561-563: Gina Colvin Interviews John Dehlin on the 10th Anniversary of Mormon Stories Podcast

MeAndFam

Gina Colvin interviews John Dehlin across three parts for Mormon Stories’ tenth anniversary, tracing his life from a religious Boise and Houston childhood through to his excommunication. Dehlin describes growing up devout, his ancestors among early Mormon pioneers, and a socially and spiritually rich Houston stake in the 1980s, shaped by an intense seminary teacher named Lawrence Layton. At BYU he found refuge from a hostile Baptist dating scene, then served a mission in Guatemala, where he grew troubled by pressure to report baptisms he did not believe were sincere, comparing the group pressure to the Asch conformity experiments.

Returning to BYU “broken” and “in a dark place,” he found intellectual community in a religion colloquium alongside professors like Richard Bushman and Terryl Givens, and describes the pull between Sunstone’s “why I stay” panels and its more disaffected voices. His career took him through Bain, Arthur Andersen, the LDS Church’s own offices, and Microsoft, where he says his literal belief in the church’s exclusive truth claims ended around 2001, before he worked for MIT’s OpenCourseWare project. He launched Mormon Stories in 2005 with an episode about his own mission, followed by his first interview, with Greg Prince, and calls his interviews with Carol Lynn Pearson, Michael Quinn, and Grant Palmer among the most memorable.

Dehlin talks candidly about the strain the podcast put on his marriage, his first bishop’s decision to leave him alone after receiving hundreds of listener letters, and the years of being caught between believing and disaffected audiences that led to his 2015 excommunication, which he calls both devastating and exhilarating. He closes by reflecting on the thousands of people he says have told him the podcast helped save their marriages, faith, or lives, and on his plans for Mormon Stories and Mormon Transitions going forward.

What’s covered

  • Part 1 (Ep. 561)
  • 03:26 John Dehlin’s childhood and early life
  • 28:11 BYU years and early Mormon identity
  • 1:01:28 Questions about baptisms and mission leadership
  • 00:00 Return to BYU and career beginnings
  • 25:52 Management consulting and career at Bain
  • 42:19 Rise of the Bloggernacle and online Mormon community
  • 1:03:35 Personal and family impact of the podcast
  • 00:00 From naive optimism to being worn down
  • 07:41 Doubts deepen and the Mormon Stories community grows
  • 47:54 Excommunication and its aftermath

Related episodes: 564: Lindsay Hansen Park Interviews John Dehlin on the 10th Anniversary of Mormon Stories Podcast · 1029-1032: Dr. Gina Colvin’s Pre-Excommunication Interview · 542-543: Gina Colvin – KiwiMormon and Fearless/Faithful Mormon Heretic

Episode Transcript

Full text · 35,700 words · 19 chaptersHost: John Dehlin · Guests: Gina Colvin, Scott Miller

This transcript is machine-generated and lightly edited for readability. The audio is authoritative. Please excuse occasional errors in names and spelling.

Introduction and Welcome

Part 1 of 3 · Ep. 561

John Dehlin [00:00:02] Hello and welcome to another edition of Mormon Stories podcast. I'm your host, John Dehlin. We're coming to you on September 3, 2015. And I have to say this is an episode that's just super exciting for me. It's one that I've been looking forward to for several years. And I'll just get right to it. Today we were interviewing Dr. Scott Miller.

John Dehlin [00:00:26] I first learned of Scott Miller when I was accepted to a PhD program in psychology. And I started reading up on psychology and I learned about this guy that was kind of a world class psychologist telling people or therapists that some of the most important things a psychologist could attend to were things that really had nothing necessarily to do with the mode of psychology treatment itself. And, and these traits are called the common factors. And they have to do with things like, you know, listening well, positive regard, empathy, belief and conviction in one's motive therapy. And what Scott was basically saying was that the clinical intervention that you choose as a psychotherapist maybe isn't as important as just some of those basic human skills that we all know are super important.

John Dehlin [00:01:20] But that was really revolutionary to me at the time because I was just about to join clinical psychology program and it was all about the intervention. And so that's when I first learned about Scott. But then later Scott was invited to give a lecture in Logan as sort of, you know, a world class specialist. And then his focus was on helping therapists become the best possible therapists they could be. And I noticed in Scott's CV in his resume that he had graduated, I believe, undergraduate from byu. Is that right, Scott?

Scott Miller [00:01:56] That's right.

John Dehlin [00:01:57] And then he got his PhD at the University of Utah. Is that right?

Scott Miller [00:02:00] That is right, yeah.

John Dehlin [00:02:01] So, so I was like, wow, this is a world class psychologist, literally known all over the world, mentioned in every psychology textbook or sort of, you know, curriculum that I had been involved with. And he came out of Utah. So after Scott's lecture in Logan a few years back, I was able to have lunch with them and I talked to Scott a bit and it turn out that Scott Miller, Dr. Scott Miller also was raised LDS. And at the time he told me about this really cool book he was finishing up about his mission of sort of a mission memoir of his time in Sweden. And I got really excited about it. And so Scott and I have kept in touch and you know, this month Scott's ready to release his book called the Book of a Mormon. Is that right, Scott?

Scott Miller [00:02:58] That's right. The real life strange times of an LDS missionary.

John Dehlin [00:03:01] Yeah. And you know, I've read, I've read probably a few Mormon memoirs over the past few years. Specifically, I can think of Elna Baker's memoir, Joanna Brooks's memoir, and Ryan McIlvaine's memoir. And this, this, this is, this book, in my opinion, is every bit worthy to stand toe to toe. And in some ways was, was much more electrifying for, because it connected with me and my mission experience with the time, kind of the general time that I was serving. I served a little bit later than Scott, but not too much later. But more importantly, Scott's missionary memoir is so candid, so real, so raw, very well written, very thorough.

John Dehlin [00:03:54] And what I love most about it is it really does a great job of capturing sort of the Joseph Fielding Smith, Harold B. Lee, Mark E. Peterson, Bruce R. McConkie Correlation, correlation sort of era of Mormonism in the 70s and 80s that many of us, I think, believe has sort of irreparably harmed the LDS Church. And so I want to talk today to Scott about three things and we're going to try and get this done in two hours. So it's going to be really hard for me because I'm used to five or six, but these are the three things I want to talk about. I want to talk about Scott's upbringing in the church because that's what we do in Mormon Stories.

John Dehlin [00:04:40] Then I want to talk about something very important. So, you know, we're launching a new project in Mormon Stories called Mormon Transitions. And the whole purpose of Mormon Transitions is to provide support to people who are transitioning either away from orthodoxy towards more progressive Mormonism or out of the church. We know that there's a massive wave of people leaving religions over the world, especially in America, and that is in no way, Mormonism is in no way an exception to this. And one of the biggest fears that I encounter when I talk to progressive and post Mormons is sort of this puzzling fear, this paralyzing fear.

John Dehlin [00:05:19] Can I become a moral person if I leave the church? Can I be a healthy person? Can I have a healthy marriage? And one of the most bizarre and potentially offensive things that I hear, but it's very common, is can I raise health happy children as a post Mormon? And here we have someone who had the courage to be, because of his convictions to leave the LDS Church back in the early 90s. Is that right, Scott?

Scott Miller [00:05:46] It would have been really, yeah, I think about the early 90s, but probably a little bit closer to the late 80s.

John Dehlin [00:05:52] Late 80s, okay.

Scott Miller [00:05:53] Yeah.

John Dehlin [00:05:54] And. And has become a world class human being in several dimensions. And so I want to talk to Scott about that, his transition and any tips or tricks he might have or just encouragement as a psychologist and as a, as a human about transitioning away from religious tradition. And then the final thing I want to talk about, and we're going to surprise you, it's not the book. We want to talk about some of Scott's research and expertise. Now, why are we not talking about the book? We're not talking about the book because we're going to be announcing the re release of Mormon Stories Book Club.

John Dehlin [00:06:32] We've run that in the past, past thanks to the good work of Heather Olson Beale and Brent Beal and others. They may join us in the future with Mormon Stories Book Club. I don't know. But what we want to do is make Scott's book available through Amazon on mormonstories.org encourage people to buy it and to read it over the next month. And then we're going to come back in a month with Scott and with the panel of some really exciting panelists and we're going to talk about his book. And just as a little secret surprise, the one and only Hans Mattsson, who is from Sweden, who is an Area Authority, 70 in Sweden, who actually has a surprise appearance in the book. Is that right, Scott?

Scott Miller [00:07:13] That's exactly right. Actually, it turns out I met Hans Matzon while I was a missionary. He came to visit the small branch that I was working in at that time.

John Dehlin [00:07:22] Yeah. So we're going to have Hans with a few other amazing guests and maybe some of you, if you listen to Scott's book and write a review on Amazon for him, will include you guys in a panel online video discussion with Scott about his book in about a month's time. So that is one not that is one of the longest intros I've ever had in Mormon Stories, but with all that. Dr. Scott Miller, welcome to Mormon Stories podcast.

Scott Miller [00:07:48] Thanks, John. It's really a pleasure to be here and to be speaking with you.

John Dehlin [00:07:52] Thank you. Okay, so let's start with, with your Mormon story, like pioneer ancestry. Tell us just about your upbringing.

John Dehlin's Childhood and Family Background

Scott Miller [00:08:01] I was raised in Glendora, California, which is near West Covina, Pasadena, Pomona. And my parents were Utah Mormons, born and raised in Utah. My father was a school principal. He left Utah in the 1950s after school to take a job as a principal in the Los Angeles area.

Scott Miller [00:08:23] And we lived in an area where there were lots and lots of Mormons right next to Orange County. There were LDS churches everywhere in the Small town that I grew up in. The community was large and I really had a great experience. And the truth is I didn't think of my religion or upbringing as any different than my neighbors who attended different churches. So one of my neighbors was Lutheran, the other neighbors were Catholic. We all went to our various churches on Sunday and we didn't really talk about it, fight about it, try to convert one another. We were all great friends. And so I, I didn't really have a sense of us as peculiar or different.

Scott Miller [00:09:06] I have no idea how they viewed us really. I know that I was treated fairly and equitably by the people I grew up around.

John Dehlin [00:09:14] So you didn't necessarily absorb the sort of feeling of Mormon exceptionalism of like Saturday's Warrior saved to the last days to save the world.

Scott Miller [00:09:25] Well, you know, Saturday's warrior was actually a little bit after my time, so I think I was almost in college by the time Saturday's Warrior came out. So I never really could relate to that. In addition, we had a very diverse membership at that particular ward that I was in. So no, I didn't really have a sense that we were that different, that odd. And that may just be the narcissism of youth. You just don't think about that very much. And I don't think my parents were Bible toting, Book of Mormon reading kinds of folks either. We prayed at dinner time, we held family home evenings on occasion. I home taught with my dad. It was just a regular part of life. It didn't seem like anything exceptional to me really.

John Dehlin [00:10:23] I actually love that because it doesn't necessarily set you up for such a terrible fall. And it could be that you were sort of raised maybe before correlation really had its full effect. I'm going to guess that some of that Bruce R. McConkie thickness didn't really penetrate Mormon consciousness sort of in a heavy way until maybe the early 80s. And so maybe you dodged a bullet a little bit. I don't know.

Scott Miller [00:10:49] I think that's some of it. I also think my parents were for example, Kennedy Democrats at a time when virtually everybody was moving to a more conservative politics amongst. Among Mormons. My father was an educator and he was always more interested in the.

Scott Miller [00:11:11] Not so much the literal interpretation of things, but the lessons behind those, the moral lessons behind those stories that we were told. So as a young person in a story I tell, for example in the book, I got in trouble at church because I must have been nine or 10 years old when I first heard the story of Jonah and the Whale. And I came home and looked in what was the source of all wisdom in my home, the World Book Encyclopedia. And I couldn't figure out how anybody could live in a whale for that long. So I took. I actually snuck the book to church the next Sunday.

Scott Miller [00:11:47] And when I had an opportunity, apparently I have no independent memory of this, my parents report it that I asked the teacher to show us where in heaven's name a person could live inside a whale's gut. At which point this person said, well, it was a big fish, not necessarily a whale. And I said, oh, well, I got a whole set of encyclopedias. You tell me which one to look it up in on the ride home. Because I was sent out of the class and Bishop met with me and my father. And on the way home, I had a really lovely conversation driving in my father's 65 VW bug home about what the meaning of the story might be rather than the literal translation of that story.

Scott Miller [00:12:31] So I think that's the kind of people they were. Correlation, I think, was tightening its grip, but it wasn't as tight as it became during the 1980s. And certainly my parents weren't a product of.

John Dehlin [00:12:43] That sounds like a really wonderful kind of upbringing.

Scott Miller [00:12:46] Honestly, I feel very fortunate, very lucky. My parents were good people. My father served in the Second World War as a medic and saw really, really bad things happen and never. I don't have a single memory. In fact, I can tell you that I didn't know until he was 74 that he'd even been in the bloodiest battle in the Pacific. I didn't know that. So he didn't take it out on us. My mom was a very supportive, traditional housewife of the time, totally devoted to the kids, and I think sacrificing her own personal ambitions in the service of us. So, yeah, I think it was a pretty good upbringing.

John Dehlin [00:13:33] Excellent. And so as we think about your transition to your mission experience, I don't want to give away too many spoilers from the book, but I do want to give people enough of a taste so that they will want to read it, because I think everyone should. So, you know, as I. As I think about.

Personality, Mission Experience, and Early Faith

John Dehlin [00:13:50] As I think about your personality on your mission, you know, you kind of get the impression that you were kind of a surfer kid, a kid that liked to have fun, a kid that, you know, that. That believed in the. In Mormonism and wanted to serve. But also, when you saw things that maybe weren't right, you. You weren't just sort of the zombie dogmatic, you Know, you would just. You were honest and open about things you. You weren't crazy about. And maybe, you know, maybe you had a little bit more salty language than the average starting missionary at the time. Just paid for us a few, maybe a few stories from your mission that would just give people a taste for how wonderful this book is and then we can jump to post mission stuff.

Scott Miller [00:14:37] I. Let me think about that. I think that I did grow up in Southern California. The beach was and continues to be my favorite place in the planet, even though I live in Chicago. Kind of stuck between the two coasts.

John Dehlin [00:14:57] You can't surf Lake Michigan. You can't surf.

Scott Miller [00:14:59] Well, you can surf Lake Michigan, but it's awful cold most of the time. And I wouldn't really. I haven't tried, I guess I should say. And the waves aren't very good. So I didn't get any pressure whatsoever to serve a mission, at least from my parents. And I think that any questioning I did was often out of naivete.

Scott Miller [00:15:22] Growing up in my home, no questions were out of order. So when things came up that seemed odd or didn't square with my sense of reality, I just said them. Now, there's another family story about me that I think gives you an indication of what's going to happen as I venture out to serve a mission for the church. And apparently when I was going to be baptized, I went in for my interview and I was arguing against being baptized, so my parents say. And the reason they said was that I was saying things like, exactly what do I need to do this for? And the bishop said, to be forgiven for your sins.

Scott Miller [00:16:06] And I apparently said, what sins are those? To which he replied, something about arguing with my brothers, not being a good boy, not following the rules at home. And I said, well, those seem fairly lightweight kinds of sins. Maybe we should wait for a while so I have an opportunity to experience them in life. Now, I didn't say it exactly like that, but according to my parents, it created a huge uproar and my baptism was delayed for a while so they could decide whether or not I was ready to become a member. It's that kind of, I think, naive questioning of what people take for granted. That's part of who I am and part of what I confront when I ventured out as a missionary for the church.

John Dehlin [00:16:49] Okay, so willing to question and to just bring sincerity and curiosity and even disagreement.

Scott Miller [00:16:59] I think curiosity is the right word. At one point during my mission, for example, we were told that, well, as often happens in zone conferences, there was a story Told by one of the church leaders, probably the mission president, about a missionary in another country who had begun to break the rules. And eventually, like all missionaries who break the rules, end up in bed with a woman. This is the moral of the story. And that missionary was sent home, much to his own shame and the shame of his family. And I was sitting there thinking I'd been out, I was a little long by this point.

Scott Miller [00:17:39] I'd been out about a year. And I was thinking, where is this going? Why are we being told yet again another story about a missionary who didn't follow the rules and ended up having sex on his mission? And I had no plans of that.

Scott Miller [00:17:54] So apparently what had happened is this missionary and his companion had begun to play tennis with some with each other first. And then two women asked if they could play tennis with them. The missionaries weren't in their suits, of course, they were playing tennis.

