you don't want those spirit children to go somewhere else where they're not going to get to non Mormon, where they're not going to get light and truth.
John Dehlin [00:33:34] All right, Anything else, Lauren?
Lauren Johnson Matthias [00:33:38] I've actually talked to Megan and Mindy both about this because my life as an LDS person actually took a different turn. I mean, I didn't get married and I. I'm a mother to one, but so I've actually. I've actually specifically said this to Mindy, that I, in many ways, imagine my life being like yours, getting married and having like six kids. And so in many ways I wanted your life. And so I think it's just one of those. I think it's also just, I think simply a life question, like the what ifs, you know, what if I had found someone younger? What if, you know, I think that I became a journalist and I did have a career because I was single.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [00:34:13] And I don't, you know. No, I don't know any other way. That's what happened. But I think I did want the LDS fantasy, if I'm going to be honest. I did. And sometimes, actually, I'm going to be honest, sometimes I still mourn it. You know, I didn't. I didn't. I didn't have it. You know, I didn't have the option to have it.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [00:34:33] So I wanted six kids and I cherish my one. So I actually listened to this. But I also think that's just like a simple life question. And I. I did love that part of the book too, because. Thank you for reading it. Because I think that's like the ultimate question about life. What if we had all been taught something different or what if something in life went a different way? Where would we all be now? You know? So I. I think it is an interesting question. And certainly Ruby knew what she want. And I think the entire theme of this book is Ruby knowing what she wants and getting it.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [00:35:06] Um, so she was raised to get married young and to have kids and be the best mom, and she was going to get it no matter what.
John Dehlin [00:35:14] Yeah. Beautiful. Thanks for being vulnerable, all of you. Let's talk about the personality dynamics in the Frankie household and specifically, you Know Ruby's emotional profile as a mom. If it's okay, and y' all jump in with anything you want to talk about. But the next place I was going to go was to page 10, where Sherry describes how much room there was for people's feelings. Megan, do you mind starting at a yes, ironically, and just read for a couple. A couple of those paragraphs?
Ruby's Parenting Philosophy and Early Childhood
Megan Conner [00:35:47] Sure. I. I just want to rewind one paragraph before that and just say. Sherry writes, ruby didn't believe in comforting me when I was a baby. Not in the way most parents do. Why would she? Her family's philosophy had always been that it doesn't hurt a baby to cry things out, you know, and then to skip. Yet, ironically, my earliest memories are of Ruby crying.
Megan Conner [00:36:08] She had tears for every occasion. Joy, sorrow, boredom, it didn't matter. Ruby wept through it all. A woman perpetually at odds with her own equilibrium. Perhaps that's why she wanted so many children. A set of Russian nesting dolls, each one slightly smaller version of the last, to absorb the tsunami of her raging emotions.
Megan Conner [00:36:30] And then the part that I really underlined and that resonated with me was just at the bottom of the next paragraph where she says, even before I could form words or thoughts, I was learning that my pain didn't matter, that my needs were inconvenient.
John Dehlin [00:36:49] Yeah, yeah, yeah. And I think there's a point where she says the only person that was allowed to have feelings was Ruby. In the family.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [00:37:00] Yeah. Yes. She had the feelings. I just think in general, the way I keep explaining it is it was a very authoritarian child rearing. The emotions weren't okay. And she wanted a little army, you know, not only was she the only one to have feelings, I've got to pull this quote up, and I'm jumping ahead. I'm sorry, Mindy, because you have this organized.
Mindy Caldwell [00:37:23] Oh, no.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [00:37:25] And I want to go through that. But this was interesting, too. It says Ruby, too, had her favorite Harry Potter moment, though hers came from Harry Potter and the Half Blood Prince, A scene where Dumbledore, challenged about performing restricted magic within Hogwarts, simply responded, quote, being me has its privileges. End quote. Ruby would quote this line often with a glimmer in her eye. The idea of being above the rules clearly resonated with my mother.
John Dehlin [00:37:52] Is that Dolores Umbridge? Is that the name or. Who's the character?
Lauren Johnson Matthias [00:37:55] Dumbledore.
Megan Conner [00:37:56] No, it's Dumbledore.
John Dehlin [00:37:57] Oh.
Megan Conner [00:37:58] And. And he's saying, you know, he's doing some magic. That's not allowed.
John Dehlin [00:38:02] Okay.
Megan Conner [00:38:03] And he says, being me have. Because he's the headmaster, Sherry.
Mindy Caldwell [00:38:08] Sherry mentioned that. I think Ruby reminds her of Dolores Umbridge. She resonated with the Dolores Umbridge character because of the strictness and the. My way or the highway.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [00:38:19] Yes, Umbridge. I'll just read that because I have it here. Umbridge, that I enjoyed most. Shari is saying, for some reason, the tyrannical, power hungry, condescending, sanctimonious sadist who ultimately faces her comeuppance. That's who Sherry resonated with. But Ruby had her favorite Harry Potter moment, and hers came from this moment when Dumbledore states, being me has its privileges. In other words, Ruby would quote that line often because the idea of being above the rules resonated with her mother. I think that it kind of explains her parenting thoughts. I'm in charge. I'm in control. I am the only one with emotions. You guys can't have them, but I'm above the law. I. That was like a really important moment for me to understand what's going on in that house. Why is, why. Why is there so much hypocrisy and self righteousness? Well, there you go. She really believes that she has these privileges her children don't.
John Dehlin [00:39:22] Yeah. What y' all think about, you know, this question of. Was there abuse before Jody enters the picture? There's kind of the piano lessons, but.
Mindy Caldwell [00:39:33] Oh, there's clearly.
John Dehlin [00:39:34] Do you want to reflect on, you know, what was said there?
Lauren Johnson Matthias [00:39:36] Yeah.
Megan Conner [00:39:37] Well, just before we jump to. To piano lessons and to. And to physical abuse, I want to talk about the concept of childhood emotional neglect, because that is abusive and I don't know how many people are aware. There's a doctor, Dr. Jonice Webb, who writes a book called Running on Empty, and it's about the concept of childhood emotional neglect and how that environment of not being able to feel emotions or having your emotions stifled by a parent where, where it's not safe for you to feel things. It turns into a specific amount of behaviors or types of behaviors as an adult where you feel really empty, where you're not able to name your emotions or process them properly.
Megan Conner [00:40:23] And I just, I underlined this part of the same chapter. This is on page 11. It says this. Sherry writes, I can't help but feel sadness for the baby girl who cried for her mother, who wanted a different kind of love than the kind she received. A love that allows for vulnerability, for tears, for the full range of human emotion. A love that allows a child the freedom to feel.
Megan Conner [00:40:46] And I think it's so important to point out that when we don't allow children to express their emotions in healthy ways, they learn to stifle them and it's going to come out sideways at some point.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [00:41:00] Point.
Megan Conner [00:41:00] So just to say that part of the abusive environment in the Frankie household was Ruby not allowing her kids to. To have emotions or to share them authentically.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [00:41:15] And I think that is a staple though, of the Frankie household. What Megan just said from the very beginning, not being held as much, crying out. That's sort of, though the parenting philosophy, I would say, with the Griffiths. I think that's what we learned with the family of origin.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [00:41:35] Think the documentary was an Amazon documentary, Shiny Happy People, where they talk about blanket training. Well, Ruby's sister Bonnie shares blanket training on her YouTube channel. I think that. So I'm saying before Jody comes along, there's already a foundation set that this is. That the, this is how you raise children. You raise them to say, I'm in charge to, as you say, stifle the emotion to get complete obedience from the children. And Sherry states that there's not just emotional abuse. This is clearly emotional. And Sherry states that she longs for and mourns this little baby that wasn't held enough that, that she was. But also we hear about physical abuse too.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [00:42:20] The, the slapping of the hands or of the mouth or tugging the ear. Tugging the ear. There is also this physical abuse. Nothing that would send them to the hospital that she states.
John Dehlin [00:42:29] Nothing that would show a mark.
Mindy Caldwell [00:42:30] That would show a mark. What did she had. She described it really well. Oh, she.
Megan Conner [00:42:37] It's on page 14 where she talks about the abuse. Yeah, I can read it if you.
Mindy Caldwell [00:42:42] Oh, she calibrated. I think she uses the word somewhere that she calibrated her physical abuse to where it would be enough to instill fear in her children, but not to show marks. Yeah. Which works at least on her.
Megan Conner [00:42:54] Absolutely.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [00:42:55] And so there's this fear. She doesn't want her mother touching her. And she. So I just think that this is again, the sort of authoritarian looking for complete obedience from sort of this army of children.
John Dehlin [00:43:06] And also this tough love where, you know, I think I remember her talking about Ruby making the kids run laps if. Or do push ups if they. That stuff didn't come from Jody. That. That was going on early on.
Mindy Caldwell [00:43:21] Yes, that was before Jody.
John Dehlin [00:43:22] And also kind of breaking the kids down to break them back up. We should probably share the pajama story. Does someone want to tell the pajama story? Do you guys remember that?
Mindy Caldwell [00:43:31] Where she has the baby and her mom gives her the Set of pajamas. Yeah.
John Dehlin [00:43:34] Yeah.
Mindy Caldwell [00:43:35] I think this is an important theme that. That comes up often in the book where Ruby is planting seeds of motherhood in Sherry very, very early. And she points out little things about her appearance that will make her appealing to a future husband. Or, you know, she talks about, you know, Sherry has anxiety and. And develops this habit of biting on her lip. And her mom says something like, no husband is ever going to want you with disgusting scars on your lip. But Sherry very, very early realizes that she has this disconnect with. With her mom. And it was after one of the babies is born. And it's in page 18.
John Dehlin [00:44:18] Page 18 and 19. It's how chapter four kind of begins. Go ahead, Minnie. Good.
Mindy Caldwell [00:44:25] Yes. So it's after baby number four is born and Ruby's mother gives her a set of silk pajamas. And Sherry witnesses this intimate little moment where the grandmother gives the pajamas to. To Ruby. And Sherry says, when I get older, can I have. Can I have silk pajamas like you? And. And Ruby responds with, when you have a baby, that's when we can be friends. And so I think she's sending a message to Sherry that I'm your drill sergeant. I'm your drill sergeant until you're a mother and you have your own baby. And that's when we can be equals. That's when we can be friends. That's when you can get all of the love from me that. That you're craving. And so not until you're a mother. And this is when Sherry is six years old, is when her mom says that to her.
John Dehlin [00:45:14] You mentioned the Griffiths, Lauren. I. I caught this. I don't know if y' all caught this, but at the very end, Sherry says, one of the things I'm most proud of is I'm breaking the multi generational cycle of abuse. Which implies that the abuse predated.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [00:45:31] Correct.
John Dehlin [00:45:31] Sherry. And possibly Kevin.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [00:45:34] Correct. And I think that's a. That's Ruby.
John Dehlin [00:45:37] I keep saying, Sherry, I know the abuse predated Ruby.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [00:45:41] Absolutely.
John Dehlin [00:45:41] Okay, keep going.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [00:45:42] Absolutely. No, I was gonna say. Yeah, I agree with that. And I think that's why I think I keep going back to this family of origin. I think it's really important to point out that there's a theme ensue. And yes, this sets a foundation before Jody comes in play. I mean, I'm jumping ahead. But as we've stated on our channel, that Jody didn't teach Ruby how to abuse. He. She gave her permission. So it's. There's something already there. The way she sees her children, the way she's raising her family, the way she is abusing or this tough love, you know, and clearly, I think that there is a point where the Griffith family is raised to sort of parent in this authoritarian way, to want strict obedience from the children.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [00:46:31] And that's, I think, the multigenerational thing that Sherry is probably attempting to break, and that is the foundation of all of this. So she's almost primed for what's going to happen in the future. And so, yeah, like, Ruby is. Is doing this.
Mindy Caldwell [00:46:45] You know, she's doing this jumping ahead just along that. That line. In chapter 17, Sherry says connections, or Jody Hildebrandt reinforced what Ruby had been doing all along. It gave her a manual to refine her tactics.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [00:47:03] Right.
Mindy Caldwell [00:47:04] So I think that it was. She was ripe. She was ripe for the teachings of Jody Hildebrandt because she had already been kind of laying those foundations for all of those years.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [00:47:13] They had the same worldview already.
Mindy Caldwell [00:47:15] Sure.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [00:47:15] So it worked.
Mindy Caldwell [00:47:16] Right.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [00:47:16] So Jody found Ruby, and unfortunately, they already had the same worldview about children. Thus she was primed and ready for what she was about to teach and willing.
Mindy Caldwell [00:47:26] Yep.
Childhood Emotional Neglect and Early Abuse
John Dehlin [00:47:27] Let me check in with y' all about one other thing. I know we're spending some time on a lot of time on this early part, but again, like you said, Lauren, sometimes the why is is kind of the most important thing. So I want to check in with y' all on something. So I remember growing up having very close family members. Let's just say aunts or uncles or even my parents.
John Dehlin [00:47:46] How cliche is it that in. In any given Mormon ward, there's like, this perfect couple that looks perfect. The. The mom is perfectly dressed and makeup and hair. The dad's a businessman in the business suit. They appear wealthy. They appear like the perfect family. All the kids are sitting in a neat little row. And then you find out, like, I was going to say, dad's in prison or like, like, they get divorced or there's abuse, and it just blows up. And this happened in my family with close family members. It happened. My parents got divorced after 25 years of marriage. And I, as a kid, I was always going, why?
John Dehlin [00:48:22] Why are these apparently beautiful Mormon families just exploding in complete chaos? And what I. What I felt, even as a kid is there's this so much pressure to look perfect and then to hide what's really going on and to always put your best foot forward. And that's clearly what Ruby ends up doing with eight passengers. But I. I do think, tell me if y' all think I'm wrong. That is a Mormon trait. And Ruby Sherry writes about it on page 13. She basically is talking about her mom's food blogging and she says, home cooking. What, what's that?
Mindy Caldwell [00:49:05] Good Looking Home Cooking was the first blog.
John Dehlin [00:49:08] Yeah. And she says, the truth is, I'm not sure she ever made those dishes, meaning the ones she blogged about. Sure, Ruby was always baking something, but most of the recipes on Good Looking Home Cooking were aspirational rather than realistic. Part of an image that of the smiling, flower smudged mama, the gaggle of cherubs gathered around the table. Even at this early stage of her online career, Ruby was showing her willingness to sacrifice authenticity on the altar of appearances. My question to y' all and your experiences is, is that a Mormon cultural trait?
Lauren Johnson Matthias [00:49:45] I'd say it's Mormon. I'd say it's evangelical too. Again, this goes back to also shiny happy people.
John Dehlin [00:49:50] High demand religions.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [00:49:51] High demand religions.
Megan Conner [00:49:52] Those.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [00:49:53] Yeah. And Mormonism too. Yes. But I just keep going back to this. I actually said to my husband once, a psychologist who couldn't believe how many kids the Duggars had. And nobody really can. Right. That's why they're a TLC family. But I said, look, you know, if anybody's gonna have a lot of kids, it's them. Because she's so sweet. Look at her. Like, she just raises, has these good kids and she's there and she's this full time mom and then shiny happy people comes out. To go to your point, John, and we learned that there's this strict obedience and this tough love going on in that house too.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [00:50:22] Going to your point of like, how things look perfect. And I don't even think it's the desire to look perfect. It's the desire to be perfect there. I, I want to take that a step further. It's not look, it's to be. They're. They're not saying, we want to look. Even though it's chaos behind closed doors. It's no, we're going to be. Be perfect. I'm going to raise you with strict obedience even in our home. This is again, the sort of parenting style. We're going to get rid of the warmth and the emotion and all I want again, are these soldiers. So, so, yes, this is, I would say, a high demand religion issue. It's, it's. Yeah, it's concerning, in my opinion.
Megan Conner [00:50:58] Yeah. And it's, it's also, I think part of it is just the cultural shame for sin, you know, and for things not Being perfect. Because I think in Mormonism and also like you're saying, Lauren, high demand evangelical in that world, there's a correlation that that gets made between sin and things just going wrong in your life. It's like if, if you are doing everything right, if you are praying hard enough, if you are keeping all the rules and following all the commandments, then God would reward you. And so when something bad happens, it's because you've done something wrong to deserve that. So we want to keep all of our, you know, warts hidden because otherwise there's a lot of shame and judgment in the culture that like, oh, if you have a child go to go astray, you must have done something wrong as a parent.
Megan Conner [00:51:52] You know, if you lose a job or if your kid has to go to rehab or anything like that, it's an indication of your righteousness. And because there's all of that shame and judgment in, in the church, I think that's the reason why there's so much, you know, of this veneer of the COVID up of the inauthenticity, because it's really not safe in the culture to have normal human mistakes happen. You know, it's kind of silly even saying it out loud, but for kids to misbehave in church, I mean, for me, for my parents, that was like the ultimate. You know, you were going to really be in trouble if you misbehaved in church.
Megan Conner [00:52:34] And a lot of the times when I was younger, I remember my parents would not necessarily ever compliment our grades or our musical accomplishments or anything like that. But if somebody at church commented on how well behaved their children were, they talked about it for weeks.
Megan Conner [00:52:53] And that was, that was just about the main part of the validation that we in my family that we ever got as kids was like, oh, so and so said you guys were so well behaved in church and we loved your talk and those kinds of things. That's what we got rewarded for.
Mindy Caldwell [00:53:10] I think it's important to note as well that for these women like Ruby and I can speak from my own experience. Let's stay at home moms. How your family looks like that is. That is where your purpose lies and not just how they look, but how they act. And it's the product of your hard work is what people can see. And so, yeah, I think that it's a trap that you fall into maybe as a stay at home parent, because it's what you have to show for all the hard work that you're doing. You know, you're like, if My family looks put together and nice, then maybe that's validation for me that I'm doing, doing something right. And so I found it interesting too, where or along these same lines that, oh, shoot, I kind of lost my train of thought. But yeah, it's just, it's tricky as a stay at home parent and
Lauren Johnson Matthias [00:54:06] with
Mindy Caldwell [00:54:07] all the, all the children, it's a balance because, you know, I think it's easy to look at the kind of authoritarian and dictator style, which clearly is not healthy, but when you have all these. I think they said by the time she, Ruby was 30, she had her six kids by the time she was 30, plus she'd had some miscarriages in there. That's a lot to go through, you know, in, in by the time you're 30 and, and you know, there has to be some sort of order and balance. But, you know, so just finding that within a loving and accepting, an emotionally available way is I think, where she was missing the mark.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [00:54:41] Yeah.
Megan Conner [00:54:42] And I think that because of how we're taught from a very young age in Mormonism that our highest calling is that of wife and mother. And also the prophets literally tell us that our kids will be better off and everything will be better if we stay at home with our kids and we don't pursue a career. So there's a lot of pressure to do that and not everyone can. And that's why when we're saying at the end of, end of the book, you know, when, when Sherry questions, you know, I wonder what it would have been like if Ruby would have waited to have kids.
Megan Conner [00:55:14] Maybe she would have learned more about how to deal with children and how to parent more responsibly. And it resonates with me too, because when I first started having kids, I was super young. My first child was born when I was 20 years old and I began my parenting career parenting the way I was parenthead. And I think a lot of us do that because we don't really know another way to do. And the way that I was parented with was with a lot of manipulation and a lot of control and a lot of shame. Just the way that's happening in this book. I was shocked at how similar it was.
Megan Conner [00:55:49] And so when I started having kids, I started doing the same types of things. And when my oldest daughter was about 6, 7, I just had this realization that I was creating children who were going to fear me the way that I feared my parents, not love me. And I decided I wanted to do things differently. And that was when I really Started changing a lot of the things that I was doing as a parent and sort of breaking away from Mormonism, honestly, even at that young stage, because I didn't want to control my kids. I wanted to love them, you know. But I just think when we're in that culture, you're sort of predisposed to that.
Megan Conner [00:56:29] And certain personality types, like rubies, are going to take that to the extreme, unfortunately. And I think that's why we see Mormon families blow up so often.
John Dehlin [00:56:38] Yeah. And then. And then you add to that the influence of. Of social media and trying to be a YouTube channel and trying, you know, and then even add to that potentially your missionary zeal for Mormonism and wanting to portray the church right. So maybe that's the next place we can go. Margi highlighted a quote at the bottom of page 43. I don't know if. Do you have your book, Lauren? Is that even on there?
Lauren Johnson Matthias [00:57:09] I only have screenshots of the book. I tried to log in.
John Dehlin [00:57:12] Oh, Megan Kinnegan can share her book with you.
Megan Conner [00:57:14] Yeah, you guys can share.
Perfectionism, Mormonism, and Family Vlogging
John Dehlin [00:57:15] Let's read a little bit, Lauren, if you don't mind. Let's read starting with the final paragraph at the end of 43, where it says in many ways, and then just stop when you feel like, you know, the point's been made sufficiently. But this is about. This is really good missionary zeal and vlogging and the ethics of vlogging and
Lauren Johnson Matthias [00:57:35] Mormon vlogging really, in many ways, family vlogging is a very LDS aligned pursuit, a natural extension of our original, our traditional practices. Vlogging offers a modern form of bearing testimony and keeping personal and family records while simultaneously engaging in passive missionary work. Vlog means church members can share their faith values and daily lives with a global audience, potentially attracting interest in the church and its teachings. In a way, the synergy between YouTube and LDS families seems almost predestined, fitting perfectly with the church's desire to be, quote, unquote, in the world, but not of the world, end quote. Allowing members to engage with modern culture while maintaining our distinct values and beliefs. Do you want me to keep going? I couldn't agree more with this.
John Dehlin [00:58:24] I mean, it's kind of. This next paragraph is kind of important. Yeah, keep going. Yeah.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [00:58:28] Perhaps that's why Utah and the broader LDS community have become such powerhouses in the realms of family vlogging and traditional lifestyle content creation. Some of the earliest and most successful family vlogging channels have come from our communities. Documenting life with most multiple children, showcasing the appeal of family life to a mainstream audience while demonstrating how modern media can be harnessed to share testimonies and values in a reliable, engaging, relatable, engaging way.
John Dehlin [00:58:57] Yeah, like Mormon family vlogging is a global phenomenon. And it's even ironic this book's coming out in 2025. But I think some New York Times level journalists declared 2024 the year of the Mormon Housewife because of not just secret housewives, but also the tradwise phenomenon Ballerina Farms. Like it's not going away. What do y' all think about that? Mormonism and vlogging.
Megan Conner [00:59:24] Well, I specifically, I, I agree too, and you're fine. I specifically remember a conference talk, a general conference talk when we, we as women were encouraged to get out there in the universe and blog about our righteous lives. I remember that encouragement and I, my sister and I were like, oh, wow, we should, we should start a blog, you know, and we did. We started a parenting blog. It quickly went south because the title of it was God is the Only Perfect Parent. And I did about three blogs and I went, I can't write this.
John Dehlin [00:59:56] Yeah. Any other thoughts on why Mormonism? It leads the world in family vlogging?
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:00:03] I, I don't I.
John Dehlin [01:00:05] Good or a bad thing?
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:00:05] I couldn't agree with this more. I. I also resonated with Sherry discussing her journaling. Growing up, I was so into journaling. I think beyond just showcasing and missionary work, I think it goes into ancestor worship and how we are supposed to be leaving, you know, our history for the next generation.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:00:27] And I think that, I think there's also, like, I think for me there was a bit of a panic that if I didn't leave journals or if I didn't leave my history, then, then nobody will know, you know, what it was like, or no one will know me. I remember feeling a panic in Sunday school where they, they, this was a, this was. I missed a lot of like the horrible Sunday school lessons that I heard. But here's one. It was about journaling. And I don't know if I was in young women's or the end of primary. I was, I feel like I was like an early teen, though.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:01:01] And they gave a story about journaling and recording. And this was before social media. And they gave a story of a little girl who was about to go into young women's and her mom said, hey, how about this? I'll go get my journal so I can relate it to you about what it was like when I went into young women's. And the little girl goes, yeah, I would love that. And then the mom said, but guess what? I didn't keep a journal. So I can't let you know what it was like.
Mindy Caldwell [01:01:29] Nothing like a healthy guilt.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:01:32] I have about 60 journals from growing up and I'll tell you, one of the most traumatizing things is reading your journals from junior high. I want to burn them. I wish no one ever told me to keep those journals. I don't want to know what's in those journals and scrapbooks too. I did that. But I think it also, I think it's a bit of a Venn diagram. It's oh look, now you can be a missionary with your journals. So it's this double edged sword. You can be a missionary with your journals, but there's also this idea of, of you're leaving a legacy for your children and your children's children and you want them to then see.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:02:07] Well, I want them to see what a happy family we are. So I, I think that that's a little bit of it too. I just want to throw that in is there's not just we can be a missionary but the whole journaling and recording your history starts with this idea that we're going to remember our past ancestors from their journals. We're never going to forget them and no one's ever going to forget us and we're going to pass this on to the next generation.
John Dehlin [01:02:27] So yeah, yeah. And I thought, you know, there were points, you know, one of my biggest concern with this book is just thinking how much can we believe of her as a reliable narrator. But for me, one of the fantastic things about the book is she reads from her journal. She reads actual passages of conversations she had with her therapist, conversations she had with her dad, reactions to an exchange with Ruby. She's reading from her diary and quoting from her diary. What a fantastic resource.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:02:58] That's true Sherry. Grateful you kept those journal entries. So there's a great example of like thank you Sherry for keeping a journal.
John Dehlin [01:03:05] You don't need Ruby's journal so much.
Mindy Caldwell [01:03:07] But yeah, that was the time for, for Sherry. I think that her starting that journal was crucial in her. I think she was around 11. Is it 11 or I can't remember what age but around the time that the, that the, that eight Passengers is launched is when she starts writing. And, and I was really happy for her that she had that outlet where she could just whatever, whatever the motivations were. I was grateful for her that she could have that outlet. And she'd say things like my mom's been being A today. And yeah, like, I was like, good for you, Sherry, you know, like, pushing back and, and she really was able to start, you know, expressing herself in a.
Mindy Caldwell [01:03:48] In a safe place for her that she hadn't had. So I'm really grateful that Sherry kept those journals. It was. And I think it showed that from an early age, she's a really good writer and she's a deep thinker and was able to express those feelings in a very. In a pretty eloquent way.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:04:04] Heartbreaking. When she writes in her journal, I don't think my mom loves me.
Mindy Caldwell [01:04:07] I don't think my mom loves me. That was so sad.
John Dehlin [01:04:12] Yeah. Let me read a quote from, from Zachary's mama. Zachary's mama writes. It's a comment from our live stream. She writes, curiously, not being brought up Mormon. I recognize a lot of these parenting behaviors in my own life and lives of others growing up. The parental picture today is very different than generations past. So that's true. You know, if you read the works of, like, Jonathan Haidt these days, this idea of helicopter parenting, of over nurturing your kids, it almost reflects a little bit of the sentiment you were talking about, Lauren, that there's another angle, which is have in modern times, have parents swung too far to nurturing and are they over nurturing their kids? So with parent parenting, sometimes you're almost damned if you do and damned if you don't.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:05:02] Hey, if it's one or the other over nurture, everyone over nurture versus abuse.
John Dehlin [01:05:07] Yeah, I think I agree.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:05:09] If it's about tough love or over nurture, I just say swing to the over nurture.
Consent and Exploitation in Family Vlogging
John Dehlin [01:05:16] All right, well, again, y' all jump in anytime. I've got this list. But the next thing that, that Margi flagged for us was this notion of consent and the ethics of family vlogging. And I know that Sherry recently, I think, presented to the Utah legislature her thoughts. But before we jump to that, let's jump to page 53. And Mindy, maybe, maybe you could read. It's a paragraph that starts mid page, but it's basically Sherry reflecting on consent. Is. Is child consent in family video youtubing and blogging even possible? So do you want to read that paragraph?
Mindy Caldwell [01:06:00] Okay, tell me where you want to.
John Dehlin [01:06:01] Starts with what? What are the lasting repercussions?
Mindy Caldwell [01:06:04] And this is just timeline wise. This is after the. Shortly after the eight Passengers has been launched, I believe. Okay. What are the lasting repercussions of growing up on camera without any say in the matter? How does that constant exposure shape a child's sense of self, their future relationships, their very understanding of privacy. And what does consent really look like when you're a child too afraid to say no? Personally, I mourn those precious formative years spent in service to someone else's vision. Ruby might claim her kids were always on board, but the truth is we never really had a choice in the matter.