Scott Miller [00:18:10] What came out of this story was that we were still allowed to play tennis but would have to be in our suits. So I was sitting in this room with, I'm thinking maybe 60 other missionaries from our mission at the ZONE conference. And I thought, play mission in our suits. I'm in Sweden at the time. It cost about 300 crowns to clean a suit, which was an inordinate sum of money to a missionary living on $250 a month. There was no way anybody was going to play tennis in their suit. So I just raised my hand, naive person that I am, and said, you know, nobody is going to play tennis in their suit because it costs too much to have the suit clean, not to mention how crazy this seems.

Scott Miller [00:18:50] So why don't you just say we can't play tennis in our suits. And the admission president said to me, we can discuss this at your personal priesthood interview. You. Then I knew I'd overstepped the bats. So it was one sort of crazy making kind of experience after after the other. Really?

John Dehlin [00:19:11] Yeah. And I'll just say that your treatment of the mission, you, you, you incorporate a lot of Swedish into the, the book, which gives it a lot of flavor, a lot of fun experiences. And then I think, think it's, I think it's neat how you tie a lot of the stories into sort of providing the non LDS reader with a, a better understanding of many of the cultural, historical and doctrinal aspects of Mormonism. But it's just a great and delightful read. Give us, give us maybe one more story from the mission experience and then we'll just leave the book. Any, any, any favorite Sort of story from the. From the mission you want to provide as a teaser to get people to read it.

Scott Miller [00:19:59] Another experience I had at a Zone conference. You know, missionaries are always hungry. We're always starving, riding around on our bikes, traipsing around in the snow from 9:30 in the morning till 9:30 at night. And at this particular Zone conference, in the middle of the speeches and presentations, both inspirational and training speeches that were being given, the smell brownies began to waft into the chapel. And it was intense and incredible. And I hadn't had a brownie by that time for a long time.

Scott Miller [00:20:35] And after that meeting, we were ushered into another room where we all sat around a table. And there in the middle were these piles of brownies. The smell of them again, I just. I can't even capture in words big glasses of milk by each of the spots at the table.

Scott Miller [00:20:54] And the mission president gave a blessing and then said, dig in. And you can imagine all these famished missionaries. I mean, we dove in and the people were stuffing the brownies in their face, at which point people began to retch and gag. And it turns out. And I had sat there because, I don't know, by this time, something seemed wrong to me about this.

Scott Miller [00:21:19] We'd never been given brownies before, and it just. Something smelled rotten in Sweden. And so I sat there. I didn't stuff mine in my mouth. And it turns out that these brownies had been baked with salt rather than with sugar. And when people began to retch, then the mission president went on about how things are not always as they appear in the world, and how that things that look really good on the outside and even are very enticing can be rotten on the inside.

John Dehlin [00:21:54] Oh, so it's a setup.

Scott Miller [00:21:56] The whole thing had been a setup.

John Dehlin [00:21:58] Oh, man. And I'll just say there's a really fun story about pickle juice. There's. There's really fun stories about when, you know, you and your companion confronted a gang and how that turned out. He talks about you talk about sexuality and even masturbation and rules about being in the bathroom and. Yeah, and it's. It's. I don't want people to think that it's just this kind of lightweight, trivial romp through fun, silly mission stories. It's actually quite intense, gripping, serious and interesting and funny kind of sort of journey. So, anyway, I hope that's enough of a teaser.

Scott Miller [00:22:42] Thanks. Thanks, John. I think it's a really good teaser. And I can certainly say that, like a lot of people who've gone on a mission that those two years aside, died from the birth of my children are the ones that have had the most impact on the arc of my life, really. So. And the difference is that the mission experience for me was much more complex than saying it was the best two years of my life.

John Dehlin [00:23:07] Yeah. Okay, so listeners, pause your podcast. Pause YouTube. If you're watching on YouTube, go to MormonStories.org click on the link in the top left. Order Scott's book, read it within a month, and then we'll come back and talk with Scott about the book. Now Unpause. And Scott, let's talk about post mission. So, okay, talk to us about how, not wanting to give any spoilers away, but talk about how you ended up leaving the church after your mission, like in the early 80s, kind of before you, you know, sort of followed the path that so many returned missionaries follow.

Losing Faith on the Mission and Coming Home

Scott Miller [00:23:50] I really lost my faith while I was a missionary, and maybe lost isn't the right word. What I discovered was that I didn't really have what I thought I had when I left. And I searched and searched on my mission, and then after I came home and I couldn't find it, rediscover it. And my experience as a missionary was such that I didn't really want to be a part of an organization that could treat people like they treated them and act the way that they acted towards their members, the missionaries, and the culture in which they were embedded.

Scott Miller [00:24:40] So I had put in a year at BYU as an undergraduate student prior to leaving and going to Sweden, and I had been two years in Sweden, and I had really spent a great deal of time trying to master the language. It was something that was important to me. I wanted to be a part of the culture. I didn't want to be apart from the culture. So I spent a lot of time trying to sound Swedish and make sure that my language was, when spoken, was correct.

Scott Miller [00:25:13] And I thought, I've got to go back to byu, mainly because I was going to earn nearly a year's worth of language credits if I did. They had a fantastic language department there. And so I applied and got a job as a RA in one of the dorms and finished my undergraduate education at byu.

Scott Miller [00:25:37] Did a minor in Swedish while I was there. And in the process, I was actually going to study biology. And I was interested in veterinary medicine at the time. My uncle, who was the mayor of Springville for years and years and years, and a state senator for a while, had a veterinary practice together with another veterinary physician named Pervance, just on the border between Springville and Provo.

Scott Miller [00:26:11] So I went to work there for during my first year back. And I decided that removing dog's testicles was not what I wanted to do for the rest of my life. It was mind numbingly boring to me. About that same time, I'm taking an undergraduate psychology course from a guy named Hal Miller who was in the department of psychology, an experimental psychologist, a former student of Skinner's.

Scott Miller [00:26:39] And what was amazing about Hal Miller to me was at the very first class, he told you, you don't have to come to class. He didn't care. All you had to do was read these books and turn in the assignments, pass the quizzes and you'll get an A. Here's how you can get an A, a B or a C. But his classroom was packed. People actually were there who weren't even registered for the class. Listening to these lectures. I wanted to be Hal Miller. I wanted to be that invested, interested, curious, excited about learning and knowledge as Hal Miller was. And so I changed my major to psychology.

Scott Miller [00:27:16] I worked closely with Hal and had a fantastic education, really at BYU in psychology. As I got near the end of my time, I was trying to make a decision about what I would do to make a living. Because psychology, psychology as an undergraduate really qualifies you for unemployment and very little else.

Scott Miller [00:27:38] So I had a conversation with Dr. Miller and he told me to go see another psychologist who was working over at the Comprehensive Clinic, whose name was Michael Lambert. And Michael Lambert, if you're talking about world class psychologists right in Utah's backyard, you know, it gives me chills on my arms to think about the contribution that Mike Lambert has made to the field. I went over and talked to Mike Lambert. He said experimental psych is not what you want to do. You want to do clinical psych if you ever hope to eat and have a life.

Scott Miller [00:28:13] And he said, why don't you come and do some work with me? He was writing some chapters for what is the bible of psychotherapy outcome research. It's called the Handbook of Psychotherapy and Behavior Change. I was assisting one of his graduate research assistants summarizing research articles.

Scott Miller [00:28:30] It was an amazing experience, Complete and utter openness to what the science was telling us about human behavior and about how to help people as well. And Michael couldn't be a nicer and more open person. For me, it was a oasis at BYU in a sea of very conservative thinkers. Michael, Hal and many of the other professors I met there were really amazing people.

John Dehlin [00:29:01] Yeah, yeah, they are. I remember Hal Miller from my BYU days and I actually was accepted to work with Michael Amber, but I went to USU instead. But great people. So tell us just a bit about, you know, when and how did you decide to sort of part for Mormonism and, and what was that like in the 80s, early 90s, when maybe it wasn't quite as cool or popular to leave the church? What was that like? Was it hard? How did you do it? What toll did it take on you at the time?

Early Marriage and Life After the Mission

Scott Miller [00:29:41] Well, about a year after I came home, I met, I actually married a person that I had grown up with in Glendora who was also lds. I think looking back on that, because we're no longer married, we divorced after about six years of marriage.

Scott Miller [00:30:00] I was incredibly lonely and we were so ill suited for each other. She was a very nice person, a very good person. We were like oil and vinegar, not in a negative and antagonistic way, but literally floating on top of one another rather than, than being with each other in a real relationship.

Scott Miller [00:30:21] And I made it pretty clear from the outset that I was not interested really in Mormonism, that I would go the requisite amount to church in order to finish my education at BYU so that I could graduate, not come to the attention of the honors system there and get on with my life.

Scott Miller [00:30:46] And I think she was very understanding and supportive. I think it was quite hard for her. Her family was. Were true believers. Although fun loving California people, they were, they were true believers. But I, shortly after we were married, I went only to the requisite amount of church meetings. I never went back really to the temple.

Scott Miller [00:31:11] If I think about it, I never went back. And shortly after we were married, stopped wearing my garments and moved on with my life. I thought during that time several times about writing about my mission experience because it had been so pivotal in my decision that it's not a place for me to be in.

Scott Miller [00:31:36] But at the time I didn't want to invest the energy and tie up the energy in thinking about and reviewing my Mormon experience. I also wrote a paper for Sunstone, and I think this must have been 1986 or 87, where I compared the mission experience to things I was learning about in graduate school, about how people can control others through brainwashing and thought reform.

Scott Miller [00:32:15] I presented that paper, I think it was probably at the 1986 or 1987 Sunstone Conference. The reaction was really kind of interesting. And for a moment I felt like, well, here's a community that I can connect with. If I talk about evolution, for example, I'm not going to be castigated or have people raise their eyelids at me and question whether or not I'd lost my fate. It was more about an exploration and joint curiosity.

Scott Miller [00:32:47] The paper was published in Sunstone. I did a PBS documentary with a filmmaker named Bobby Berleffi called called Mormons Missionaries to the World. She had found me through that particular article and asked me if I'd talk with her about my mission experience. In the meantime, she follows several other missionaries in different parts of their mission right from before they were going to, when they went to being midway through. And then a couple of people like me who'd already finished and either had the kind of experience I had or it was, or for others who it was a faith building experience.

Scott Miller [00:33:26] I went back to Sunstone the following year and I had rewritten the paper and had further thoughts. They invited another psychoanalyst actually to comment on the paper. I'm trying to remember what his name was now. A Jungian analyst. And my experience of that experience event was that it was the same people talking about the same things.

Scott Miller [00:33:58] And that's not what I wanted to do. Now people can have support when whatever community they belong to. For me, I suddenly knew that I didn't want to 10 years, 15 years be rehashing this same stuff about Mormonism. I was ready to say, I'm going to move on, on. And so probably around 1988, 1989, I was done.

John Dehlin [00:34:23] Okay. So I think when people contemplate leaving the church, there are several sort of components to their being. There's their identity, there's their morality, there's their family connections, there's their community, their existential worldview about who they are, where they came from, why they're here, where they're going, growing so many relationships. And I think for many people, those things are so significant, so binding, so compelling that they're almost like hooks.

Fears About Leaving the Church

John Dehlin [00:34:58] And just so many people I meet just say, I'm just worried if I leave the church, I'll lose control or I won't stay moral, or I won't be able to raise good kids or my family will disappoint, disown me, or I won't be respected by my peers. I imagine that you faced at least some of those concerns. Or they'll just say, I don't know where I'll go after I die. I just can't abide the idea of there not being a God or not knowing the afterlife. Like that's too much for my psyche. I can imagine that some of those hooks were in you And I guess my biggest question is, especially in the late 80s, how do you.

John Dehlin [00:35:39] How do you. How did you overcome those barriers and say, I'm going to do this even. Even kind of against a lot of inertia. Your life's inertia, let's just say.

Scott Miller [00:35:51] Well, I think as I, as I, as I sort of, a lot of those. A lot of those hooks I think I dealt with as a missionary. I had never felt as alone in my entire life as I felt as a missionary.

Scott Miller [00:36:12] I spent lots and lots of nights hugging the toilet in whatever dump of an apartment I was living in in Sweden, crying my eyes out from the loneliness. Loneliness, because oftentimes the people I was hooked up with at the time couldn't possibly understand my experience or lack of belief. And secondly, because if I told them, then in our mission, there was an organized way to report all this information back in weekly correspondence and calls with the mission president. So you couldn't trust the person that you were living with to keep a secret or have conversations about what you were really struggling with. You were to look at one another and help them stay on the straight and narrow.

Scott Miller [00:36:59] So I think a lot of this, I began to work out as a missionary, and as I say, I think I lost my faith or my faith lost me midway through my mission experience. And I stayed mostly because I thought it would bring a tremendous amount of shame to my parents and my family.

Scott Miller [00:37:24] And secondly, I really believed that if I gave up on what was a difficult thing to do, that that would set an awful precedence for me in my life. Sometimes in life you have to do stuff you don't like and do it for a long time. People do this every day when they go to jobs that aren't great jobs, but they do it because it puts bread on the table and it makes their family life possible. And so I thought, number one, it would be quite selfish of me to just go home. And number two, I worried what it would mean, you know, the next time I have a difficult experience, would I just give up?

Scott Miller [00:38:01] And one of the things that came out of my mission, I'm sort of, I guess, drifting a bit here. One of the things that came out of my mission, John, that I value is I feel like I can almost do anything.

Scott Miller [00:38:17] If I could do that and survive for that long a period of time, I could almost do anything. And so some of those hooks, some of those problems I'd worked out before, the idea that you're not going to be a moral person simply because you're not Mormon I had a strong sense of who I was in the book. I do talk, for example, about the constant refrain about masturbation. I mean, it was before I left. It was while we were there constantly in every interview, the mission president looking you in the eyes, asking you if you're morally worthy.

Scott Miller [00:38:54] The code word for whacking off, you know, So I, at some point, after, I think, naively believing that this person was there to help me, it became clear that that's not what it was about. Secondly, as I. Again, as I relate in the book, I was going to the library, I was breaking the rules, and I was doing tons of research about this, this. And suddenly things I've been told and I think accepted, not believed, but just accepted on face value. Like your parents tell you stuff, you just believe it.

Scott Miller [00:39:29] Masturbation leads to homosexuality. You know, it's absolutely laughable. Even in the early 80s, it was laughable that masturbation was unhealthy, that it would lead you to have poor connections with people. If so, nobody's going to have a relationship that I know of.

Scott Miller [00:39:49] So it was these kinds of experiences and having plenty of time on myself to think that and then enduring the experience that I think had me decide that, you know what? I'm not such a bad person. I'm always. I'm conscientious to a fault. I'm just gonna have to. I'm just gonna have to trust that.

John Dehlin [00:40:17] How about the fear and concern about disappointing loved ones? How'd you surmount that?

Scott Miller [00:40:24] Well, With my folks, I decided early on because I really wanted to come home early on, really want. And beyond just the homesickness that everybody feels, I felt like a square peg in a round hole. And not only that, I felt like our whole mission program was a square peg being pounded into a beautiful round hole called Sweden.

Scott Miller [00:40:54] So I decided that I was going to do this for them. But I've got lengthy journal entries where I say that this is it. I've paid my price. When I get home, I am now an adult, and I will have to make adult decisions, and the pieces will have to fall where they may.

Scott Miller [00:41:14] I don't think my parents had any idea. In a way many parents don't have any idea about what goes on with their kids. A lot of the time during the day, I don't think they had any idea what I was experiencing as a missionary in Sweden.

Scott Miller [00:41:32] Otherwise, they may have taken different. They may have taken different steps. So when I got home, I was fairly blunt about what I was going to do. That I really wasn't interested in Mormonism anymore, that I wanted to go to graduate school. I was going to give up veterinary science and become a psychologist. My mother's response to that was, oh, God's God, you know, not that field.

Scott Miller [00:41:58] Couldn't you be a real doctor instead of this phony doctor? Psychology was sort of, I guess, in her mind, next to Satan worship in some respects.

John Dehlin [00:42:10] Thanks to Bruce R. McConkie.

Scott Miller [00:42:11] Yeah, but you know, my parents were good people and I think they understood and interestingly enough, I think they almost stepped back and took a hands off approach. I'm not sure they knew what to say to me or how to talk about it. And I do believe that my folks believed that the relationship with me was more important than whether or not I went to church ultimately. Did it bother them? Yeah, in the same way that when your own children make choices that don't fit for you, that you hope for them in any way, that it worries you, that it bothers you. We know our way. My parents knew Mormonism, but at the same time they loved me. And that was going to be the overriding interest.

John Dehlin [00:43:03] What about the fear that if you were to have children that they wouldn't be good moral people? Did you ever have that sort of worm in your brain or did you just never?

Scott Miller [00:43:13] You know, to me this reminded me of. First off, I think on my mission I experienced. I want to be careful here because I don't just want to be inflammatory. So I'm talking here about my experience of the people that I served with. They may have a very different experience of this, but it's my experience, to me, of course, that altered the arc of my life. And so I would say I experienced a kind of sadism that dressed up in the garb of holiness, that if that was what moral meant, then I didn't want my kids to be anywhere near it. So I think. And the pickle story that you tell or that you mentioned is one example that this missionary serves me pickle juice

John Dehlin [00:44:13] as a juice for breakfast. You thought it was orange juice?

Scott Miller [00:44:18] I did. And it was kind of. There was a sadistic quality to it. And then just some of the interactions and the emphasis was so horribly misplaced that I decided early on that. That those people had no corner on morality either and that I had to think about for myself what was a good person and then try to convey that to my own family, my own kids.

John Dehlin [00:44:48] So as we think about that sort of. Was it a seven year marriage that you had?

Scott Miller [00:44:54] Six, about six years.

John Dehlin [00:44:56] I can only Imagine putting myself in your shoes. That sort of going through a divorce as a non believing sort of post Mormon only fits the stereotype of like the life falling apart of, of choosing sin or selfishness and sort of sending this message to everybody that you kind of failed and, and we're gonna, and we're gonna choose a life of, of waywardness. Was that an emotional tax that you were burdened by or, or not so much did you kind of move beyond.

Scott Miller [00:45:30] Let me, let me just say that and go back to something you said earlier. Post Mormon. I don't view myself as a post Mormon and I know we have to have a language to try to describe this particular experience any more than I'm a post child now that I'm an adult. I'm not a post child. I am an adult with a continuous experience of myself from the time I was little. And, and it's the same thing with Mormonism. I would say I'm beyond my childhood, which includes Mormonism. And there are many wonderful aspects to that upbringing. But I'm not a kid anymore. I'm an adult and I'm making more adult decisions.

Scott Miller [00:46:16] And I think if you're moving away from the faith or anything that you've been committed to, including a marriage, you have to see both sides of this and see it as an integrated part of yourself. I was listening to the interview with Clark Johnson again, who was the person you interviewed, who was in the Book of Mormon, the play.

Scott Miller [00:46:42] And he has such a lovely way and such a mentally healthy way of talking about leaving the church. And the truth is you don't leave, you move on, you move beyond. Like I say in my ham fisted way here, that I'm no longer a child. But Mormonism is very much a part of who I was. Would I go to the Mormon Church now? I'm not interested. But I'm not interested in go visiting my elementary school either, you know, so.

John Dehlin [00:47:14] So you don't identify as a post Mormon?

Scott Miller [00:47:16] No, and I don't really identify as a Mormon either. I'm Scott Miller, I guess, with an identity as a psychologist and a researcher, a parent, a partner who was raised in Glendora. Now I haven't been in California. Here's another perfect example. I haven't lived in California since I moved to the Midwest, which was about what? Well, the very early 90s. But I still, if you would have seen me yesterday, I had my Newport Beach T shirt on and a swimsuit all day. Where the hell am I gonna swim? I'm living in the Midwest. So I still have that part of my surfer childhood with me. Even though I'm not a surfer, I'm really not a Californian anymore. I've lived out of the state for longer than I lived in it.

John Dehlin [00:48:13] So when you did experience that failed marriage, it sounds like you didn't carry a lot of shame with that. You were just ready to move on, is that right?

Scott Miller [00:48:29] I struggled with that decision for several years. And I will tell you that on my wedding night, I knew I'd made a mistake, a mistake that I swore I would never make again. I had told myself as a missionary that when I got home, I had to really think through things before I made decisions that were hard to undo.

Scott Miller [00:48:55] And so I struggled back and forth about undoing this decision that I had made, because now another person was involved here, so it wasn't just me. But on my wedding night, I knew this was a mistake. So there really was no honeymoon for me. And the next three years was really trying to make something work that I had already decided wasn't likely to work.

Scott Miller [00:49:22] And so I did have guilt, but mostly about this other person that I was with being hurt by my decision, because I think her view was that this was forever and we were going to have a traditional Mormon family somehow with kids and live in the celestial kingdom. And, you know, that wasn't what was going to happen. And I knew it from the beginning.

Scott Miller [00:49:52] And so there was a selfishness, I think, in that decision that I felt guilty about. The selfishness was, I'm so lonely and I'd love to start having sex. And the truth is, my marriage didn't solve either of those problems.

John Dehlin [00:50:12] Wonderful. Okay, so I don't know if this part really is going to be unique to Mormons in any way, but you get divorced, you sort of move on from Mormonism. There's a lot of people out there that are also moving on from Mormonism. And this may just be basic life skills, but let's just say you were to get give three major pillars of sort of transitioning away from a fundamentalist religious tradition into a life of happiness, success, health, and meaning. What would be some pillars also, as a psychologist that you would offer people to sort of frame their approach to finding health and happiness and healing. Healing. After being caught up in this religion for 20, 30, 40, 50 years, are

Navigating the Transition Out of Mormonism

Scott Miller [00:51:05] you looking for, you mean, like, practical steps?

John Dehlin [00:51:07] Just. Yeah, just. Just. Yeah, just kind of wisdom. Like just, you know, three or four pieces of wisdom that you think helped you leave this tradition that had such a grip on you. But also succeed phenomenally in your life. So it's kind of the Oprah meaning sort of give us three or four pieces of wisdom that we can sort of orient our lives by kind of question.

Scott Miller [00:51:39] Yeah, well, I guess I would say I feel it would be the height of presumptuousness to advise people about that. I think each person's journey truly is unique. And I have several close friends who are still in the faith, although at different levels, and struggle. And so I have a great life. John, does that mean there are never worries or anxieties or depression and discouragement? Absolutely not. So the truth is that if you think leaving Mormonism will make you happy, you've got another thing coming.

Scott Miller [00:52:23] So the way to solve that is to have a vision, in my opinion, about where you want to go and what you want to achieve and make that decision, make that vision happen. All I did was say, I don't want this. I really want this over here. I couldn't keep saying this isn't what I want. I had to specify what it was. I really did want.

Scott Miller [00:52:46] I wanted a. A career in psychology. I wanted a freedom to think and do what I wanted. So I think having a vision, not just being against what you've experienced, but being for what you want in your life.

Scott Miller [00:53:03] The second thing I think is you're going to need help. And the best help is people who don't know anything about Mormonism and who don't care about Mormonism. It's amazing how many people, when you say I was raised a Mormon, they go, what's that? You know, if you're inside Mormonism, it consumes your entire world. Most people don't give Mormonism a second thought. And not because they're mean or rude or they don't. They're anti Mormons. They just don't think about Mormonism. We inside the faith think about it every second of every day and make every decision based on. Based on that they don't have any idea about it.

Scott Miller [00:53:45] So you need to hang around, I would say regular people, people whose entire lives aren't consumed by this activity. And pretty soon you start to find there are amazing people who live rich lives that have nothing to do with Mormonism, every aspect of it. And I been very lucky to have met people that are a supportive community to me, not the supportive anti Mormon roots community, but supportive of my vision, where I want to be, who I want to hang out with, the sense I have of myself as a person. So I would say the second piece is community. Reach out and after you've been out of it.

Scott Miller [00:54:36] Because I've been gone a long time. You know, it was one of my worries about writing this book that I just haven't thought really. And Mormonism hasn't really consumed my life for a very long time. There'll be a day when you look back and you'll hear something about Mormonism. And you may. You may think, oh, yeah, I remember that. But then you'll think, wow, that's the weirdest and strangest belief possible. How could I have ever.

Scott Miller [00:55:02] How could anybody believe that? It's tantamount to somebody knocking on your door right now if you're stuck in it and saying, look, there's this blue God. His name's Vishnu, he has eight arms, and if you believe in him, you're going to go to heaven. You would go, mm. And you would shut the door.

Scott Miller [00:55:20] That's the reaction people have to the Mormons. And neither here nor there, doctrinally wise. If you want to move beyond that, you just have to surround yourself with people that are different than that. You know, as for the worries about, you know, moral debauchery, you know, I think one good thing I got from my faith was not the moral rules of Mormonism. Don't have sex before marriage, don't masturbate.

Scott Miller [00:55:53] That wasn't it. But I do think psychologically, there's an important principle here for mental health, and that is delaying gratification. And being able to delay gratification is an important component of success.

John Dehlin [00:56:06] The marshmallow test, right?

Scott Miller [00:56:08] It's the marshmallow test. If you want a fantastic read, there's a brand new book out written by the person who came up with the marshmallow test. And if you don't know about that, what essentially researchers, psychologists have found, found is that if you take a younger child and put them in a room all alone, sounds like my mission. And you put a marshmallow on the table and you can say, you can eat this now, or if you wait, you can have two later, and then you leave the room. And it just so happens that kids who wait, and the longer they wait, that the waiting period is predictive of success in life in terms of income and durable relationships, et cetera.

Scott Miller [00:56:51] So I think that's what I got. And that's one of the messages I say to my own child, that it's. But it's not couched in this language, I think unhealthy language about sexuality, but more about needing to work hard to get what you want and not always getting it right away.

John Dehlin [00:57:15] So that's something that you've kept, that's actually been useful to you.

Scott Miller [00:57:19] Yeah. And so the two parts for me in terms of somebody who's beginning to transition is number one, don't be against something before something. Look for the vision, where do you really want to go? And that can be a challenge because again, Mormonism is all consuming and I don't think you realize how all consuming it is until you're outside of it.

Scott Miller [00:57:40] And the second piece of this is to start to make friends and have community outside of Mormons. And I think those two pieces have really served me well. And then I guess if there's a third point, it's I've been patient with myself because in the beginning, you know, you have feelings. And I wouldn't say my feelings were more guilty, but struggling with, how could I ever have believed this?

Scott Miller [00:58:15] What is wrong with me that I ever sort of gave this a second thought? And those negative sort of punitive, that negative punitive self talk was a struggle for me more so than oh my God, there's no God, we're all going to die and that's it. You know, that kind of stuff, I didn't really, it didn't occupy my mind

John Dehlin [00:58:42] so much real quickly. So do you. Is trying to reconstitute a theological sort of existential worldview important to you or is your focus sort of just on living your life and letting the afterlife be or not be?

Scott Miller [00:59:01] Well, it's interesting to hear you use that word because I think if somebody says to me and you haven't asked, but I'll say it, if somebody says, well, do you believe in God? I usually say I don't believe and I don't not believe.

Scott Miller [00:59:16] It's just not something that I spend my life thinking of on a day to day basis. I'm trying to do the best job I can in the work that I do. I'm trying to, to improve in my relationship with my partner and be a good father to my son.

Scott Miller [00:59:32] That takes a lot of bandwidth just to do that. There's plenty of guilt there. But I think my outlook on life is more existential. Meaning that I'm trying to understand and make meaning in my own life in the here and now. But I'm not consumed by what happens after I died and I'm not worried about how I got there. I'd have to really think more about that.

Scott Miller [01:00:04] But I think I'm more interested in making meaning in the here and now and trying to be a decent person with the people that I live with and interact with.

John Dehlin [01:00:16] How have you avoided the paralyzing fear of death and possibly the termination of your existence?

Scott Miller [01:00:23] Well, this is another interesting thing that was really. That made me. Reminded me when I listened to the interview with Clark, and that is, for a long while, I think I didn't care if I lived or died. And Clark says the same thing, which is kind of interesting. Here I am a member of the only true church on earth, and as the plane takes off, if it crashes, I'm thinking the same thing Clark said in his interview, which was fantastic to hear somebody who had a sort of similar experience, that if it crashes, you know, that's not so bad because life really is a lot of work.

Scott Miller [01:01:00] And I was. And I was, I think. I wouldn't say tortured, but I was before I made the decision that, you know, I'm going to move on from here, here, I think I struggled. So once I was beyond that decision, had made that decision, and I'm moving on, then it's interesting how that angst lifted, really. And I'm not worried about what happens after. If there is a God, I figure that person will take care of it. And if there isn't, it'll be like before I was born. I won't know anything anyway.

John Dehlin [01:01:41] And sufficient the day at hand, basically.

Scott Miller [01:01:43] Well, there are enough challenges about being a good person that I. I think that's enough to focus on.

John Dehlin [01:01:51] And opportunities for doing good. Right. That's how I see it.

Scott Miller [01:01:54] And. And opportunities for doing good with your. By your family, by you. Yeah. Yeah.

John Dehlin [01:02:01] Okay, so let's turn. Tell me how many minutes you have left. I want to squeeze every drop out of the lemon, but at the same

Scott Miller [01:02:08] time, I have about 20 more minutes.

John Dehlin [01:02:09] Okay, good. All right, so let's jump into your amazing career. Tell us. You know, I think of common factors and I think of super Shrink as just the shorthand for the. The two big things I'm aware of. Talk us through. And, you know, most of our listeners obviously aren't mental health professionals or psychologists, but there are a few. But just talk us through some of the. The biggest parts of your profession and your research and your clinical work. And. And in a way that might be broadly useful to 40 to 80,000 Mormons and former Mormons and humans out there.

Graduate School, Career, and Professional Life

Scott Miller [01:02:50] Well, right out of graduate school, I took a job in Milwaukee and moved from. I did a postdoc in California in Palm Springs, and I moved to Milwaukee and I began working. I was very fortunate. Began working with two leading minds in the field at the time, and they were developing a very specific approach to treatment.

Scott Miller [01:03:15] And what was interesting about this experience is I gained immense confidence as a practitioner, because I have to tell you that when you finish graduate school, most therapists, it's an exception that you leave graduate school thinking, now I know how to help people.

Scott Miller [01:03:36] What you leave with is a ton of ideas, no practical experience, and really, you're winging it. So I got a great deal of confidence by going to this place. Unfortunately, after working there for several years and doing research, we found that the particular approach that we were working on wasn't any more effective than anything else, which, if you're trying to sell books, is not a good thing to find. You know, you want to find that your method is best. And so the question was, what to do? And it's created huge controversy in the team that was working together. But eventually the team split, and the half that I was with was going to follow where the science led us.

Scott Miller [01:04:20] And the science said, this method that we're using just isn't where it's at. I didn't say we weren't effective. What I said was we weren't any more effective than everyone else. So the question is, well, why believe that? Why believe in this method if in fact it's just as good at getting you to home base as anything else? So we began looking at factors that all approaches have in common. We had sort of an ecumenical approach. All roads lead to Rome. What are the factors that each one of these particular approaches operationally in unique ways

John Dehlin [01:04:55] and just really quickly to give listeners an understanding of what we're talking about. Just as an example, a therapist can use various modalities in their approach to treating clients. They can use cognitive therapy, cognitive behavioral therapy, Freudian therapy. There's a hundred thousand different types of therapy out there. And basically what you're saying is, in many ways, there's not a lot of difference. And so I just wanted to make

Scott Miller [01:05:20] sure listeners understood, and let's even draw the parallel even closer, given that subject of your podcast. You know, there are many religions, and all of them say, ours is the one. And some of them say it more loudly. We don't have to mention who on this podcast. So essentially what we were saying was is that, look, in the end, all these different religions have a way of getting you to home base or to heaven. That's not satisfying to any of the people who believe completely in that particular

John Dehlin [01:05:53] religion or who want your time and money.

Scott Miller [01:05:56] That's right. So then the question is, well, how do we? How do we solve this? I'm not the first person to say that. Well, you know, all of these religions sort of do very similar things and say similar things. And that's essentially what we were saying about our treatment approach in psychotherapy, which, as I've already mentioned, appeals not at all to the true believers. And it doesn't solve the question about, well, which one should I join then? Do I just roll the dice? You know, so ultimately we even gave up the common factors because it didn't convince anybody, knowing that they all preached the same thing.

John Dehlin [01:06:33] And tell us just quickly what those

Scott Miller [01:06:35] were, because listeners won't know which were

John Dehlin [01:06:38] what the common factors are.

Scott Miller [01:06:39] Oh, things like a strong therapeutic relationship with your provider. We know as researchers that most of the difference in outcome between treatments are attributable to the relationship with the provider. It's not about their college degree, their training, their certification, or which method they're using. It's really about how the patient feels about their therapy therapist and whether that therapist invites a high level of engagement on the part of the patient.

Scott Miller [01:07:15] Which also says that if you're a consumer of a mental health service and you don't like your therapist and you don't feel engaged, you feel like that they're not helping you, you should get out. They don't have any special wisdom. If what they say doesn't engage you in the process and doesn't help you, you should leave.

Scott Miller [01:07:33] And what we have done, done, I think most recently is say, how do you know when to leave? How do you know when the particular counselor or church is one you shouldn't stick with much longer? And so we developed a set of metrics, set of tools that clinicians can use that clients or their patients fill out that indicate when there's a mismatch, a lack of fit and a lack of progress, and as a result, that empowers both the consumer of the service and the provider of the service to enter into that conversation. Maybe this isn't the right one for you.