John Dehlin [01:06:40] What do you all want to say about just this culture of family vlogging, of always having what she called that, Jake, those janky cameras in their faces at every moment?
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:06:49] Well, let's just talk about, let's just take what Megan just said about how the, the LDS Church pushed this, you know, go be a missionary. Now fast forward to Sherry Frankie speaking about what that was like for her growing up to the Utah legislature and saying, this is terrible. It's almost like it was a social experiment and here we are. So let's just talk about that. Like here we are and this is the outcome of this social experiment. And I think that she also plays into how her family made a lot of money. She admits that they went from really trying to get by with so many kids and to being young to buying a new car and having all of these things and being able to do
Mindy Caldwell [01:07:32] tax write offs on and the brand deals. Brand deals and paid vacations and that
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:07:39] it was fun and that it was exciting, but the payoff is so tragic. And I think I also want to put in that like these LDS women that are doing this are taught to stay home, right? They're taught to stay home and to be a homemaker, yet they're smart and they're brilliant and they're visionaries and they want to do something more and they can put this out there and make money for their families. And I just, I just can't. I, I got to go back to this moment of like, hey, do this, you know, decades later and hear Sherri Frankie saying, and speaking up at the, at the Utah legislature saying, this is horrible. I didn't have the ability to say
John Dehlin [01:08:20] no, but it's so much pressure for a kid because the parents are saying we got to set a good example for the church. The church wants us to project a good image. So it's for Jesus, it's for God, but also it's our livelihood and you know, we're not going to be able to make ends meet. And also millions of people are watching. How does a kid say no to that?
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:08:40] Right, right, right.
Megan Conner [01:08:42] Yeah. And I think we, we discussed a little bit beforehand we, we watched or some of us watched the Reaction from Sherry's aunt, who is also a vlogger. Family vlogger.
Mindy Caldwell [01:08:52] Bonnie.
Megan Conner [01:08:53] Bonnie, yeah. And she was very adamant that they have discussions as a family about this. And when Sherry's book came out, they, they revisited it and they said, you know, should we still be doing this? Is this still okay? And she, she insists that her kids are on board. But how can you actually know that when the pressure is so high?
Megan Conner [01:09:15] You're asking 8, 10, 12 year old kids to go against their family, their parents, and, and to give up money. And what, you know, what, what do most 8 to 15 year old kids want? They want the latest video game, they want the latest sneakers, they want stuff that money, you know, can buy. Right. And so if you have this channel that's making a ton of money and you know that if it goes away, that means fewer video games, fewer vacations, you know, not as cool cars, all of that stuff goes away. And for a child to be able to understand that, I don't think that they have the emotional capability at that age, at that developmental age to make those kinds of choices.
Megan Conner [01:09:59] So for me personally, the answer is kids can't consent. They can't consent to family vlogging because they have no idea what the repercussions are going to be.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:10:09] We've seen the tragedy of child stars for decades. That's nothing new. Right? We've seen it played over and over and over, over again. And the tragedy, you know, and what comes from that, it's even more than like, imagine saying to a child, you are the breadwinner. You are our family's breadwinner.
John Dehlin [01:10:28] Yeah.
Mindy Caldwell [01:10:29] Pressure.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:10:29] The pressure from that. Like, and if you don't do this, we're gonna have to go back to work and this is going to be hard on the family. And if you don't perform, the family doesn't make money. I mean, these children are their family's breadwinners now. Like, it's, it's, you know, even before
John Dehlin [01:10:49] they know it, like, there's that, there's that one first video that goes viral. What, where the baby crawls out of the crib and. Yeah. What's mommy doing while the baby's crawling out of the crib?
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:10:57] Right, right.
Megan Conner [01:10:57] Yeah, sorry. Filming it.
John Dehlin [01:11:00] Yeah, yeah, yeah. There's no such thing as, as child consent when it comes to anything sexual and vlogging. Right, yeah, yeah.
Megan Conner [01:11:12] And what Sherry said when she was in front of the legislature is there's no such thing as an ethical family vlog. For, for exactly those reasons. And, and on the Same page. While we're talking about it, too, Sherry goes on to say, what about Ruby? If I can just read this little part, what might be the emotional repercussions of her snowballing online success? Yes, Ruby's drive was bringing in money for her family and validation for her ego. But none of those superficial rewards could fix what was broken inside her. Instead, they seemed to fuel a vicious cycle, pushing her to seek more validation, more views, more content, often at the expense of her family.
John Dehlin [01:11:53] Yeah. So another theme is kind of Sherry's mental health. What we see is her starting to have tummy aches, thinking that it's demonic possession, which is kind of a little dark and sad of. Of her feeling sick to her tummy in her bed. Eventually, you know, consider, you know, learning about the term scrupulosity, religious OCD and perfectionism.
Ruby's Mental Health and Demonic Possession Beliefs
John Dehlin [01:12:25] And, you know, and clearly. Well, I want to say this. When I first saw some sort of video from Sherry, I'm just going to be totally honest, My immediate reaction was, wow, she really seems to have a flat affect, which is a term in, you know, psychology, meaning not very emotionally expressive. Right. And as soon as I read that part of the book where it's like, no one was allowed to have feelings but Ruby, then Sherry, Sherry's development, it could be personality, but it made perfect sense to me that if Sherry developed maybe with a bit of a flutter affect, maybe that was just survival, right?
Mindy Caldwell [01:13:07] Yeah.
John Dehlin [01:13:08] But it's also clear if she was having tummy aches and suicidality, even as a kid, she was internalizing all this distress from both the conflicts with her mom, but also this family vlogging, that was super stressful. What do you guys. What were your reactions about that kind of how it was impacting her mental health, her personality development? Anything you want to say about that?
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:13:31] I mean, it makes complete sense. I don't think how it couldn't. I think it was interesting for her to realize in Google, you know, this is this again. This generation also growing up with Google. Right. I'm going to find out what's wrong with me. I hear depression. I hear, oh, my gosh, that's me. I realize I have a stomachache. I realize that I'm internalizing stuff. And I'm gonna. I'm gonna go to my parents and I'm gonna tell them. And I think the difference between how Ruby react opposed to Kevin is interesting because you do see that maybe Kevin is more empathic and does understand a little bit more about emotion at the beginning, maybe when she's younger and then things change.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:14:05] So that was a really interesting moment for me to see how Kevin did handle Sherry's emotions at first, opposed to later, after Jody jumps into the picture. But I. I think it makes complete sense. I don't know how a child wouldn't internalize that. I thought it was also interesting, though, that she learned about scrupulosity from her bishop. She went in to talk to her bishop and kept repeating, and he's the one that brought it up. And he said, you're dealing with this. And then she went and looked it up, too. That was interesting.
John Dehlin [01:14:37] Yeah. I think it would be useful to talk about the eyebrow waxing scene. Yeah.
Mindy Caldwell [01:14:46] That is in chapter. Where are we before we go there, though.
John Dehlin [01:14:51] Oh, go ahead.
Megan Conner [01:14:51] Can we talk about the demonic possession?
Mindy Caldwell [01:14:54] Yes, let's go back to that.
Megan Conner [01:14:55] Because. Because I can't tell you how many people, you know covering the Lori Valo Daybell case as. As much as you and all of us have done. Right.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:15:05] The.
Megan Conner [01:15:05] The comment that I get more than. More often than anything else from true believing members of the church is that we don't believe in demonic possession.
John Dehlin [01:15:12] Mormons don't believe in demons.
Megan Conner [01:15:13] Don't believe that. So I just want to read this.
John Dehlin [01:15:15] This part.
Mindy Caldwell [01:15:16] Okay.
Megan Conner [01:15:16] Please, can we put this to rest for just a second?
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:15:19] And this is your family's case. Let's remind everyone this is your family.
Megan Conner [01:15:22] My family. Yes, exactly. But. But Sherry writes about her nightmares. She's having all these horrible nightmares, and I think it's. I think it's important to. To read the descriptive language. She says as soon as the lights went out, others would appear. She was saying there were things in the dark she was afraid of. She said grotesque figures straight out of a medieval landscape. Demonic entities leering with twisted grins. Their contorted faces haunted my sleepless nights, their agonized stories playing out in my dreams. Why might a little girl harbor such tangible fears of demonic possession? I'm sure the deeply religious paradigm I was steeped in played a role. We firmly believe in Satan's power and the ability of his legion of fallen spirits to possess individuals. We believe that evil can inhabit physical forms.
John Dehlin [01:16:15] And she's saying that as if she believes it now, right?
Megan Conner [01:16:17] Yes. Well, she's still very much a believer, I think, as far as we know.
John Dehlin [01:16:21] I didn't mean to talk about.
Mindy Caldwell [01:16:22] No, no, no. Yes.
John Dehlin [01:16:24] Okay.
Mindy Caldwell [01:16:24] I was going to point out that I believe the part that you're reading. She's five.
Megan Conner [01:16:29] Yes.
Mindy Caldwell [01:16:29] When she's remembering.
Megan Conner [01:16:31] Yes.
Mindy Caldwell [01:16:31] These. I mean, obviously she wouldn't have probably described it that way as a five year old, but looking back, that's how she's describing that.
Megan Conner [01:16:38] Yes.
Mindy Caldwell [01:16:38] Having those experiences in that, in that. At that young age.
Megan Conner [01:16:42] Yeah. And she's writing in present day language. We firmly believe.
Mindy Caldwell [01:16:46] Yeah.
Megan Conner [01:16:46] So still to this day, and she says, we believe that evil can inhabit physical forms, sometimes fleetingly, sometimes for extended periods. Having been raised to believe the very air I breathed was thick with unseen forces battling for dominion over my soul, it was a small step for my young mind to imagine that battle raging in my own bedroom.
John Dehlin [01:17:08] Yeah. It's one thing for kids to learn fairy tales or even ghost stories. It's another thing for them to believe that those evil spirits are real and all around them all the time.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:17:18] Yeah.
Megan Conner [01:17:19] Battling for their soul all the time.
John Dehlin [01:17:21] It's dark.
Megan Conner [01:17:23] Yeah.
John Dehlin [01:17:23] I'm glad you brought that up, Megan.
Megan Conner [01:17:25] Anxiety, religious scrupulosity. I mean, that's the reason why there are so many of these mental health problems, is the beliefs.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:17:32] Are there.
John Dehlin [01:17:33] Yeah. A question from one of our viewers, De Hender 07 asks, and this may jump ahead in the timeline, but we'll take some of these questions as they come. Why haven't the Mormon Church excommunicated Ruby, Frankie and Jody Hildebrandt yet? You can be excommunicated for being gay or criticizing the church or having a popular podcast, I'll say, but not excommunicated for torturing children. Make it make sense. So I know this is out of the timeline, but. But anyone have a response?
Mindy Caldwell [01:18:07] Do we know.
John Dehlin [01:18:07] I don't know that we know.
Mindy Caldwell [01:18:08] I don't know if we know that Ruby's membership has been.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:18:12] Yeah, I don't know that.
Megan Conner [01:18:13] Yeah, I don't know. But we, we discussed this when, you know, when I was on Mormon Stories first with the Valo case about why Lori hadn't been excommunicated. And the thing is, we don't. We don't know. But, but what is interesting to me is that there have been plenty of public excommunications, plenty of them. You know, yours, for example, Sam Young, you know anybody who's an advocate for change in the church. Lots of public ones. But I find it interesting that these criminals, these child abusers, child killers, there's no public denunciation of them or of their actions or of their criminality or abusers. Or abusers. Yeah, exactly. And we, we only know that Chad Daybell was excommunicated because somebody leaked it. Right.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:19:00] Love those leaks. Love those leaks coming.
Megan Conner [01:19:03] So we don't, I mean, I don't know if any of you know. I guess we don't know if, if either of them have been excommunicated, but you would think that the church would want to take swift action against someone who's been convicted of a horrific crime like this to say they are no longer allowed to be Mormons.
Mindy Caldwell [01:19:19] Yeah. You know, to publicly distance from these people.
Megan Conner [01:19:22] Exactly.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:19:23] Well, if we say pics or it didn't happen, that's probably what they're saying. It didn't happen.
Mindy Caldwell [01:19:27] No.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:19:28] No proof.
Megan Conner [01:19:28] Yeah.
Mindy Caldwell [01:19:29] Yeah, maybe.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:19:29] I think. I think they are trying to distance themselves. I agree with you. I agree. I'm just like. Right. It would be nice to know. But they're just going to put their. They put their blinder on any of these things.
Mindy Caldwell [01:19:40] I'll draw more publicity to an already hot topic that a lot of people are talking about. That, that casts.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:19:46] They.
Mindy Caldwell [01:19:46] They'll love to use the publicity machine if it casts them in a good light, but if anything, that's going to cast them in a negative light.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:19:54] It'll. It'll always forever upset me that your family's case, they did not speak up when Tyler and J.J. were missing.
Mindy Caldwell [01:20:00] Yeah.
Megan Conner [01:20:01] And I. I wonder though, too, how
John Dehlin [01:20:04] they did the opposite. They told people not to cooperate with police authorities.
Megan Conner [01:20:07] They told people not to get involved with the investigation or to testify in court without checking with their attorneys first is really what they said. It's the same thing, though, basically saying it's not okay for you to just get involved. You know, but I wonder, thinking about it, how much of this stuff that they really are aware of, you know, the 15 who, who sit in the ivory tower over there. I know that they've got plenty of people giving them information, but I think they're so far removed from the actual real lives of their members that they maybe don't know how much publicity this stuff is getting and how it affects actual members of the church and how they are talking about it. So I wonder if they just. If they just don't know how pervasive and common the reporting is on these types of cases and that people are talking about them.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:21:02] I think there's some truth to that, too. I remember talking to someone who, you know, knew one of the apostles, and she said, you know, I don't know, I don't even think they're even talking about.
Mindy Caldwell [01:21:12] Just like, maybe they're not talking about it, but there's certainly like PR people, you know, minions down the line that are staying on top of everything. But who knows how much that the top leaders Absorb or are informed, but I agree.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:21:25] But it's a poor decision, though. It's a poor decision.
Mindy Caldwell [01:21:27] I agree.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:21:27] As someone that's kind of into PR and like how one should handle a certain situation, I'm always kind of assessing, analyzing. As someone that's been in the news in Utah and Idaho who had to reach out for the LDS Church for comment and kind of understand a little bit about the workings of the PR department, they missed the mark on addressing these.
Megan Conner [01:21:48] Well, that's a great point, both of you. And I think it makes me think that there is some pervasive rule about PR that they don't address these types of cases. Because certainly people are reaching out, reporters are reaching out, asking for commentary.
Mindy Caldwell [01:22:03] Absolutely.
Megan Conner [01:22:03] But I'm sure there must be some kind of a, you know, just a blanket PR rule in the church that we don't talk about true crime or we don't address the cases of our members becoming criminals.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:22:14] I don't think it's a rule. I think it's a case by case basis. And that's why I think I can say they missed the mark on this one. Certainly not the case for Elizabeth Smart. They let them have every press conference every day on the front lawn of the LDS Church building. So it's a case by case basis. And that's why I think I can say they missed the mark on this one. You know?
Megan Conner [01:22:31] Yeah, I agree with you totally. I will just point out, though, that Elizabeth Smart didn't do anything wrong. She wasn't the criminal.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:22:37] Oh, I agree.
Megan Conner [01:22:37] In that case, you know, so whether they would have given PR to someone who is a criminal, you know.
Mindy Caldwell [01:22:44] No, I agree.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:22:44] I think we can all see the differences.
Megan Conner [01:22:45] Yeah.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:22:46] Yeah.
Gaslighting, Therapy, and Control Within the Family
John Dehlin [01:22:47] Well, let's jump to the. The eyebrow. The eyebrow story on page 70. This is just an example of how exploitative things got. And so basically, I guess, Ruby gets the idea of waxing Sherry's eyebrows and she even bribes her. So basically, you know, starting in, like, the second or third paragraph. Come on, Sherry, this is Ruby. Come on, Sherry. It'll be great. A great video for the channel. I'll give you a hundred bucks. Right.
John Dehlin [01:23:22] And then Sherry says, okay, you can watch my browser. Plopping down in the chair she'd set up in the bright glare of the ring light, Ruby had a salesperson's gift for making everything seem like an adventure. And $100 in the name of beauty sounded just fine to me. The pain was nothing compared to the horror show I witnessed in the mirror afterward. Ruby had waxed off half My left eyebrow leaving a sharp 90 degree angle that made me look like I was perpetually shocked by my own reflection. Who needs symmetry when you can rock the quote Spock meets surprise squirrel look. I was mortified, but of course, Ruby kept the camera rolling, zooming in on my face like she was documenting a rare species of unibrowed teen in its natural habitat.
John Dehlin [01:24:11] The money shot, indeed. Sherry, I'm sorry. She exclaimed, her voice quivering with what I'm sure was remorse and. And definitely not barely contained glee at striking content gold.
Megan Conner [01:24:25] Yeah.
John Dehlin [01:24:26] Sure enough, the video titled Sherry, I'm so sorry with a thumbnail of me mid ugly cry racked up hundreds of thousands of views. Wonderful. I thought I always wanted to be famous for my crazy eyebrows. I had to wear huge sunglasses for a few weeks to hide my mother's handiwork. And I don't recall ever seeing that hundred dollars either. Like, isn't it hard enough to be a teenage girl?
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:24:54] So hard to be a teenage girl. And I mean, I'm. Who thinks that that was on purpose? I do.
John Dehlin [01:25:00] I was just gonna ask that.
Megan Conner [01:25:01] I totally do.
John Dehlin [01:25:02] Everyone agree? Everyone agree. Premeditated for the views.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:25:06] Oh, yeah.
John Dehlin [01:25:07] Yep. And yeah. Did she fake. Did Ruby fake being horrified or. Right.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:25:12] Yeah, yeah. And she says there's a gleeful undertone, you know, oh, I'm so sorry, but this gleeful undertone.
John Dehlin [01:25:18] Camera rolling.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:25:19] Yeah, yeah, absolutely.
Megan Conner [01:25:21] Absolutely.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:25:21] And like, I know what it is to, you know, I have a YouTube channel. You have a YouTube channel. John, I know what it is to like you. You want something that stands out. I. We call it. We call it a hidden true crime. You know, clicky. You know, not clickbait, because clickbait is bad, but clicky. You want something that, you know, people are going to say, oh, I want to watch this. And you want to put your best stuff for say, this is what you're gonna get. And to think that someone might be using children to do that. I think this is a really profound moment of realizing what this is when all of a sudden your children are your YouTube channel. What are you willing to do for that clicky thumbnail?
Mindy Caldwell [01:25:57] Sherry mentions how she started to learn to recognize her mom's vlog voice, where just like the regular stuff, when they weren't on camera, her mom would shout or whatever the dynamic was. But then she started to kind of dread when she would hear that blog voice because she's like, here we go. Got to get into performative mode and let's see what. What happens. But yeah, that story. That's a sad story.
Megan Conner [01:26:23] Yeah. And later, when Sherry is testifying in, in. In front of the Utah legislature, she says all she wanted to do was go in her room by herself and cry and grieve alone. But, you know, Ruby kept the cameras rolling. You know, I think it's just a profound look into how that does affect kids. Like, kids need to be able to have their private moments, their emotional moments, you know, make their mistakes in private, you know, have a certain amount of anonymity in an environment where it's safe to fail, you know, so that they develop resilience. And when you, when you learn from such a young age to exploit those private moments, it's got to be really distorting for kids.
Megan Conner [01:27:10] And I think it's distorting to the rest of us too, although we probably don't realize it when we consume that kind of content, I think. I think it changes something in us too, you know, and I don't think that that's good for anybody either.
John Dehlin [01:27:27] Yeah, agree.
Mindy Caldwell [01:27:28] There have been a few comments online, you know, in Reddit forums and whatnot, where people have. Have some remorse and some guilt for kind of getting so involved in the day to day lives of these families and their videos, not realizing that they were kind of contributing to this exploitation. And, and yeah, Sherry says several times throughout the book some sort of iteration of this, of this theme, one that I just came across in my notes is she said, this is a cautionary tale of what happens when the line between authenticity and performance becomes blurred beyond recognition. I think that's a great description.
John Dehlin [01:28:06] Thank you.
Megan Conner [01:28:07] Yeah.
John Dehlin [01:28:08] Comment from a viewer, Gail Sinatra. Thanks, Gail. Gail's amazing. She writes, I'm convinced Ruby has a touch of sadism in her meaning pleasure from causing other people pain. Thank you all for your coverage of this saga.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:28:24] Well, it's not just Gail that thinks that. Sherry. Sherry thinks that too. And she. I, I actually always note that word because it's a big word to use when it comes to crime, you know, of others, a motive. Right. You don't just throw that word out, in my opinion. And I did note that Sherry used that word several times when discussing her mother and Jody.
John Dehlin [01:28:44] Yeah, and Jody, what did y' all make? So there's this part of the book where finally Sherry is allowed to go to a therapist. And at some point she, I guess, tells the therapist, gets up the courage to tell the therapist that she doesn't like playing the piano anymore. She wants to stop. So the therapist works with Sherry to get up the courage to bring Ruby in And tell Ruby that she doesn't want to play the piano anymore because it's making her sick and she doesn't like it.
John Dehlin [01:29:18] And Ruby fakes to the therapist, that sounds great. Okay, Sherry, no more. No more piano for you. That's fine. And then lo and behold, a few weeks or months later, Ruby just. Just out of the blue, says to Sherry, oh, you know what? I talked to your therapist. And your therapist says, you're good. You don't need to be in therapy anymore. And Sherry's like, I think I still need therapy. And Ruby's like, nope, you're good. You're all done. Your therapist said so. I mean, I'm a. I have a psychology degree. And so what'd y' all think about that?
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:29:53] Oh, yeah, I think. I think it might have even been like the next.
Megan Conner [01:29:56] It was like the next, very next. I have this part started.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:30:01] Yeah, go ahead.
Megan Conner [01:30:02] Well, if you had something, I wanted to hear what you had to say. But this. I had this dog eared and. And writt all over because it's a tough one. This is. This is really bad. So what. What Ruby says is Sherry writes instead. Ruby just said, okay, Sherry, you don't have to play piano and we never have to talk about it again. That was in front of the therapist. And I just. It sucked me right back into being a teenager because those were the kind of things that my mom would do too. She would say one thing in front of the person, but you knew that underneath that was like, oh, I really messed up. This is going to be bad by
John Dehlin [01:30:40] kind of telling family secrets or being authentic or saying you have a need or.
Megan Conner [01:30:44] Well, the. The intimation was Ruby was the one making Sherry get up at 6 o' clock in the morning and practice the piano. And Ruby was the one smacking her hands when she made a mistake. And Ruby was the one shaming her for not learning the songs fast enough. And so by Sherry telling her therapist that she didn't like piano, that was calling Ruby out in Ruby's mind, I'm sure was calling Ruby out for, you know, being a horrible mother. And who knows what else Sherry is telling this therapist. And now this therapist knows that I'm not the perfect mom. And if she knows, who else?
Megan Conner [01:31:18] I can just see the wheels of anxiety turning in Ruby's mind that Sherry is telling the family secrets. Like, that's really, really terrible. And so what goes on then is that Ruby gaslights Sherry into believing that the therapist has gone, cleared her at a time when Sher's having suicidality, she's having religious scrupulosity, she's having huge anxiety that's having a physical effect on her detrimentally. And the exchange that takes place. I I just think it's. I. I would love to just read through this a little bit.
John Dehlin [01:31:51] Yeah,
Megan Conner [01:31:54] it wasn't she Sher says it wasn't long ago that I had shared my thoughts of suicide with Ruby. But what Ruby says is great news, sweetheart. I had a chat with Dr. Winters today and she thinks you're just fine.
Megan Conner [01:32:10] She doesn't want to waste our money on unnecessary sessions, so you don't need to eat so fast. No therapy today, Mom, I ventured, my voice barely a whisper. She really thinks I'm fine? Yes, Ruby said, her eyes bright with an emotion I couldn't quite please place. You're fine. You're not around. Jake, who was the boy that she kissed and that was a huge problem. There's an obsession with Mormon moms getting their daughters away from boys who they have innocently kissed.
Megan Conner [01:32:42] You don't have a smartphone. She taken away her smartphone, gave her a brick. So you're good. So in Ruby's mind, you're not around Jake, you don't have a smartphone. You're fine. Never mind the fact that she's been mentioning that she's having suicidal ideation. She said. Sher says, is this because I quit piano? Mom, are you mad about how that happened? Is that why I can't do therapy anymore? Not at all. No more therapy. Doctor's orders. Sherry says. It didn't make sense to me. I needed more time. I was making progress, inching towards something I felt like healing. Mom, I'd like to carry on if I can, I said, pushing my bowl away.
Megan Conner [01:33:17] Ruby's smile faltered for a moment. Listen to me, Sherry. The doctor thinks you're a very well adjusted girl with. How do I put it? And active imagination. Wait, she thinks I'm making this up? Ruby says Mommy's little drama queen is looking for attention.
Megan Conner [01:33:37] So Ruby intimates that Sherry's not suicidal. She doesn't have anxiety or religious scrupulosity. She's just making it up. And Ruby doesn't want Sherry talking to a therapist anymore.
Mindy Caldwell [01:33:52] That's sad. And that. That part made me sad because at first when she confesses to her parents about her. Her suicidality and some of her anxieties like Kevin took it seriously, like Ruby didn't, she pushed it away and she said something kind of flippant like, oh, she just needs to eat, eat better and sleep better. And she'll be fine. And Kevin said, ruby, this is serious. We need to take this seriously. So I think that was an opportunity for Kevin to put his foot down, and we gradually see Kevin just get less and less power and become more of a shell. But, yeah, that part was heartbreaking for her.
Mindy Caldwell [01:34:31] And it just made me feel sad because the doctor clearly didn't cancel the therapy and probably was confused as to why they were counseling so abruptly. Yeah, that's my interpretation anyway. Me, too. But how sad for. For Sherry to have it suggested to her that it's all in her head and that she's a drama queen, and that's just going to make her retreat further and maybe not feel safe, you know, to even approach Kevin. If Ruby laid down the law at that. At that time.
Megan Conner [01:35:03] Yeah, I was glad to see Kevin stand up for Sherry at that point. I thought that was a really important. And then Sherry ends the chapter by saying, whether Ruby was lying or my therapist had betrayed me, the result was the same. My little therapy experiment was over. In this family, the only safe emotion was no emotion at all. And I think there's just. There's a little bit of a stigma right around therapy that a perfect mommy vlogger would not want people to know that one of their kids needed therapy, because that's a reflection on the parent.
John Dehlin [01:35:41] And I also want to add. Thank you for that. I also want to add that at least in Utah Mormon culture, there's been a history of sort of feeling like if you read your scriptures and pray and are obedient and go to church and have a good diet and get exercise, you. You shouldn't ever need to go to a therapist. And in, you know, decades past, top church leaders, including Bruce McConkey, have even sort of denounced the mental health profession as being sort of of the devil. So there is kind of a cultural predisposition against mental health treatment. Although I think in the past 10 to 15 years, some of the apostles have tried to fix that, including Jeffrey R. Holland maybe giving a talk on depression. But there is a deep, woven cultural suspicion here within Mormonism against seeking mental health treatment.
Mindy Caldwell [01:36:38] Yeah. Yeah.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:36:39] And I also wanted to say, Megan, like, I think your voice is actually so important when it comes to this, because, you know, I've always joked, like, I know I. I know more about your family than I ever should, or your extended family.
Megan Conner [01:36:52] Sorry, Tim. You know, everyone does.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:36:56] And I don't mean your specific family, your mom and dad. I mean your extended family, your cousin Lori, you know, and Lori's family. And the Cox family and, you know, the Val. So. And I think that what I have seen is, right, sort of this idea when it comes to families like this, this, like, no mental health, it's very fearful. It's all sort of like, everything's fine, nothing to see here. And anyway, I just want to thank you for sharing your voice when you do interviews and on your own YouTube channel, because I actually see this as a theme when I cover a lot of cases where everything looks good on the surface and there's something that's not okay. And I think that's something I've learned a little bit more about covering crime. And so, yeah, I guess I just want to point that out.
Mindy Caldwell [01:37:46] Yeah.