Scott Miller [01:08:17] And that in and of itself is sort of a. Interestingly enough, it's kind of a monumental finding. And I'm not the only person to point this out. I stand stand on the shoulders of a remarkably great thinker. One of them I've already mentioned, Mike Lambert, who was onto this a decade before we were. I think our unique contribution, perhaps of late, is that once we began using these metrics or these tools to measure the outcomes, we found that, interestingly enough, not some treatment approaches, not some religions were better than Others, but rather some therapists, some members of a religion, some ministers within those religions were better than others.

Scott Miller [01:09:06] And we wanted to find out what made those therapists top performers, how come some of them really excelled at engaging. The people that they worked with were able to engage a much broader and more diverse clientele than others. And that's what we've been trying to unpack and understand so that other therapists who are less able can improve their work.

John Dehlin [01:09:32] And that's the super shrink idea.

Scott Miller [01:09:35] That's right.

John Dehlin [01:09:35] And if you're comfortable, just share with us sort of the big secret that the super shrinks have on all the other mental health professionals out there. If you don't mind. I don't mind giving away the secrets.

Scott Miller [01:09:47] Well, I'll tell you this. It's not their amount of education, communication. It's not the technique that they use. Iq, not iq, not emotional intelligence either. It's not years of experience. It's not number of hours doing therapy. It's not prior social skills and abilities. What it is is these therapists are able to relate to and engage a broader and more diverse clientele. 97% of the difference in outcome among providers is their ability to engage clients. What it means is that the best engage more and they engage clients who have a much more diverse presentation. So I think if you tie this back to religion, it's about relationships and it's about people. And for us, what we're trying to do is help therapists let go of their dogma about what they know needs to be done with a patient or a consumer and embrace the client.

John Dehlin [01:10:59] And isn't the secret sauce of that engagement simply having a regular dialogue between therapist and client about what's working and what's not working? Just a candid weekly. Hey, how did today's session go? Was it good for you? Was it not good for you? What worked, what didn't?

Scott Miller [01:11:18] That's right.

John Dehlin [01:11:19] Isn't that it?

Scott Miller [01:11:20] Yes. In addition to having a norm reference. So not only do I have to have a conversation with the person that I'm working with and assess whether or not it's working or not working, whether they're engaged, whether I've offended them, etc. I also have to. I also have to have some norm to compare to. And therapists, because they work in isolation in their offices, their view of what's normal and not can become terribly skewed. People are not. People in general are not like patients in therapy in particular. So you have to have some kind of norm reference to know when what I'm believing is not, not actually common.

John Dehlin [01:12:07] Okay.

Scott Miller [01:12:08] And I think that, you know, again, to see, I may be stretching things to the breaking point here, but to me that's the same thing that needs to happen. If you're thinking about moving beyond your Mormon roots, you have to have a different norm reference. If you continually compare yourself to the people at the sacrament meeting, you're going to be pretty discouraged and depressed most of the time because not even they are representative of most Mormons.

John Dehlin [01:12:38] Right, right. And I just, I just have to, I'm sorry for drawing parallels here, but one of the, I think one of the illnesses probably of our, of our church culture is there isn't, there isn't a way, There is no interest in feedback. Right. I mean, from, from the general authorities down to the bishops, it's not about, how's this working, what can we do better? Let's have a symbiotic mutual relationship. It's sort of unidirectional. It's like, here's what you are to do and here's what we're going to do and you can, you can sort of pay, pray and obey. But, but, but the, but the goal is submission. Not, not an interaction of respected sort of co. Equals.

Scott Miller [01:13:24] Right. And I can say that this is not a problem unique to Mormonism. I would say the healthcare industry as a whole has operated under this idea that the doctor tells you what to do and you either do it or not. And if you don't do it well, then, my goodness, you're non compliant and helping therapists and healthcare practitioners shift this mentality. Thank goodness for the millennium.

Scott Miller [01:13:53] I think that the millennials are changing the shape of our culture at the present time and much for the better. In fact, I just read a stat here today. Listen to this. Let's see, where is it? It says that millennials, people under the age of 35, want feedback 50% more often than non millennials.

Scott Miller [01:14:15] It's about inequality of relationship. And I think that we need to move in that particular direction because society is changing, culture is changing, you need the other person. You don't need an authority telling you what to do all the time.

John Dehlin [01:14:31] Yeah, beautiful. Okay, so the way that we always end Mormon stories. Scott and I sure have loved our time together and I, I know that we could talk for hours more, but the way that we end is with people sharing the equivalent of their testimony. And when we say that, what we mean is if you have any parting wisdom or thoughts or experiences that you want to share, sort of as what you stand for and what you believe in and who you are. Let's even say, if you have had to give your own eulogy or write your own tombstone, what would you want kind of said or written in those circumstances?

John Dehlin [01:15:19] I now I'm going to stall for a bit to give you a chance to collect your thoughts. But that is, that is, that's how we always end Mormon stories. And you've shared a lot of really good things with us today. You even shared your wisdom about what, what advice you'd give to people who are transitioning and in addition to your research. But how would you feel about giving us your lived sort of final thoughts of inspiration or wisdom to how you would want to be thought of or remembered or what words you would want to share?

Scott Miller [01:16:00] If somebody asked me how I hope to be remembered, I would hope they would say that Scott had an undying curiosity and sense of wonder about the world and faith that in the end it would all work out.

John Dehlin [01:16:19] So curiosity and sort of faithful optimism.

Scott Miller [01:16:25] Yeah. I think that ultimately it all works out. And if it otherwise, there's not much to worry about. You know, my mother spent the better part of her life anxious and worried, worried about money and worried about who would get her possessions after she died and worried about what would happen to us as kids. And now she's dead. So, you know, what was all the worry about? So I prefer to live in a world of wonder and curiosity. And if I have helped other people or if I've stimulated people to think of the impossible as possible, then I think I've done my job as a psychologist, as a partner,

John Dehlin [01:17:18] the father.

Scott Miller [01:17:19] And there is so much. The world is such a large an interest, interesting place. There is so much. The minute you open your eyes, there's something to be curious about and interested in.

John Dehlin [01:17:32] Yeah. So seize the day.

Scott Miller [01:17:35] Seize the day.

John Dehlin [01:17:36] Carpe diem. All right. Dr. Scott Miller, you are an inspiring human to me, and so I'm honored to share you with your. Some of. I don't want to say your former people, but share with you a lot of my listeners. So I'm so delighted.

Scott Miller [01:17:56] I'm grateful, John. And I think that what Mormon Stories does and what the community that you've created is really very important. And I value our connection and our friendship.

John Dehlin [01:18:09] Thank you. Okay, so, listeners, you have a very important duty and responsibility. You are to go to MormonStories.org, you are to click on that link. You are to purchase Scott's book, Book of a Mormon. What's the subtitle again?

Scott Miller [01:18:27] Real life and strange times of an LDS missionary.

John Dehlin [01:18:29] All right. And you were to read that book in a four week period. It's a great read. It's a fast read. I read a third of it over just one weekend so I know you could do it too.

Scott Miller [01:18:41] Can I say one thing about the book, John?

John Dehlin [01:18:43] Yeah, please.

Scott Miller [01:18:43] It's not a. This book is told through the eyes of a 19 year old. It's told in real time. So it's a novelized version really of the mission experience. This isn't a retrospective look at what happened on my mission and I believe you would agree, John, it's not a screed. I'm not interested in that. I was interested in simply telling the story.

John Dehlin [01:19:05] Yeah, no, I think it's a really important book. I don't know of a better book to capture sort of the Mormon missionary experience in the 70s and 80s 80s and I think that's a really important. That's when the missionary program exploded. And so I think it's just super important part of our history and culture and just great life lessons for everybody, non Mormons included. So go get the book, go buy the book.

Scott Miller [01:19:28] Thanks.

John Dehlin [01:19:29] Start reading the book and in one month's time we're going to bring Dr. Scott Miller back to Mormon Stories to Mormon Stories Book Club. We're going to bring on Hans Mattson, the former Swedish and area authority. We're going to bring on some other guests, some of you who are willing to go up and write a review of the book. We will select you to join us and we're going to have a fantastic dialogue about this amazing book as the kickoff launch to the the New Mormon Stories Book Club. So we'll see you in a month, Scott.

Scott Miller [01:20:04] Perfect. Look forward to it, John.

John Dehlin [01:20:06] And all the listeners out there, there, please go to mormonstories.org please give your feedback to Scott. If you have questions or comments, maybe Scott will be able to review that and interact with some of you.

Scott Miller [01:20:17] And you can find, you can find me on the web by the way. So if you, what's your website? Well, Scott D. Miller.com and you can email me through the web. There's a Facebook page called the Book of a Mormon that you can leave messages there as well and I'll, I'm, I'm looking at those and respond. Responding in time.

John Dehlin [01:20:34] Brilliant. Brilliant. All right. And, and just finally to all of you who support Mormon Stories, especially financially, just know that, that your donations make this all possible. It's how I feed my family and it's just super appreciated so thanks to everyone who supports us and Dr. Scott Miller. We'll see you in a month.

Scott Miller [01:20:54] Thanks, John.

John Dehlin [01:20:55] All right, take care.

Scott Miller [01:20:56] Thanks.

Returning to BYU and Reconnecting with Mormonism

Part 2 of 3 · Ep. 562

Gina Colvin [00:00:01] Nearer my God, to thee Nearer to thee. This is part two of John de Lynn from the beginning. Okay, so you end up back at byu. You're a little bit broken.

John Dehlin [00:00:16] Yeah, I was dark. I was in a dark place.

Gina Colvin [00:00:19] Right, Tell us about that. What do you mean you're in a dark place?

John Dehlin [00:00:22] Well, I'm, I'm, you know, all this stuff, it took years. It wasn't until like the summer before my senior year that Alder Oaks contacted me. And so, you know, imagine my sophomore, junior and half of my, you know, senior year just living with this darkness.

John Dehlin [00:00:44] I was still active in the church, I was still attending, but I, as soon as I came back, I ran into this man named Ted Lyon who, who I've had on Mormon stories, but he's the son of T. Edgar Lyon, who was the right hand man to Lowell Bennion, who had served in the institute at the University of Utah.

John Dehlin [00:01:10] And Ted Lyons introduced me to these BYU courses called Colloquium, Honors Colloquium. And these were sort of where the liberals at BYU hung out and taught the students the honors program. Joanna Brooks was part of it, and all the thinky, intellectual kind of kids were part of the honors program at byu. That's where the student review crowd hung out. And Ted Lyon challenged me to take an Honors Colloquium class at BYU as a sophomore. And so it was there that I got introduced to Sunstone and Dialogue and, you know, thoughts about evolution and Age of the Earth and all the science stuff. You know, just imagine a full year of like, curriculum at BYU that was like the best of Sunstone and Dialogue.

John Dehlin [00:02:02] That's what my sophomore year at BYU was. And interestingly enough, it was that colloquium experience and that sort of Sunstone and Dialogue experience that saved me in the church because I'm like, oh, there are people who know these things and have difficulties and who are able to talk openly about these things and who are willing to admit that the leaders are imperfect and they're still active in Temple Recommend holding and faithful and BYU professors. And so instead of me just feeling like everything was dark and corrupt, I was able to find a bunch of professors that were like, oh, yeah, the church is flawed and this is Bill Bradshaw and, and Ted Lyon and Lamont Tullis and all these other Lynn England and Clayton White and all these Sunstone attending sort of professors at byu.

John Dehlin [00:02:55] And they were able to just say, yeah, the church is flawed and there's a ton of problems all through the history. And as soon as I ran into that crowd. I was like, oh, well, then I can stay in the church, because there's tons of people like me who doubt and question and find imperfections in the church but are still able to make it work. And so that being part of the honors program, Honors colloquium, and honors Religion classes really, really rescued me at byu. And so, yeah.

Gina Colvin [00:03:27] So you were reconsidering your membership before you were integrated into this colloquium?

John Dehlin [00:03:32] I wouldn't say that. I would say because I still believed through. I was still a believer through. I'd say, you know, just. I was still a. I would say, in many ways an orthodox believer through kind of 2000, 2001, seven, eight years after I left BYU. What I was, was depressed and confused and in a really dark place psychologically, not knowing how to deal with the cognitive dissonance of knowing that the church is true, but having experienced such a traumatic experience on my mission that then seemed to go to the, you know, the fish seemed to be rotting at the head. And I, you know, I, at the time, I probably would have gone more the Rock Waterman direction than the, you know, ex Mormon direction, because I still.

John Dehlin [00:04:24] I still maintain belief in the church. So just consider me dark and confused at this point. Not. Not really ex Mormon material. You know what I mean?

Gina Colvin [00:04:35] What. Why did it hurt you so much? Because, I mean, thousands. And when we had the same baptismal challenge discussion culture down here in New Zealand. But why were you so dark about it? Thousands and thousands of missionaries kind of put up with it. Why could, why, why did you know what was happening with you that you just couldn't just say, well, you know, that's just, that's the way it is.

John Dehlin [00:04:57] I don't think thousands of, you know, my mission was unique. We were the second highest baptizing mission in the world. We were baptizing over 700, 750 people a month and some companionships were baptizing 40 or 50 people in a month, and it was baptizing these children and it was corrupt. I doubt that that's a typical missionary experience. I would say it's not even two standard deviations within the mean.

Gina Colvin [00:05:28] But why could you say that's corrupt, but, you know, other missionaries just let it, you know, run off their shoulders?

John Dehlin [00:05:36] No, no, I, I've spoken with so many missionaries from my mission afterwards who say it was terrible.

Gina Colvin [00:05:41] Okay, okay.

John Dehlin [00:05:43] It was, it was more. It was more sort of the Stanley the Milgram experience. If you, if you've studied psychology at all, and the Obedience to authority sort of study that was done with Stanley Milgram where they, where they have a subject come in and administer shock up to lethal levels to, to the actors who were pretending to receive, to be receiving the shock. 70% of the participants were willing to administer what they believed was a lethal amount of shock to the recipients because of social pressure and peer pressure. And that was what our mission was. And so people were deeply disturbed by it. But very few people were willing to go against the grain. And that's just, that's what the obedience to authority sort of psychological literature is just all about. How could the Holocaust happen? It's because people are very unwilling to go against the grain in a very authoritative hierarchical structure.

Gina Colvin [00:06:46] Yet you did. And I'm trying to get to the heart of why you'd stick your head up above the parapets and say, and call this out.

John Dehlin [00:06:55] It's not because I believe too little. It's because I believe too much. I considered these baptisms once I found out that kids were doing cannonballs in the baptismal font during a lot of these baptisms, that these missionaries were literally baptizing 10 and then watching movies and traveling to other countries during the week. There was this egregious level of disobedience and, and then this egregious level of disrespecting God's sacred ordinances. I was believing too much at that point, and it felt like a bastardization of God's holy ordinances.

Gina Colvin [00:07:36] What were you believing in?

John Dehlin [00:07:40] The plan of salvation, in the correlated plan of salvation in God the eternal Father and his wife or wives, in, you know, Jesus and the atonement and God the church being led by the holy prophet, being one true church. Like, I was as orthodox and as literal as a believer as you could, you could have expected.

Gina Colvin [00:08:06] So the whole suite, you are okay with the whole suite and the way that you.

John Dehlin [00:08:09] Oh yeah. I didn't, I didn't feel like I had any latitude to question, not with my seminary teachers. I, and I didn't have intellectual parents that taught me nuance. I had not been exposed to sunstone or dialogue. I had been exposed to ultra orthodox, highly conservative seminary teachers and Sunday school teachers. That, that, that taught me a very obedience based, literalistic worldview on Mormonism.

Gina Colvin [00:08:39] You know, the reason I'm plugging away at this is because you're somebody who's always stuck their heads above their head above the parapets. And, and I want to know where that's coming from. Like, what is that?

John Dehlin [00:08:52] It's probably, it's probably privilege. Honestly, I Mean, I'm six foot six. I'm, you know, white, male, heterosexual, healthy. You know, I was athletic in the day, and I think I had a lot of privilege. So when there's a lot of other people who. Who maybe didn't feel like they could stick their neck out, I probably just felt enough pride and arrogance and privilege that I was safe to do so.

Gina Colvin [00:09:21] Okay. But it's not just pride and arrogance because it's principled, isn't it?

John Dehlin [00:09:25] I felt like I. I would have. I would have felt that way at the time. Yeah. So I. I was also very idealistic. I mean, you know, my parents had been divorced. The church had sort of saved me and rescued me, and I bought the literal orthodox narrative, hook, line and sinker. And so I, you know, again, I had girls saying, please have sex with me in high school. And I'm like, no, you know, that's. I'm a righteous, righteous priesthood holder. Like, I. I took all that narrative extremely seriously. And I was. You never tasted alcohol, Never tried a cigarette. Still to this day I haven't.

John Dehlin [00:10:04] You know, I was just your ultra orthodox member with a lot of privilege. And I think that combination made me feel. And I. And my parents weren't, you know, for whatever you could say about my parents, they're awesome. They taught me to be honest and not to nuance, and they taught me to stand up for what is right. So did the church. And so I just. I honestly, I think I just felt like I was standing up for what was right. And I guess I had enough privilege to where I felt in empowered to do so. But I don't think I was some hero, you know, it was. It was my privilege that made that even possible. Does that make sense?

Gina Colvin [00:10:41] Yeah, it does. It does, yeah. Yeah. I mean, I think about, you know, school teachers, and usually it's the big, tall white dude that does really well in the classroom because everyone's in awe. So.

John Dehlin [00:10:52] Yeah. And I was captain of the varsity basketball team, student body president, you know, just straight A student. Just. I had all the privilege in the world, you know.

Gina Colvin [00:11:01] Right, yeah. And in many respects, this is the first time, really, that that privilege is being questioned. It's being subsumed in favor of other people's privilege. So that must have been a kick in the guts.

John Dehlin [00:11:12] Yeah, it was awful. It was awful for everybody.

Gina Colvin [00:11:15] Yeah. Yeah. So I just want to talk about this colloquium community. What was that like for you to go into this space where the discussion is free? It's critical. It's, you know, it's, you know, finding a conversation that suits you. What was that like for you?

Mormon Intellectual Community and Sunstone

John Dehlin [00:11:30] Oh, you know, just think about your best experience with Sunstone or Dialogue and imagine being able to have that every day with a room full of the smartest students at BYU and the best, coolest professors. So, I mean, imagine having Carolyn Pearson or Richard Bushman or Terrell Givens as your, as your college professor or, you know, Maxine Hanks or, you know, whoever you want on the female side.

John Dehlin [00:12:04] You know, imagine being able to study religion and history and science by the finest minds who are progressive and open. You know, two or three days a week for one or two hours. Because the colloquium was a six hour class that met for two hours three times a week. It was super intense and it was so beautiful. It was. We're talking about evolution and age of the earth and dinosaurs and Joseph Fielding Smith and Bruce Armaconki and problems with the church and feminism and sexism and racism. It was just this. And, you know, I wouldn't have stood for it as a freshman, but after my worldview had been cracked open, it was like Sunstone and dialogue on BYU campus in the Maeser Building with the finest minds and the smartest students all there eating it up.

John Dehlin [00:12:58] We're talking about dinosaurs and fossils and the age of the earth and Adam and Eve and Joseph Fielding Smith and what Bruce R. McConkie said and how they were wrong and abortion and women's issues and feminism and, you know, Bill Bradshaw was my teacher in honors religion class. And, you know, it was just this amazing mixture of faith and intellect that was so exhilarating. Joanna Brooks was a part of it, you know, and so many other really bright and shining minds.

John Dehlin [00:13:30] And it was, it was exhilarating. I loved it. I couldn't get enough of it. And it rescued me because it was like having Sunstone and dialogue at BYU six hours a week. You know, it was incredible with, with the finest minds. All the Benson scholars were all there in these classes with you, you know, feminism and everything. You know, it was great. It was like this. It was like this renaissance. You know, Joanna was there with, you know, she wasn't in my class, but she was on campus. And it was just a very exciting time where the Student Review, which was this alternative student newspaper, was, Was thriving.

John Dehlin [00:14:08] And the September 6th hadn't happened yet, but it was about to happen. Sunstone was really raging and thriving and it was just like. It was just this amazing, almost Camelot few years of inquiry and of faith, but also questioning and it was amazing.

Gina Colvin [00:14:26] Right, right. And there was a bit of a pause, sort of starting at this time to creep over byu. Were you. And you said, was it in your junior or senior year that you started to be aware of the kind of attack on intellectual freedom?

The September Six and BYU's Academic Climate

John Dehlin [00:14:43] Yeah. I mean, so I don't know if you'll know any of these names, but Cecilia Konchar Farr was an English professor. She ended up getting kicked out of BYU while I was there. David Knowlton was an anthropologist. He was publishing regularly in Sunstone. He got kicked out while I was there. Gail Houston was another one that got kicked out. And then, you know, I wasn't Like, I'd never attended a Sunstone. My first Sunstone was in 2004, 2005. But I started here, and that still felt unsafe to me. But, you know, you started hearing about what was going on at Sunstone, and, you know, you started hearing rumblings.

John Dehlin [00:15:23] And so that was too dangerous to be a part of. But you heard about it, and you're curious about it, and it felt scary. But it was enough in the news that you kind of started to hear about it. And I do remember, oh, oh, and Joanna Brooks was leading Take Back the Night sort of things and Voice. There was a feminist group on campus that I still. I didn't get feminism at the time, so I'm like, oh, those feminists, you know, and, you know, but it was just this exciting time where, you know, there's a lot of intellectual life, but it appears like the church is starting to clamp down.

John Dehlin [00:15:58] And you. You know, I still consider myself sort of a Rush Limbaugh Republican, but I was, you know, also. And faithful, but also starting to learn these exciting new things. And I still sort of viewed Sunstone and dialogue as scary. And it all kind of culminated my senior year in the September 6th happening. So the September 6th stuff happened my final semester at BYU, and as I remember, in the fall of 1993, and I remember some of the September 6 holding a press conference at a hotel down in. In Provo. I don't remember why, if it had to do with the professors that were getting kicked out or the September 6th themselves, but I remember, I seem to remember Paul Toscano and Joanna and all sorts of students doing this sort of thing and just feeling like it was a crazy, crazy, exciting but scary time, you know?

Gina Colvin [00:16:54] Right, right. And you were afraid personally, or you're afraid of the conversation. You're afraid for other people. What was happening with you personally?

John Dehlin [00:17:04] Well, I, you know, I had, you know, I Was at the time, I considered myself still very much believing. And what Joanna was doing, what the Student Review was doing, which was the alternative newspaper on campus, what the September Six were doing, I can't say I was like, yeah, this is awesome. I was more like, this seems scary. This seems dark. This seems like these people are intellectuals fighting against the church. But at the same time. And I didn't get feminism, maybe, maybe some would say I still don't. But, I mean, certainly at the time, I didn't get it fully. I didn't get a lot of the racial issues.

John Dehlin [00:17:39] I didn't get a lot of the intellectual issues. And so I was, like, still feeling very faithful, feeling intellectually invigorated, but also feeling like these people were going too far, the Toscanos were going too far. And, you know, Maxine Hanks and all the Joanna Brooks and Voice on campus, which was the feminist group, that's a little bit too far. But at the same time, I was curious, and so it felt really confusing. Like, on the one hand, I liked this stuff, but on the other hand, it felt contraband. On the other hand, these people were marching and doing things that seemed scary. But on the other hand, it felt kind of exciting, and I was kind of confused, but also excited.

Gina Colvin [00:18:22] What conversation were you most excited about was? Evolution?

John Dehlin [00:18:27] Yeah, it would have been more science and abortion and age of the Earth and faith questions and doubt, probably some church history stuff. And I knew about the feminist group on campus, but it probably was curious, but seemed a little bit scary.

John Dehlin [00:18:52] I knew about the racist sort of history in the church, and I felt like that was wrong, but I probably then and still do, lacked a lot of real deep understanding about matters of race and social justice. So it was mostly around science issues and matters of intellectual freedom and curiosity and some of the church policy issues and the leadership and how the leadership could punish people and how liberals and conservatives had a tension between them. But I would not have called myself a feminist back then.

John Dehlin [00:19:32] I would not say that I was LGBT friendly back then. I was against racism and questioned the priesthood ban by that time. And I started having questions about church history, but I was still very new to the inquiry. So I didn't deeply understand the problems with church history at that point. I was just excited to hear people talking about the difficult things and excited to find a community where we could start talking about them. And most of the issues were around age of the Earth, evolution, you know, those sort of things.

Gina Colvin [00:20:08] That's my sense. My sense is that you're part of A conversation. You're enjoying that conversation. But you hadn't turned that into activism.

John Dehlin [00:20:15] No, no, no, no, I was not. I was scared of activism at byu. And I would look at people like Joanna and Brian Waterman as sort of scary, you know, at that. At that point, they would have been scary to me.

Gina Colvin [00:20:28] Right, Yeah, I can see that about Joanna. Yeah.

John Dehlin [00:20:31] No, she. She was awesome. But at the time, I was like, well, they're protesting. That's too far. You know, that's feminism. That's. That's weird. And, you know, homosexuals, I, you know, that's, you know, that's. That's going off the deep end. You know, that sort of thing would have been me.

Gina Colvin [00:20:46] Right, right. Okay. So you get to the end of nine, you get to 1993, and you're graduated now with a Political science, was it?

John Dehlin [00:20:54] Yeah, yeah.

Gina Colvin [00:20:55] Okay. And your first job. Now, hold on, hold on, woman.

John Dehlin [00:20:59] Yeah. So I met Margi my senior year. I had dated Mary Holland, Jeff. Jeff Holland's daughter. I had married Orrin Hatch's daughter.

Gina Colvin [00:21:07] You hadn't married her?

John Dehlin [00:21:09] I did. I. Did I say married?

Gina Colvin [00:21:11] Yes.

John Dehlin [00:21:12] Okay. I dated. I dated Mary Holland. I dated Alyssa Hatch, Orrin Hatch's daughter. I had, you know, I had. I had tried to find. I knew that I had had this sort of dark thing brooding inside me because of my mission.

John Dehlin [00:21:29] And so I was trying, subconsciously, I was trying to find someone who was thoughtful enough and open enough and progressive enough to where if this dark thing inside of me started spilling over, it would be someone that could deal with that. So I. I intentionally didn't marry sort of Molly Mormon orthodox woman.

John Dehlin [00:21:52] I held out to find someone who I felt like was, at least in some ways, progressive and super thoughtful. And Margi was exactly that. She was an English major. She was very well read. She was very independent, even though she was active in believing. And even though Margi and I ended up having a really tough ride in. In the early to middle parts of our marriage, I always loved her intellect and her independence, and that's why I married her.

Gina Colvin [00:22:24] So when did you get married?

John Dehlin [00:22:25] In December of 1993.

Gina Colvin [00:22:28] Right, okay.

John Dehlin [00:22:29] So. Right. You know, the. The Christmas New Year's after my. I graduated.

Gina Colvin [00:22:33] Right, okay. And you took your first job.

John Dehlin [00:22:37] Yeah, I took a job in D.C. working for a consulting firm. But very quickly, Bain and Company, which was Mitt Romney's firm, they reached out to me and invited me to interview, and I interviewed with Bain and got a job. And at the time, pretty much only Harvard, mit, Wharton, Stanford, sort of Graduates got into Bain. And I got into Bain from BYU because there was this small group of Bain partners who had done BYU undergrad before they went to Harvard Business School. And so I left Washington, D.C. after only a couple months and went to work for Bain in Dallas. And Mitt Romney was still at Bain Capital at the time. And so that was my first real job out of byu, was with this elite management consulting firm where all the managing partners had been at either Harvard, Stanford, Wharton, Pennsylvania, or mit.

Gina Colvin [00:23:32] That would have been pretty heady for you as a young graduate.

John Dehlin [00:23:36] Super heady, especially because I was a political science major and I didn't really know anything about business. But I. But, you know, Bain was, was elite. And yeah, we were consulting Fortune 500 companies. I was assigned to Continental Airlines to help turn them around, and Lockheed Martin. The merger of Lockheed and Martin Marietta, these defense contractors. And everyone was brilliant and rich, and it was extremely heady. And Mitt Romney was at Bain at the time. And I knew that there was one of us at the headquarters of Bain, and there was this legend at Bain that the Bain partners had run Bain into the ground.

John Dehlin [00:24:15] And then Mitt Romney came back and saved Bane. And so even though I was in the Dallas office, I knew that one of my fellow Mormons had turned around my parent company when it. When it was troubled. And so I viewed Mitt Romney as a hero back in 1994, long before he was ever a household name.

Gina Colvin [00:24:37] So was there at the time a strong Mormon culture threaded through Bain?

John Dehlin [00:24:43] Yeah, absolutely. So one of the managing partners at Bain Dallas, Mark Godferson, I think he's a stake president today somewhere in Dallas, and he was one of the managing partners in Bain Dallas. And then Mark Jones was a general manager at Bain. These guys had both graduated from Harvard business school with MBAs. Mark Jones was a general manager at the time at Bain Dallas, and there were several associate consultants who had graduated from byu. And so there was sort of this, I would say a third of the Bain Dallas office were BYU graduates.

John Dehlin [00:25:24] And so, yeah, it was. And there was enough, you know, and. And Jeffrey Holland's son, Matt Holland, originally he went to Monitor, which was a competitor to Bain in Boston. And, and so there, there were a lot of Mormons joining these management consulting firms. And McKinsey was another one that had a ton of Mormons in it. So there's a strong culture of Mormons in this management consulting industry.

Gina Colvin [00:25:52] Well, I'm curious to know, like, with Mitt Romney's presidential campaign, Bain took a hit publicly. And lots of questions about business ethics, et cetera, were raised. What were your thoughts at the time on that kind of criticism?

John Dehlin [00:26:08] Well, I only stayed at Bain a year because the technology, the Internet boom happened around 1994 and I realized that the Internet was going to be something really huge. And so it was at Bain when I first learned about what a web browser was and what the Internet was and how to connect to it. And I immediately, I stayed one year at Bain and then I moved to Chicago to work for Arthur Andersen, which was the world's leading accounting firm at the time. But they also were world leaders in technology. So I lost track of Mitt Romney after that year of, of my time at Bain up through the point where he started running for president. But I was, I was excited when I heard he was running for President. And, and I remember that very well, but I wasn't at Bain at the time. So tell me your question again.

Gina Colvin [00:26:59] Oh, well, I was wondering if you had a reaction to, you know, some of the charges launched at Bain for the sort of unethical business practice and they're sort of speaking.

John Dehlin [00:27:09] Yeah, absolutely. I left Bain not just because the technology bubble started emerging, but also because I was uncomfortable with some of the things Bain was doing. I just noticed that these presidents of companies would call in their management consulting sort of buddies from business school and asked them to do these sorts of Turner corporate turnarounds where they would lay off a third of the workforce or find ways to sort of make the appearance of turning the company around for kind of a quick sale. And it just felt, it just, it wasn't grounded in something that felt wholesome to me. I'm not saying it was evil, but at the time it just felt, it just felt a little bit questionable.

John Dehlin [00:28:03] And so part of why I left was because it seemed like a little bit gimmicky, a little bit relation based and a little bit sort of like swoop in, buy the company, turn it around, or charge exorbitant fees, make these short term recommendations that weren't necessarily good for the company so that then you could have a quick sale, profit from the sale of the company and then move on to other sort of victims. I'm not saying that's what management consulting is, but it felt a little bit too much like that for me. And so I was happy to leave Bain after a year.

John Dehlin [00:28:43] And so I, when those sort of allegations came out about Mitt Romney, I empathized with them. But, but he was sort of a white knight to me at the time still. He was in salt. You know, he was in Boston, I was in Dallas.

John Dehlin [00:28:57] He was. You know, I would have probably viewed him as the Mormon good guy who was a shining light in an industry that sometimes was a little bit questionable. But I certainly could empathize with a lot of the management consulting concerns about turning a company around and selling them for a short sale and making a profit, but not necessarily adding value to the economy. That sort of stuff I detected back in 1994 and was part of why I felt like I needed to leave.

Gina Colvin [00:29:24] So there was that growing sensitivity to these sorts of, you know, maybe speculative or morally questionable things. Yeah, yeah.

John Dehlin [00:29:33] I. I fell into management consulting. I was a political science major at byu. I was thinking about law school or some sort of PhD, and I just went to Bain, honestly, on a whim. It was like I literally went to the employment office at byu and it's like, what are good jobs? I'm not ready to go to grad school yet. They're like Bain, McKinsey monitor.

John Dehlin [00:29:54] And I just applied to all those schools. And then Bain showed interest because I had, like a 3.96 GPA and, you know, it was on scholarship and all that stuff. And so. And I interviewed, I guess. Okay. But I didn't know what I was doing. I didn't have any business background. And once I really caught wind of what they were doing, it just didn't feel meaningful to me. And so my professional career was just this attempt to try and do something really meaningful to help the world. And Bain didn't fit that mold for me. And so I just started jumping around until I could find something meaningful.

Gina Colvin [00:30:29] Does they have a bit of a boys club, like, in terms of your job prospects, is there a way that being a BYU alumni.

John Dehlin [00:30:35] Oh, yeah. Oh, yeah, right. Totally. Yeah. There were VPs and management consultants at Bain and other places that are like, they would recruit at. It would be like, Harvard, Stanford, Wharton, MIT, and BYU. And the managing partners, general managers, and VPs at Bain would go to BYU to recruit, and they'd get you in.