Megan Conner [01:37:46] So thank you. And definitely that was the theme in my family. I asked for therapy when I was 13 years old, and my parents said no. And it was. The implication was that just exactly what you said, John, is that if you pray hard enough and read your scriptures hard enough and just give your burdens to the Lord, he will take care of them for you. And they didn't know at that point that I had severe trauma from my childhood, early childhood. But then there was ongoing trauma in my house growing up as well that they didn't want to acknowledge. And when I later, as an adult, went to my bishop and said, you know, I think that we need marriage counseling.
Megan Conner [01:38:25] We need. We need therapy. The bishop cautioned me against going to a therapist that was not church sanctioned because he said therapists have all kinds of wild ideas about what they think is healthy for you. You really need to go to a therapist who is Mormon, who's lds, who understands how important the faith is to you, so that they don't give you some kind of a treatment modality that's against our faith, you know, so there is that suspicion.
John Dehlin [01:38:53] Yeah.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:38:54] And I just want to make a quick clarification. I said the Vallows. What I meant by that was Lori Valo. I know that Charles Vallow was murdered recently and his trials coming up, so I didn't want to pinpoint that on.
Megan Conner [01:39:03] Right.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:39:04] Any. I just wanted to make that clear. Yeah. Any ballast? Okay.
Megan Conner [01:39:07] Lori's family. Yeah.
John Dehlin [01:39:11] Yeah. Well, that was really sad in a dark part. Thanks for sharing all of you around that. So I think maybe. Maybe we could talk about. About Chad a little bit. And, you know, Sherry wasn't the only victim here. You could argue that. That all of the seven or eight passengers were. Were victims as well.
Megan Conner [01:39:39] Yes.
John Dehlin [01:39:39] Anyone want to share their thoughts of what they learned about Chad before? Because it's Chad. That introduces Jody. Right. So anything, Anything. I mean, anyone want to talk about how Chad was depicted? That was interesting or.
Mindy Caldwell [01:39:53] Before we dive into Chad, I do want to mention that Sheri makes it clear very early on in the book that she will be naming Chad as her sibling. And none of the other siblings, there's no initials like they're hardly mentioned in the book except for of course near the end where. Where the children in Ivan's are discovered and of course her. Her concern for their safety, you know, as things were escalating. But I really admired that about her. She said they've been victimized enough and there's not a lot of mention of, of the other kids. And so Chad. Chad is the only sibling in the book that. That Sherry names by name.
John Dehlin [01:40:36] A great point.
Mindy Caldwell [01:40:36] Yeah.
John Dehlin [01:40:37] She said they deserve a childhood, basically. That was great point, Mindy.
Chad's Role and the Family's Unraveling
Megan Conner [01:40:41] Yeah. And also if we're going to try to stay chronological, I think we should mention too that Sherry starts her own YouTube channel.
Mindy Caldwell [01:40:48] Right.
Megan Conner [01:40:49] And she mentions this to Ruby. Ruby says she's going to approve all the content, but also that she will not shout out Sherry's channel on the eight Passengers channel because she wants Sherry to build it herself until she reaches 100,000 subscribers. 100,000 subscribers, which that's a pretty big feat to do on your own without any help from any other channels.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:41:10] Yeah, it really is.
Mindy Caldwell [01:41:11] Yeah.
Megan Conner [01:41:11] And so you know, Sherry's channel does eventually reach reach the mark and it's right around the same time that eight Passengers reaches a million views. And Sherry is willing to go ahead and give. Sorry. Ruby is willing to give Sherry the shout out on the channel, which she does. And then immediately after that she says to Sherry, by the way, I'm going to be taking 10 off the top as a management fee for you. And so there's no way that you
Mindy Caldwell [01:41:39] would have grown without. Without my expertise and my influence on you. Yes. Even though she never mentioned Sherry's blog that she worked so hard on.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:41:51] Yeah.
Mindy Caldwell [01:41:53] Is what Sherry calls it. She called it.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:41:55] And no.
John Dehlin [01:41:57] Yeah.
Megan Conner [01:41:58] She said, I just want to read this whenever. Whenever Sherry's quoting Ruby. You really think you would have. Do you really think you would ever have started a YouTube channel, let alone a successful one without my help? You owe me, Sherry. Business is business. Like to hear that from your mom, you know, that's really sad.
John Dehlin [01:42:19] Yeah. Yep. There's a. There's a. I mean, there's a way to interpret that you're trying to get your kid to be self sufficient or you don't want your kid to get into social media, so you're going to make it harder for them, you know, but the way the story's told, it
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:42:34] just seems not those things.
John Dehlin [01:42:38] Couple comments from our viewers. Marissa writes, I don't know if it's Marisa or Marissa. Keep teaching about the importance of recognizing the signs of child abuse and exploitation. We need to do more to protect children everywhere. Totally agree, Marisa. Vala Haux writes, you guys are amazing. I agree. Thanks for sharing your thoughts and knowledge with us. And then finally, Sequin writes, anyone else remember being taught to ask to shake hands with an angel so that you will know if it's an angel or if the being is the devil appearing as an angel of light? And then she actually cites doctrine and Covenants 129, which is modern day Mormon scripture where Joseph Smith quotes God saying that that's how you can tell a righteous angel from an evil, wicked spirit is by offering to shake their hand.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:43:31] Yep.
John Dehlin [01:43:31] That's a great.
Megan Conner [01:43:31] It's in the canon.
John Dehlin [01:43:32] Yeah, thanks. Thanks for that, Vala. Okay.
Megan Conner [01:43:37] To Chad.
John Dehlin [01:43:38] Yeah, no, that was great. And please keep jumping in. Y' all have done so much prep at any point. Reflections on Chad. Did you learn anything about him? She kind of paints him out as a jokester, a prankster, but also as an athlete. I didn't realize that he potentially was a good enough athlete to win a college scholarship. Did y' all know that?
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:44:00] No. But that was the most heartbreaking moment for me.
Mindy Caldwell [01:44:02] Yeah.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:44:03] Was that Sherry understood what they were making him give up and. And what they were asking him to give up were his sports teams. That everything that mattered to Chad were sports. That was what he had, was his outlet. That was his life. That was. Those were his talents, that he had scholarships possibly on the table. And because he was a. I would call it a typical teenage boy. That's how Sherry explains it. Just, you know, a bit of a. I don't know. I. I don't know. It sounds like a teenage boy to me. You know, a little goofy class clown that they didn't know what to do with him, how to reign him in. And so they took his sports away. And Sherry seemed to be the one that was just absolutely shattered for him. Not his parents, but Sherry. Yeah.
Mindy Caldwell [01:44:49] Did the sports getting takeaway happen before or after he went to the Anasazi?
John Dehlin [01:44:55] Yeah, maybe. Maybe we can talk about the Universal Studios Orlando episode.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:45:01] That was great. That was really proud of him.
Mindy Caldwell [01:45:03] Yeah.
John Dehlin [01:45:04] Someone want to recount it? Mindy, you got that one.
Megan Conner [01:45:07] Okay.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:45:07] Smart. In other words, yes.
Mindy Caldwell [01:45:09] Yeah, I. Let's look up. It's in chapter.
Megan Conner [01:45:12] I actually have. I can tell you. I can tell you, Mindy, because I'd love for you to read it.
Mindy Caldwell [01:45:16] Okay.
Megan Conner [01:45:17] It was. It's around page 90.
Mindy Caldwell [01:45:19] Okay.
Megan Conner [01:45:22] Where they talk about the biggest brand
Mindy Caldwell [01:45:24] deal, the wet ones.
Megan Conner [01:45:27] Wet Ones, Yeah.
John Dehlin [01:45:28] Okay.
Megan Conner [01:45:29] Yeah. So it's down. Our itinerary starts at the bottom of page nine. City.
Mindy Caldwell [01:45:33] Our itinerary was planned with military precision. Each camera worthy moment scheduled down to the millisecond.
John Dehlin [01:45:38] And where. Where are they? They're in Orlando.
Mindy Caldwell [01:45:40] They are in Universal.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:45:42] Hollywood.
Mindy Caldwell [01:45:43] Orlando. No, it's in Orlando.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:45:45] Oh, they're in Orlando.
Mindy Caldwell [01:45:46] It's confusing because it says Universal Studios Hollywood, but it's. It's in Orlando.
John Dehlin [01:45:50] Okay.
Mindy Caldwell [01:45:50] So, yeah. I vividly remember being in our van when Ruby said she had a plan. We're going to make a big mess so that we can show how well Wet Ones works. We made it gross. Gummy bears smeared on windows, slime everywhere. Chocolate all over everyone's faces. All to demonstrate the effect, the effectiveness of wet ones. It was all going so well until Chad brought the chaos. The park had opened early just for us, which was a big deal, so we could get footage walking through the empty park. But while Ruby was filming her brand deal talking points, her brand deal talking points in front of the iconic globe, Chad was being, in her words, an absolute punk, making constipated gargoyle faces and photobombing her carefully orchestrated brand content.
Mindy Caldwell [01:46:35] Ruby's dream of picture perfect family content was rapidly devolving into a blooper reel. So she banished him to the hotel room while the rest of us enjoyed the theme park. Chad, ever the rebel, wasn't about to let Ruby's parental decree keep him down. He snuck out of the hotel room, took a taxi, somehow sweet talked his way back into Universal Studios and had a great time by himself. When we got back to the hotel, he was gone. We had no idea where he was for a while. And that, as far as my parents were concerned, was the absolute final straw. In Ruby's and Kevin's eyes, Chad was becoming some kind of juvenile delinquent, a malfunctioning robot. And they just needed to find. To find some way to reprogram him. I don't know if we want to
John Dehlin [01:47:17] all keep so, you know, just really quickly. In family systems, sometimes there's the misbehaving kid, but sometimes that misbehaving kid is actually playing an important and a healthy role. Yes, in the family system. Y' all are nodding your Head y' all wanna.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:47:33] The malfunctioning robot, like, let me, you know.
John Dehlin [01:47:36] But what's the positive, potentially positive aspect of that, of Chad's behavior in this case? Right. What's it saying? What's. What's. Maybe let's theorize of what Chad's behavior is trying to communicate to the. The family.
Megan Conner [01:47:51] Well, when you grow up in this family system where everything is under the microscope and there's scrutiny and there's also reward for vulnerability online and your parents are really involved in the vlog, and that's their main focus, how else do you get attention? How else do you find out how your parents feel about you? You know, how else do you get noticed? Unless you're the one stirring up trouble, you know, so if you're. If you're the victim of childhood emotional neglect and you don't really have a face and you're just another one of the eight passengers, you know, how do you distinguish yourself? By acting out.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:48:27] And I don't even know if this was him getting into trouble. I think it was him coming up with a solution. First off, I feel really happy for the kids and understand why the channel maybe brought them some joy as they get to make a mess in their car.
Mindy Caldwell [01:48:40] Right.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:48:40] I thought that was a moment too, where they get to put gummy bears and put chocolate all over the face. This is a family that has to be perfect. And all of a sudden, because of this brand opportunity, they get to be messy. Like, already. That's fun. I'm like, I get why these kids are torn. Like, this is a moment where it probably was really enjoyable for them. And then they get to the park and Chad is again doing what I think is really great. He's rebelling. He's showing. This is ridiculous. Like, I want to be goofy. I want to be fun. I'm photobombing like that again, is joy.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:49:09] That's, I think, representative of what's going on in the car. You know, he's just continuing it like, I want. This is. I don't want to be a robot. We're at Universal Studios. And then when he sent home because. Or back to the hotel, excuse me, because he's not a robot and he's saying, let's have fun. He's going to say, you know what? I'm going to come up with a solution and I'm going to go back to the park because I'm a kid and we're here in Orlando and we're here to go to this park, and I'm going to go have a blast without you guys.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:49:39] So in some ways, I think he's showing this family what a solution is to this robotic lifestyle. And if. If they would only listen and see what he's doing, they could probably have a healthier family system. So I actually see Chad is coming up with some bit of a solution if they would just open their eyes.
Megan Conner [01:49:58] I agree with that.
Mindy Caldwell [01:49:59] Totally. Good.
Megan Conner [01:50:00] Yeah.
Mindy Caldwell [01:50:00] I wonder if he's starting to internalize and be resentful of just the perfectionism and just the. The phoniness of. Of what their life is, that I was proud of him when he's kind of pushing back as a parent. As a parent who sometimes wants things that you've planned to just go. Well, I get the aggravation for Chad's behavior, but knowing the whole story of what. What they'd endured, I mean, there's a story of Chad being a really little boy who is mischievous and cuts a little piece off of Sherry's hair, and Ruby punishes him by taking him to the bathroom with the clippers and shaving off a large section, like in the middle of his head as a punishment for doing this.
Mindy Caldwell [01:50:42] And, you know, those experiences, they build up. And I think that I. I think Chad, in this moment at Universal Studios, is just maybe pushing back at the perfectionist, you know, veneer that his family is trying to portray. And Chad knows very well how important this trip is for. For his family, you know, and, And. And I think he knew what. Which buttons to push with Ruby. And.
Mindy Caldwell [01:51:07] Yeah, I'm not sure he anticipated the response to that, but I don't know. I just see Chad as a fun, goofy, you know, a little bit naughty, just trying to, like, find his way, find his voice in this family.
Megan Conner [01:51:21] Yeah, I do see a little bit of that vindictiveness, though, knowing how important the shot was to Ruby and, And. And knowing that that was the time to push the button. And it may have been sort of a, you know, getting back at her for not treating him well or not, you know, giving him the sort of mothering that. That he wanted and needed. So the healthy side of that is if you have a kid who's acting up, you know, maybe consider why they're acting up and that they might need a little more attention or love or, you know, something that they're not getting. Right.
John Dehlin [01:51:56] I just think about how much I would hate the camera being in my face all the time and always having to perform for everything.
Megan Conner [01:52:03] Yeah.
John Dehlin [01:52:04] And another explanation is just rebelling and acting out, even subconsciously, is a Way to say this is stupid.
Mindy Caldwell [01:52:10] Yeah.
John Dehlin [01:52:11] Can we just have a family vacation and have fun? Why is the camera always on?
Mindy Caldwell [01:52:14] Yeah.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:52:15] Yeah.
John Dehlin [01:52:15] We're ruining this fun trip that we could have.
Megan Conner [01:52:17] You know, I agree with that. I also think it's important to note, you know, Sherry goes on to talk about this. This experience where they send. Right after this, they send Chad to a bunch of different therapists. And basically the therapists say Chad is too young for us to diagnose and pathologize at this point. He's, you know, he's a normal kid, basically, is what these therapists were saying. Which is why I think Ruby ends up reaching out to Jody because she sees a way for Chad to be diagnosed and pathologized. Sherry says not to mention. So he says he usually ran circles around those poor counselors, you know, but he said Chad was often the most manipulative person in the room. Turns out growing up on camera is excellent training for pulling the wool over people's eyes. That's good.
John Dehlin [01:53:09] Yeah. Well, that's where things. That's where the villain, the real villain, enters the. The picture.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:53:16] Yeah.
John Dehlin [01:53:19] At the. At the end of. At the end of part two, at the end of this chapter. Basically says, looking back, my parents should probably have just given Chad the space and time he needed to grow up. Teenagers act out. It's practically in the job description. But no, Ruby and Kevin couldn't fathom such a simple solution. Instead, they doubled down, more determined than ever to find a Chad whisperer. Someone aggressive enough to break through his defenses. Oh, boy. Be careful what you wish for. They were on a mission to find the perfect person to crack his code and rewire him to their liking, which is how the monster came into our lives.
John Dehlin [01:53:59] And then it says, a monster masquerading as a mental health professional armed with a tight smile, she would say, khaki shorts, I'm sure, and a mind full of psychological warfare tactics. A monster who would see my mother's inner darkness and cultivate it, nurture it, until it eclipsed all light. A monster named Jody Hildebrand. And that's when. That's when the villain is introduced. What do you think about that intro, Lauren?
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:54:29] It's powerful. It's really powerful. And again, she says. She says that will eclipse my mom. What does she say? That. That she. Again, this is this duo coming together.
Mindy Caldwell [01:54:41] That is this creation of this black hole. Light.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:54:46] Eclipse. All light. It's quite the intro because I imagine that Sherry looks back at that moment and just again and again and again. What Would have happened if Jody hadn't been suggested to the family what would have happened if she didn't enter the picture? This was the moment that such frightening things began. Yeah.
Megan Conner [01:55:06] To happen.
John Dehlin [01:55:07] Have y' all wondered where passengers would be if Jody had never come in? I guess they. I guess Ruby's behavior.
Mindy Caldwell [01:55:15] Yeah.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:55:16] Yeah. It was starting to take the channel down. Her behavior already. I want to say this, too, that it's interesting. So you said they were. They were looking for anything to rewire him, Anything to get Chad to their liking. I. I want to say too, like, this is something that I've learned about crime as well, and assessing the whys behind crime is that we are always looking for the answer that as they take them from counselor to counselor and everyone's like, look, there's nothing. Like, you're good. They're determined. No, there's got to be an answer. There's got to be a solution. And I think so oftentimes human beings, we just want an answer to everything, Whether it's Chad misbehaving, whether it's.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:55:54] You know, there are just some things that don't have answers. And I feel like it's such a slippery slope. And I see this in Ruby a lot. So I just want to point out that to her, there is a solution to everything, and there's going to be a absolute. An absolute solution to figuring Chad out. And that is such a slippery slope and something that's frightening. I think, when we think that there is always just something to learn that will give us that solution and there's
Mindy Caldwell [01:56:22] an urgency to getting your kid fixed.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:56:25] Yeah.
Mindy Caldwell [01:56:25] When you're, you know, when you have a very popular YouTube channel, I think there's. Maybe that's not the kind of content that she was hoping for. Like, how do we deal with our troubled teen? So I think that there was a sense of urgency in. In trying to figure out what was wrong with Chad, quote, unquote, versus just kind of letting him develop normally as a teenage boy who was goofy and. And gregarious.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:56:46] I know. So healthy, really, when you look at it, like, if this is trouble, you know what I mean? Okay. You know, all the things that could. You could be dealing with, you know.
Megan Conner [01:56:55] Yeah. He wasn't shoplifting or addicted to drugs or, you know, harming other people or anything like that that you see, you know, so many kids get sent away to. To boot camps or whatever for. He was just acting out. He was a class clown. He was, you know, mischievous.
John Dehlin [01:57:13] You know, he was messing up the. He's Messing up the video shot, Right?
Megan Conner [01:57:16] Yeah, exactly. So when Mindy, when you're saying, like, there's an urgency to get him fixed, but there wasn't an urgency to fix Sherry's problems, you know, it's like there was an urgency to fix the problem that he was messing up the content.
Mindy Caldwell [01:57:28] Well, he was more visible.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:57:30] Exactly.
Mindy Caldwell [01:57:30] Yeah. And Sherry suffering privately.
Megan Conner [01:57:32] Right. She talks about how she would shut down and distance herself, and she later gets in trouble for that too, because she's not engaging enough in the videos, you know, but fixing the problem of Chad messing up the content was pretty important.
John Dehlin [01:57:46] Why would Ruby want Chad to see a therapist but not Sherry?
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:57:50] Exactly.
Megan Conner [01:57:51] Because Chad was messing up the content.
Mindy Caldwell [01:57:53] I think what we're saying.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:57:54] Yeah, Chad needed to be fixed.
John Dehlin [01:57:56] Sherry was. Fell in line.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:57:59] Sherry's issue was that Sherry's issue was her internal. Was her own depression. That didn't bother Ruby. Chad's behavior was an issue to. To Ruby.
John Dehlin [01:58:12] It's a. It's the difference between internalized.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:58:14] Yeah.
John Dehlin [01:58:14] You know, and externalized.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:58:16] The issue was how it affected Ruby. It wasn't what was going on internally,
John Dehlin [01:58:20] what was best for the kid.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:58:21] Yeah. It wasn't what was best for the kid. It was what was best for Ruby.
John Dehlin [01:58:24] For the shot. That's for the money shot.
Megan Conner [01:58:27] Yeah, but that's a good point, Lauren. I mean, I think it's such a common theme that we. That we come back to over and over that these. These controlling people, like, all they care about is what is best for them. They don't care about how their behavior affects those around them. They. They have this lack of empathy, you know, this inability to really understand what they're doing and. And how it's going to affect someone. And we see this with the punishment that they give Chad by taking away his sports. Ultimately, Ruby has no idea how impactful that is to him. She just knows that that's the button to push to perhaps get him to. To fall in line more.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:59:09] When someone is so desperate for control and they are so desperate to control others, that is where crime can occur. So I'm just saying that that's a pattern I see in my reporting. I can't help but see how desperate Ruby is to control others and her children.
Jody Hildebrandt's Influence and Counseling Tactics
Megan Conner [01:59:22] So
John Dehlin [01:59:25] one part, the next. Next part that comes to my mind that was really disturbing was the way Sherry paints the picture. She learns about Jody Hildebrandt, immediately senses that Jody's off. And Sherry gives the impression that at the very beginning, she Googles Jody Hildebrandt, learns about Adam Paul Steed's experience. She doesn't name Adam Paul Steed in the book, which bothered me a tiny bit. I wish you would have just mentioned him.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:59:53] Him.
John Dehlin [01:59:55] His story is important. She mentioned his story without mentioning his name.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [01:59:57] Right.
John Dehlin [01:59:58] And then she mentions that she knew Jody had had her license revoked and had had acted super unethically back at the very beginning of the relationship. And it. It gives me the impression that if Sherry knew that, that, that, that Kevin and Ruby also would have known that about Jody from the start. But. So that was interesting that they were aware because I knew about Jody. Right. But I didn't. I could imagine a family along the Wasatch front. A friend says, hey, this. This therapist that can really help. And they don't even bother really Googling the therapist or Bishop recommends a therapist. And so they just see the therapist and they don't really know about sketchy behavior. So it surprised me to know that Sherry and likely Ruby and Kevin all knew about some of Jody's problematic behaviors from the start.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:00:57] I think what Sheri found took some digging, because when this case broke, the day it broke, I went digging and I found out about Adam Paul Steed, and I found out about people calling Jodi Hildebrandt a cult leader from like 2019. Yeah, there was a lot of past stuff on social media, but I don't know if it's something that Ruby and Kevin would have found. Some light Googling. It's more of like, wouldn't you agree? Like, Mindy's a sleuth. Like, yeah, you had to. You had to dig into their social media accounts and then scroll back to 2019 or find a certain profile.
John Dehlin [02:01:30] No, there was a solid Tribune article that basically said Jody Hildebrandt's a bad therapist that lost her license for violating client patient confidential.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:01:38] But that still wasn't a top Google.
John Dehlin [02:01:39] Okay, okay, okay.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:01:40] That's what I'm saying.
Megan Conner [02:01:40] It's still.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:01:41] You're still gonna have to dig. Like, so I. It. I don't know if it means that Kevin and Ruby. No, but it means that Sherry is smart and was like, I'm gonna find out.
Mindy Caldwell [02:01:51] Well, Sherry finds out and goes to Chad and says, I have a bad feeling about this lady.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:01:56] Let me tell you what I found out.
Mindy Caldwell [02:01:57] Yeah, yeah. And. And he replies to her, sherry, she's just some middle aged lady. If I don't do therapy with her mom's going to make my life even worse. I survived the desert. I can survive Jody Hildebrandt. And so he kind of, you know, pushes off her concerns. And then. And we found. I saw this pattern that made me sad. Chad rats Sherry out to her mom and says to Ruby.
Mindy Caldwell [02:02:22] She tells Ruby that. That Sherry's talking about. About Jody. And Jody responds, you know, sorry, I'm getting the names all wrong. Ruby. Okay, rewind. Chad routes out. Routes out Sherry to Ruby for raising concerns about Jody. And then Ruby's response is, anyone who doesn't like Jody is hiding something. So very quickly, I think Ruby allowed herself to get sucked into the cult of. Of Jodi Hildebrandt and her. Her way of thinking.
Mindy Caldwell [02:02:51] So that was. That was unfortunate to see the few times that. That the. That Chad would turn or, you know, Kevin would turn and. And Sherry just, you know, gradually just felt more and more alone. That she didn't have anybody in her family that she could turn to.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:03:05] Yeah.
Mindy Caldwell [02:03:06] To express concerns.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:03:07] Yeah.
Megan Conner [02:03:08] And there's also that dynamic in controlling family systems of ratting each other out as siblings. You know, the parents reward the kid who rats out the other kid. And so the kids not getting much validation from their parents, they feel this obligation to rat out their siblings because it's a way of gaining more acceptance and approval from their parents and, and sort of ingratiating themselves and saying, see, I'm on your side. I'm going to tell you when someone else is doing something bad, I know you appreciate. So it's just a bid for validation, I think.
Mindy Caldwell [02:03:40] And Sherry mentions that earlier she. I think she gets accused on. In the online community of like, sucking up to be, like, Ruby's favorite. And I love this quote. It's brief, but she says, I'm not sucking up. I'm surviving. There's a difference.
John Dehlin [02:03:57] So it seems like. And this is so Utah. It seems like one of Jody's first recommendations is that Chad go to a wilderness camp called Anasazi.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:04:06] So Utah.
John Dehlin [02:04:06] Why are you laughing?
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:04:08] Because it's. It's so Utah. I was a reporter in all of, you know, Utah and, and Idaho. It's a very Utah thing. It helps our economy, the laws here. Everyone goes and recruits all these wealthy families from back east. And it's. It's a thing here in Utah. It helps our economy. They promote these camps. You have people promoting them all over the country. This is a really weird thing about the state of Utah. And I think that everyone should be aware. Aware of it, because as a reporter, people need to be aware. And the way they are managed and the way they are not managed, and one reason we can get away with them is because we don't have some certain policies that other states have. This is a Utah thing, and it's something everyone should know about. So go learn about why Utah has a bunch of wilderness camps. I'll just say that.
John Dehlin [02:04:51] And I. And I'll. I'll say. I don't think I've said this before. I do have some close friends. We have some close friends that have worked in these troubled teams. So do I. And people I respect and admire, people who don't have any undue allegiance to the Utah or the church will say, a lot of good happens in these camps. So I don't think our point is that nothing good happens there. But on the other hand, parents are allowed to kidnap their children in the dark and have them be carried off by strangers because of weird laws in Utah that support this type of stuff.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:05:25] I don't doubt. I want to clarify. I don't doubt that there are plenty of good things that can happen in these camps. I'm grateful for good people that work at these camps. But I'm sure there's also a lot of good things that happen in the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints, too. And it's not all bad usually, but I'm telling you. But that there are policies and things about the system that are very, very concerning and people should not be looking the other way or just say because one child or a bunch of children are helped, things are going okay. There are a lot of concerns about this. And I'll shout that from the rooftop. We've got to fix the system in these camps.
John Dehlin [02:05:53] And just Google Paris Hilton Utah trouble teen kids.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:05:56] I'll just Google every. Every southern Utah camp that's been investigated or shut down or people being arrested because of how these schools are being managed.
Megan Conner [02:06:06] Yeah. And to your point, John, that, that parents are allowed. And I agree with you, Lauren, there needs to be more awareness about it because I've talked about this on my channel before and people will say, what? That's a thing? Yes, it's very much a thing. And to your point, parents can kidnap their. Their kids in the middle of the night and send them to these camps when they really don't need it. And I would argue it's like a
John Dehlin [02:06:27] girl has premarital sex with her boyfriend, she's kidnapped and sent off to a camp for six weeks or ten months, you know?
Megan Conner [02:06:35] Yeah. And. And it's the kind of situation where if the parents are the ones who get to determine what the definition of a troubled teen is, we're seeing a perfect example of it right Here, where Chad was just a mischievous kid, and he gets sent off to a camp where there are kids who are abusers and addicts and who actually have problems.
Mindy Caldwell [02:06:55] Criminal behavior.
Megan Conner [02:06:56] Criminal behavior. I would argue that perhaps the times where there has been a good result is when you have a kid with a legitimate problem that goes to a camp where he finds competent mental health help. And those are probably the stories of kids who have a good experience there. But the camps where they lump everybody in together and convince them all that there's something really terribly, horribly wrong with them when there sometimes isn't, that's when it becomes harmful. And I remember hearing one of the stories about a young lady who got sent to camp for having premarital sex, but she was in a group of kids who were basically drug addicts.