Gina Colvin [00:30:58] Right, right.

John Dehlin [00:30:59] It's absolutely a good old boys club. And I remember at least one female BYU consultant that was there, but it was mostly a boys club.

Gina Colvin [00:31:09] Right, right. So you graduate in political science, you go into management consultancy, and you stumble upon software development or those techie things.

John Dehlin [00:31:20] Yep. Yeah, yeah. So I went to Arthur Anderson. I worked there a year, and then I went to join a computer consulting firm, worked there for a couple years, moved back to Salt Lake in 97 to actually be a consultant to the LDS Church. So I worked for a year as a, as a consultant to, as a technology consultant to the LDS Church where I actually worked on a general authority candidate tracking system in addition to a.

Gina Colvin [00:31:48] What? A what, sorry?

John Dehlin [00:31:50] A general authority candidate tracking system.

Gina Colvin [00:31:53] Do tell.

John Dehlin [00:31:55] Yeah, so they, they had this database that, that tracked mission presidents, temple presidents and stake presidents and it was a way for them to track over time, you know, so just imagine general authorities going to stakes missions and temple presidencies to interview people on their regular general authority work. And while they would be interviewing these people, they would ask questions about their family, about their financial situation, about, you know, how they're doing as leaders. And then the, and then all that information would be logged in this general authority candidate tracking system so that they could have knowledge over time about these candidates for general authority so that when it came time to call someone as a general authority, they could have all this information to help inform the decision.

Gina Colvin [00:32:50] Oh, nice.

John Dehlin [00:32:51] Yeah.

Gina Colvin [00:32:53] Okay. Hey, can I just ask that you, were you largely self taught where it came to technology?

Work at Bain, Arthur Andersen, and Career Moves

John Dehlin [00:32:58] Yes, completely self taught. I never took a computer class in college.

Gina Colvin [00:33:02] Oh, aren't you clever.

John Dehlin [00:33:04] Well, I don't know. Or lucky. You know, I kind of learned on the job. My brother had been a computer guy and he kind of pointed me in the right direction. He had worked for Microsoft. He was working for Microsoft by this point. So I could say my brother was a bit of a mentor to me

Gina Colvin [00:33:21] in that regard and that interest in technology. So you work for Microsoft, but that interest in technology takes you back to Utah in 2004?

John Dehlin [00:33:31] Yeah, it started. I worked for WordPerfect Corporation in 93. That was my first high tech job. And that's where I first got introduced to computers. And so, so yeah, once I went to Arthur Anderson, I really, I didn't go to tax and audit, I went to their technology group. So Arthur Anderson taught me technology more and then I became a consultant and I kind of learned on the job. And. Yeah, okay.

Gina Colvin [00:33:59] I would like to ask you about OpenCourseWare and instructional technology, but only because I'm, you know, in education. So do you want to say anything about that? What OpenCourseWare is?

John Dehlin [00:34:08] Yeah. So. Okay, so I, after, after I worked at church headquarters for a year, I went to work for Microsoft. I worked there seven years. And then when I left Microsoft, I came here to Logan and eventually went to work for MIT while I was getting, while I was in graduate school for instructional technology. So I got a master's in instructional technology at Utah State and, and I became MIT's only employee west of the Mississippi. And MIT did something called OpenCourseWare, where they believed that educational content should be shared openly and publicly. And so I was their world evangelist for convincing other universities to share their learning materials on the Internet with. With everyone who could benefit. So that's what I did. For a couple of years. I worked for MIT sharing OpenCourseWare. Was that what you asked me about?

Gina Colvin [00:35:08] Yeah, it was. It was, yeah.

John Dehlin [00:35:10] Yeah.

Gina Colvin [00:35:11] Now, so what? So where we've got to then is that you have a whole kind of professional and also an ideological sort of foundation to start looking for ways and bringing the conversation of Mormonism and intellectual. Mormon intellectualism to a broad public. So all of the stepping stones are there. You've got the questions, but now you've got the technology.

John Dehlin [00:35:42] Yep. Yeah, that was really. That was all part of it. Yeah, it was. It was a combination of all the privilege that I had that made me being able to speak out, plus all the experiences that I had that were deeply troubling to me. And then all the technology background and privilege associated with working for companies like Bain and Arthur Anderson and Microsoft, where I felt like I had power and a voice to speak out. And that all laid that groundwork for me, feeling like I had enough privilege to be able to start Mormon stories in 2005.

Gina Colvin [00:36:17] So with all of that privilege, you go to Sunstone and you become involved with them.

John Dehlin [00:36:23] Yeah. So, yeah. So, I mean, folks will know that while I was at Microsoft, it's when I started, you know, I still consider myself a believer, but around 2000, 2001, I was called as a seminary teacher, and I started reading church history for the very first time in depth because I wanted to be a really good seminary teacher. And that's when I learned for the first time in depth about Joseph's polygamy. I discovered Michael Quinn. I discovered Fawn Brody and Simon Southerton and Grant Palmer and Sunstone and Dialogue in Depth. I really started studying Richard Bushman. And it was there that I had my massive faith unraveling while I was a seminary teacher at Microsoft.

Gina Colvin [00:37:12] Okay.

John Dehlin [00:37:13] And so then that took over my world for a couple years in terms of just putting me in a super dark place where I started really questioning the church in very serious ways. And that led to me choosing to leave Microsoft and move to Logan to try and figure this out and to be a part of the solution for all the people going through faith crises. And that's. That's what led to me starting Mormon stories in 2005.

Gina Colvin [00:37:42] Do you know, and I think about the language that Mormon stories has bought to people who are in a faith crisis. So for instance, the word faith crisis or the terminology faith crisis, true believing Mormons that, I mean, they are part of the, the kind of lexicon, the Mormon stories lexicon. But you didn't have that. You didn't have the words faith crisis, the words faith crisis, did you?

John Dehlin [00:38:06] Probably not, no.

Gina Colvin [00:38:07] Okay.

John Dehlin [00:38:08] Because I had not attended Sunstone yet and I had only read these historical books. Mostly I hadn't had a community to process this with. What happened When I went through my faith crisis at Microsoft, I started going to the. There were these boards for Mormons at Microsoft where they would talk about Mormon things as Microsoft employees. And I'd be like, have you guys heard of Fawn Brody? Have you guys heard about, you know, Simon Southerton? And I would, I would just freaking out trying to find people I could talk to about this kind of stuff. And nobody wanted to talk about it or had heard about this stuff or knew anything about this stuff.

John Dehlin [00:38:45] And they all just kind of responded with silence or with contempt. And, and so I felt just totally alone and isolated. And that's when I started learning about Sunstone and I started listening to some Sunstone audio recordings. I was able to watch the September 6th sort of anniversary. They did a 10 year September 6th anniversary at Sunstone, like in 2003, which I was still at Microsoft at the time. And I was able to watch those reflections by the September 6th and go, oh, that's what they were talking about. That's what they were doing back in 1993. And I started learning about the rich intellectual tradition of Sunstone and dialogue during those final years at Microsoft.

John Dehlin [00:39:31] And that's partly what made me feel like I needed to jump from Microsoft and join this discussion. Return to Utah, go to Sunstone, meet Dan Witherspoon and all these people, learn about dialogue and start being a part of a constructive solution to these problems.

Gina Colvin [00:39:50] But Sunstone wasn't necessarily addressing the, I suppose the psychological or the emotional impact of faith crises as such, weren't they? They seemed to me at the time to be more of an intellectual tradition, engaging with, you know, sociology and history.

John Dehlin [00:40:08] Yeah, that's right. Yeah. I remember attending my first Sunstone and getting to know the board members and Dan Witherspoon and Mike Stevens and others and basically just saying, do you guys realize there's this huge crisis of faith thing happening out there where people feel alone and desperate? Are you guys doing anything to be a part of that?

John Dehlin [00:40:33] And you Know, just. I feel like I kind of got blank stares. But then they responded with a lot of excitement, and I was just like, hey, Sunstone board, let's. Let's use Sunstone to help people through this very difficult crisis of faith sort of experience. Because I just know it happened to me. I've started at Microsoft to find out others who this was happening to, and we need to be a part of the solution here. And so in my original proposals to Sunstone, they put me on the Sunstone board almost immediately. And my proposal was to have Sunstone be a place that's a soft landing for people having a crisis of faith. And that was my original proposal to Dan Witherspoon and all the Sunstone people.

Gina Colvin [00:41:17] So this was a bit of a change for Sunstone too, as well, wasn't it?

John Dehlin [00:41:20] Yeah, I think they were focused on history and anthropology and September 6th and descent. And there was not a pastoral feel that I felt at Sunstone at the time. It was more essays and historical pieces and anthropological pieces, but not a pastoral sort of move. And so I went to Dan Witherspoon and I went to the board, and I'm like, let me. Come on, let's use Sunstone as a way to really help all the. All the people that are struggling with their faith and all the. I believe that more people are going to start struggling with their faith, and let's have Sunstone be that safety net that catches them before they fell out of the church.

John Dehlin [00:42:04] And that was kind of controversial because there was a lot of ex Mormons at Sunstone, and some people were very uncomfortable with Sunstone being used as a way to keep people in the church. But at the time, that was my. Honestly, that was my motivation.

The Rise of the Bloggernacle and Online Mormon Discourse

Gina Colvin [00:42:19] Yeah. And so the intellectual tradition takes on a new track. It's sort of. Mormon intellectualism had always been sort of a bit of a standalone, and now it was absorbing attention, absorbing a new kind of orientation where there is attention to the personal and interpersonal faith and to the ruptures that are individually experienced by Mormons who are now finding things out that they otherwise might have been ignorant about.

John Dehlin [00:42:56] Yeah, I remember there being this weird sort of silos at Sunstone because you could attend the why I Stay panels and you could. You could be totally inspired by all the people that stay. Right. And you could go listen to Paul or Margaret Toscano, you know, rage against the Machine.

John Dehlin [00:43:18] But there. There wasn't a sort of. I didn't feel a pastoral sense of like, how do we help all the pain and suffering out there, it felt like everything was sort of siloed into these intellectual buckets of either the believers in some sessions or the angry discontents in the other, and a bunch of history people wanting to talk about sometimes obscure, sometimes not obscure historical details. There's all the people that are still angry about September 6th, but there was not sort of this, how do we help people through the journey? And that's when I made my first proposal to the Sunstone board.

John Dehlin [00:43:57] It was very much as a future psychologist, as a pastoral sort of thing that said, man, there's a lot of pain going on here. There's a lot of people leaving the church. How do we heal the pain and save the church from just dissolving? And so that, you know, I'm sure there are other people that tried that before me, but that's what I think resonated with Dan Witherspoon and Toby Pingree and Bill Bradshaw and whoever else was on the board at the time, Michael Stevens, I think they liked the energy that I was bringing and sort of the pastoral mission that I seem to be bringing.

Gina Colvin [00:44:44] So what was the state of the bloggernacle at that time? Did it even exist? Was there an online presence?

John Dehlin [00:44:51] There was around 2004. There were a few Mormon blogs. Times and Seasons was the Juggernaut by Common Consent had just come online. Steve Evans had left. I think my history is foggy, but I seem to remember Steve Evans leaving Times and Seasons and starting by Common Consent. Right around that time, I actually was part of the discussions that sort of led to By Common Consent, blog and Dialogue, having a bit of a formal relationship that Steve Evans ended up sort of formalizing with Greg Prince and others. And, yeah, the blogger knackle just started bursting onto the scene. So within a little bit of time, feminist Mormon housewives would have come on the scene and Lisa Butterworth would have been really big.

John Dehlin [00:45:42] And there was this just whole 20, 30, 40, 50 Mormon blogs all over the world. You know, that was all the rage in 2004. 2005 was sort of the blogger knackle exploding. And podcasts. Podcasts were just starting to appear in 2004.

Gina Colvin [00:46:02] Why did you think that podcasting or blogging was going to address some of those concerns? For those who are experiencing doubt, faith

John Dehlin [00:46:12] doubts, you know, I came to, you know, even though I had worked at Bain and Arthur Anderson and Microsoft, I felt like a neophyte when it came to Mormon discourse. I was not well read with Mormon history. I was just starting to read these things. I didn't have a PhD or a master's or legal training. At the time, I just had a bachelor's degree. And so I would go read Times and Seasons blog and By Common Consent, and it just felt like this heady intellectual discourse that really wasn't reaching the heart of all the pain that I had plugged into as I started trying to talk to people about their problems and finding out all the pain for women, for gays and lesbians, for intellectuals, for people of color, for sexual minorities.

John Dehlin [00:47:07] And it just felt really, the blogger knuckle felt like a bunch of cool Ivy League kids having these esoteric, intellectual, inside clubby sort of conversations that really weren't pastoral and that really weren't trying to solve any significant problems. That's how I experienced By Common Consent in Times and Seasons. It felt very cliquey, very clubby, very intellectual, but not really trying to solve the problems. And so I had discovered podcasts by that point and just fell in love with this idea of letting people tell their stories, because I didn't think intellectual debates were going to get us anywhere. I know that dialogue. I knew by that point the dialogue had been around since the 60s, that Sunstone had been around since the 80s.

John Dehlin [00:47:53] We had had decades of sunstone and dialogue, and there was still tension and problems. And so for me, what I felt the creative idea was with Mormon stories was how about just letting people tell their story, and instead of trying to talk history or debate minutia or be witty and see who could come up with the best intellectual jab or defense or critique, what if we just let people tell their stories, share their emotions, be authentic, and let those stories speak for themselves. And so that I think if there was an innovation with Mormon stories, there had been a few Mormon themed podcasts up to that point.

John Dehlin [00:48:32] There was one called the Church is Not True. There was a couple others that had just started. But Mormon Stories, I think, was the first one that just said, let's let people tell their stories and really dig deep on their emotions, on their history, on their experiences, so that people could not just have fun intellectual inquiry, but they could deeply connect to their narrative, to the emotion, to the intellectual stories going on, and really be moved. And so in some ways, Mormon stories was subversive because I really wanted to reach people intellectually, but I felt like doing it through the heart and emotions and through story was going to be the most effective way to reach people.

Gina Colvin [00:49:17] And that's very much part of the cultural turn. I mean, just theoretically speaking, attention to affect and emotion and, you know, the heart is a sort of a critical approach addressing concerns for social transformation. So this is what I'm sensing from you. You actually wanted some social transformation.

John Dehlin [00:49:38] I wanted. It was. It was partly me wanting to figure out how to stay in the church, but having tapped into all the pain while I was at Microsoft and having experienced my own pain, I'm just like. I can't just solve my own problem. That's too isolated. That's too selfish. I'm gonna. I'm gonna. There's too many people suffering. I'm gonna make this a public discussion that helps as many people as possible. And that. That. That was what that was about.

Gina Colvin [00:50:08] Right?

John Dehlin [00:50:09] It was saying, there's too much pain and suffering for this to just be me figuring it out. I'm gonna bring as many people along for the ride as I can to help as many people as possible and to make as big of a transformation in the church as I could.

Gina Colvin [00:50:22] Right, right. Yeah. And this idea that a shared conversation, shared narratives, will maybe assuage some. Some people's sense of loneliness, and, you know, they weren't alone in this.

John Dehlin [00:50:34] Totally. Totally. It was to help people not be alone. It was for me to not feel like I was alone. It was to get stories out there, to get the conversation. I just had this naive optimism that if I could get everybody talking and being open and honest, that we would all find some way to stay and to believe and to be healthier and stronger as a church and as a people.

Gina Colvin [00:50:55] Why do you think that's naive?

John Dehlin [00:51:00] I don't know. Look at what happened.

Gina Colvin [00:51:02] It's not the end of the story.

John Dehlin [00:51:05] No, I'm just saying. Well, I didn't understand. So first of all, I hadn't really, really understood the complexity of the issues. I had. I had. Yeah, I had read Michael. You know, I had read Michael Quinn. I had read, you know, Fawn Brody. I had read Leonard Arrington and. And Richard Bushman, and I knew about Sunstone and Dialogue, but I didn't know. I didn't really know Joseph Smith's history.

John Dehlin [00:51:33] I didn't really understand what it was like to be LGBT and Mormon. I didn't understand feminism. I didn't understand racial issues fully. And not that I do now, but, I mean, I was just really naive, and I didn't understand all the deep problems with church history. And so I was like, oh, well, I learned about this guy named Leonard Arrington, and I learned about this guy named Eugene England, and I learned about this guy named Lowell Bennion, and I learned about these smart, faithful people in Sunstone and Dialogue, and they've made it work.