Megan Conner [02:07:38] And they were telling her. She was like, no, I don't have any of those problems. But the counselors were telling her that she had to confess, otherwise they weren't going to let her out ever. So she began thinking, well, I am an addict. I do have a problem. And so it ends up destroying the mental health of a lot of these poor kids who get sent to these camps for not a good reason.
John Dehlin [02:08:02] No, it's a real problem. And I know the legislature knows, and I know they're trying to contemplate reform because it's become a national embarrassment.
Megan Conner [02:08:12] Yeah.
John Dehlin [02:08:12] To Utah.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:08:13] Reform is. What I want is not to get rid of camp that can help children, but reform is needed.
John Dehlin [02:08:19] Yeah. So I thought it was interesting to find out that the price tag of Anasazi, which is Arizona, not Utah, $14,000 for 40 days.
Mindy Caldwell [02:08:30] I wrote down 49.
Megan Conner [02:08:31] 49. Yeah. 49 days.
John Dehlin [02:08:32] What, did I get that wrong?
Mindy Caldwell [02:08:33] 14,009 days.
John Dehlin [02:08:37] That's a lot of coin.
Megan Conner [02:08:39] Yeah, That's a huge.
Mindy Caldwell [02:08:40] She said her parents didn't think twice about it.
John Dehlin [02:08:42] Yeah, yeah, yeah. I call it a project, Chad. Quick fix.
Megan Conner [02:08:47] Anyway, which is why I think, you know, that's the other problem with these camps is the huge price tag, you know, the huge commitment for the family. And then if your kid doesn't reform in the allotted time, well, you can re up, you know, if you want to. But these camps are making a ton of money, and they probably don't pay their people very much as well.
John Dehlin [02:09:07] Yeah.
Megan Conner [02:09:10] So.
John Dehlin [02:09:11] So, yeah, Chad goes, I. That's when people started reaching out to me is. I think about it. There's a point where my viewers and listeners started saying, hey, John, are you aware of eight passengers? You know, did you hear that that Ruby sent Chad to Anastasie. And I'm like, who's Ruby and what's Chad and what's on a sassy. Do you all remember was that one of the first points where passenger starts to. To. To sort of get real public opposition?
Mindy Caldwell [02:09:43] I think the first time I heard about eight passengers was the beanbag. And we. And that's after sausage. But the beanbag story is. If I go back, I think that's the first time I started hearing about. About Apex.
John Dehlin [02:09:53] For me, it was Anasazi.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:09:54] Okay. Sheri states in the book that the beanbag scenario was the worst thing that happened.
Mindy Caldwell [02:10:01] Yeah, for sure. It tanked their channel.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:10:04] And the fact that Ruby didn't even realize it until like she, she knew the content and she was still okay putting it out because she was just so blind to realizing just how terrible it was. Making Chad sleep on the beanbag.
Megan Conner [02:10:18] I'm really fuzzy on the dates for all of this because I, I don't. I didn't know anything about eight passengers. So about what year would this have been when people started reaching out to you, John? About eight passengers.
John Dehlin [02:10:30] So I'm going to say 2021.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:10:35] Wow. Okay.
John Dehlin [02:10:36] 2020.
Mindy Caldwell [02:10:37] Like the beanbag incident happens in May of 2020.
John Dehlin [02:10:40] Yeah.
Mindy Caldwell [02:10:41] Is when that video comes out.
John Dehlin [02:10:42] That's the beanbag.
Mindy Caldwell [02:10:43] The beanbag.
John Dehlin [02:10:44] So it would have been. That's 2021.
Mindy Caldwell [02:10:46] That was 2020.
John Dehlin [02:10:47] Okay.
Mindy Caldwell [02:10:48] So they moved into the new house in Springville in 2019. So. Yeah. When do you think that, that you started hearing around that time?
John Dehlin [02:10:56] No, it was in this very room. It was in this very room where we had a threat. We had a faith crisis retreat. It's the retreat where I met Zach and, and Gerardo. Gerardo helps me. They came, but another attendee came and just started telling us that he was part of this twisted, distorted therapy group where some therapist had him sleeping on his mattress in his office. And his wife, he wasn't allowed to have any hugging or touching with his wife for six months. I learned about this.
Mindy Caldwell [02:11:28] That's the first time you heard about Jody Hildebrand.
John Dehlin [02:11:31] Yeah.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:11:32] Wow.
John Dehlin [02:11:32] And so I. So this guy, he's just this heartbreaking story of like it's just because I masturbated a couple times and now my wife wants to kick me out and she's going to these support groups where these non licensed therapists are all treating me like I'm an addict and they're encouraging my wife to kick me out of the home. And immediately I'm like, dude, come on, Mormon, I'll shut this woman down. Come on, Mormon stories and we'll tell the story. And he was like, I can't. I do mlm. I don't want to. I don't want to, you know, tell my story. I'm worried about what the repercussions might be. I'm terrified of Jody.
Megan Conner [02:12:12] Right.
John Dehlin [02:12:12] She's got her hooks into my wife.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:12:14] Yeah.
John Dehlin [02:12:14] And then I'm terrified that she might sue me. And so. And so that put me on notice about Jody pretty early on. But I could never. Even when people would reach out to me and say, I'm really concerned about Chad, I'm concerned about Anastasia, I'm concerned about the beanbag. I didn't know what to do because I'm not going to like, open the OSF up to a defamation suit by third, fourth hand me making a bunch of named accusations because that's how people like, you know, Jody would operate.
Megan Conner [02:12:48] Right.
John Dehlin [02:12:49] But at the same time, nobody. Everyone was too terrified to speak up. And so, you know, anyway.
Mindy Caldwell [02:12:56] And haven't you found that even since it's so hard to have anybody that will. And. And likely a lot of them are still active in the church, but especially now that all the scandal has brought out, it seem or has. Has gotten out. It seems like it's real quiet. Nobody wants to come forward and talk about their experiences.
John Dehlin [02:13:14] Yeah. Yeah. Okay. So Chad goes on Asazi, he comes back and then, you know, he starts
Mindy Caldwell [02:13:22] therapy with Jody weekly.
John Dehlin [02:13:24] Yeah.
Mindy Caldwell [02:13:25] For himself.
John Dehlin [02:13:26] Yeah. And. And it's quite a bit of money, right?
Mindy Caldwell [02:13:29] Jody's $175 an hour.
John Dehlin [02:13:31] Yeah.
Mindy Caldwell [02:13:31] For her private coaching.
John Dehlin [02:13:33] But then also it's. It's like this funnel because she starts with one member of the family, but then she starts saying they don't just need individual. That you're rolling your eyes. Lauren, do you want to continue?
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:13:43] Oh, I just. I can't stand her business model. I can't. It's disgusting.
Mindy Caldwell [02:13:46] I think.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:13:46] I think you have to sometimes have no soul to be able to take every, you know, manipulative business. Business, you know, model there is, and put it into just one. And that's what Jody Hildebrandt did. She took. She took the funnel, she took the mlm. She took the, you know, the. Here's a better deal. She. I mean, she. She took the cult, she took the team, she took the 10 percentage of the coaches. I mean, what did she do? And then she bought a $5 million home with it. I mean, she is. No shame. I mean, sometimes, you know, I've always said I'm like, man, sometimes I wish I had no shame so I could just be wealthy. Like, she took everything from these people. I mean, every. Every sketchy business model there was, and she put it into connections, and people are like, okay, sign me up. I'm just like, oh, it's just Manning.
John Dehlin [02:14:36] It reminded me of L. Ron Hubbard with the Scientology and the auditing, where you get somebody to tell all their deepest, darkest secrets so you could use it against them. Right.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:14:45] Yep.
John Dehlin [02:14:45] And then, so there's individual stuff, but then she's got the group stuff, and then she does couple stuff, and before you know it, she's got her hooks into the entire family. And families are paying thousands of dollars a month.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:14:58] Yeah.
John Dehlin [02:14:59] Or more to the point where they're hitting up grandparents, draining retirement funds to be able to pay thousands of dollars a month for Jody's support.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:15:08] Reliance isolation, Reliance separation, like, everything. Yeah, it's a.
John Dehlin [02:15:14] It was a cold. It's a full blown cold.
Mindy Caldwell [02:15:16] Yes.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:15:17] Brainwashing. Yeah.
Megan Conner [02:15:18] Can I point out one. One more thing that is a common recurring theme. This is when Sherry is pushing back against her mom. And you know, when. When Ruby finds out that Sherry has defamed Jody to Chad. Sherry says, but, mom, she had her license suspended. Her own kids don't speak to her. Ruby says, her kids couldn't handle the truth. She's been called by God to help people. So this is the recurring theme we see all the time. Somebody says they're called by God, they have a special mission, and that gives them license to take your money and to indoctrinate you into their cult so that they can have power and control.
John Dehlin [02:16:01] Okay, so. Oh, Mindy.
Mindy Caldwell [02:16:02] Oh, no, I just was agreeing. I said, yep.
Jody's Cult-Like Hold and Isolation Strategies
John Dehlin [02:16:04] So, okay, here's another question that I have highlighted, and I have my own internal debates about this. Is it fair. Would it be fair for someone to say that the Mormon church prime and high demand religions, broadly prime people such that they would be susceptible to a cult leader?
Mindy Caldwell [02:16:28] Yes.
John Dehlin [02:16:29] So, Lauren, you immediately said, well, yeah, you want to expand? Or.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:16:33] I mean, yeah, I mean, Sherry says it in her book. She says that it's similar. She says that these people are all. She says that her mom thought she was like Joseph Smith and that Jody thought she was like Joseph Smith. And so Joseph Smith is the founder and first prophet of the LDS Church. He is the one that, you know, taught people and converted people to Mormonism and started Mormonism. So when you have Jody Hildebrandt saying, I'm like Joseph Smith, and all these people are primed to believe in Leaders and follow authority then and to look for answers from a higher power then. Yes, like they are people that follow any religion or, or again, also, I wanted to say prime through.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:17:12] We're talking about family systems through an authoritarian family system are also going to be primed to want to follow somebody so that they can tell them what to do. You know, and the LDS Church is also part of that. You know, with authority.
Mindy Caldwell [02:17:27] I think we're taught to trust, you know, trust the church members and church leaders without proper vetting and maybe sometimes pushing down your intuition that something might be wrong. I think you trust. And I think when they were introduced to Jody, they were introduced by a trusted friend.
Mindy Caldwell [02:17:43] And. And then you get into the machine of it, right? And you start getting involved and you see that there's all these people that maybe are in your circle and. And I'm sure that. I'm sure that there are some. Some aspects. Am I being too generous by saying there may have been some aspects that were helpful for some people? In fact, Sherry says that like after Jody got involved in. Or after Ruby got involved with Jody, she did yell and, and was kinder, although then she said her psychological and manipulate manipulative abuse ramped up, which Sherry thought was even worse. But I just think we're primed to just trust and, and to outsource our own authority instead of like looking inward to our personal authority.
Mindy Caldwell [02:18:31] I think we're so conditioned to outsource. So if there's somebody who's claiming to be. Have answers or have like a more of a closer connection for whatever reason, but Jody, it. It stumps me. Number one, she's a woman. You know, like, I am honest for sure, but I'm. Honestly, I'm stumped that. That somebody like Jody, not just a
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:18:53] woman, a woman wearing khaki shorts.
Mindy Caldwell [02:18:55] Yeah, it's. It's really actually perplexing because it kind of goes against the norm cult and especially like, you know, adjacent to Mormonism. It's fascinating to me. So she must have had, you know, I think she just must have had some such, you know, manipulative powers and convincing methods that she was able to convince people. I think often to your interview with her niece Jesse, where Jesse talked about Jody, Jody's own child, saying that she didn't feel safe around her mom because she said my mom is so convincing that she would tell me that if she told me the sky was yellow, I would believe her.
Mindy Caldwell [02:19:38] And I think. And Sherry even says where her parents want her to have therapy with Jody. And Sherry's looked into Jody enough to know that there's some real problems there. And Sherry says in her book, over my dead body was I letting that woman anywhere near my brain? That was her initial reaction. And she ends up having to have therapy with her. But yeah, she ends up becoming an acolyte for sure. For a time. Yeah, for sure. She was, she was a perfect little Jody robot for a while.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:20:11] Yeah.
Megan Conner [02:20:11] And I was gonna. Just off of what you were saying, Mindy, I totally agree with you that we in the church are conditioned not to self validate. We are conditioned to seek our validation from our priesthood leader.
Mindy Caldwell [02:20:26] Right.
Megan Conner [02:20:26] Who tells us if we're worthy or not to go to the temple. And so because we don't learn that self defense validation and we outsource it to other people, it makes us particularly susceptible to someone like Jody who speaks authoritatively, who has a mental health degree and a license. At one point it was suspended and then she went on to practice without her license. Just as a coach. Right. But she's had that experience and she does speak with power and she is convincing and charismatic. And also I think the insight speak that she developed sort of made people go, oh, that's a different way to think of it. Maybe I'm thinking of that word wrong. It's not that I'm experiencing depression. I'm in distortion.
Mindy Caldwell [02:21:13] We have to bring up truth and distortion.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:21:14] Yes.
Mindy Caldwell [02:21:15] Which Sherry describes as two innocuous words that would soon become the bane of my existence. And I think that that was, you know, crafty on Jody's part to. To develop these words that would explain pretty much any scenario that you're going to be in in life. You're either in truth or you're in distortion.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:21:32] Yeah.
Megan Conner [02:21:32] And you're talking to, yes, black and white thinking. And you're talking to a population of people who genuinely do want to improve and become better and become more righteous or more able to follow the rules. And so she's presenting this new way of looking at it. You're also talking to a population of people who is not used to healthy mental health language. And so you've got Jody presenting this new language and members of the church are going, oh, I never thought of it that way. I've never considered this as a mental health concept before. So it does absolutely make members of the church vulnerable to someone specifically like Jody.
John Dehlin [02:22:15] I'll add, we know from, you know, the arrests and from the pen papers that, that Jody and possibly even Ruby were meeting with Brad. Was it Brad Wilcox or Jeremy Yagi? Like a Mormon general authority.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:22:30] It was the journal, actually. We never got. We were never given the pen papers.
John Dehlin [02:22:34] Okay, the journal.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:22:36] Yeah, the journal. By the way, the pen papers. You can actually see law enforcement handle the pen papers. Or is it pen papers?
Mindy Caldwell [02:22:43] Pen papers.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:22:44] The pen papers in the body cam footage. It's so painful to watch because Kevin has explained what they look like and how they give it to him, and then they put it back, and I. You just want to scream, no, but the journals. Yeah. Brad Wilcox was.
Mindy Caldwell [02:22:58] Brad Wilcox, I think it was.
John Dehlin [02:22:59] Yeah. It's like Ruby writes, Jody was meeting with Brad Wilcox, who's one of the top leaders in the Mormon Church. Jody's meeting with. With Jeremy Auggie, a top general authority in the church. And what I'm saying there is. I know it was part of Jody's modus operandi to tell everyone, and I think it's true that she had relationships with top Mormon church leaders.
Mindy Caldwell [02:23:25] Oh, she used that flex, for sure,
John Dehlin [02:23:27] that they didn't know how to treat masturbation and pornography, but that she did. And so she. That sort of reverence and deference to authority was an important part of what led people to be susceptible. Because how many of us, when we were orthodox mortal Mormon, if we heard, oh, I just got out of a meeting with Boy K. Packer or Jeffrey R. Holland, we'd be like, oh, yeah, I'm paying attention. We know that Tom Harrison invited her to be a part of his kind of therapy conferences.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:23:58] Yeah. Yep. And so God, back into therapy. Yeah.
John Dehlin [02:24:02] And then. And then finally, just this. The. The. The morality, the. The porn and masturbation shame doctrine. And fear is. Was just her money. That was her money train. If that didn't exist, I think if there weren't the obsession in the Mormon Church with porn masturbation. And I want to be clear, I am not standing here as, like, some big fan or proponent of porn. That's not the point. But the point is, if the Mormon Church hadn't pathologized pornography use to such ridiculous, toxic degree, given how prevalent it is, there would be no Jody Hildebrandt in the way, because she was just getting her fuel off of that outrageous, excessive obsession with what psychologists would say, at least in terms of the masturbation part is healthy, normative behavior that created Jody Hildebrandt, in my opinion.
Megan Conner [02:25:02] Yeah. And I think, John, you were the one who told me that Jody was instrumental in helping develop the church's addiction recovery program, which labels anyone who watches pornography at all as an addict. And I can't tell You. How many young men and adult men have mentioned to me, either in private conversation or anecdotally to other people, that they went through the addiction recovery program because they were forced to by a spouse or by a potential girlfriend or potential. Someone they were engaged to because they had looked at porn once or twice. And the insistence was, well, you have to go to addiction recovery at the church before I'll continue to see you or before I'll marry you or if our relationship is to continue. And. And these. What these men were describing was, as you're saying, just normative behavior that was pathologized and labeled addiction. And that's one of Jody's main tactics.
John Dehlin [02:26:03] It was her cash cow.
Megan Conner [02:26:04] Yeah.
Mindy Caldwell [02:26:05] She takes it even beyond that. She. There's the woman who cheated, quote unquote, because she noticed that her mailman was attractive. And, you know, I think that Kevin had a. An experience where he admitted that he found another woman attractive at the gym. And so, I mean, this.
John Dehlin [02:26:22] We're not even talking.
Mindy Caldwell [02:26:24] Yeah. We're not even talking about, like, porn and masturbation, although certainly that would be, you know, demonized by her as well. But just any type of sexual impropriety or what she, you know, what she described as that would be considered distortion. And one of the most disturbing ones that comes up in the book is. Is convincing these poor husbands that them showing any. Any affection to their daughters is hinting at inappropriate affection or incestual. Yeah. Or pedophilia. Yeah. I mean, it's just. She just twisted and got into the minds of. Of these. These people that were part of her program in such a damaging way.
John Dehlin [02:27:07] Yeah.
Megan Conner [02:27:07] Well, I guess if finding people attractive is being in distortion, then I'm in distortion like 100.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:27:14] I want to know what the postman looks like.
Mindy Caldwell [02:27:16] I'm like.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:27:17] I want to see picks.
John Dehlin [02:27:19] Well, clearly, Jody was in distortion. She was. She was hot for Ruby, right?
Mindy Caldwell [02:27:24] Yeah. I think that. I think we haven't quite gotten there yet, but I think that that's so much the root of all of this that we're talking about. Probably goes back to her. Her repression of her own sexuality.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:27:35] Yeah.
John Dehlin [02:27:36] Let me read a couple big. I mean, I don't know if you've got something you want to read. Let me just read a couple comments really quick and then go ahead. So Cosmically Forsaken says, can we also talk about how Jody ended up Sherry's first session asking her about Sherry, talking badly about her. We did cover that. Cosmically Forsaken. So rewind a little bit and you'll definitely hear us talking about that. But thank you, my good friend Brett, who invites me to basketball every Thursday. I've only been able to go once. I want to go again. Brett writes, well, when I was working for the highway patrol, we often got called out to use the helicopter to search for the kids that ran away from the wilderness. Therapy programs at taxpayers expense.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:28:18] Wow, that's interesting.
John Dehlin [02:28:19] That's dark. Thank you, Brett Hutchings, for that. I'm going to get to basketball soon. Don't stop inviting me. Brett Dehendio07 writes, I don't. I didn't know that Jody had kids until today. Now I'm interested what her kids think of her. John, get on the case. We need the tea. We need an interview. Well, go back and, and listen and watch my, my Jesse.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:28:44] Yes.
John Dehlin [02:28:44] Yeah, Jesse talks about that Jesse Hildebrandt interview. Also Lauren, you've interviewed Jesse as well.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:28:51] Jesse, not Jesse, only Adam. Paul Steed.
John Dehlin [02:28:54] Okay, okay. Well, Jesse goes by they, them pronouns and Jesse's. I've interviewed them twice. Super articulate. Jesse talks about it. But I was going to just make this joke like how's the world that a woman who's kind of masculine presenting, who's divorced and whose two kids are totally estranged from her and who's lost her license in a super uber patriarchy in Utah was able to gain so much power? I mean, I'm summarizing what we've been saying for the past, you know, 15 or 30 minutes. But yes, Jody was completely estranged from her own children and had a messy divorce. It was married for like 12 minutes, you know what I mean?
John Dehlin [02:29:37] And it's just so weird that she was counseling on marriage, on sex, on parenting. It's just mind blowing. So anyway, thanks for that question. There's one more quickly I wanted to share. Thanks. No, that's it. Thanks to everyone for the, for the donations and the super chats. So Megan, did you have another point you wanted to make about?
Megan Conner [02:30:01] Well, no, I'm just kind of going through what I marked in the chapters where Sherry talks about Jody's counseling, quote unquote counseling and, and all the different tactics that she uses. And you know, when I finished, probably it was after isolation tactics, winning the self loathing Olympics because you have to do that in order to be acceptable to, to Jody. Then you know, Jody gets Sherry to keep this rigorous personal inventory of all the things that she's doing wrong because, you know, Sherry comes up with a list and Jody goes, well, that's kind of half hearted. I Don't really think you're trying hard enough.
Mindy Caldwell [02:30:40] Oh, that right. Was heartbreaking.
Megan Conner [02:30:41] Yeah.
Mindy Caldwell [02:30:43] Like all of the tiny little things. Seven instances of whatever.
John Dehlin [02:30:48] You know, she just like being prideful.
Mindy Caldwell [02:30:49] Like, you know, that's in chapter 20. It's. The chapter is called Dirty Laundry. And this, this line broke my heart where Sherry says, working with Jody was a dream come true for my inner mean girl. I'm like, oh, poor Sherry, that's tough.
John Dehlin [02:31:05] Meaning that that Sherry was already, with her scrupulosity and ocd and depression, was already beating herself up enough, and Jody needed. Needed something to come at her with. And so since since Sherry wasn't externalizing her bad behavior like Chad was and she and Sherry was pretty much being the good girl, then Jody had to flip it and like, say, you're being prideful, you're being too confident, you're not humble enough, you don't have enough empathy, you don't have enough.
Mindy Caldwell [02:31:35] You're engaging in adulation, you think you're better than everybody else. That's one thing she talked about.
Megan Conner [02:31:39] Yeah.
Mindy Caldwell [02:31:40] Yep.
John Dehlin [02:31:40] It was like a psychological warfare.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:31:43] Yes.
Mindy Caldwell [02:31:43] Psychological warfare. Warfare on this poor girl.
Megan Conner [02:31:46] To answer the question of how did. How does Jody do this? I think she got really good at gaslighting people and she knew exactly what to say to push the buttons to get people to hate themselves, basically. And, and to think, oh, man, Jody knows better than I do about my own experiences. I better listen to her. And, and this is really telling too. Jody confronts Sherry about what Sherry said to Chad, basically saying, chad, don't listen to her. Don't go to her for therapy. And so Jody says, before we hang up, I'd like to address something. Sherry, I heard you had some disparaging things to say about me.
Megan Conner [02:32:23] Oh, crap. Blood rushed to my cheeks. Oh, I'm sorry about that. Jody says, don't be sorry, be real. Fine. Yes, I had some concerns. Then Jody says, I said, be honest, Sherry, you are spreading gossip, lies, and rumors. Would you consider that to be compassionate behavior, or do you prefer to blindly believe everything you see on the Internet?
Megan Conner [02:32:49] So can you imagine vulnerable Sherry with this therapist who has an incredible amount of control over Sherry's well being and where Ruby has literally sung her praises, you know, and said how wonderful she is, and so now Ruby is. Or sorry, not Ruby. Jody is telling Sherry that she has been spreading lies and gossip and asking her, you know, would you rather just outsource your critical thinking and believe everything that you read, or do you want to be honest? It's like somebody in a vulnerable position.
Megan Conner [02:33:28] You know, Jody is clearly taking advantage of that disparity, you know, that. That power differential to gaslight her. And Sherry says, well, I mean, if it's the truth. I started feeling like I was walking into a verbal minefield. Oh, you're going to learn a lot about truth, Sherry. You'll love it. Chad does, and he's much better now, isn't he? Jody said brightly, shifting gears. He seems more respectful, I said quietly. And your mother doesn't shout as much as she used to, does she? It was true. Ruby didn't raise her voice as much as she used to since she'd been in Connections. The question is, this is Jody speaking.
Megan Conner [02:34:09] Are you willing to do the same work to be a happier and more fulfilled person for your family and one day for your spouse? Sure I am, I said, feeling like I just signed a deal with the devil, or at least the devil's life coach.
Mindy Caldwell [02:34:24] I love that.
John Dehlin [02:34:27] So I think, I think a really important part of understanding not just Sherry, but also what ends up happening to Kevin is Jody's tactic of isolation. And I've got that flagged. Margi flagged it for a starting 100, page 106 at the bottom, but maybe, maybe Mindy. Oh, actually, let's have Lauren Reeve. So Lauren, at the bottom of page 106 it starts talking about Jody's tactics around isolation. And this ends up being important for both Sherry and Kevin as well. Do you mind just reading until you feel like.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:35:03] Yeah. Where does it start?
John Dehlin [02:35:05] Starting with the self imposed isolation was part of Jody's 106, bottom of 106.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:35:10] Yeah, this self imposed isolation was part of Jody's twisted rings of responsibility concept. If you were distorted, you'd be stripped of every responsibility except self improvement. No jobs, no community, no family. Just you and Jody's teachings in a vacuum. Solitary confinement. But you have to pay for the privilege. All in the name of healing. These separations typically lasted at least six months, the minimum time Jody deemed necessary to demonstrate genuine change. Her logic, which is a good business
John Dehlin [02:35:43] model, by the way.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:35:44] Right, I know, I know. Again, like that's what I mean. Every sketchy business model, Jody's like, boom, she's on it. Her logic was that anyone could fake remorse or make short term adjustments, but sustaining change for half a year proves sincere transformation and a better paycheck for her. Yeah. Adults were essentially put on probation in their relationships, expected to prove their worth to Jody to earn back the privilege of family closeness. The six month rule also applied to kids and Any significant transgression could result in a half year sentence of restricted privileges, increased scrutiny, and constant pressure to demonstrate change.
John Dehlin [02:36:28] Yeah, like. And that's how I met. You know, my contact is just. He was sleeping on a mattress in his office because he was under that six month probation. Right? Yeah.
Megan Conner [02:36:41] And then now we understand why Kevin didn't see his family for an entire year.
John Dehlin [02:36:46] Yeah, yeah. And you have to understand Adam Paul Steed's story to maybe have a chance at understanding Kevin. Because not only would Jody say, you know, it would start with, okay, husband moves out and sleeps in another room. And then it was, oh, husband relapsed. No hugging, no touching, no kissing, no emotional connection for six months. And then inevitably, the husband's sleeping alone in a room night after night with no sexual connection at all. Of course he's going to relapse and at some point masturbate. Right. And then that's a relapse. And that's when Jody would encourage her support groups to pressure the wife to kick the husband out of the house.
John Dehlin [02:37:32] So that's kind of like central to the con. But then what Adam Paul Steed's story tells us is that if you. As a husband, and it wasn't always a husband, but I think it was mostly the husband because. Because Sherry does talk about kind of this being a male hating sort of group.
Mindy Caldwell [02:37:51] Kevin says that when he comes home from one of the first things, he's like, it's just a bunch of men hating women.
John Dehlin [02:37:56] Yeah, yeah, yeah. So it's. And, and, and at that point, if the man ever stands up to Jody and tries to defy her, Jody ends up convincing the wife that the husband is sexually molesting the kids and then starts to get police potentially involved.
John Dehlin [02:38:18] And that's why. And again, you know, sometimes people get after me for thinking that I'm a Kevin apologist. I think we can talk all day long about Kevin's accountability. But how could. How could Kevin have been absent for six months to a year? I'll tell you how this is. If Jody had him afraid that if he violated Jody's isolation rules, that she was going to turn him into the police as a. As a child sex abuser?
John Dehlin [02:38:47] That's. I mean, I'm speculating a little bit, but that putting the pieces together, from the contact that I made at my retreat to Adam Paul Steed's story and others, I could see why, even with lesser things, Kevin would have been terrorized.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:39:01] He wanted his family back. If he wanted his family back, he was supposed to stay Away Dumb. Yeah. That's what Jody. That's why, like, that's what Jody did.
Megan Conner [02:39:11] Yeah.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:39:11] It's incredible, right? If you want your family back, stay away from it. Is it crazy? Yeah, but that's. That's her tactic.