John Dehlin [00:52:08] So if I can just take all this knowledge to the mainstream, then we'll all develop these really sophisticated, complex testimonies, and we'll all help slowly create space for intellectuals within the church, and then we'll all be singing Kumbaya, you know, by the end, because the church will grow and become strong and minorities will become more accepting and all faiths will all become more mature, and it'll be Shangri La. And, you know, that's honestly how I saw it playing out in my idealistic side.

Gina Colvin [00:52:43] Yeah, I suppose that's because your aha moment occurred for you in this environment of full disclosure. So you're saying, well, hey, if that can occur for me, then maybe it can occur for other people. They can have the aha moment too.

John Dehlin [00:52:56] Yeah, yeah, totally. I just felt we would all figure it out together and the church would be better and stronger for it. But what we needed, what was evil to me, was people suffering in silence, was people not being able to talk, was people not being informed of the issues of people being punished. I could remember the September 6th by this point, and I'm like, we can't. You know, it's not right to punish people who are asking good questions. Because once I had tapped into the history, I'm like, wait a minute. Michael Quinn had a point, and Margaret Toscano and Paul Toscano had a point.

John Dehlin [00:53:28] And. And, you know, Maxine Hanks had a point, and these people shouldn't have been treated that way. And Lavina Feli Anderson had a point. And instead of the church just punishing these people, we need to bring all this discussion out in the open, make it mainstream. Then the church can't just keep punishing these people. By that time, I had been inspired by the civil rights movement and the jails filling up and feeling like, you know, they can't. They can't excommunicate everybody. So if we just make these conversations, you know, and still, I think Dialogue and Sunstone had been successfully get ghettoized by this point. And so I'm just like, no, no, no, we're not going to.

John Dehlin [00:54:09] We're not going to ghetto Sunstone and dialogue and marginalize intellectual discourse to the. To the, you know, the 6,000 people who care about it. We're going to blow the discussion of Mormon discourse into mainstream Mormonism through the subversive means of stories and reaching people emotionally. And once we do, there'll be too many of us to keep throwing us in jail, you know, like the September 6th, they'll have to address the issues, and we'll all become healthier. The church will be healthier. The people struggling will be healthier. It'll all be healthier. Just once sunlight becomes that disinfectant. And that was the naive sort of play that Mormon stories was. It was to say, sunlight will clean everything.

Gina Colvin [00:54:52] Right, Right. So you've got moral outrage. You've also got your own personal issues that you're dealing with. And this is you now saying activism. This is your sort of, you know, moment in activism.

John Dehlin [00:55:05] Yeah, because by the time I was at Microsoft, I had had so much pain, and I had talked to secret Microsoft employees who had addictions or pornography or sexual sexuality kind of concerns. And I'm just like. Or faith issues. And I'm like, we can't just have all these people suffering in silence, and we can't have all these members thinking that the history was one way when the history was a totally different way. We have to just blast all of this into the sunlight, and sunlight will be the great disinfectant.

Gina Colvin [00:55:37] Right? Yep.

John Dehlin [00:55:38] For everybody.

Gina Colvin [00:55:39] Okay.

John Dehlin [00:55:39] You know.

Gina Colvin [00:55:40] Okay.

John Dehlin [00:55:40] Yeah.

The Origins of Mormon Stories Podcast

Gina Colvin [00:55:41] So when was Your first podcast?

John Dehlin [00:55:45] 2005.

Gina Colvin [00:55:46] Okay, who was it?

John Dehlin [00:55:48] Greg Prince. Well, I did an episode on my mission experience as my very first episode, and I just told my story, and I didn't even interview anybody. That was episode one. But the very first person I interviewed was Greg Prince.

Gina Colvin [00:56:00] Okay, well, tell us about that. That. That moment where you put it online. How was that for you?

John Dehlin [00:56:05] It was really. It was. It was just really mixed. It was scary. I was petrified. Like, I had lived through the September 6th. But then, you know, I had heard about Thomas Murphy and Simon Southerton and maybe Grant Palmer, you know, being disciplined in one way or another. But it felt like the church had kind of backed off a bit. It felt like it was becoming more progressive. Rough stone rolling, you know, was about to come out, and the blogger knackle was happening. And I think I had this naive optimism that this could be a new era. But at the same time, I had this terrible fear that I could end up like the September 6th.

John Dehlin [00:56:48] And so I just remember being petrified and scary to push the button, but also just optimistic and naive because I had learned about Lowell Bennion, Eugene England, Leonard Arrington, you know, Juanita Brooks by this point. And I'm like, hey, there's a rich intellectual tradition in Sunstone and dialogue, and a lot of these people weren't excommunicated. And so I'm going to just have. I'm Scared as heck, but I'm going to just have this faith that truth and openness and sincerity and candor and transparency and sunlight will win in the end. So it was petrifying, and it was exhilarating. It was scary, terrifying. I didn't know if someone would shoot me or hurt me or kill me.

John Dehlin [00:57:39] I didn't know if I'd be excommunicated. I didn't know if I'd be celebrated. I just had no idea. But I knew that after I'd been exposed to all the pain and all the difficulty and complexity, I knew that I couldn't just stay silent, so I had to speak out. And so it was just my. My moment of. Of standing up and speaking out, and it was terrifying and exhilarating.

Gina Colvin [00:58:04] Right. And when did you know that you were onto something, that people were listening and paying attention?

John Dehlin [00:58:12] Immediately. I mean, immediately I started getting emails, and people started downloading the episodes, and it immediately immediately jumped into the hundreds and then the thousands. I mean, immediately within a few episodes, thousands of thousands of episodes are being downloaded, and people are emailing me from all over the world. Seriously, imagine just soon as you publish one or two episodes, you're getting 10 or 20 emails a week from people who are writing pages and pages of their life story about their, you know, addictions, their. Their divorce, their mental illness, their ecclesiastical abuse, their. Their struggles was history. It was like. It was like imagining this huge water balloon in the sky, and I just punctured a hole in it, and the water just started pouring down on my head, and I could not answer all the phone calls and emails and requests for visits that immediately just opened up as soon as I released the podcast.

Gina Colvin [00:59:13] That was. Sounds weighty.

John Dehlin [00:59:15] It was. It was heady and weighty and amazing and terrifying. It was everything. Yeah.

Gina Colvin [00:59:21] So how are you responding, aside from sort of being overwhelmed? How are you responding in particular in terms of your faith? So it's one thing to say, okay, I'm aware that people are struggling with their faith, and I'm personally struggling with my faith. And then you publish something, and suddenly a whole world sort of washes over you that is similarly struggling with your faith. How are you managing that?

John Dehlin [00:59:49] It was exhilarating and heady and terrifying because I was always worried that I was going to get excommunicated. I was always worried that I was always feeling like I was inadequate. But then so many people were so generous. I mean, very early on, I had somebody fly from, you know, Pennsylvania, you know, drive to Logan and hand me an envelope with $500.

John Dehlin [01:00:22] And I had an almost identical experience with somebody who flew from New York City, flies to Logan, you know, flies to Salt Lake, drives to Logan, has breakfast with me and hands me an envelope with $500. And it's just like, you've saved my life. You have changed everything for me. I have people telling me that I've saved their marriage, that I helped save them from suicide, that I've helped them stay in the church when they felt like they couldn't.

John Dehlin [01:00:49] And it was, I've saved their marriage, I had helped prevent divorce, they're gay. And now, you know, just imagine thousands of people with incredible pain and all of a sudden they view you as this doctor that's giving them the medicine that's curing their pain. That's what it was.

Gina Colvin [01:01:09] So you're throwing really into this place of providing kind of single handedly pastoral care for thousands of people.

John Dehlin [01:01:18] Yeah, I think that's how it felt. And by this time, by the time Mormon stories really started going, I was working for MIT in Cambridge and I was flying literally all over the world. And wherever I would go, people would want to meet me. And they would meet me at the airport, they would pick me up at the airport, they would let me stay in their home and they would treat me like royalty. They would drive me to every single business appointment that I had, feed me, and all they wanted was someone to talk to. If you will let me talk to you in the drives between your business appointments, I'll let you stay in my home and be your personal chauffeur for the entire time you're in my city.

Gina Colvin [01:01:58] Wow.

John Dehlin [01:01:59] And it was, it was that way in Beijing, it was that way in London, it was that way in Cambridge, it was that way in Seattle. Everywhere I went, I was meeting with, every single lunch or dinner I had free, I was meeting with these people who were just suffering or exhilarate, you know, having exhilaration over what I was doing to help them.

Gina Colvin [01:02:24] That's, that's, I mean, that's kind of cool, but it's sort of got to mess with your head a bit.

John Dehlin [01:02:28] Yeah, I know, it was. Yeah, you get a messiah complex. You start feeling like you're there to save the world. Like you're, you're ushering in a new millennia for the church and you're saving marriages and you're preventing suicide and you're helping people stay in the church and you know, and everybody's treating you. I mean, honestly, you start feeling probably like people treated, like people treat royalty or like they Treat prophets or general authorities. You really do start feeling like a general authority to the disaffected. And people, you know, that just. People want to give you money. They. They act in reverence in your presence. They. They will spend any time with you that they can just imagine every trapping of celebrity. You. I started feeling that.

Gina Colvin [01:03:18] I kind of feel overwhelmed for you suddenly being thrown into this place of what you call the general authority, the disaffected. How was. And I know Margi's very sort of, you know, very private, but how is she coping with these sudden demands on you?

Marriage Pressures and the Weight of Holding Others' Stories

John Dehlin [01:03:35] It was. It was very complicated because. Because we had had a rocky marriage. In several ways. Moving to Logan was good for us in several ways, because I wasn't working 60 to 80 hours a week for Bain or Microsoft or Arthur Anderson. I was home more, and I was in school.

John Dehlin [01:04:04] But there are a lot of very important emotional conversations and discussions that we were never able to have. You know, just sort of me being a workaholic, me trying to save the world, us having four kids, her trying to raise the four kids, us bringing our own demons to the marriage. And so I think she was uncomfortable with parts of it, but she was also very supportive. She had gone through the faith crisis with me, so she believed that there was a need out there. But she also is a very private person. And so she didn't like me bringing strangers into our home or me always being on the phone or traveling, having to save the world with my messiah complex.

John Dehlin [01:04:56] You know, it started to bleed over into our church experience, and we're trying to figure out how to raise our kids in the church while I'm doing the podcast and becoming a celebrity and traveling throughout the world. And then there was just a lot of basic things in our marriage that we, you know, were struggling with. And so it was. It was very hard on our marriage. But she was also very supportive, if that makes sense.

Gina Colvin [01:05:26] Yeah. Yeah, it does.

John Dehlin [01:05:27] And very. And very troubled. She was annoyed by it and supportive of it, and it was healthy and unhealthy. It was all that.

Gina Colvin [01:05:36] Right. Right now, I'm just. You're holding and accumulating not just the stories that you're producing. You're holding and accumulating story upon story upon story, people's personal stories. What's the impact that's having on your attachment to the church or your faith?

John Dehlin [01:05:58] You know, I went through some ups and downs. So originally, I'm, you know, I'm teaching, you know, the first several years of Mormon stories. I was teaching elders quorum and active in the church. And so I was trying to make it all work. I was friends. I had made friends with Greg Prince, and I was, you know, meeting all these faithful, thoughtful Mormons, Bill Bradshaw, who I had known at byu, and, you know, just all the thoughtful, faithful Mormons. I was aware of them. And so they were inspiring me. I would go to the, you know, the why I Stay panels at Sunstone were my favorite ones to attend at Sunstone.

John Dehlin [01:06:37] And, you know, the whole purpose of Mormon stories was to help people stay in the church and to stay faithful and active. And so for a time, that's what it was for me. It was just this naive optimism that. That if we just talked openly, we could figure it out and all be happy.

John Dehlin [01:06:57] So that was sort of one path, and we were doing that in the church. But then I started really digging into the difficult stuff, and I started really digging into Michael Quinn and the Toscanos and the history, and really digging into Grant Palmer, and I started interviewing, you know, these people, Grant Palmer and Michael Quinn and Simon Southerton. And, you know, and I started seeing all the pain and the difficulty that the church can inflict on gays and feminists and intellectuals and women and minorities and racial minorities. And so it was like there was this naive optimism that was driving me, but there was also all this pain I was encountering for the people for whom the church didn't work.

John Dehlin [01:07:51] And I was learning more about Joseph Smith and what he did. I was starting to put the pieces together more. I was starting to see the impact of the church on the people for whom it didn't work. And it all of a sudden became a lot more complex than if we just all naively, optimistically, are positive, we can figure this all out. It was. Was like, people are killing themselves, and people are being marginalized and mistreated in very significant, severe ways. And there are entire classes of people that are second or third status in the church.

John Dehlin [01:08:28] And most importantly, these people who are having a faith crisis are misunderstood and being mistreated, and the church isn't really doing anything to help them, and they're becoming victims, and marriages are being torn apart, and people are being driven to depression and sometimes even suicide because of all these issues. And it just became, you know, overwhelming. You know, there's this. I think there's. This is gonna sound cheesy or altruistic, but there's this moment in one of the Superman movies where, like, Superman's becoming overwhelmed by all the calls for help that he hears, and there's a point where he just, like, flies up into space and, like, puts his arms out and sort of.

John Dehlin [01:09:08] You could tell he's becoming overwhelmed by all the need that's out there. And I think at some point, not to put a Messiah complex on myself or Superman complex, but at some point I just started getting really overwhelmed by all the pain I was tapping into. And it just. It started to become unacceptable. I was experiencing pain, but more importantly, people of color, women, minorities, LGBT people, the historical. You know, the intellectuals, all the divorces and sadness, it just started becoming unacceptable to me.

John Dehlin [01:09:43] And it started making me angry. And it started turning me from this naively optimistic person that feels like if we just all talking, you know, we'll figure it out. It started turning me to feel like this is doing real harm to a lot of people and the church isn't doing enough to fix it. And I'm starting to get really angry and impatient.

Part 3 of 3 · Ep. 563

Gina Colvin [00:00:01] Nearer my God to thee Nearer to

Gina Colvin [00:00:10] thee this is the final episode of John de Lynn. From the beginning, as I said in the introduction, one of the things that's really defined your work in Mormon stories is that you've. You have very publicly lived, you know, your feelings about the church. You know, and some, in some respects, that's been a criticism. It's like, well, what's, you know, how does John feel about the church now? You know, so you start from, from that place. So talk me through these phases. So 2005, you're very naive and optimistic that if you just. You can disinfect all the church with sunlight. And at what point are you starting to being worn down by it and furious about it?

John Dehlin [00:00:47] Yeah, I don't have the timeline really solid in my mind. I would need to go back. But I can tell you that during those early years, I. I took Mormon stories down at least twice. I don't know if you know this, but I.

John Dehlin [00:01:02] I literally took it off the Internet twice because I was feeling so overwhelmed by the pain. I was scared of being excommunicated at some points. I was wanting to go to graduate school and scared that if I applied to byu, they might not accept me. Like, different. During different points, I was terrified and scared or overwhelmed by all the pain and suffering. And so between 2005 and 2009, I took Mormon stories down at least twice, just completely off the Internet. And then during those times, there were times where I was really naively optimistic and excited and apologetic and hopeful. And then there were other times where I was just really cynical and angry.

John Dehlin [00:01:49] And I can tell you that when I created stale ds.com that was on one of my optimistic upswings after a negative downswing, you know. And, you know, I can. I can say, you know, I don't know exactly the timelines, but I just know that between 2005 and 2010, which was when I think I brought it back for the time where I haven't brought it down since then, it was a real roller coaster ride for me. And during that time, there were times where I was teaching elders quorum and super active. And then there were other times where I went totally inactive for almost a year.

John Dehlin [00:02:25] And then I'd come back and I'd be rejuvenated and I'd say, we can do this. And then I'd get. After a year or two, I'd get really angry and want to burn the whole thing down. And I definitely went through those cycles between 2005 and 2010.

Church Leaders' Responses and Growing Tensions

Gina Colvin [00:02:40] So what were your ecclesiastical leaders doing? Were they sort of. Were they aware that this was happening for you in this very turbulent sort of faith life?

John Dehlin [00:02:48] Yeah, my first bishop was Bishop Farmer, and he was the first one to question me about what I was doing. And I just pulled this tactic where I had all my listeners write him a letter, you know, to tell him if I'd help them stay in the church. And literally I got like 200 letters and I packaged them all up and gave them to Bishop Farmer. And I said, here's a couple hundred people who can testify to you that I've helped them stay in the church. And through that, in my interviews with him, he's like, wow, I get that this is sort of beyond my pay grade.

John Dehlin [00:03:23] And he just agreed to leave me alone, you know. And then my second bishop, Bishop Stevenson, started asking some questions, but again, I probably did something similar. And he never really took action against me either. And it wasn't until my third bishop, Brian Hunt, where. And that would have been in 2013, I'm going to guess.