John Dehlin [02:39:17] Yeah.
Megan Conner [02:39:18] And also just a couple of things that, you know, one of the things I learned from Adam Paul Steed's interview is actually the first step that Jody does is she puts the men in a separate group. Men in one group, women in another group. And when you first go to group, all these men are already convinced that they are addicts, that they are bad, that they're shameful, that they're engaging in these horrible behaviors, and they're essentially the MO of the group is to get the new person on board with the same way of thinking. Because if I remember correctly, Adam Paul Steed said that he went into this men's group and they were all, you know, confessing, like in an AA type of situation, you know, hey, I'm.
Megan Conner [02:40:00] My name is Matt, and I masturbate, and I'm an addict. You know, Adam was thinking to himself, that's not me. I'm not a pedophile. I'm not, you know, distorted. I don't masturbate that much, whatever it was. And then he said, just gradually he realized that he had to accept that otherwise there were going to be repercussions from Jody. Like, if you don't accept that this is bad about you, then we're going to take the next step and it's going to be more invasive. So it starts with this idea of self betrayal. It starts with gaslighting. It starts with making you doubt your own experiences and.
Megan Conner [02:40:37] And then it goes all the way, you know, to isolation and, you know, all of these repercussions. And I think. And I'm obviously not. Not a man, but, John, maybe you can lend to this. I think a lot of men are terrified in this day and age of being wrongfully accused of some kind of sexual misconduct. You know, I. I've spoken to so many men that that's, like, one of their greatest fears. And so they'll do just about anything to avoid even the appearance that something like that is. Is going to be happening.
John Dehlin [02:41:06] Absolutely. While we're on this topic, let's just jump to page 199. And again, any of you jump in. We're kind of jumping around a little bit here. But on page 199, Sherry talks about how Jody saw sex everywhere. It. It starts with literally, Jody saw sex every. Do you want to read it, Mindy?
Mindy Caldwell [02:41:29] Sure. Jody saw sex everywhere. In every interaction, every glance, every fleeting thought. In her mind, the world was a cesspool of lust and distortion, a roiling sea of Desire, a 21st century Sodom and Gomorrah, with only her twisted version of truth offering any salvation.
John Dehlin [02:41:47] And I think the next paragraph's just
Mindy Caldwell [02:41:49] a part of me pitied her. A repressed, self loathing, deeply damaged woman trapped in an environment in which she felt compelled to. To conceal her true nature. Surrounded by women she couldn't have, Women who were married to men she resented. In her mind, there was only one path to justice. Crush the sperm donors and liberate the females.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:42:10] Wow, that's such a. That's such a paragraph, right?
Megan Conner [02:42:13] Yeah.
John Dehlin [02:42:14] Very well written.
Megan Conner [02:42:15] So.
John Dehlin [02:42:15] So I guess there was that obsession with. Is Jody, you know, lesbian? Or is. Was. Was Ludy. Was. Was. Was Ruby lesbian or were they bisexual? Did y' all even want to talk about that? Is that just too dumb or.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:42:29] No, no, I think it's important. I think it's an absolute question that everybody's had. Every. Every interview you and I have done have talked about this. Everybody's wondered, and Sherry certainly delved into it, which. Is she queer? Yeah. Is. Is Jody queer?
Megan Conner [02:42:44] And.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:42:45] And is her mother?
Megan Conner [02:42:45] Is.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:42:46] Is Ruby? And she actually also discusses Ruby's sexuality. And the answer is yes. The answer is they. They were physical. And at one moment. I mean, I hope I'm not jumping too ahead. I'm the one just talking off of memory. I don't have the books in front of me.
Mindy Caldwell [02:43:02] You're great.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:43:03] But one moment. Is that. That Jody moves in with the families. She moves out of Paige's home. She mentions Paige Hannah, right? Yeah. I don't think she says Paige Hannah, but we know it's Paige Hannah. She moves out of Paige's home and into the Frankie's home, and she is staying in Sherry's room. So Sherry gets kicked out of her room.
John Dehlin [02:43:21] Can I just pause and say how ridiculously unethical it is for a therapist or even a coach to be living with their clients?
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:43:29] I know 100. Well, not only that, but in the same bedroom. So she takes over Sherry's room, and it's Ruby and Jody's room, and nobody's allowed to go in there unless you text first.
John Dehlin [02:43:38] Your kid. Your kid's a senior in high school.
Megan Conner [02:43:40] School.
John Dehlin [02:43:41] It's your last year with your kid, and you're gonna kick them out of their bedroom so that some weird stranger can come live in their bedroom?
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:43:49] The therapist with who's going to then be with your mother in your bedroom.
Megan Conner [02:43:55] So.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:43:56] And that nobody was allowed to go in there unless you texted. And that Sherry goes in there once and she notices massage oils and candles and all these things, and she's like, this looks like somebody's honeymoon suite. And then she does her thing. And then she goes in there once
Mindy Caldwell [02:44:09] and I can't remember.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:44:10] Oh, no.
John Dehlin [02:44:10] She.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:44:10] She sees one in the middle of the night. She's up late. She watches Ruby come out in a robe with her hair disheveled and looking.
John Dehlin [02:44:19] Smile.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:44:19] With a smile on her face. Readjusting her robe. And then go back in thinking that nobody saw her do that. And. And that she does. And then in the end, jumping head reads her. Reads stuff on the laptop that she got during that search that Kevin was mad that she grabbed some things. She saw confirmation of their physical relationship so that we can now know that they were physical. And then Sherry. Sherry speculates that her mother, too, is private in being, you know, queer. So there's your confirmation. I mean, if you didn't. I don't know if any of us needed more confirmation. I think we've all had a lot of confirmation. But. But there you go. Their. Their relationship was physical. And those are the things that Sherry saw and experienced.
Mindy Caldwell [02:45:07] There wasn't a note. This is again, jumping ahead at the information that was. That was gleaned from the laptop that she says something like, Ruby complained that she, like, had to be a giver, but, like, wasn't a receiver or something like that. And I think that Sherry. It was. It was kind of an interesting little note in the book that's important. I forgot that it made me think. And perhaps this is a, you know, different time to talk about this, but. Or there's another time to talk about this, but I wonder. I wonder how, like, was Ruby really queer? Or do you think she was just under the spell of Jody and. I don't know. I don't know. It's interesting.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:45:49] Sherry speculates that she is. So I'll just. Yeah, I. I think we all wonder that. According to Sherry. That's what I think was interesting. I think. Think more so than Jody, because I think we all kind of knew is that she speculates that her mother is indeed. And. But it's private. So that was interesting. According to Sherry. And what you just brought up, Mindy, is important that the thing she reads where she realizes that they have a physical relationship is that Ruby is upset that Jody is always asking for physical. And what about Ruby? Like, she she wants that too. And so she's shocked that all of a sudden her movie, her, her mother is the giver in this relationship.
Mindy Caldwell [02:46:26] Like the tables had turned.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:46:27] The tables, yes. Yeah,
John Dehlin [02:46:30] yeah. And then there's, there's also the scene where Sherry comes back home and wants to go into her bedroom and Kevin says, you're not allowed to go into there unless you text first.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:46:45] Yeah, yeah. Her own bedroom. Her own bedroom too. Let's just like put that in.
John Dehlin [02:46:50] She can't go to her own bedroom, per Kevin, because no one can go into the bedroom with, with Ruby and Jody and Pam.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:46:58] Right, right.
John Dehlin [02:47:00] Unless they text first.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:47:01] And I'll say this too. You know, Sherry discusses this too, like she just can't believe it. Sherry seems to have a lot of disgust, I mean, rightfully so, about Jody. She talks about her appearance, she talks about the way she eats, she talks about, you know, the khaki shorts. And she just can't believe. I mean, you can tell that Sheri is sort of appalled by this person in, in many ways that now is like living in her bedroom with her mother. Like she just can't wrap her mind around what is happening to her family. Like, how did this happen?
Mindy Caldwell [02:47:36] I just think that Jody's a walking contradiction. She talks about health and taking good care of yourself, but they're, they're going to Dairy Queen every single day. And she talks about, you know, Jody eating, consuming gallons of ranch dressing and she doesn't keep herself clean.
John Dehlin [02:47:52] And, and also she, I mean, not to shame this, but Jody was self harming with, with, you know, scars and cuts up, up and down her arms. And she would always wear long sleeves to cover the self harm, not to shame it, but just to show the. The physician needed to heal thyself. Keep going. I'm sorry.
Mindy Caldwell [02:48:12] No, I just think. I just think there's just so many contradictions in the methods and the principles that she was preaching as part of connections that she herself, the rules didn't apply to her. And I think you find that in cults, the cult leader can do whatever they want, but they're still going to preach these principles to their followers.
John Dehlin [02:48:35] And I'm always just, whether it's Keith Renery or L. Ron Hubbard or Warren Jeffs, like cult leaders are, are just predictably dorky or dweeby looking so often.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:48:49] Throw in Chad Dabel, throw in Chad Bell if we're going to go there.
Megan Conner [02:48:54] Yeah, no, I know, I know.
Mindy Caldwell [02:48:55] So it's, it seems rare that it's just like a really dynamic.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:48:59] Right.
Megan Conner [02:48:59] There's Something.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:49:00] Yeah, yeah, No, I know. I agree.
John Dehlin [02:49:03] You don't think Chad's cute?
Mindy Caldwell [02:49:04] Fascinating.
John Dehlin [02:49:06] I'm kidding. I'm sorry. It's dark. Okay.
Megan Conner [02:49:10] No.
Visions of Glory and Prepper Ideology Connections
John Dehlin [02:49:16] All right. I just dropped all my pages. Okay, so really quickly, is it worth mentioning the Visions of Glory stuff? It's on page.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:49:26] How dare you say that? You get the band back together and then you say, is this worth mentioning?
John Dehlin [02:49:30] You can give. Give, Give Lauren the book. I think it's on one page. 158 where it gets mentioned. But if y' all want to say anything in terms of background or memory, let's. Let's go there. Since this is the Visions of Glory. Chad and Laurie Davis.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:49:47] Yeah. And which chapter is this? It's a couple chapters.
Mindy Caldwell [02:49:49] 26.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:49:50] Okay, this is 26. So I'll read this. And then we also have to read some as a chapter. It's the True Crimes.
Megan Conner [02:49:55] Chapter two is important.
Mindy Caldwell [02:49:56] Yes, yes, very important.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:49:57] Okay, so we'll get there. So tell me where to start. I see Charles the Lion underlined. That's important. That's important. We can't forget Charles. But where do I. Where does this.
John Dehlin [02:50:07] Wherever you are.
Mindy Caldwell [02:50:07] Here, let me find.
John Dehlin [02:50:09] I mean, the Visions of Glory part is like the second main paragraph.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:50:13] Oh, there it is.
Megan Conner [02:50:13] We're introduced.
Mindy Caldwell [02:50:14] We're introduced to Pam Botcher, the friend, and they become kind of a. She calls them the Three Musketeers of the Apocalypse, but. Yeah.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:50:21] Oh, yep, yep. Okay. So they're talking about the apocalypse. You know that. Yeah, I'll start there a little bit.
Megan Conner [02:50:27] So let's.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:50:27] Yeah, let's start with the Apocalypse, because I think that's important. So Pam, Jody's oldest and dearest friend. We know. Pam Botcher. That's where the older siblings are found. High up in connections. Was always popping by with a case of soda and a high pitched hello that set my teeth on edge. The three of them, Ruby, Jody, and Pam, would hole up in my old bedroom for hours on end. They went boating in Lake Havasu in Arizona for a week and would make little shopping trips down to Mexico, coming back with grocery bags full of pills. When I asked about it, Ruby claimed it was all part of their grand plan to stockpile antibiotics for the end of days.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:51:04] Put a pin in that. We got to talk about that. It was as if they had formed their own exclusive Apocalypse Collective, and the rest of us were decidedly not on the list. They, like many doomsday preppers in the LDS Church, were obsessed with a book called Visions of. Of glory, published in 2012. The book not endorsed by the mainstream LDS Church was a wild ride of near death experiences, apocalyptic visions and doomsday prophecies. It became the basis for many LDS prepper fantasies feed into into their fears and justifying their extreme preparations.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:51:43] The book's contents range from New Age style spiritual encounters to graphic descriptions of impending disasters, foreign invasions, viral plagues, massive earthquakes devastating the entire United States, including our own Wasatch front. It was all very trippy and apparently very convincing to Ruby, Jody and Pam. So, and tell me if I'm wrong.
John Dehlin [02:52:08] I don't know if I remember this right, but when this story was breaking in our episode, were we speculating the Visions of Glory might have been involved?
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:52:16] We talked about it. We showed. We showed. So when this story broke, that was actually the first episode that John and I did was showing. By the way, Tom Harrison is absolutely connected to Jody Hildebrandt in Tom Harrison is absolutely connected. And this Visions of Glory book to Chad and Lori, Chad Dabel and Lori Valo, to Jody Hildebrandt and Ruby Frankie and to Tim Ballard. That beginning story that's still developing and we went through all of it. The one thing we did struggle with was we could show that Jody Hildebrandt was absolutely connected to Tom Harrison and to Visions of Glory. But we had a hard time pinpointing Ruby Frankie.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:52:56] So now we know with the fact that absolutely they were into this book. And another thing that's really important to point out too, I've been to Jodi Hildebrandt's house. I visited it and it is a prepper enclave. And I even asked, you know, I was there, she had food storage. And when we talk about these pills in Mexico that they claimed that they were storing up. One thing I have learned in these like very sort of extreme prepper groups that are, you know, part of the LDS faith, but these LDS members that are sort of finding these, their little on claim of LDS preppers is they are not just stockpiling food.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:53:32] And I think this is important to explain. They do stockpile drugs, including illegal drugs as well as firearms, because they believe that they are going to be trading them in the last days too. Using them, trading them, exchanging them. This is not just, I guess I just want to point that out when because I like I said, I have been into kind of delving into these extreme groups. They are not just stockpiling food and water. They are stockpiling a lot of very interesting things because they are ready to barter in the last days.
John Dehlin [02:54:05] Yeah. So I wondered because You. You read about what's going on in these rooms behind closed doors in the Frankie home in Springville. And I wondered if they were taking psychedelics and they were sneaking off to Mexico to get psychedelics, and then that true, too.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:54:19] And then let's throw that antibiotics as well.
John Dehlin [02:54:23] Is that right?
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:54:23] Probably. Let's throw in that. Yeah. They were probably stockpiling them, and then we can also assume what else they were doing with them.
Mindy Caldwell [02:54:30] Yeah, I know. There's been some speculation about Kevin's police interviews.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:54:34] Yes.
Mindy Caldwell [02:54:35] When he was talking about witnessing with his own eyes that, you know, he had seen, like, plates fly across the room at the house in Ivan's, and. And really strange things. And maybe there's some speculation that perhaps he had, you know, purposely or inadvertently taken psychedelics that were causing him to maybe see some of that stuff. So that's a theory that I've seen.
Megan Conner [02:54:56] Yeah. And my question when I heard about that was, was he being given psychedelics without his knowledge?
Mindy Caldwell [02:55:02] Yeah, that's what I said. Either, you know, purposely or maybe. Or not inadvertently or.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:55:08] Yeah.
Mindy Caldwell [02:55:08] Or, you know, I agree.
Megan Conner [02:55:10] Lauren, I remember you interviewing my cousin Braxton, who is an extreme prepper.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:55:16] Yes.
Megan Conner [02:55:16] And he talked about some of this, about storing things that, you know, a lot of preppers had alcohol and cigarettes and things like that that they were storing. I remember him telling us as a family at one point that he had hundreds and hundreds of pounds of coal buried in his front yard, you know, because fuel sources and whatever. So I guess it doesn't surprise me to hear that they're also going to Mexico to get drugs and to store those types of things as well. But it's troubling.
John Dehlin [02:55:45] And, Lauren, why does it matter? Why does the Visions of Glory connection here matter? Why does the prepper connection matter? Like, other than just we made a connection. Great.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:55:54] Well, I'll tell you why It Matters from Sherry's book. And actually, I'm sitting here looking for my phone that I had because I do have the screenshots that I wanted to share from the next chapter that talks about.
John Dehlin [02:56:03] Is it right under your right by your knee? That's not your phone by my knee.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:56:06] This is the battery charger that was. I've totally had. I've totally had it.
John Dehlin [02:56:12] You did it under your leg.
Megan Conner [02:56:14] Right. Right there.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:56:15] Okay.
John Dehlin [02:56:15] You did. You did a screenshot of a. I have a screenshot.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:56:19] So why does it matter? I'll tell you why it matters. Okay, well, Sherry will tell you why it matters.
John Dehlin [02:56:23] Okay.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:56:25] Yeah. Thank you, Sherry. So. All right. Okay. So this is from the chapter True Crimes. Shortly after. So from Sherry's own words, shortly after moving into my new shared apartment, I sat with my new roommates in the living room watching a true crime documentary, Sins of Our Mother. Pause real quick. That's actually a documentary on Netflix that I worked on. My husband John is in it. Dr. John Matthias is a psychologist in that it's on Netflix. And I also suspect that maybe now I understand a little bit of the play on words with her book. Hers is the house of my mother, and this is Sins of Our Mother.
Watching True Crime Coverage From the Inside
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:57:07] So I'm speculating there, though. So I sat with my new roommates in the living room watching the true crime documentary, Sins of Our Mother. It was about an LDS couple, Lori Vallow and Chad Dabell. They had gotten married super fast after both their spouses died under sketchy circumstances. Chad's former wife, Tammy daybell, died in October 2019 under suspicious circumstances. And Lori's former husband, Charles Vallow, was shot and killed by Lori's brother in July 2019.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:57:36] In September 2019, Lori's two children, Tyler Ryan, 16, and Joshua JJ Valo, 7, were reported missing. Lori and Chad married in November 2019, just weeks after Tammy Dabel's death. And while their kids were still missing, the couple were immersed in these same extreme religious beliefs and doomsday preparations as Jody and Ruby. And the way this family spiraled into darkness felt horribly familiar. Their intense belief in the Second coming and their obsession with Tom Harrison's visions of glory prophecies, it was all the same stuff Ruby and Jody were always going on about. But it wasn't until watching that documentary that my hope faded into the darkest thoughts I'd had yet.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:58:24] That Ruby and Jody were just as unhinged as Chad and Lori, if not worse. If we don't do something soon, my siblings are going to die. Why does this matter? Because we are seeing a copycat and repeat crime. And I have always stated, I do believe these children were about to die. I do believe that if that little boy had not escaped, they would not be here today. And they were dubbed that they had demons in them. And this.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:58:53] This book is affecting a lot of people's extreme beliefs. And we have not just seen it once now we have seen it twice. And why does it matter? This is why Sheri Franke realized it in that moment. My siblings are about to die. This book is concerning. It is not the end all, be all. There are many facets here. Of course, I agree it's not the book's fault, but it is a book that the LDS Church has not openly discussed.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [02:59:23] They outed Julie Rose books. I want to point that out. People say, well, they don't ever out a book. They don't ever talk about books that aren't mainstream books. No, they do. They made sure everybody knew that Julie Rose books were not to be read. And they called it spurious spirit spirits. Spurious material. They have not yet said this book is concerning. This book is problematic. And that in itself concerns me. And it is something that is on my mind all the time and something that I have angst about. Angst about all the time. This matters. And we need to be talking about it and be aware.
John Dehlin [03:00:00] Yeah. And in the reporting we did on our Visions of Glory episode, you know, we found out that not only was Visions of Glory, at least across a year to the most sold book in Utah according to Thrift Books, but that Tom Harrison. And by the way, the book Visions of Glory doesn't have Tom Harrison's name. It has a pseudonymous Spencer. Spencer. Right. But we know Tom Harrison's the author. Not only do we now know that Tom Harrison was directly connected with Neal A. Maxwell and likely Mormon apostle, a late Neal A. Maxwell, but that likely Tom Harrison has been consulting the Mormon Church as a mental health professional at a very high level for multiple decades. And that not only when, when this book started to be viewed as a problem, was, was Tom Harrison not disciplined or excommunicated. We found out that he was made a bishop.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:00:59] Yeah, they, they, they threatened excommunication. He wrote a letter, he apologized, and then he was made a bishop. And he has always worked closely with the LDS Church, including mental health, with missionaries, if a missionary can is ready to go. And when you bring up Brad Wilcox meeting with Jody Hildebrandt or other leaders, I can't help but wonder.
John Dehlin [03:01:18] Oh, of course.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:01:19] If Tom Harrison was helping that Tom Harrison started the. The Bringing Eternal Core, Bringing God Back into therapy. He worked closely with many LDS leaders. And I have also always speculated why hasn't the church talked about this book? Why haven't they said this book bad? Don't you know? Yes, it's not sold a deseret book that. But they haven't said like they have other books that this is a bad book. And it makes me wonder who's friends with who here. I am very concerned that this book. And you know, yes, you're right. And then we also know as a fact that Chad Dabel was indeed meeting with Tom Harrison, as was Julie Rowe. So Chad Dabell was meeting with Tom Harrison. Ruby or sorry, not. Jody Hildebrandt was meeting with Tom Harrison. This book has a cult following within this place. This book talks about death and destruction and earthquakes and a lot of demons.
John Dehlin [03:02:19] Evil spirits.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:02:20] Evil spirits entering you.
John Dehlin [03:02:22] Possession.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:02:22] Possession. It's, it's something that is very. Yeah, I keep saying that. I'm. Now I'm repeating myself. Rinse and repeat is very concerning.
John Dehlin [03:02:32] And the church knows how to excommunicate people because they excommunicated me for doing a podcast. No, I don't know of anyone who's killed anyone because of Mormon stories or at least associated with it. Touch wood, like knock on wood. But they know how to excommunicate. Sam Young for advocating for the sexual abuse of children. Natasha Helfer for promoting sexual mental health practices. They know how to excommunicate somebody if they're causing trouble. To this date we know of no negative consequences to Tom Harrison for any of this. Not that we wish ill upon him, but retract the book. Take the book away. Pressure John Pontius's widow. Widow to take it down. The church could shut this book down if they wanted to, and they don't.
Megan Conner [03:03:14] But they won't.
John Dehlin [03:03:15] Yeah.
Megan Conner [03:03:15] And the reason I believe that they won't is because it supports their theology. It is a faith promoting book as far as they're concerned because it supports the idea of, you know, the afterlife of the end times. It supports, supports the idea of prophets coming back from dispensations and ruling. And in the back of the book there is a very similar vision that was given by a prophet of the LDS Church and it supports that vision. And so if the LDS Church were to denounce this book, it would destroy some people's faith.
John Dehlin [03:03:49] It'd be denouncing its own doctrine.
Megan Conner [03:03:51] Its own doctrine, its own theology. And that's the number one reason why they won't do it.
John Dehlin [03:03:55] It.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:03:55] Well, you know, I disagree because I think I'll disagree with it because I think Julie Rose book also supported some of that theology and they, they disowned that book. I, and I think they were clearly concerned about the book when it first came out because they threatened excommunication according to the letter that Tom Harrison had to write. I don't think Neil Maxwell would have been happy with it necessarily. That's, that's personal opinion. So I'll do that. I think that they don't because they know many people believe in it.
John Dehlin [03:04:20] Too many people.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:04:21] Too many people love it. I do agree with the faith promoting. I Don't. I do agree with the faith promoting, but they have said that certain books, even if they promote certain faith inspiring things, don't meet all doctrinal requirements. And I think that Julie Rose book inspired people in a similar way and they denounced that book. So what is it about this book? I think that too many people love it and there are too many people supporting it. And it makes me wonder who is supporting, supporting it. Yeah, that's what I wonder about.
Megan Conner [03:04:50] Yeah, I agree with you. Yeah. And it's another one of those areas where if the church makes a definitive move in one direction or the other, they're going to lose a lot of people because some people love it, some people hate it. And also I think an important point is that when they did threaten Tom Harrison with excommunication, they said, you need to stop talking about the book publicly. You need to stop saying that it's literal.
John Dehlin [03:05:10] Because he's going around to wards giving firesides.
Megan Conner [03:05:12] Giving firesides. And we have recordings of those that we played on our last episode that we did about this. And Tom Harrison said, okay, I'll write a letter and anybody who asks me about it, I'll say, this isn't literal, it's not real. So faced with excommunication, he towed the party line. He did what the brethren told him to do and they want to reward him for it.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:05:32] And now he's. Exactly. Megan. And now he's contradicting himself though, because he tells some people this was all John Pontius has nothing to do with me. He, you know, John Pontius is. This is John Pontius fault. This is not what I told him. But then according to John Pontius's widow, who's publishing a website, she's saying, no, Tom Harrison supports this and he's signing off on this website. So, so, so what's he. And I think also the secret of under, you know, underground, sort of him being underground makes it a little bit more enticing and exciting too.
Megan Conner [03:06:04] Yeah. So publicly he says it's not real. The church told me to say that it's not real. These are just my own ideas. And then in private meetings with Chad Daybell, he's saying, but it really is real. Yeah, it really is real. Go ahead. And you know, your visions are just as real as mine. You know, I believe in the power of what God told you as well. And he's, you know, I, I remember the recording that you have on your channel, Lauren, of when likely Chad and Lori met in person for the first time, where Chad is Giving a. A speech at a fireside. And Chad is giddily describing how Tom Harrison talks in this book about he can literally mold rock. And it's just clearly so fascinating and alluring. Yeah, Chad Daybell was clearly very fascinated with that.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:06:51] Well, let's talk about this. So your cousin treats that. Sorry, Lori Valo. Your cousin Lori Valo treats that a book still like scripture.
Megan Conner [03:07:00] Yes.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:07:00] And she's a. She's about to represent herself in her second murder trial of her husband, Charles Valo. And she still believes strongly in this book. I know that from many people now, multiple sources who have communicated with her behind bars. I have seen the receipts. As we say, she is still preaching that book, believing strongly in that book and encouraging people to read that book. So if you want to know about what the Gospel of Lori Valo is, you can know straight from Laurie. And if you now want to know what the Gospel of Ruby Franke and Jodi Hildebrand is, Sherry, Frankie just told us, and it is the Vision of Visions of Glory by Tom Harrison.
John Dehlin [03:07:41] Go Google. Everyone go to Google Images and Google Lori Valo poolside, which is the photo when she was first confronted by police officers.
Megan Conner [03:07:51] She was served.
John Dehlin [03:07:52] What book is under her knee when she's poolside? If you zoom in, it'll be Visions of Glory. So we've definitely beaten this horse dead.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:08:00] Yeah. Well, no. Well, I'm gonna, like, throw one more thing out there, though. But. But the other thing about it is when it comes to poolside, I actually forgot what I was gonna say. I was like, that needs to be said. And then you said, we'd be like, no, one more thing. And now I'm like, having short term memory loss.
Megan Conner [03:08:16] It was poolside in Hawaii just after she had married Chad. And the police were for.
John Dehlin [03:08:22] The kids are dead. Like, yes. Ex husbands are dead, right?
Megan Conner [03:08:25] Yes. And the police are coming to her to present her with papers that essentially say, you have so many days to present your children or to produce your children or you're going to be arrested. And, you know, they ask her if she understands everything. She says, yes. So now she's. Now she's going to be representing herself and she's. We, you and I both have talked to people who are speaking with her during. In prison right now. And she has her copy of Visions of Glory. It is marked up just like a Bible. She's been Colby reported on his channel. Colby is Lori Valo's oldest son, her only living child, her only surviving surviving child.
Megan Conner [03:09:06] And Colby said that his mom is in prison with her little cohort of people that she believes that she's helping by preaching about Visions of Glory and by, you know, preaching her version of the gospel to these women who are also on death row.
John Dehlin [03:09:25] Yeah.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:09:26] And my memory never came back, so we'll move on, and. And then in, like, an hour, I'll be. I'll raise my hand.
John Dehlin [03:09:30] That's great. Mindy, you didn't say anything about Versions of Glory.
Mindy Caldwell [03:09:33] I feel like it's been covered. We talked about it a lot. I appreciate. I appreciate some of the things. I mean, as I've said before on previous podcasts, Visions of Glory is the reason I started getting interested in the daybell case, which, you know, has now kind of snowballed into these other, you know, these other cases that we've covered because of my own family member who gave it to me and. And who firmly believed it and probably still does.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:10:01] So I know what I want to say.
Mindy Caldwell [03:10:02] Okay.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:10:03] I know what I want to say. And it's.
John Dehlin [03:10:04] We all stalled long enough for Lauren. Thank you, Laura. That was good, you guys.
Mindy Caldwell [03:10:10] I saw the light. I saw the light flick on for you.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:10:13] It's actually about disinformation that's out there.
Mindy Caldwell [03:10:15] Yeah.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:10:16] I. I want to. I want to just clarify something, so. Because I have a moment when we. I came out with the letter that Tom Harrison sent me, and there's a lot of disinformation online about people that love this book and defend this book, and it's that the letter isn't real. So I just want to, like, take the opportunity to say the letter was written by Tom Harrison in 2014. He sent it directly to me. He addressed the envelope. He wrote on it, it came from him, he signed it, and it came to me. There are a lot of people speculating that this letter isn't even real and that it was made up. So he wrote this letter in 2014 denouncing the book that he sent to me. And I just want to say right now, it is real, and it came from Tom Harrison himself.
Megan Conner [03:10:58] And I stand as a witness that I have seen that.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:11:01] I've got three witnesses. I've got three witnesses.
Megan Conner [03:11:03] I have seen the envelope. I've seen the postmark, I've seen the
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:11:06] address, but I still have it. That's the difference. I still have the letter. I got the letter. So it's not somewhere else now. Yep. It's not hidden.
Megan Conner [03:11:12] That's right. It's not hidden. It hasn't been taken up from the earth by an angel. It still exists in the physical Real form.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:11:19] I got the receipts.
John Dehlin [03:11:22] Well, Julie's laughing behind the scenes, so. So now maybe it's time to turn to. For me, what was maybe the darkest part of this book, which is the part about Derek, which I think was a surprise to. I mean, obviously we still have the incarcerations and the kids, but I think this is an okay place to talk about Derek. Is that all right?
Mindy Caldwell [03:11:47] Agreed.
Megan Conner [03:11:47] Yeah.
John Dehlin [03:11:48] And Derek is a pseudonym, but this. Does someone want to just kind of recap? For those who haven't read the book yet, this is a spoiler, but we got to talk about it. Got to talk about Derek. So for those who haven't read the book yet, who wants to kind of recap Derek?
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:12:02] Do you want to do that, Mindy?
Mindy Caldwell [03:12:03] Goodness, I'm nervous. To recap Derek, you're the best equipped.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:12:07] You got the vibe.
John Dehlin [03:12:09] Do we know where Sherry meets Derek? I'll do a little description. So, Derek, I. I assume that when Derek meets Sherry, he's in his mid-40s, he's living somewhere in Utah county, and she's just to say 15, 16.
Mindy Caldwell [03:12:26] No.
John Dehlin [03:12:26] Well, years old. When they don't know when they don't
Mindy Caldwell [03:12:29] know when they first meet.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:12:29] We don't know when they first meet.
Megan Conner [03:12:30] Well, she says in May 2021, right after I graduated high school, he asked for my help with social media strategy for his company, offering me a side gig to help him put together videos for YouTube.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:12:40] Yeah, but they knew each other, though.
Megan Conner [03:12:42] They already.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:12:42] Yeah, so we don't know when they officially met someone that she knew. Will you read that, though? Yeah, read.
John Dehlin [03:12:47] Yeah, yeah, he's married. Go ahead.
Mindy Caldwell [03:12:51] We should just read from.
Megan Conner [03:12:52] Well, she says this is page 146 near the bottom. She says my rebellion started small in ways that might seem inconsequential to an outsider, but felt monumental to me at the time. One of these small acts of defiance with my friendship with Derek. It started innocently enough, I suppose, a friendship that turned into something else. Derek was high up in the church, a family man and landowner in his 40s. In May 2021, right after I graduated high school, he asked for my help with social media strategy for his company, offering me a side gig to help him put together videos for YouTube. Having just turned 18, it meant a lot to me that a respected adult like him had singled me out and recognized my skills and talents. After my first meeting with Derek, he couldn't stop singing my praises.
John Dehlin [03:13:40] And this quote, I have to say. This is quoting Derek. This is Sherry quoting Derek. Quote, I have to say Sherry, you really impress me. He said once. The way you think, the way you see the world, it's refreshing. You're mature way beyond your years. And again, this is a man in his late 40s who is. I'm gonna just say, grooming Sherry as a super impressionable, very vulnerable, very vulnerable young woman.
Mindy Caldwell [03:14:10] As soon as I read that line, you're mature way beyond your years.
Megan Conner [03:14:12] Yep.
Mindy Caldwell [03:14:13] Just my prickles just went, oh, no. Where's this gonna go?
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:14:17] Yeah.
Megan Conner [03:14:17] And then almost immediately, she starts confessing to him or confiding in him that she is unhappy in her family situation. And he's like, oh, tell me more. Because that's a way that predators find a way to victimize people, is by finding out their weak spots and the places that they're missing things in life. And then they show up and provide those things.
John Dehlin [03:14:38] And so he kind of employs her. Correct.
Mindy Caldwell [03:14:41] Right.
John Dehlin [03:14:41] And so it's a working relationship, but very darkly. It starts to turn sexual.
Megan Conner [03:14:49] Yeah. And this is a part that I. I start and. And probably should have highlighted and underlined as well. But this is where it starts to get dark. It says he started doing little things. Kind gestures that made me feel seen, cared for. This is on the next page. 148. A door dash delivery. When I was having a tough day. A little shopping trip. If I needed something, even if I didn't. One day he told me, his voice low and intense. I'm the only one who really cares about you, Sherry. You know that, right?
Megan Conner [03:15:18] Each time he sent me gifts, I felt a little guilty, pressured, somehow. This man who was showing me so much kindness. But for some reason, I wasn't always sure I liked it. One day I accidentally called him dad. And that was the first time I saw Derek angry. I think we're more than that, aren't we? He said, his face a storm cloud. I didn't mean to offend you. Please don't be mad. When I eventually told Ruby that I was working with him, she had a fit and forbade me from seeing him any further. I have a really bad feeling about this guy, she said, jody and I don't think it's appropriate for you to be working with him one on one like that.
Megan Conner [03:15:54] Tell him you have to stop. Okay, sure. I'll stop talking to Derek. I lied. I was sick of people telling me what I should do. I was 18 and old enough to make my own decisions. Besides, I knew why they didn't like him. It was because Derek had been Jody's neighbor and probably knew too much. That's why Jody didn't want him in my life. Well, guess what, Jody? Oh, well, guess what? Jody wasn't the boss of me anymore. And very soon Ruby wouldn't be either because I was going to college in the fall, which meant I was an adult now and no longer answerable to anyone except God.
Shari's Early Adult Years and Sexual Assault
John Dehlin [03:16:26] Then it goes on to talk about once Sherry leaves home and starts attending BYU is the first time in my memory that Sherry reports having a sexual encounter with Derek. And it progresses and it progresses and it progresses to the point where he's tracking her location, he's asking her who she's with at any moment, he's calling her and saying where are you bringing your gifts? And, and, and the relationship lasts for a few years. Am I right?
Megan Conner [03:17:05] Yep.
Mindy Caldwell [03:17:07] Yeah, I think we're going to get pushback if we don't talk about that first encounter that they had. That.
John Dehlin [03:17:12] Do you want to read about it?
Mindy Caldwell [03:17:14] You all know what I'm talking about, right?
Megan Conner [03:17:15] Yeah, it's on page 165 is where it's starts. I didn't, I didn't dog ear it until 166 because that's when the real manipulation comes in. But it was basically her first day at college if I remember correctly.
Mindy Caldwell [03:17:31] You want to read it?
John Dehlin [03:17:32] You want to read it, Mindy?
Mindy Caldwell [03:17:33] Sure. This is chapter 27 and it's titled Dirty Shameful, Ruined. So the, the lead up to this experience is she, it's her first day and Derek by this point they've, they've been seeing each other in this, you know, quote unquote professional scenario. Although like Megan mentioned, there had been gifts and, and lots of compliments and she had mentioned to him that she was uncomfortable with some of his compliments and, but. So they'd had a lot of contact with each other, a lot of texting it sounds like, and, and stuff. So.
Mindy Caldwell [03:18:10] So it's like her first day of freedom. She's back at her dorm room and she says that. Suddenly a text lit up my phone. How's your first day, Sherry? It was Derek, right on cue. Want to stop by the office later once you're settled in? I got you some back to school gifts. Remember that North Face jacket you said you wanted? Wow. Thank you. See you later. And then she describes. I don't remember driving to his building. I wasn't sure why I felt so nervous. In hindsight, perhaps it was my intuition trying to tell me something to turn around, go back my college dorm and never talk to this middle aged man again.
Mindy Caldwell [03:18:45] But I didn't do that. And by the time I arrived, I was gasping for breath, my vision narrowing to a pinpoint. Should I just continue reading through this experience? Sherry, what's wrong? I heard him say as I stood at his door. I can't, I choked out, my chest heaving. I can't breathe. I think I'm having a panic attack. Derek guided me to the couch, his hand gentle on my shoulders. I tried to focus on his voice, on the steady rhythm of his words, but the panic was rising like a tidal wave threatening to pull me under.
Mindy Caldwell [03:19:18] Sherry, listen to me, he said, his voice cutting through the static in my head. I think skin to skin contact will help you calm down. Can I take your shirt off? I froze, my mind reeling. No, I thought. No, no, no. But my mouth wouldn't work. The words stuck in my throat, and I shook my head, tried to push him away. But he was stronger than me, his grip iron tight around my wrists.
Mindy Caldwell [03:19:43] I'm getting emotional. Sorry. Trust me, he murmured, his breath hot against my ear. Just let me help you, Sherry. And then his hands were on me, rough and insistent, yanking my shirt up, exposing my bra, my skin. I squirmed, I fought, but it was useless. He was bigger than me, stronger than me, and the more I struggled, the more powerless, powerless I felt. See, he said. It's not so bad now. Just relax for me. Be a good girl. Somebody else can take over.
Megan Conner [03:20:12] Yeah, I honestly, I. I kind of think that's enough. You know, I don't think we need to like detailed everything else. But what. What was really telling for me and, and unfortunately familiar is that at the end of this she says she doesn't remember how she made it back to her dorm that night.
Megan Conner [03:20:31] It's like the dissociation, you know that that is so telling of such a traumatic experience that she doesn't even really remember getting back to her dorm. And she just laid on her bed for hours and hours. And she says I couldn't meet, I couldn't move, couldn't think, couldn't feel. I laid there for hours, staring at the ceiling as the world went on around me. I heard the laughter, the chatter of my fellow freshmen through the walls. But I was separate, cut off. I've sinned, I thought. I've ruined everything. It felt like a punishment, a divine reckoning for all the ways I had failed, all the ways I had fallen short.
Megan Conner [03:21:08] In my mind, my frozenness, my inability to move was a sign from God, a punishment for my transgressions. This is the spirit telling me I need to repent I thought, and how heartbreaking that we as women who have been in those situations, blame ourselves first and think we have sinned. We're the ones who did something wrong because that's what we're led to believe. It's what we're brought up thinking and understanding and being told by priesthood leaders.
Megan Conner [03:21:37] And, you know, I, we've talked before about the book the Miracle of Forgiveness and how it basically shamed people into thinking that any transgression like this was partially your fault. And subsequent talks by general authorities. Now I know that they have dialed some of that back and in recent years there have been some other talks by general authorities saying it's not your fault, it's never your fault. But those of us who came up during that time period, those are hard things to unlearn. And I personally never talked about the first time that I was assaulted at college because I knew that my mother would say that it was my fault.
Megan Conner [03:22:16] I put myself in a bad situation. I never should have been there. If I hadn't done X, Y and Z, it never would have led to that. And so I just think it's, it's a harmful, unfortunate part of our culture that I'm glad to see finally they're, they're doing some repair on that, you know, to try and tell victims, it's not your fault.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:22:39] Warren, I'm just listening. It's heartbreaking. This is really heartbreaking. This was the part that we brought up at the beginning that there's a story and an experience in here that has nothing to do with, you know, her mother, but Sherry's own story that she decided to share. And I'm grateful she shared it because it is, and it is heartbreaking. Like you, Mindy, you know exactly where it's going when she explains meeting this middle aged man. And my heart goes out to her. I mean, I have a lot more to say, but I think Sherry's words are best. I don't even know if there's anything else I can say that Sherry doesn't. I, I think that everyone needs to read it and understand it.
Mindy Caldwell [03:23:20] I agree.
Megan Conner [03:23:21] Well, and you say that it's the one thing that has nothing to do with Ruby, but I think it has everything to do with the way that she was brought up. You're right, she was, she was brought up to, to not trust her own instincts. Obviously that panic attack was her own instincts saying, you should not be here, run away. She saw the warning signs and the red flags, but she didn't trust them. And that's also part of Jody's tactic too, to get people to not trust themselves and trust their own instincts. So when you're raised in that environment and put that together with the childhood emotional neglect where your parents are not validating enough and they're not loving enough and you don't get that physical affection and they're distracted and they're distracted by this huge elephant in the room that is not you.
Megan Conner [03:24:05] It's like your parents main goal in life is not your safety and well being. It's the truth. It's subscribers, it's followers, it's views, it's money, it's brand deals. And I can speak from experience on this, that when you're raised in an environment like that, you crave any kind of validation or affection or attention that you get and you'll take it wherever you can get it. It happened to me over and over because of that being raised in that environment where I didn't have the sort of underpinnings and the foundational love that I knew my parents cared about me and loved me. So I was willing to accept that kind of affectionate tension from anybody. And so I'm just identifying so much with Sherry in a way I thought I never would.
Mindy Caldwell [03:24:53] I think it's important that to note just that after this happens, she his like possessiveness and his control just really ramps up. He asks her not to talk to any boys at school. He asks to have her share her location on her phone.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:25:13] He stalks her.
Mindy Caldwell [03:25:14] Yeah. Yes, he stalks her. And, and you know, sometimes hundreds of messages a day. If I recall, she says in the book phone calls, you know, it just becomes a really, really unhealthy experience and relation. I don't, I hate to even call it a relationship, but it's coercive controls of control scenario for her. And there is actually, I think we should just let, let people read the book to find out. You know, certain things escalate and, and, but I think one of the saddest part parts of the book, it's chapter 31, it's called the Poison well and it's where she's feeling like this, this situation for her is crazy making.
Mindy Caldwell [03:26:04] But she was addicted to the scraps of validation that Derek gave her, the morsels of support. And she finally, in a moment of desperation decides to reach out to Ruby. And Ruby doesn't respond for 24 hours. And then, then tells her, you were very selfish in texting me. And then they decide to meet up for dinner where it seems like Sherry is wanting to build up the courage to tell her parents about what's been going on with Derek. And it just completely backfires.
Mindy Caldwell [03:26:32] They call her selfish and they're not supportive, and to the point that at the end of the dinner, they invite her to pay for the dinner, and she's at this table in this restaurant sobbing over chocolate cake and then has to pay for the dinner. And, and then she ends that chapter by saying that Derek was yet another poisonous adult in my life. And my heart just went out to her so bad. I'm just like, ah, just there's just one adult that, that she can, that she can count on to be there for her. And there, and there is. And that's a, That's a bright spot of this story is there is a former teacher, and I don't know if this is a good time to talk about him, but there is one former teacher that's not a predatory.
Mindy Caldwell [03:27:14] And she describes this man as Mr. Haymond and his wife. And they, they become a safe haven for. For Sherry as this, as this kind of saga progresses.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:27:25] So, so often when people are in their most vulnerable state, that's when people take. When predators can take advantage of that. It's just so heartbreaking that just one thing after another. You're right, that, that, that, that couple was wonderful to help her, though.
Megan Conner [03:27:41] Yeah. I want to point out one part, and this is kind of what we're all talking about here. Page 189, where Sherry says. And she's talking about Derek and she's talking about, you know, ending her relationship with him. And she says, what irony. While all this was happening, I was studying abuse of power in my college classes, learning about the dynamics of coercion, about the ways in which abusers groom and manipulate their victims. But even as I intellectualized these concepts, even as I wrote papers and participated in discussions about the insidious nature of abuse, I was unable to apply that knowledge to my own life. My brain wouldn't let me go there.
Mindy Caldwell [03:28:25] So fascinating and heartbreaking.
John Dehlin [03:28:28] Yeah, I think it's maybe also thank you to all of you for being willing to share and to be so vulnerable. I think it's also worth mentioning that the Mormon Church, their reports with, you know, Jason Resendez and others of the Associated Press, that and the Boy Scout, you know, sexual abuse scandal, they're kind of credible. There's credible evidence to suggest that the Mormon Church has a, a sexual abuse problem per capita that rivals, if not exceeds that of the Catholic Church. So this is very Mormon. The fact that a young girl is Being groomed. And not just groomed by some dark, apostate community member who's hiding around the shadows.
John Dehlin [03:29:15] This and Lauren, I think we agree that you were okay talking about this. Lauren knows. Lauren's been able to identify who Derek is. We're not going to say who he is, but she has identified it. He has held high levels of authority, authoritative positions, both in the church and in the community.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:29:36] Correct. Yeah. And that's all I'll say. But like, very high levels. And Sherry mentions that this is someone that is in a. Not just a position of power. I mean, I guess that is a position of power, but someone who she should absolutely be able to trust. Absolutely be able to.
Megan Conner [03:29:51] To trust.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:29:52] And that is what's so. That's. It's just so upsetting. And, and. Yes, exactly. And. And I want to say. Yeah, you and you have an isolated community and we're taught to trust one another. And I. I agree there's a big problem. It's. It's. Yes. Thank you for sharing the statistics. This is someone that Sherry should have been able to absolutely trust and never been concerned about. I keep repeating that. I mean, it's. It's so upsetting.
John Dehlin [03:30:23] Is there a chance you will be reporting at some point on this?
Megan Conner [03:30:26] Yeah.
John Dehlin [03:30:26] If it becomes yes, this probably will become a story.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:30:29] I think this is likely going to
John Dehlin [03:30:30] become a story because his position is such that words.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:30:33] It's gonna likely become a story. And yes, she was technically over the age 18, so I don't know how that works, but I have. I. I sense that this is going to become a story.
Megan Conner [03:30:41] And one thing we know about predators like this is that there's never just one victim.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:30:46] Oh.
Mindy Caldwell [03:30:46] That was one of my first thoughts when I read it. I'm like, this guy seems fine tuned in his tactics and I could be wrong, but it just seemed like.
Megan Conner [03:30:54] Like he knows exactly what's the only victim.
Mindy Caldwell [03:30:56] Yeah.
Megan Conner [03:30:57] Yeah.
Mindy Caldwell [03:30:57] Or she might not be the only victim.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:30:59] Yeah.
John Dehlin [03:31:01] So because this is Mormon stories, like, I. In addition to everything that's been expressed, I was tuned in to the church discipline part because the. Part of the. In part of the book, Sherry decides she wants to end it and she goes to her Mormon bishop and. And one of the weird things was the bishop's response was, I need to talk to the stake president. That seemed weird to me because my understanding is that unless somebody has the Melchizedek priesthood and. Or has been endowed, the bishops can make the call on discipline, disciplinary action. So why was a bishop needing to consult with the Stake President about a non priesthood holding 18 year old or 20 year old woman. To me the only reason that makes made sense was because she's a public figure. Right?
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:31:55] That's a good question that. Yeah. And you know more about this than I do. I didn't even think of the public figure thing. I thought maybe it was because what she was also implying was that someone in a higher power, like no, that's true. Like, so the bishop could have been like, dude, what do we do? Like she's saying that this, this married
John Dehlin [03:32:12] man who's this upstanding member of the community who's had a high level leadership
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:32:16] in the church, which is also upsetting because what's how I took it, and you guys correct me wrong, is that the bishop was like, actually had more empathy, understanding, like listening to it one on one, like, you're good cherry, like, don't worry, this isn't your fault. Then he somehow goes and talks to the state president for some reason that we're speculating on right now as to why. And then it's the state president comes back and it's like, no, take your capital recommend away. She can't. So that goes to your point though. Why are they talking about that? So if, if it is about the perpetrator and who did it, why then are they, why then is the stake president now jumping in on what her punishment should be?
John Dehlin [03:32:53] Yeah, the power. Even if she wasn't a minor.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:32:56] Yeah.
John Dehlin [03:32:57] The power differential, the age difference, the fact that this guy was a high level leader in the church and a high level member, all of that speaks abuse, Speaks.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:33:07] Right.
John Dehlin [03:33:08] Lack of consent, you know, speaks outrageous power dynamics. So there's an argument to say she should have never had her temple recommend
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:33:17] taken at all, which again, I think the bishop understood that. But as you point out, for some reason we don't know again why the bishop then talks to the stake president and the stake president makes the call, like why?
Mindy Caldwell [03:33:28] Strange.
John Dehlin [03:33:29] Yeah.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:33:29] Yeah.
Mindy Caldwell [03:33:29] And one of the most heartbreaking parts of this story is the fear of discipline, the fear of her getting her temple recommend taken away or not being able to take the sacrament or losing her church membership. She had a real fear of that. That was one of the reasons that this carried on longer than it should have. Because I think she was so scared to go and talk to the bishop about what had been happening. And it's just so sad that her fears, she didn't lose her church membership, but her fears were realized when she, when she finally confessed. And I think it's important to Note that at least initially, the bishop asked for the information on this person that.
Mindy Caldwell [03:34:11] And in order to track him down for dis. You know, for potential discipline. And then the bishop reported back to her that this man had been tracked down, had been interviewed, denied everything, and was let off at that point.
John Dehlin [03:34:26] And there was no disciplinary action on him, on the perpetrator, which, again, is very moral.
Mindy Caldwell [03:34:31] Par for the course.
John Dehlin [03:34:32] The Mormon Church seems to have a history of punishing victims and protecting perpetrators. It's inexplicable, really, or completely explicable, if you understand how patriarchies often work.
Megan Conner [03:34:48] Yep.
Mindy Caldwell [03:34:48] Right.
Megan Conner [03:34:49] Yeah, absolutely.
John Dehlin [03:34:50] Yeah. So by the time she finishes the book, Derek in quotes, had not received any church discipline. In the afterword, she clarifies that since submitting the manuscript, he has received some discipline. My sense was. Was the Church, I'm speculating, caught wind that this story was going to come out and knew that this is going to be a part of the book. So then they hurried and took action so that it wouldn't. It wouldn't. That wouldn't be left there of him having no consequence at all.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:35:25] Yeah, maybe. So it's very vague as to why that's. That could be true. I also wondered if it happened to somebody else. Judy, good point. Yeah. Like, I wondered because all of a sudden, like, I just noticed that all of a sudden he was. Later. I mean, maybe it has to do with it, but it felt like, okay, could there have been someone else too? Could there have been another person that came forward?
Megan Conner [03:35:44] I don't know.
Mindy Caldwell [03:35:46] And it. In the afterword, it doesn't even say what the. What the result of his disciplinary.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:35:51] Right. So he could have been.
Mindy Caldwell [03:35:52] He was being brought before a formal disciplinary council. His calling stripped away. A small victory, but not enough is what she says.
Megan Conner [03:36:01] He never lost a simple recommendation.
Mindy Caldwell [03:36:03] He never loses his temper.
Megan Conner [03:36:04] Recommend.
Church Discipline, Derek, and Institutional Failures
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:36:04] Well, then that would say there was never a discipline.
Mindy Caldwell [03:36:07] Or.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:36:07] Or he didn't.
John Dehlin [03:36:09] For adultery with a teenager, and He's a late 40s man.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:36:14] Well, she, you know, she also implied something. Sorry. And I'm so sorry that we're all speculating on. She also mentions, though, that, like, she almost felt like she wasn't believed because she had deleted all of her texts and so that he was. He was denying it.
Mindy Caldwell [03:36:28] Yeah.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:36:29] So it could be that they just said they were like her word versus his word kind of a thing, which always maddens me too. You know, she deleted all of his texts to get rid of everything into. And so then there's also not believing her. So they go talk to him, he's like, this doesn't happen.
Mindy Caldwell [03:36:44] Yeah.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:36:45] And they believe him over her. Yeah.
Megan Conner [03:36:47] Or he may have just downplayed it and said, you know, we texted back and forth. She worked for me, you know, she was in a vulnerable position. She probably imagined more than actually happened. I stopped. Probably wasn't the best idea. I ended it. You know, I don't have any contact with her anymore. And so of course, the. I think we can equivocally say that in these situations, not just the LDS Church, but in many of these situations everywhere, it's the male offender who is a respected community member who gets believed
Mindy Caldwell [03:37:21] over the victim 100%.
John Dehlin [03:37:24] And there's an incentive in, in the church to protect the perpetrators. Because if, let's just say if he's had a high level of church leadership, or let's say he was a high level church leader while he was being a perpetrator, then that really reflects poorly on the church. Every calling is supposed to be, you know, divinely inspired of God. Why would God be calling him to a high level priesthood position when he was grooming and abusing teenage girls? So the church has an incentive to keep it quiet, to not believe her and to protect him again, like Ruby, because it'll hurt the church. And so the concern isn't about the victim or about the treatment of young women. From a, let's just say, a narcissistic church perspective. The church's primary interest is in protecting the church. Victims come third or fourth.
Megan Conner [03:38:21] This is why I say that the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints operates in society as a narcissist. This is institutional narcissism. It's an institution that cannot recognize its own fault and has no empathy for the people that it harms.
John Dehlin [03:38:41] Very tough. Any final thoughts about Derek, or have we said too much?
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:38:45] No, I think we're good.
John Dehlin [03:38:46] Okay.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:38:47] I mean, unless you guys have other thoughts, I. I'm good.
Mindy Caldwell [03:38:49] I think I. I would encourage just. Just get the book.
Megan Conner [03:38:53] Read the book.
Mindy Caldwell [03:38:54] There's more to this story.
John Dehlin [03:38:55] Yeah, for sure.
Megan Conner [03:38:55] Thank you.
Mindy Caldwell [03:38:56] There's more. Thank you, Sherry, for being so vulnerable. That had to be very scary to outline this part of her story, but it's a big part and, and I am grateful that she included it. Although it was very, very difficult. One of the hardest parts of the book to read. For sure.
John Dehlin [03:39:13] For me, it was.
Mindy Caldwell [03:39:14] Yeah, probably the hardest. Yeah. And. And I think maybe the other parts of the story were like, more familiar and not to make them less horrific, but it just was such a Surprise. And you just feel so much for her that she's already been exploited and victimized. And then for this to happen, it's just so awful. So, yes, please get the book. Read about her story in her words. And. Yeah, that's all. I think we've said enough.
Megan Conner [03:39:37] Yeah. I just think the great thing about telling this story is that it's going to help so many other victims. It's going to help so many people recognize these patterns of behavior, of manipulation of grooming. And it's going to help so many people who will resonate with this story and say, oh, my gosh, this happened to me too. I didn't realize that it was grooming. I didn't realize I was being manipulated. I didn't realize it wasn't my fault.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:40:04] Yeah, right.
Mindy Caldwell [03:40:04] That's the number one.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:40:05] And it doesn't matter. We don't often hear about these stories. You know, she's. It doesn't matter that she's over 18. Clearly he.
Mindy Caldwell [03:40:11] Clearly that, you know, power dynamic.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:40:13] Yeah, it's a clear power dynamic. And this happens so often. And it's just.
Mindy Caldwell [03:40:19] Yeah.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:40:20] Difficult.
John Dehlin [03:40:21] And just to remind people, the book is the house of my mother, Sherry, Frankie by it. Not that we're ending, but just. That's just a plug. Really quick, I have to ask. Do Ruby and Jody get any credit for telling Sherry to stay away from Derek or not? Because they. They got that one, right.
Mindy Caldwell [03:40:42] Yeah.
John Dehlin [03:40:43] A lot of misses but they got that one.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:40:45] No, because I don't think their intention or motive was pure.
Megan Conner [03:40:47] That's it.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:40:48] I think that was. It was a control issue.
Mindy Caldwell [03:40:50] And don't make me look bad.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:40:52] Yeah, it was a control issue. They didn't want. They wanted power and control over Sherry and Jody was probably, you know, jelly
Megan Conner [03:41:00] over, you know, and it wasn't. It wasn't. Oh, tell me more. It wasn't. Let's really dig into this. Tell me how you're really feeling about this. It was like, just don't talk to that guy. That's bad. Just cut it off. Don't. You know? And there was. As far as we see in the book, there was no revisiting by Jody or Ruby about how are things going with that. Were you able to end it? How did you know? How did it go? And again, Lauren, I think 100% the motivation was not about Sherry and. And protecting Sherry. It was about protecting Ruby, protecting eight passengers.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:41:31] Protecting damage and control.
Megan Conner [03:41:33] And control.
Mindy Caldwell [03:41:33] Y.
John Dehlin [03:41:35] All right.
Megan Conner [03:41:36] Also, broken clocks. Right. Twice a day. Right. I mean,
Mindy Caldwell [03:41:41] I guess we'll give him one Little win.
John Dehlin [03:41:43] Love that quote.
Mindy Caldwell [03:41:44] Yeah.
John Dehlin [03:41:46] Okay, so I guess we could turn to when. I mean, there's this period where Sher's just, like, family list. Like, she can't even talk to her dad, and her dad's on campus with her at byu. Like, there's this point where she bumps into him and both of them just look at each other. Because I guess at this point, Kevin's been so terrorized by Jody that he is afraid to talk to his own daughter on campus. So she's living estranged from the family. Kevin is estranged. He's kicked out. He's living. Even Chad was supposed to be living with Kevin. And then all of a sudden, Chad's not living with Kevin.
John Dehlin [03:42:25] Chad's estranged. And then, like, Sherry tries to reach out to Chad, and Chad's like, why are you bothering me? So clearly, Chad was poisoned regarding Sherry. So, like, Sherry's just completely on her own family lists. Like, one hero of the story is the family that kind of takes Sherry in.
Mindy Caldwell [03:42:44] Yes.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:42:44] Correct.
John Dehlin [03:42:45] Is that a real name? Do we know if that's a real name?
Mindy Caldwell [03:42:47] I think I might have seen on Reddit that. I think it is.
Megan Conner [03:42:50] Yeah, I saw on Reddit.
Mindy Caldwell [03:42:51] Is it the real name when she changes names?
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:42:53] She says she switches names, but she doesn't. She. Yeah. And otherwise she uses real names. Yeah. Yeah.
Mindy Caldwell [03:42:59] They were thinking I might have read that, that perhaps that wasn't the real name, but I could totally be wrong with that. I don't know if she would want to respect their privacy or.
Megan Conner [03:43:06] But yeah, no, they were good.
Mindy Caldwell [03:43:07] I should have looked into her. Yeah. Yeah.
Megan Conner [03:43:09] But I think that's one of Jody's tactics, you know, the isolation and then the poisoning, the well of. And I think triangulation.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:43:16] Yes.
Megan Conner [03:43:17] I think Kevin absolutely was poisoned against Sherry. And that's why I think it explains some of his behavior after the arrest and everything like that.
Mindy Caldwell [03:43:25] That chapter on just the. The break of Kevin really broke. It broke my heart. It's chapter 34. It was called Facsimile Father, and it just kind of lays out the. All of the steps that Kevin had to take in the isolation. Just like you were speaking to earlier with the. With. With your. Your friend that you met. You know, he's invited to leave. He's. He can't communicate with his kids. He can't. You know, I think that's at the time where they run into each other at byu and. And how. How horrible to, like, run into your own dad. They have to pretend like they don't see each other. It was Just terrible. And I want to. I want to say just one quote about that, about that. It was very poignant, I thought.
St. George Events, Arrests, and the Criminal Case
Megan Conner [03:44:09] While you're looking it up, I'll just mention that after I finished the book, I went and re. Watched Kevin's arrest video. Or not. Sorry, not arrest video. His. His interview with the police immediately after the. The children were found. And that phrase was very haunting. Invited to leave, he says to the police, you know, they say, why haven't you been around your family for so long? And he says, I was invited to leave.
Mindy Caldwell [03:44:34] Yeah.
Megan Conner [03:44:35] And that's Jody's term for getting the men out of the house.
Mindy Caldwell [03:44:39] So this is just a brief journal entry from. From that same chapter. She said, I went to counseling today and talked it through. I'm so angry with my dad for not sticking up for himself and for abandoning his family. I'm furious at mom and Jody for ruining our family. I feel like a part of me has died and I will never get it back. I don't know how I'll ever recover or forgive them. I don't know how to help my siblings. I don't even know how to help myself. And then at the end, she says to this day, referring to Kevin, it's a miracle to me that he survived the misery of his exile and didn't end at all. A chilling thought has crossed my mind since then. Maybe that's what Jody and Ruby wanted. Maybe they were hoping he'd just disappear forever.
John Dehlin [03:45:21] Chilling meaning die.
Megan Conner [03:45:23] Right.
John Dehlin [03:45:23] And I. I have to wonder whether Jody's techniques have led to some deaths by suicide. Of course it's speculation. I haven't heard of any. But Adam Paul Steed certainly was driven to the point where other people would have chosen that route. So, you know, I guess we'll see if. If anyone ends up coming out with. With that result. But to know that, yeah, Sherry speculated that maybe Reuben, Ruby and Jody were hoping that that would be. Kevin's end was just super sad and dark.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:45:59] Yeah.
John Dehlin [03:46:02] Does anybody believe that Kevin just resigned his job at byu? Like, I found that hard to believe. Number one, if you're supporting multiple households.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:46:12] Right.
John Dehlin [03:46:12] Why would you ever resign your job? And then the other thing is, we know that Ruby wasn't sorry. Jody wasn't beyond inserting herself between her clients and in Adam Paul Steed's case, his educational institution. But certainly she could have called Kevin's ecclesiastical leader and or BYU and basically said, this guy's a child abuser. Fire him or take away his temple recommend. Because why in the world would Kevin Just, like, stop working at byu.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:46:47] That could have happened. But there's also talk of Jody having husbands quit their jobs. Part of. As part of isolation, isn't there? Yes.
Megan Conner [03:46:54] During the isolation chapter, it was no. No friends, no jobs, no distractions other than working on yourself.
John Dehlin [03:47:01] How does she get paid if she gets her clients to quit their jobs? I just.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:47:05] But maybe they can coach for her. That was another thing they were too, is every time they coach someone else, she still gets 10%.
John Dehlin [03:47:13] Kevin was helping.
Megan Conner [03:47:14] Yeah.
John Dehlin [03:47:14] Connections.
Mindy Caldwell [03:47:15] Yeah.
Megan Conner [03:47:17] Whoa.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:47:18] And then. Did you hear that, too, in the end? That's what's crazy, too, is not only does she not make money teaching them how to coach, once they go out into the world and do their own thing, she forever wants 10% of everything they ever do, ever. I'm like, what?
Megan Conner [03:47:33] It's wild because they would be nothing without her.
Mindy Caldwell [03:47:35] Yep.
Megan Conner [03:47:36] Yeah. But also, going back and. And watching that police interview was. Was. Was very telling. Like, he was very clearly brainwashed. He really believed that he deserved that isolation. He really believed that. He. He said to the police, they said, why was it that. That you left? And he said, it was because of the way that I treated my wife. I did not treat her well.
John Dehlin [03:47:58] But also, does he say, I'm an addict, you know, I have an addiction, and I'm trying to work on my addiction?
Megan Conner [03:48:03] Yes.
John Dehlin [03:48:03] Meaning he masturbated, related to pornography.
Megan Conner [03:48:06] He said. Yes. And so you can see very clearly in that interview, he believes what Jody told him about himself.
John Dehlin [03:48:12] Yeah. Yeah. Which is sad.
Mindy Caldwell [03:48:14] So sad.
John Dehlin [03:48:16] Once the. Once the book got to the part that we're all familiar with, which was the. The, you know, the St. George stuff and the crimes and the police showing up and the police. It was. It was stuff that I was really familiar with. So I found myself feeling like, okay, I knew about that. I knew about that.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:48:35] Like, prepped. You've been prepped for it. Yeah.
Megan Conner [03:48:36] Yeah.
John Dehlin [03:48:37] Was there anything about sort of like St. George, the police getting involved, the imprisonment, the police visiting the Springville home, breaking in and all that that was new or interesting to y' all that we haven't already covered in a previous episode? And what. You know, while I'm asking you that, think about that for a second. Yeah. Anything. Anything that was dark or interesting or.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:49:09] I thought it was interesting. I don't know if this had come out, but that. And maybe it had in a recorded jail house phone call, but I think she might have said it was Ruby telling Kevin, but that on the way to the jail, Ruby didn't talk to Jody, did you guys catch that? Did you guys know that?
Megan Conner [03:49:25] Yes.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:49:26] You knew that?
Megan Conner [03:49:27] Megan knew it?
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:49:28] No.
Megan Conner [03:49:28] I mean, no, It's. I just. I mean, I knew it for myself. I didn't talk to anybody about it. I don't. I didn't cover this on my channel or talk to you about it or anything. So I thought that was very telling, you know, the fact that Ruby already was distancing herself from Jody and getting ready to blame everything on Jody in the police car. In the police car, like, already she was ready to throw Jody under the bus. And then the other thing that. That I think was called to my memory after reading the book was that Ruby's confession, her very tearful confession, hearing her described so accurately as a narcissist by Sherry's, you know, documenting her behavior, reminded me that she's not capable of true introspection, of true remorse.
Megan Conner [03:50:20] And so that likely also was just an act to. In order to get her sentence lessened. So I don't. I. When I first heard it, her confession and her tearful, you know, my six little ducks or six little chicks, I think I wanted to believe that she truly was remorseful for what had happened. But in reading the book and the description of the way that she behaved all the time, I. I can't believe that now that that was genuine.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:50:49] You and John both wanted to.
Megan Conner [03:50:51] I remember that.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:50:52] I remember that you were like. That day. You were like, oh, man, she's crying. I know.
Mindy Caldwell [03:50:57] Yeah.
John Dehlin [03:50:58] You guys, Ruby's crying. She must be sad and remorseful. Sherry didn't buy it for a minute.
Megan Conner [03:51:03] No,
Mindy Caldwell [03:51:06] but.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:51:07] No, but John too. Like, my John Doctor. Well, John, you guys are both doctors, too. It gets really complicated. My John, that's what he actually stated. There was no apology. Even though she said, my little duck. She never said, I'm so sorry for what I did to them. And then she said, I should have protected you. That's still not saying I'm sorry. What I did was wrong. And then as. That's when my John said, you know, Jody gave her permission. She did. Exactly. But she wanted to. And she. She talked like it was some Emmy award speech. Thank you to this person. She actually thanked the police officer that arrested her, but she didn't thank her children again. She didn't. She didn't thank her little son for escaping, for example. But thank you to the police officer who. I mean, she was playing to her audience and.
Mindy Caldwell [03:51:54] But I remember that it was very performative, for sure.
Megan Conner [03:51:57] Once a.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:51:57] Way to go, Sherry. For like.
Megan Conner [03:51:58] Yeah, yeah. Once I listened to Dr. John's analysis of that. I was like, oh, you're right. I fell for it again. You know, somebody had crocodile tears, and I was like, oh, I want to believe that they really.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:52:09] I admire. I think that we should always give people the benefit of the doubt. And I. I do, too. I admire. I'm just teasing you guys.
Megan Conner [03:52:15] I. I don't know. I. There's a. There's a part of me that. That is kind of like, you know, my harsh inner critic that's like, megan, you dummy, you grew up around narcissists. You've been surrounded by these people your entire life, and yet you still want to believe that there's a possibility for them to redeem themselves somehow. Yeah.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:52:31] You want everyone to have redemption. It's true.
John Dehlin [03:52:35] I was struck by how both Jody and Ruby, if I'm not mistaken, compared themselves at different times, either to Christ or to Joseph Smith or both.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:52:46] Yep.
John Dehlin [03:52:47] Did y' all notice that?
Mindy Caldwell [03:52:48] Yeah.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:52:48] Yeah. And those are in some recorded jailhouse phone calls. And they.
Mindy Caldwell [03:52:51] They do a call to Chad is where Jody, or, excuse me, Ruby, compares her, like, drinking from the bitter cup. You know, compares herself to Jesus Christ. And. And Sherry is astounded.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:53:05] And I'm just gonna throw out because this is my. My thing, but so does Lori Valo and Chad, and so does Tim Ballard and I just.
John Dehlin [03:53:14] Tom Harrison.
Mindy Caldwell [03:53:18] I want to give a quick shout out to the neighbors, those neighbors that.
Megan Conner [03:53:22] Oh, my God.
John Dehlin [03:53:23] Which neighbors in St. George?
Mindy Caldwell [03:53:24] The Springville neighbor. Well, clearly the neighbors in St. George that helped facilitate. Facilitate the rescue of the kids.
John Dehlin [03:53:30] The book doesn't really talk about that, which is.
Mindy Caldwell [03:53:32] It was interesting.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:53:34] It was Sherry's story. She's like, that's my. My sibling story today. Yeah.
Mindy Caldwell [03:53:39] Shout out to the. The Mr. Haymond and Mrs. Haymond who became a safe haven for her. And also those alert neighbors in Springville who texted Sherry and just said, sherry, it looks like your mom got rid of your dog. Sherry, it looks like your mom took your kids out of school or your siblings out of school. Sherry, it looks like your mom's moving. You know, like, these alert neighbors. I'm so grateful for them. And I think it's important to note that Sherry did try to reach out to Child Family Services, or dcf, dcfs on more than one occasion. And it was. It was difficult for them to make a case based on the evidence, based on the free range parenting law. And Sherry seemed very frustrated about that. And I shared her frustration.
John Dehlin [03:54:21] Yeah. The whole time, I'm like, where is DSF dfs. Dcfs.
Mindy Caldwell [03:54:25] Dcfs.
Megan Conner [03:54:25] Yeah. I also want to say, you know, in my career as a teacher, I was a mandated reporter. And so I did a lot of working, unfortunately, with. With the Texas version of dcsf. Did I say that right?
Mindy Caldwell [03:54:37] Why is it so?
Megan Conner [03:54:38] Why is that?
John Dehlin [03:54:39] Department of Child Services.
Megan Conner [03:54:42] Yes. And so I just want to. To give a plug for anybody who is in a situation where you witness something that could be abusive, to just say something, just make the report and do it. Because what these family services individuals need is a pattern.
John Dehlin [03:55:02] Yeah.
Megan Conner [03:55:03] And they need documentation and they need multiple reports in order for something to happen. I think this case is a prime example of that, where viewers of eight passengers were calling in and reporting. And that was. That was the. The beanbag incident. You know, they were calling in and reporting it and saying, you know, we should look into this. And I guess people did come and visit the home. Ruby put on her little show. They were like, ah, nothing to see here. Right. So it is so easy for abusive parents to get away with abuse for those reasons. So if you see something, please say something, please report it. Even if you think, oh, it could be nothing. Well, guess what? If it is nothing, they'll find out it's nothing. But if it's not nothing, it goes
Mindy Caldwell [03:55:47] on the record exactly as the first
Megan Conner [03:55:48] report goes on the record. And if you don't report it, it's never going to get seen. It's not. The problems aren't going to go away.
John Dehlin [03:55:56] That was probably one of the most heroic things Sherry did, because obviously Ruby and Jody cared about their image. You know, global celebrities, a big business built on their reputations. From the very beginning we talked about, it was all about appearance. It was all about projecting perfection. So what could be more horrific or scary? What could be more horrific for Ruby or more scary for Sherry to turn her mom in to Utah Department of Child and Family Services multiple times, knowing that her mom would likely find out, which she did.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [03:56:40] Yep.
John Dehlin [03:56:40] And then she faced the wrath of her mom, saying, how dare you turn your own. You're a traitor. Doesn't. Doesn't Ruby call Sherry a traitor at some point in the book for turning the family in? And by the way, how did Ruby ever find out that it was Sherry that turned her in? At least one of the times, Maybe
Megan Conner [03:57:00] they just assumed that it was Sherry, you know, because of the information that was given. But yeah, that was incredibly courageous of Sherry to be willing to do that. But I think we also see, especially towards the end of the book, you know, from the time where she says, something's going to happen to my siblings. They're going to die. Her concern for her siblings is just through the roof. And I think she's. She's so anxious about it that she feels like, okay, I can do something to help here. And so she makes those reports.
Megan Conner [03:57:29] And I didn't realize that on the day that the police went into the Springfield home, that was when Sher. Sherry was there that day, and she was, she was just beside herself, worried that they were going to find bodies. You know, she was so anxious about, please tell me, are they okay? Are they dead? She was expecting body bags. I mean, it was, it was really terrible.
Mindy Caldwell [03:57:53] Yeah, that was. And she did post to social media that day with just the one word caption of finally.
Megan Conner [03:57:59] Yeah.
Mindy Caldwell [03:57:59] And that's really poignant, I think.
Megan Conner [03:58:02] Yeah. And that's how the book starts, where she, she talks about this started on social media. It should end on social media, too.
Final Reflections on the Memoir
John Dehlin [03:58:13] Well, I've got a couple, like, final questions. Are there any other moments in the book that you all wanted to make sure we cover before we do? Just a couple of closing questions.
Megan Conner [03:58:25] I think we covered so much of it, but I just want to reiterate. Just go buy the book and read it. Please support Sherry. There's so much that we couldn't cover. I mean, we could keep talking for another three hours or four hours, but there's just, there's a lot in there that I think is really important for people to hear and know, especially if you've been fans of Eight Passengers or followed this case. I think this is. It's groundbreaking. It's brave, it's vulnerable. It's very well written. And I, I can't say enough good things about Sherry or about this book. So.
Mindy Caldwell [03:58:54] Very well written, Very well written, Very well written.
John Dehlin [03:58:57] Couple comments from our viewers and listeners. Unexcited says Female Panelists Appreciation Fund. So people are loving that we have female panelists. I'll make sure they get that. Zachary's mama writes curiously not being brought. I think we already read that one, so let me go on.
John Dehlin [03:59:19] We read that one, too. Let's see. Sorry. Thank you to. Okay, now we're. Now we're at the. Now we're at the parts we haven't read. Sorry, one more second. So thank you to my Mrs. Lonely hearts and Christina Ward. I promised that all the. The super chats would get read. So Rebecca Simmons writes. Thank you so much for continuing to cover the Frankie story. I've been following the story since June, and this means a lot to me. Thank you, Rebecca. Marta Herbert writes. So proud of Sherry for breaking away from the generational abuse the Griffiths family was abusive. I don't know what Marta what she knows, but that's Marta's opinion.
John Dehlin [04:00:05] Thank you for sharing JC Nevermo in Utah. Grateful to these amazing women and host John for covering this. More kudos to Sherry for speaking out. LDS purity culture and rigid gender ideology is unhealthy and ripe for abuse. Thank you for ATC and advocacy for change. Do you all know what ATC is? Anyone know?
Mindy Caldwell [04:00:31] Not sure.
John Dehlin [04:00:32] Okay. Dewey Loves Duckies writes, this show introduced me to Lauren and Megan, who I now follow I Love Mormon Stories podcast. Not Mass State Police, John Maven, Mindy and all associated. You're amazing, brilliant people. Thank you. Dewey Loves Duckies. Thank you, Danny Claw for your support. Troublemaker Baker writes. Sherry, quote, I'm most happy about everyone hearing about my dad's story. It's disgusting that people assume he was a part of it after his own kids have testified against that. And then people still say it's a lie. F those people. I'm not sure that's a quote from.
Mindy Caldwell [04:01:18] That's a quote from. That's like a recent Snapchat from Chad, I believe.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [04:01:23] Oh, is that from Chad?
Mindy Caldwell [04:01:24] I'm pretty sure that's from Chad.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [04:01:25] Troublemaker Baker is a moderator for my channel, so. And she often will quote things. What is she quoting?
Mindy Caldwell [04:01:30] I've got it. I've got a screenshot of that. I believe it's from Chad. A recent. A recent post from Chat.
John Dehlin [04:01:36] Okay. Because
Mindy Caldwell [04:01:38] this one has.
John Dehlin [04:01:40] Oh, right. Okay. Yeah. Thank you. For my moderator, I don't know if that's Maven or Julie, but it's Chad. Okay, so let me read it again now in Chad's voice. Chad, the question was, how do you
Mindy Caldwell [04:01:52] feel about being able to put out your story? And this is his response.
John Dehlin [04:01:57] Okay, so Chad says, I'm most happy about everyone hearing about my dad's story. What?
Lauren Johnson Matthias [04:02:04] Kevin. Okay, so, yeah, but it's Sherry's story.
Megan Conner [04:02:07] No, but is this in response to them coming out with an episode where the three of them are going to talk publicly about they are going to
Mindy Caldwell [04:02:16] be on a docu series that premieres in February, and it's been confirmed that it's three episodes of 50 minutes each where at least Kevin, Chad, and Sheri are all participating on this docu series that's on Hulu Disney. And so I think that he was answering questions about that docu series. And so maybe he's referring to. I'm glad that this docu series will give my dad, Kevin, the opportunity to speak. I think he's feeling very defensive of Kevin. Right.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [04:02:43] And a lot of people accuse Kevin. And I think that even Sherry's book also shared shed a little bit more light on where Kevin was. And so I think that. So Chad is saying.
Mindy Caldwell [04:02:52] Yeah, I think it ends sounding like they're repairing their relationship, you know, as a family. So.
John Dehlin [04:03:01] Okay, well, thank you, Trouble Maker Baker, for that one final Dewey loves duckies. Speaking of small end, narcissism, coercive control relies a lot on shame. Shame is at the heart of narcissism. And unfortunately, as I have said on Mormon stories, shame sometimes is at the heart of the LDS Church business model model when it comes to how repentance and sin and porn and masturbation and sexual sin and modesty and repentance in the atonement all and worthiness interviews and
Lauren Johnson Matthias [04:03:31] all interoperable and distortion. But really, that's what she said at the Eternal Core Conference. She said, I thought of. I needed a better word for shame. What was it going to be? Distortion. I'm like, oh, yeah.
Mindy Caldwell [04:03:45] Oh, goodness, yeah.
John Dehlin [04:03:49] Let's see. So the, the big question, and I want y' all to ask any questions or make any insights before we end, but obviously I started with the question who do we shoot? You know what I mean? Who's to blame? Is, do we all agree that Jody's the main villain, according to Sherry, that without, without Jody, maybe Ruby would have been an overbearing, semi abusive mom, but it takes Jody to lead it where kids are almost dying, or is that, is that giving too much credit to Jody?
Jody as Ringleader and Questions of Narcissism
Lauren Johnson Matthias [04:04:23] I think you can just give them different titles. I would say Jody is the ringleader, but again, she gave permission to Ruby, who felt already a certain way about her children and about human beings in general, and she dehumanized her children and help to punish them as we see in her journal. So I feel uncomfortable putting all the blame on one person, but I do feel safe calling Jody a ringleader and cult leader of sorts.
Mindy Caldwell [04:04:54] And a sadist.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [04:04:55] Yeah, and a sadist and. But that doesn't remove anything.
John Dehlin [04:04:59] Ruby. Ruby.
Mindy Caldwell [04:05:00] I'm calling Jody a sadist.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [04:05:01] Jody. Jody.
John Dehlin [04:05:02] But do we agree that Ruby also.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [04:05:05] Yeah, I agree that Ruby's also. That's what I'm saying. I don't want to put all of the blame on one person. I don't feel comfortable doing that. But I. In fact, I don't even think putting blame on one person takes away any blame from another. I do Feel comfortable calling Jody the ringleader, the cult leader, sadist, in where she deserves to be. But Ruby also dehumanized her children and participated in their abuse, according to her journals, and did those things to her children and allowed it to happen and is also where she needs to be. So I'm comfortable maybe giving them different titles, but not placing blame on one more than the other.
John Dehlin [04:05:42] Yeah, I was just wondering, would there be people incarcerated in federal prison without Jody? Maybe. I was asking that, but your point's perfect.
Megan Conner [04:05:51] Well, this is. This is the same question gets asked for your family.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [04:05:56] That's exactly where I was going.
Mindy Caldwell [04:05:57] Hard to not draw that comparison.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [04:05:59] Yeah, that's exactly where I go.
Mindy Caldwell [04:06:00] Laurie and Chad.
Megan Conner [04:06:03] Well, because so many people said, you know, when the case first broke and first came out, everybody was describing Lori as the perfect mom, as the cheerleader, as, you know, somebody who is appearing in society as. As, you know, what. What everybody thought was such a wonderful, sweet, kind person. Until she met Chad. And then, snap, everything changed. And I think a lot of people were saying the same things about Ruby, that she was this great mom, she was a vlogger, she was doing well. And then Jody came and. And bam, Abuse. I think in both cases, there is documented, verifiable evidence, this book proves it.
Megan Conner [04:06:37] That both Lori and Ruby were doing incredible harm prior to meeting their dyad. Prior to becoming a diet becoming a dyad. Exactly. That's what I meant. So, yeah, I. What I have to say is we've got documented proof in this book that Ruby was doing incredible emotional harm and some physical harm to her children before she ever met Jody. And she had that unempathetic take where she didn't care about how it was affecting her children. She just wanted what she wanted. Same thing with Lori. She just wanted what she wanted, and she was going to do whatever she could to get it. And so do they get to federal crimes?
Megan Conner [04:07:16] Do they get to actual, you know, killing children? Do they get to the type of abuse where her kids were almost dead without that dyad? I think in both cases, Chad gave Lori permission for her beliefs to grow and to. To turn toxic, even more toxic than they were. Jody gave Ruby permission for her parenting style to be seen as correct, as healthy. And so it just. I think it escalated everything. But I don't think that it necessarily means we wouldn't have gotten here without that dyad.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [04:07:51] I agree. I think you nailed it. And. And if you got my personal opinion, since I'm here and I've got the mic, I'll Say it. I think that when it comes to who the ringleaders are in both cases, because I really do see these as very copycat crimes, it's actually frightening to me the parallels.
John Dehlin [04:08:06] Chad and Lori versus Jody and Ruby.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [04:08:09] Jody, Ruby, Chad and Lori. I think that if you want to know who I think the ringleaders are in both, I think that it's Jody and I think that it's Chad Dabel. But I think all four of them are where they need to be. And I think that this, the diabolical things that they did together wouldn't have happened had they not met. So it took all. It took them both.
Mindy Caldwell [04:08:32] That's well said. What was the quote really quickly? Ruby and Jody weren't just similar, they were symbiotic. But that was interesting. That's in chapter 17.
John Dehlin [04:08:44] Meaning they help. They reinforced each other. Helped each other out. Made each other more strong and effective.
Mindy Caldwell [04:08:50] Yep.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [04:08:51] Yeah.
Megan Conner [04:08:51] Affirmed each other's toxicity.
Mindy Caldwell [04:08:55] Yep.
Megan Conner [04:08:55] Yeah.
John Dehlin [04:08:58] So I was going to ask is as far as. So sorry, I'm just fumbling on my thoughts here. Little bit. But I guess Kevin, I liked your point, Lauren, that everyone's got their own blame and someone's increase or decrease in share of the blame doesn't impact someone else's increase or decrease. They're sharing the blame. Does Kevin come out as more or less blameless in, you know, now that you've read Sher's book?
Lauren Johnson Matthias [04:09:38] For me, I kind of had heard his interview already into and understanding Jody's sort of M.O. and her program. For me, the book didn't change my opinion. I think that Kevin is guilty in that he looked the other way and put his head in the sand and it's disappointing that he couldn't see straight when, you know, Ruby and Jody were across the hall sharing a room together.
Megan Conner [04:10:08] No.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [04:10:09] But. But it's disappointing. I don't necessarily know or have ever felt that he knew that this abuse was going on. I think he, I think if he's guilty of anything, it's putting his head in the sand. And it's disappointing and I'm disappointed and not doing more. But I also see that I do believe that he was taken by a cult.
John Dehlin [04:10:36] So, so along those lines as, as Sherry is describing all in detail, all the cult like characteristics of Jody and connections or even of her mom. Right. For those of us who have studied high demand religions and for those of us who view Mormonism as a high demand religion. Religion. I'm curious to know if y' all were having the same experience. I was because as she's describing Jody as almost like a cult like leader, describing Jody's techniques, describing the coercion, describing the manipulation, the shame, the punishment, in my mind I'm thinking, Sherry, can't you see that in the church? Can you see that in Joseph Smith? Like at the very beginning, Sherry's talking about remembering back to Nauvoo and she talks about the. Was it the widow? The.
Mindy Caldwell [04:11:34] Her ancestor.
John Dehlin [04:11:35] Ancestor burned down. Right. Like she's got Mormon history on the brain. She's seeing a cult leader in action and then she's seeing priesthood leaders fail her all around her. She's questioning inspiration. And in my mind I'm thinking, where are you going to draw the parallels to either Joseph Smith and how he formed the church? Or when are you going to find or express the parallels between Jody and connections and the modern church? And I know that we all may not agree here on the panel, we may not all see the church in the same light, but were any of you hoping to see Sherry draw some of those connections?
Lauren Johnson Matthias [04:12:20] I think I was personally curious about what her current views are, you know, which she touched on some, you know, and she seems to still be a believer at this time. So I was certainly curious from what she shared. I. For me, yeah, yeah. And this is just Lauren. And then you guys can share your thoughts. I think that to Sherry, the, The LDS Church is her heritage. You know, again, bringing up her ancestors and things she learned from them. I think it's her community, I think it's her village, it's her schooling, right where she went to school. It's.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [04:12:59] And I'm not just talking, I'm talking high school and BYU because she went to a private school. I think that the church is sort of everything that's comforting in her world. And it is her world. And so I think I understand where it's not. The parallels might, might stop. The connections wasn't always a part of her life. Connections is something that was added to her life and her family, her community, her village, her schooling, her heritage is lds. So it's, I think, I guess to summarize all that, it's a lot more complex.
John Dehlin [04:13:39] Megan.
Megan Conner [04:13:40] Yeah. Speaking as someone who exited several abusive and coercive situations before ever taking a look at the church. The church was the last thing to leave in, in, you know, for me, I, I was, you know, my family system, my marriage, my career, there were so many things that I deconstructed. And I think the reason it took me so long to get to the church was because during Those horrible times in my life, it was my lifeline. It was a constant. It was something that I knew. And even though I didn't feel fully acceptable in Mormonism, I felt like a second and a third class citizen a lot of the time.
Megan Conner [04:14:22] My belief in God and Jesus Christ and I think what carried me through that was the idea that I learned in Mormonism that God knows my name, he knows my circumstances, and that all of this suffering is going to be for my good at some point. And so I didn't want to look at my Mormon faith. I didn't want to look into, I purposely did not look into polygamy as a problem or racism as a problem because I didn't want to know the truth at that point. I wanted to be in the safe place where I had my faith. I had this belief, it was working for the rest of my family.
Megan Conner [04:15:01] And I just had to be silent for a while. And I think, I think it's the reason why so many Mormons say my shelf broke. It's not that I put something on my shelf and then I took it off later and examined it. I waited until there was so much stuff on the shelf that it literally came crashing to the ground. And that's the only thing that made me take a look at it. And it was no different for me.
Mindy Caldwell [04:15:23] Mindy, I think that what you've both stated is beautiful and poignant and my thoughts are, this girl is so brave. I think we need to remember she's still 21. She's been through a lot. She's 21 years old and she wrote this amazing book and bravely told her story. I'm going to take the wins. A big win for me reading this book as an observer, not knowing her personally is that it's seems like she, she has learned to take back some of her own power. And she even references where she's learning to not trust.
John Dehlin [04:16:04] What? You read it?
Mindy Caldwell [04:16:05] Oh, did you find it?
John Dehlin [04:16:06] Yeah, it's just right here.
Mindy Caldwell [04:16:07] I was trying to find it.
John Dehlin [04:16:07] No, go ahead and read it.
Mindy Caldwell [04:16:08] Okay.
John Dehlin [04:16:09] Yeah, Margi marked it.
Mindy Caldwell [04:16:10] Thank you, Margi.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [04:16:11] Thank you, Margi.
Mindy Caldwell [04:16:13] Okay, and so this is after. She's. Okay, so she's talking about Derek. He said this is the after. This is the afterward.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [04:16:20] Oh, yeah. This was profound. Thank you.
Mindy Caldwell [04:16:22] So good. He said Derek was being brought before a formal disciplinary council. His calling stripped away. A small victory, but not enough. Derek had, had never lost his temple recommend like I had. And the experience had taught me a vital lesson that just because a church leader says something doesn't mean they're right. Doesn't mean it's necessarily coming from God. With everything I'd gone through, I'd realized that what a human being says holds less value to me than my personal conversations with God. Those now are my North Star. So I feel like that's a huge personal revelation for her to have that.
John Dehlin [04:17:02] And that sounds like the wheels are turning.
Mindy Caldwell [04:17:05] I mean, they could be. It's not that I would wish that on her. She's recently announced that she got engaged, and, and I just, I just wish her the best in whatever the journey, you know, leads her. And if that is her staying in the church and finding a way, I honor that. Yeah, I just think she's been through so much, and if that, you know.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [04:17:26] Yeah, yeah, I completely agree. Well said. I honor her. She has taken back her voice. She is. She is. I honor her journey wherever it goes. And I don't even want to speculate or think that maybe she's. We want something like she is taking back her power.
Megan Conner [04:17:41] I agree with that.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [04:17:42] That was well said. And wherever that leads her, I just honor and respect her.
John Dehlin [04:17:47] Absolutely. Absolutely. We got a comment that I, I do want to read. I read the quote from Marta Herbert where she basically alleged abuse in the Griffiths family. And she responded and said, I'm a Griffiths.
Mindy Caldwell [04:18:05] Ruby.
John Dehlin [04:18:05] Ruby is my niece.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [04:18:07] So, you know, what does she say?
John Dehlin [04:18:09] She, well, remember, originally she said earlier, okay, okay, the Griffiths are an abusive family. And I'm like, well, that's her.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [04:18:16] I don't know what she knows.
John Dehlin [04:18:17] That's her opinion. And then she says, I'm a Griffiths.
Reactions to the Book and Media Coverage
Mindy Caldwell [04:18:20] This was one mental note I had earlier that I wanted to circle back to was I, I do think people that have followed eight passengers, and not just the Ruby and Kevi Frankie family, but the other. I can't remember all their names because I haven't. There's Bonnie and then there's Julie and Ellie, and then there's Ellie and then Bo, the brother, and I believe the grandparents. The Griffiths grandparents also have a YouTube presence of like a couple hundred thousand followers. Like, this is a family thing that they've done.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [04:18:46] Right.
Mindy Caldwell [04:18:46] And I, I, it sounds like those that have followed these families for several years. I think we're hoping for more Griffiths content or scoop or, you know, updates in the book. And I didn't find that there was a ton of that. There was a mention of Ruby trying to recruit her siblings into the whole connections thing, and they were turned off by that. And then in very cult fashion, she blocks them or Separates herself from them. Yeah, but so for those that. I guess that's a bit of a spoiler if you're hoping for more Griffith's things. I know that some of her, Some of Ruby's, we mentioned earlier, I believe that a few of her siblings, I think, have released at least.
Mindy Caldwell [04:19:31] Bonnie today released a video talking about her reaction to. To Sher's book. And it was. That part of her video was very supportive of Sherry and Kevin and the. And the Frankie kids.
Megan Conner [04:19:45] So. Yes. And. Sorry, go ahead. I. I just want to say in watching that video this morning that, yes, she was very supportive of sharing the book, but. And then she gives a lot of pushback on Sherry for talking about generational trauma in the Griffiths family. And. And Bonnie says there is no generational trauma trauma. I just think Ruby was built different. And I will just say from experience, when you're still in the family system, it's really hard to see how dysfunctional it is.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [04:20:16] Is.
Megan Conner [04:20:16] And it sounds to me like Bonnie is still in the system.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [04:20:20] Yeah, I. Yeah, you're right. The book. Sherry speaks warmly of her aunts in the book. And her answer, spoken of warmly in the book. I'll give my personal opinion. I have been disappointed that they haven't spoken out more and condemned this behavior more on their channels. And I've been disappointed by that myself and have felt frustrated watching how they have handled this and not stood up more for the victims.
Mindy Caldwell [04:20:50] I agree.
John Dehlin [04:20:51] So what did you think of Sherry's criticism of 2020 as someone who's a journalist? I thought it was kind of. I don't know. I. I guess I don't want to call it harsh because she had the experience, not me.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [04:21:01] Well, you know, I thought it was interesting. Okay. So being a true crime channel to a journalist and a true crime channel, I found it interesting, first off, that Sherry discusses how she watched a lot of True crime at this time. And I have to say, when I was going through one of the hardest times of my life, I just turned on Keith Morrison every night. Like, that's all I did.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [04:21:20] And now, of course, I have a true crime channel. But there is something to that. I think when we're going through trauma, by the way, that, like, we're looking for answers or we're just needing to understand something. And as we always say on Hidden True Crime, a better understanding of crime is a better understanding of ourselves. So. So I think that's. That's interesting. So I also want to put that into perspective. She did not like the 2020. I want to go back and watch it now, I recall liking it, but of course, it's not my family that it's about. And I think that's going to give you such a different perspective, is a lot of these things are just kind of cut and dry.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [04:21:52] They're getting rid of the emotion, and they don't really. They're not living that true part of crime. And so I imagine that it would be very, very difficult to watch any crime program cover your family. You know, that would be so difficult. And I guess one of us understands what that's like here. I was about to say, none of us can understand that. I'm like.
Megan Conner [04:22:15] And that's why I have such a great appreciation for you and for Dr. John because of all of the. The people that I've talked to about this case and. And all of the other things that I've seen, seen that that were reported about my family. You and Dr. John are so kind and respectful of the families, and you are interested not in the shock value, the sensationalism, the clickbait. You're interested in understanding the stories. And I think that is the most important perspective because it's so easy to take a horrific, grisly crime and just exploit it. You know, I've never felt like you and Dr. John have done that. Not with my family or not with any of the other cases I've watched you cover.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [04:22:57] Thank you. That means a lot. Thank you. But, yeah, I think that maybe one ability we have is we have the opportunity, like Mormon stories, to interview people, to really listen and see what they're thinking. And of course, 2020 is a program where they've got to get to the meat and tell the story beginning to end. But I am curious to go watch it again. I actually am intrigued by her saying that.
John Dehlin [04:23:22] And she's basically mad that they were recording her and her family's reaction to the revealing of the photographs of the abuse of the children.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [04:23:32] Is that right? Was that it? Was that what she said?
Mindy Caldwell [04:23:34] She had been purposely avoiding seeing photos of the children, and then all of a sudden they were.
John Dehlin [04:23:40] They like, set up. They set up a filming of showing kind of those grizzly photos to the family.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [04:23:47] That would. Okay, wow. Yeah, that would be.
Megan Conner [04:23:50] That would be difficult.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [04:23:51] And so I understand, I understand. And it's. I can't imagine, you know, what it was like, but I hope, again, I always. I always admire victims that do come forward with their own voices and their own stories, because again, programs are covering this and they're going to continue covering this and to say there are several documentaries. Yes. Several. Several. You've been contacted several times.
John Dehlin [04:24:16] I think we're both in one.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [04:24:17] Yeah, we've all been contacted several times. And for the victims to be able to say, this is my story, this is my book is always a very good thing that I know, you know, we all support.
John Dehlin [04:24:27] So yeah, let me just read. I promised I'd read all the super chats. So thank you for Danny Chow for the support. Not Born Again Bomb. Right. Says buy the book, people. We totally agree. Buy the book. Thanks Rhonda Gaines for the support. Danny Claw says, I found Mormon Stories podcast from the Jesse Hildebrandt interview. Been following closely since you helped me deconstruct from evangelicalism. And I appreciate all you do shout out to all our never Mormon viewers and listeners out there. We love that you tune in to Mormon Stories podcast. JC writes, lol. John D. ATC equals activism towards the church. Oh, that's a reference to Ahmed Corbett in his talk atc.
John Dehlin [04:25:16] Get it. I get the joke. Can't believe it. Nevermo has to clarify insider speak. That's awesome. I love it. Thank you. Jc, I want to buy you dinner. Anyway, he says, keep up the grand great work. I love that. It's my favorite. One of my favorite quotes of the day. McSpunky says hey to two of my favorite ladies, Lauren and Megan.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [04:25:39] What's up, Mix Funky.
Megan Conner [04:25:41] We love to see you in the house.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [04:25:43] Nick Spunky.
Megan Conner [04:25:44] I keep trying to get McSpunky to come on my channel to do an interview and he's. He's this close, so everyone encourage him.
John Dehlin [04:25:52] And then I think this is the last super chat we have. The Henday 07 says, I think the church is just as much to blame because they're so caught up in the urgent second coming of Christ that they send people into these psychopathic delusions over good and evil. And I do think that that doctrine, that Latter Day Saint, part of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints probably has some damage unhealthy focus
Megan Conner [04:26:20] on tumultuous end times.
Mindy Caldwell [04:26:23] Yeah.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [04:26:24] Those Latter days.
John Dehlin [04:26:25] And that's not just Mormonism, that's evangelical Christianity.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [04:26:28] But yeah, but Latter Day Saints.
Megan Conner [04:26:30] It's in the names.
Mindy Caldwell [04:26:31] Yeah.
John Dehlin [04:26:33] The last thing I'll just say is I loved and I know, Megan, you feel passionately about this. I loved Sherry's treatment of the topic of narcissism and I had actually blocked out a few paragraphs to read. Maybe we're. You. You got that?
Megan Conner [04:26:47] I have them too.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [04:26:48] Yeah, that's.
Megan Conner [04:26:48] That was the main thing that I was like, okay, this is, is important.
John Dehlin [04:26:51] Is there anything you want to read or share about that? Because it is crucial. And I know that's a topic that's near and dear to your heart.
Megan Conner [04:26:57] Yeah, yeah, I will. I don't know if anybody else has. I don't want to take anybody else's thunder on that.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [04:27:03] Go ahead.
John Dehlin [04:27:03] We all are going to have closing thoughts, so this could be yours if you want.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [04:27:06] Cool.
Megan Conner [04:27:07] Yeah, Great. So, yeah, at the very, at the very end of the book, Sherry says, always trying to solve the ruby puzzle, searching for that magic key that would have made her happy and kind. The truth is there probably isn't a magic key. Narcissism isn't a choice. It's a deep rooted defense mechanism. And I'm going to push back a little bit because it is a defense mechanism that people develop as a response to trying to avoid shame and trying to avoid difficult feelings. I think we all have a choice to either deal with the difficult feelings or develop a defense mechanism. So it's probably a complicated.
Megan Conner [04:27:48] It's more complicated than black and white, obviously. But she says, and when it can be treated, it requires extensive and dedicated effort on the part of the narcissist themselves, which is rare because most narcissists don't have the ability to be self reflective or introspective. So most of them don't ever go to therapy because they don't think that there's anything wrong with what they're doing.
Megan Conner [04:28:10] So where does that leave us? How do we deal with the rubies of the world? How do we balance empathy for the wounded person behind the narcissistic mask while protecting ourselves and others from the damage they can cause? I don't have all the answers, but I do know that awareness is a start. Understanding that narcissism is a complex disorder, not just a label for selfish people, is crucial. And recognizing fawning as a trauma response, not just people pleasing, is equally important. She has a whole chapter on fawning. And the understanding of that I think is. Is really important.
Megan Conner [04:28:47] And while all that is happening, protecting the children, regulating or outright banning family vlogging for the questionable exploitative practice that it is, would be a great start for me. Understanding the patterns has been both heartbreaking and liberating. Seeing the pattern means you can break it. It's not easy. And some days it feels like I'm fighting against my own instincts. That urge to fawn, to sacrifice my well being on the altar of others. Comfort still lurks in the shadows of my psyche. But every time I speak up instead of staying silent, every time I honor my own needs instead of burying them.
Mindy Caldwell [04:29:29] Sorry, guys.
Megan Conner [04:29:29] This is me, too. Every time I allow someone else to sit with their discomfort, instead of rushing to smooth things over, I'm severing another link in that chain of generational trauma, that toxic relay race, passing the baton of pain from one generation to the next. It must end here. It's not just about healing myself anymore. It's about creating a new legacy, a new pattern for the generations that come after me and my family.
Mindy Caldwell [04:30:26] Thank you.
Megan Conner [04:30:32] I didn't realize how impactful this book was going to be, so it's not the first time that I have seen myself in someone else's story, but it was powerful, and that's why I think this book is going to make such a difference for so many people.
Mindy Caldwell [04:30:57] Thank you, Megan. Yeah.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [04:30:59] And thank you, Sherry.
Megan Conner [04:31:01] Thank you, Sherry.
John Dehlin [04:31:05] Who wants to follow that? That was beautiful, Megan. Megan, that was beautiful. Thank you.
Megan Conner [04:31:11] Thank you.
John Dehlin [04:31:11] Yeah. Well, Lauren and Mindy, I do want to give you all a chance to give any final thoughts you had on this, you don't want to, and that's your choice. Did you all have any final. Other than, like. Thank you, Sherry.
Closing Thoughts and Guest Farewells
Lauren Johnson Matthias [04:31:24] I feel. I feel like that's a. Probably the best place to end. I. I feel content now. I feel. I feel content. And I'm. I'm interested now in where this is going to go next. You know, I'm interested in watching their documentary. I'm interested in watching Sherry's journey, although she's saying, peace out. I'm going to do this on my own. She wants her privacy now, but, yeah, I think it's going to. I agree with me. Can help a lot of people.
Mindy Caldwell [04:32:01] Buy the book, support Sherry.
John Dehlin [04:32:04] Show it.
Mindy Caldwell [04:32:05] Buy the book, support Sherry. I didn't realize until just the beginning chapter of the book that she was born in March of 2003, and that's the same month that my third child was born. And so throughout the book, I just, like, kind of pictured my child going through the same steps and. And I think I took a motherly approach to. To that, perhaps because of that, but just so proud of you, Sheri. If you see this, you wrote a beautiful book. You've been through a lot of. And I just wish the best for Sherry and for her family moving forward.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [04:32:43] Sheri does, at the end, share empathy for her mother. She talks about how she's dealing with the prison system, how it's been difficult for her mother, how she's Also heard that maybe her mother is working on a degree, which Sherry hopes is true because she pictures her mother. She wants her mother to be able to get out and find a career and be happy and maybe a little house somewhere and conclude her life outside the prison system. I thought that was an interesting bit too. Maybe something we didn't know about how Ruby is now doing we often don't hear about after the sentencing. And so I thought that was an interesting part of the book too. She wishes her well, although it doesn't seem like she's going to play much a part of her mother's life now. She wishes her mother well.
John Dehlin [04:33:37] Someone's asking where to buy the book. You can definitely buy it on Amazon. I bought the audio version and listened to it and bought a hard copy version too, so definitely Amazon. Any local bookstore I'm sure is going to have it.
Mindy Caldwell [04:33:50] Sherry reads the audio and does an excellent job.
John Dehlin [04:33:53] Yeah, yeah. And it's. I was going to make fun of the fact that this episode is half of the time of the full audiobook.
Mindy Caldwell [04:34:02] Like we covered half of the book, ladies and gentlemen.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [04:34:06] I think that just shows that we talk a lot. Yeah, we have a lot of opinions.
Mindy Caldwell [04:34:10] So much more good stuff in this.
John Dehlin [04:34:12] I think it's because the book is so good.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [04:34:14] The book is so good. Yeah. I bought both the Kindle and the audio because I was reading it and then I wanted to listen to it while I. So I bought both. So. Yeah, they're all excellent. It's. Yeah.
John Dehlin [04:34:26] Yeah. Well, beautiful. Well, I'll just say, you know, super sleuth Mindy, thank you so much for coming on.
Mindy Caldwell [04:34:36] You're welcome. It's been a pleasure to be here.
John Dehlin [04:34:38] I hope. I love having you on, Mindy. Your dear friend and I welcome back. Welcome you back anytime.
Mindy Caldwell [04:34:44] Thank you.
John Dehlin [04:34:44] John and Megan from. From midlife revolution and third verse YouTube channel. Thank you so much for coming on Mormon Stories.
Megan Conner [04:34:58] I love being here with you guys. And also I'm just going to put a plug in for Mormon Stories. The LDS discussion series was instrumental in my faith deconstruction and I think it's one of the main reasons why I was able to deconstruct so quickly and in such a healthy way. So I became a monthly donor to Mormon Stories based just on that series because I think it is well worth the price of tuition for a college course. It was that in depth and amazing.
John Dehlin [04:35:26] And you were digging the Matt Harris second Class AIDS series.
Megan Conner [04:35:28] Yes, I haven't finished it yet. Mainly because things like this keep. Keep popping up But I love that series as well. And I hope anybody who really cares about racism in the church digs into it. And even if you don't care about that much about that topic, there's so much insight and wisdom and Matt Harris's book is just incredible.
John Dehlin [04:35:50] Well, thank you for that. But please subscribe to Megan's YouTube channel. Give her a follow, support her. She's growing her channel and she's doing great work. So Midlife Revolution.
Megan Conner [04:36:04] Yes, that's the podcast at third Underscore Verse is the channel. But you can also, most people find it just by looking up Megan Connor.
John Dehlin [04:36:12] Okay, that's Megan. M, E G A N. Right.
Megan Conner [04:36:14] Yep.
John Dehlin [04:36:15] All right. And then last but not least, Hidden True Crime. Lauren Johnson Matthias with Dr. John. Thank you so much for coming.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [04:36:24] Absolutely. Thanks for. Thanks for suggesting this and doing this.
John Dehlin [04:36:28] People love our collabs. Yeah.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [04:36:30] Getting the band back together.
John Dehlin [04:36:32] Can we do it again? Can this not be the last time?
Lauren Johnson Matthias [04:36:34] I think that's the question. Are we a one hit wonder or
Megan Conner [04:36:36] do we have this? We are more in it more.
John Dehlin [04:36:38] And this is no way we're the Beatles. We're like, we're like breaking all the records.
Megan Conner [04:36:43] And the episodes are longer than an
Mindy Caldwell [04:36:45] album, so we can't seem to create a short episode.
John Dehlin [04:36:49] Friends, I don't want it. I don't want a time to go by fast with you guys. Anyway, please subscribe also to Hidden True Crime podcast. Let's make it a million subscriber YouTube channel. How do they support you, Lauren?
Lauren Johnson Matthias [04:37:03] You know, supporting us subscribing is huge on our YouTube as well as our podcast. Our YouTube is hidden to Crime. Our podcast is Hidden True Crime. But also we do do have a patreon. Patreon.com crime and we actually do behind the scenes exclusive bonuses, bonus episodes on our Patreon every week. So weekly episodes you don't hear anywhere else but Patreon. And it's a wonderful way to support us and we do give back to those that support us with those behind the scene episodes. So that's. That would be great.
Mindy Caldwell [04:37:31] Yeah.
John Dehlin [04:37:32] All right, well, support Hidden True Crime. Thanks for coming, Lauren.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [04:37:35] Thank you.
Bonus Conversation and Recommendations
John Dehlin [04:37:36] Really quickly. Just I want to make sure to mention this. I was supposed to mention in the beginning there's a new drama series on Netflix called American Primordial. Primordial. Have you guys heard about. Heard about this? No, it's. So Barbara Jones Brown reached out to me about it. It's basically a dramatic depiction of the Mountain Meadows massacre.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [04:37:58] Oh.
John Dehlin [04:37:58] And of other Utah related Mormon related In Native American Massacres.
Megan Conner [04:38:05] Wow.
John Dehlin [04:38:05] It's on Netflix. It just dropped like yesterday. Oh, it's a six part series.
Mindy Caldwell [04:38:10] You're saying the wrong title, John. American Primeval. I'm pretty sure it's American Primeval. Is it not?
John Dehlin [04:38:17] Okay, I have American Primordial. If it's American Primeval, y' all in the comments, please let me know. Just go to Netflix. It was released in the, in the past couple days. American Primeval. You're right. American Primeval. Thank you, Mindy.
Mindy Caldwell [04:38:30] You're welcome.
John Dehlin [04:38:31] For the win, super strength.
Mindy Caldwell [04:38:33] I'll get one more in there.
John Dehlin [04:38:34] Super strengther wins again. American Primeval. Watch it. I'm having Barbara and a special guest, Barbara Jones Brown, who's the co author of a book on the Mountain Meadows Massacre. She's also the head of Signature Books. She also helped Turley with the first Mountain Meadows Massacre book. She's phenomenal. We have a special guest coming on and we're going to be doing an episode on Tuesday, this Tuesday, about American Primeval and come with questions because they really want questions. A lot of people are going to want to know how much of its dramatization and how much of it's actually factually history.
John Dehlin [04:39:15] We're going to be talking about that on Tuesday. So go binge watch that. That's your homework for the weekend. Go binge watch American Primeval on Netflix and come back. Please do subscribe. Please like this episode. Please subscribe to the Mormon Stories Podcast YouTube channel.
John Dehlin [04:39:31] Subscribe to us on Facebook, TikTok, Instagram. It all helps. Thank you so much to our bread and butter monthly donors. You know, we get, we call out our super chats here on YouTube but it's our monthly donors that provide 2, 4/5 of our revenue on Mormon Stories podcast. It's just those of you who go up to MormonStories.org click on the donate button, sign up to be monthly donors. You're the ones that pay the bills. We always try and pay our co panelists, which we will for this panel as well. And we have a whole staff of Julia and, and Maven and Brooklyn and Gerardo and Margi and all our Nemo and all our other co hosts.
John Dehlin [04:40:14] We pay them and we try to pay them fairly and even generously if we can. And that's all because of your donation. So thanks to everyone who donated today. But also thanks to just our bread and butter donors. And just know we lose donors every month so if we don't replace them, we have to cut services. So if you want to become A donor. Go to mormonstories.org and become a monthly donor. All right, well, that's. Are y' all exhausted? Are you exhausted?
Lauren Johnson Matthias [04:40:39] Lauren, let's eat.
John Dehlin [04:40:40] You ready? You ready for another four hours?
Lauren Johnson Matthias [04:40:42] I'm ready for a meal.
John Dehlin [04:40:44] Okay. Megan, you exhausted?
Megan Conner [04:40:45] I'm not exhausted. It's energizing being with you guys. It is.
John Dehlin [04:40:48] That's how I feel.
Megan Conner [04:40:49] I love it.
John Dehlin [04:40:50] All right, four more. Let's go. What do you want to talk about?
Megan Conner [04:40:53] Grab another book going off the shelf. Let's go.
John Dehlin [04:40:55] Mindy, are you exhausted?
Mindy Caldwell [04:40:56] I feel good.
Megan Conner [04:40:57] I mean, it's. It's a.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [04:40:58] It's a lot.
Mindy Caldwell [04:40:59] It's a heavy topic, and it's a long time to. To chat and to think about it. But, yeah, it's. It's such a pleasure to be here with all of you and feels.
Megan Conner [04:41:08] What.
Mindy Caldwell [04:41:08] What is our running time? It feels like the time went fast.
John Dehlin [04:41:10] It's. It's four and a half. Four hours and 41 minutes. Whoa.
Megan Conner [04:41:14] Nice.
Mindy Caldwell [04:41:15] Yes.
Megan Conner [04:41:16] Wow.
Mindy Caldwell [04:41:16] Time flies.
John Dehlin [04:41:17] Time to eat.
Mindy Caldwell [04:41:18] I need Snickers.
Lauren Johnson Matthias [04:41:19] Let's go.
John Dehlin [04:41:20] Okay, well, thanks for joining us today. Thanks again to Julia and Brooklyn and Maven and Gerardo and everyone who helps behind the scenes. Stay tuned for more good stuff in the weeks, months, and years ahead. Be good to each other. Be kind to each other. Thank you, Sherry Franke. Thank you, Sherry, for writing an amazing, amazing book. And your. Your co author as well. We gave her a shout out.
Mindy Caldwell [04:41:45] Caroline Writer.
John Dehlin [04:41:46] Caroline writer. Thank you, Mindy. But thank you, Sherry, Frankie. And go buy this book, the House of My Mother, A Daughter's Quest for Freedom. We wish you all the best, Sherry, no matter where your journey takes you. And be good to each other. Be kind to each other. We'll see you all again soon on another episode of Mormon Stories podcast. Take care.
Transcript © 2026 John P. Dehlin. All rights reserved. Brief quotations are welcome with attribution and a link to mormonstories.org; all other use requires written permission.
2 Responses
The top dogs know. They don’t care.
They believe that their status in the organization implies that they are direct agents of God. They see absolutely no need to apologize.
Always great and informative.