Gina Colvin [00:03:52] I thought Hunt was your stake president.

John Dehlin [00:03:55] Bishop Hunt was my. Brian Hunt was my bishop. Mark Jensen was my stake president.

Gina Colvin [00:04:03] Right, okay. Okay.

John Dehlin [00:04:05] And it was Bishop Hunt in 2014, kind of January, February, who was the one who called me in and said, I'm going to start an investigation. And this would have been the third investigation. Both of my other bishops had called me in for similar sort of investigations. I had always emerged with their support, but by the third time, I was just starting to really lose patience. And so, yeah, so it was a very turbulent up and down. Active, inactive. Active, inactive, angry, wanting to burn it all down, Messiah complex. Thinking that I could save everything, you know, just thrashing back and forth over the years.

Gina Colvin [00:04:46] So what was bringing you back to activity? Was it the sense of actually, if I'm in, then I can make a, you know, more of an impact?

John Dehlin [00:04:54] No, it was just whenever I'd go inactive, I would feel a loss. I would feel dark, I would feel more empty. I would feel like I was not doing what was good. I felt lost, I felt scared, I felt family concerns. What about my kids? What about the well being of everybody? So it was always, I'm angry, so I feel like I need to leave. And then after a year, I'd say, no, I can make this work. There's a way to make it work. And then I'd come back and my kids would. My wife and kids, bless their hearts, they'd go out with me and then they'd come back with me and Then they'd go out with me and then they'd come back with me again. And it was just this real. Over a period of, you know, 10 years thrashing back and forth. You know, this year versus that year.

Gina Colvin [00:05:44] It sounds so turbulent and disruptive for everybody.

John Dehlin [00:05:50] Yeah, it was uncomfortable for my elders quorum, it was uncomfortable for my bishoprics. It was uncomfortable for the Internet, for Mormonism, for my family, for my extended family. It was pretty awful for everybody.

Gina Colvin [00:06:02] Well, awful in one respect, but also, really, it's continued to be a balm for. Tell me about what your downloads are at the moment.

John Dehlin [00:06:15] I will get anything between, you know, within a month or two, anything between 20,000 and 80,000 downloads. It just depends on the episode. So, you know, I'd say right now, you know, within a two to three month period, an episode will be downloaded 20 to 30,000 times. And then over the. Over a longer history, it'll reach into the 50 to 80, 100 thousands. Just over time.

Gina Colvin [00:06:43] Yeah. See, that's a lot of people, isn't it? That's a lot of people. So you're doing, you know, it's serving a purpose. There's been a kind of a consistency in the actual program, in the show, Mormon stories. And that sort of sits underneath your own turbulent journey through it.

John Dehlin [00:07:01] Yeah, there's been ups and downs, but I think listenership is as high as it's ever been. Maybe, maybe it's dipped a little bit, but certainly by 20, by late 2014, 2015, listenership was as high as it's ever been.

Gina Colvin [00:07:15] Right.

John Dehlin [00:07:16] I think the excommunication probably has affected that, but up until then, it's gangbusters. And it's still, I think, the most listened to Mormon blog podcast on the Internet, I think.

Gina Colvin [00:07:28] Oh, absolutely, absolutely. So tell me, while we're talking about Mormon stories, some memorable, like some memorable episodes. Now you've got like 560 or something episodes?

John Dehlin [00:07:41] Yeah, I do.

Gina Colvin [00:07:43] Yeah. Okay, so tell us, what was your most delightful.

John Dehlin [00:07:47] Oh my goodness. Oh, man, that's like asking me to choose my children.

Gina Colvin [00:07:53] Oh, I know. Sorry. Sorry. Okay.

John Dehlin [00:07:55] I really loved. I really loved my time with Carolyn Pearson. You know, I got four or five hours with her. That was just really delightful. I really enjoyed Richard Bushman, even though he cut short the interview. I really enjoyed my time with Taro Givens, at least early on. That was really exciting for me. And then I didn't enjoy. But my interview with Grant Palmer was just earth shattering and mind blowing for me. My interview with, you know, with Michael Quinn was mind Blowing. And, you know, gosh, it's like asking me to choose which is my favorite child. You know, there's been so many amazing interviews and experiences along the way. Yeah. There's just so many. How do I pick?

Gina Colvin [00:08:58] Well, you've given us a good sense. So what made those ones earth shattering for you? Because this is your personal journey as well that you're going through. You're taking people in these conversations and in these narratives. You're taking people through your personal story as well.

John Dehlin [00:09:13] Well, when you interview someone like Greg Prince or Richard Bushman or Terrell Givens or Fiona Givens, Claudia Bushman, you've got these intellectual giants that have been fixtures in Mormon studies for decades, and they're statesmanlike and they're faithful, and it's just very overwhelmingly powerful and influential. You just feel it's heady. You're grateful that they'll talk to you, and then you're just really optimistic that you can make it work. Because if these brilliant, sensitive, thoughtful people can make it work, you can, too.

John Dehlin [00:09:50] So that's kind of one cluster of people. And I'd say Carolyn Pearson fits in that group too, even though she's not been on the inside, like maybe Givens and Bushman have in some respect. She's every bit. Is inspirational to me.

John Dehlin [00:10:09] And then on the other hand, you're interviewing September 6th people. Paul Margaret Toscano and. And Grant Palmer and Michael Quinn, and people that have been excommunicated or marginalized, or people like Simon Sotherton, or people that the church views as enemies. And you're getting these other perspectives that are just really.

John Dehlin [00:10:34] Or you're interviewing people who have attempted suicide or been severely depressed or divorced or people who have been kicked out. And so it's this heady thrashing of, like, brilliant, inspiring, faithful people that make you feel like you can stay and make it work. And then these depressing, epic, awful stories of people like Grant Palmer, you know, being kicked out and disfellowshipped or excommunicated or Michael Quinn or whoever, and just feeling like not only have grave injustices been done, but. But the church has covered things up and hurt people and damaged people. And it really was just this thrashing of being inspired and being horrified by the abuse and the difficulties.

John Dehlin [00:11:25] And honestly, every single episode is like, me, maybe I can stay. Maybe I can make it work. Maybe if I ask the right question or learn the right thing, we can solve this problem for all of Mormonism. And then it's this other interview that's like, oh, my Gosh, this is terrible. Is abusive, this is horrible, this is racist, this is offensive, this is sexist, this is homophobic. How am I going to. How could I ever stay in good conscience in an organization that does these things to people? And it's just really thrashing is the best way I can describe it. It's just feeling pulled between angels and devils.

Gina Colvin [00:12:06] But isn't that the whole Mormon story?

John Dehlin [00:12:09] Yeah, it sure is. I mean, can be. I mean, a lot of people never really leave what we call Fowler Stage three, where they just. It's just sort of this bliss of. I don't want to say an ignorant bliss, but just sort of church is true and I'm not going to doubt and I'll live my whole life. There's certainly most of members probably are in that camp. But, you know, once you fall to Fowler Stage four, where you're really questioning, then it's this exhilarating thrashing of enlightenment and negativity that you just kind of thrash between. And I honestly only think at the most 5% of the membership really goes through this. But it certainly is an exhilarating ride for those of us who do.

Gina Colvin [00:12:57] So would you say that the church really belongs to the Stage three? I mean, is the church Stage three?

John Dehlin [00:13:04] I think so. It's starting to flirt with Stage four, but it's only in secret. It's like the essays are out, but they're not spoken of at conference and they're not publicized. Right. We want to create resources for Stage four people that can be given to them on demand when they need it. But if you look at the discourse in general conference, it's still very much a stage three discourse because they don't want to compromise the critical massive membership to cater to the fringy intellectuals. Right, right. Or social activists. So I would say that with the essays and with rough stone rolling and with some of their moves with women and other things, they're starting to flirt with progressivism. But it's certainly just a flirtation at this point. It's not a marriage.

Gina Colvin [00:13:59] Right now, part of the way that you have borne the weight of the Mormon Stories phenomenon is by growing, growing people into the community, growing. The podcasts tell us some of the ways that you've sort of pushed Mormon Stories out into other places and into other hands. I think I stay lds, Mormon Matters. You know, it's, you know, you've gone from Mormon stories.

John Dehlin [00:14:22] So I started with Mormon Stories and then, and you know, Mormon Matters was supposed to be just a different. Instead of deep individual interviews Mormon Matters was supposed to be panel discussions, and I did 10 or 20 hours of that, but then I got busy with grad school and other things, and so. But I felt like that was an asset. And it used to be one of the biggest blogs on the Internet before it imploded. It was as big as By Common Consent or Times of Seasons or Feminist Mormon Housewives.

Gina Colvin [00:14:51] Sorry, it was a blog.

John Dehlin [00:14:53] Yeah. Mormon Matters was a really, really strong, successful blog and podcast. And a bunch of the bloggers left and started Wheat and Tares.

The Mormon Matters Split and Road to Church Discipline

Gina Colvin [00:15:04] Can you tell us why there was a mutiny? Should we do that or not?

John Dehlin [00:15:08] No, I don't mind. My memory is going to be foggy, but let's see the way. Boy, I'm really foggy on this.

Gina Colvin [00:15:17] Oh, maybe we shouldn't do.

John Dehlin [00:15:18] No, no, no. I know that there were. I know that. I know that it was going very well. I know that it was super successful. It was getting lots of traction. And then behind the scenes, there were certain bloggers or members of communities that started getting uncomfortable with, I don't know, my management or how are navigating the faithful with the disaffected discourse with how I was managing things. I don't know. I'm actually really drawing a blank on what led to the rift. I know that behind the scenes, I got in some really heated disagreements with some people and ended up happening. They just said, we're splitting off, and they asked permission to start their new blog, to take all the blog posts with them, and they.

John Dehlin [00:16:17] They split off. And honestly, I'm. I'm blanking on what the main reasons were, but I'm sure if somebody reminds me, I'll be able to think about it. But, yeah, they. They broke off and went independent.

Gina Colvin [00:16:28] Okay, okay, okay. You've grown this community. So you've got State lds, Mormon Matters.

John Dehlin [00:16:34] Yeah, so stay lds. Was. So Mormon Matters came first, I think, and then. But then I let that die. Then I started Stale DS to help people stay in the church. I ended up giving out that over to Dan, you know, to Brian Johnston and others there. I ended up recruiting Dan Witherspoon to take over Mormon Matters. Once he left Sunstone. I got sad that Dan was sort of getting put out to pasture, and I felt like he was too talented to just sort of go to waste. So I pitched Dan to take over Mormon Matters, and he graciously accepted that, so he took that over.

John Dehlin [00:17:09] I started a thoughtful faith with Micah and Sarah because this was during one of my manic upswings in optimism of faith. And I Just felt like we needed a faithful podcast of interviews, and so Micah and Sarah took that over. Then when they left to start exploring sainthood, you know, I eventually landed on you and had been super thrilled with that.

Gina Colvin [00:17:38] So.

John Dehlin [00:17:38] Yeah, and then I started Gay Mormon Stories with my cousin Daniel Parkinson, and what else?

Gina Colvin [00:17:45] And then you've got the podcast communities.

John Dehlin [00:17:48] Yeah, yeah. So we started all the Facebook groups once those came. And then, yeah, we started the Face to Face communities on Facebook where we'd start a city, you know, in London or Boston or Chicago or Houston, we would have Mormon Stories communities that. That could start supporting people in the cities where they lived. Right, yeah.

Gina Colvin [00:18:09] And all of these come under, more broadly, the Open Stories Foundation.

John Dehlin [00:18:14] Yeah, I started open stories in 2010 when I was faced with grad school and $10 an hour assistantships. I just felt like I couldn't make ends meet on that income. But more importantly, I felt like Mormonism still needed more resources and support. So that's when, in 2010, I made a deal with my listeners. I will turn down assistantships that are offered to me in grad school if you guys will pay for Mormon Stories. And so they started donating more. And I created the nonprofit so that the donations would be tax deductible. And so the Open Stories foundation was sort of born, I think, in the 2010ish, as a way for me to fund graduate school and to keep providing support to people.

The Disciplinary Council and Excommunication

Gina Colvin [00:19:02] Okay, so leading up to your church discipline last year, wasn't it? Was it last year

John Dehlin [00:19:09] still this year? I think.

Gina Colvin [00:19:10] Okay, January, wasn't it?

John Dehlin [00:19:11] It was, yeah, kind of. I think it was early February where I heard the verdict, I think.

Gina Colvin [00:19:17] Right, right. What was the state of your belief? Had everything crashed down around you?

John Dehlin [00:19:26] It depends on what we're talking about. I still wanted to make the church work. I didn't want to leave the church. But Prop 8 was a big blow to me. I lost my literal belief in this being the one true church back when I worked for Microsoft. So that died. That died around 2001, you know, but I still was. Was in this mindset of it being, you know, an inspired church of many inspired churches, and still a good place to help people. So I started Mormon Stories with that mindset, and I maintained that mindset in many ways, even through 2014, 2015. But when Prop 8 happened, that was a real turning point for me in 2008 because I started becoming more sympathetic and empathetic for LGBT people, for racial minorities, for women, for feminists.

John Dehlin [00:20:32] And Mormon Stories really helped make Me aware of matters of race and sexuality and gender and things of that sort and intellectual issues. And so once I really became sympathetic and once Proposition 8 happened and the church was going to start really trying to clamp down on people that I felt like deserved our love and support, not discrimination, that's when it started getting really personal. And it looked by the end of 2012 that the church was going to. It looked like it had started backing off, like it was going to just kind of be a more friendly church and it wasn't going to be going after people anymore.

John Dehlin [00:21:17] And it felt like, you know, by this time, Terrell Givens and Roughstone rolling and all that stuff, it seemed like there was some openness that was happening. But there was a real turning point for me, I want to say around 2013, where oaks gave this talk in General Conference in October of 2013 where he basically, it seemed like he was doubling down on the proclamation on the family and on marriage being between a man and a woman.

John Dehlin [00:21:53] And the church's sort of anti same sex marriage initiative started to start ramping up again in 2013. And I just felt, I just reached this breaking point where I felt like if they're going to actually start doing actively working against same sex marriage and feminism and intellectuals, et cetera, I can't stay active and in good conscience stay quiet.

John Dehlin [00:22:26] So I felt like I had to start criticizing the Brethren openly, starting with Oakes Talk in the fall of 2013. That's when I gave my TED Talk in fall of 2013. That's when I signed on to support ordain women in December of 2013.

John Dehlin [00:22:50] And that's when I shortly thereafter got called in by my stake president in early 2014 and was told he was starting an investigation. And he named ordained women and my progressive Mormonism stuff as the reasons for the investigation.

Gina Colvin [00:23:07] But before that you'd had an ecclesiastical leader. I'm not sure it was a bishop or a stake president who'd actually really kind of caused a bit of a turn in you, a moment of tenderness towards the church.

John Dehlin [00:23:20] Yeah. So yeah, in 2000, probably early 2012, I was in a really angry spot and my marriage was on really on the ropes. And I was just really angry. And my stake president, Brian Jensen, Mark Jensen, reached out to me and just showed amazing love and patience and compassion.

John Dehlin [00:23:47] And while I was ready to burn it all down and release the Tom Phillips interview and really just go hardcore at the church, he sort of loved me back into the church for a final time. And that's when I You know, that's when I started working through some real marital difficulties with Margi.

John Dehlin [00:24:07] That's when I contracted my community work with the Mormon Stories communities. And that's when I really had these intense, long, heart to heart weekly meetings with my stake president, Mark Jensen, to see if I could baptize my son Winston. He made me wait a full year to be able to baptize Winston. I baptized Winston when he was nine.

Gina Colvin [00:24:33] Sorry, John. Why couldn't you baptize Winston?

John Dehlin [00:24:37] Because I had. By the time I interviewed with John Larsen and Mormon Expression Podcast, and my memory is foggy, but by early 2012, my language had become very strident in anger against the church. And I had interviewed a lot of people that had really disturbed the church headquarters by that point. And so my stake president just said, I don't feel like you're worthy to baptize your son, but I'm willing to work not because of any moral transgression at that point, but because, you know, because of my public statements and because of Mormon stories. He had heard enough complaints and concerns that he felt like we needed to work through my testimony, my faith, my commitment to the church, before he could feel comfortable allowing me to baptize Winston.

Gina Colvin [00:25:44] But there is no formal discipline.

John Dehlin [00:25:47] No, no, no, no, no.

Gina Colvin [00:25:48] Okay.

John Dehlin [00:25:49] No. There was just all my podcast stuff and my public statements, and he was concerned about the effect Mormon Stories was having on people, and he was concerned about my own testimony.

Gina Colvin [00:26:05] Right. So, okay, okay.

John Dehlin [00:26:08] So I did a full year of weekly one on ones with Mark Jensen, which sort of turned me around and made me feel like I wanted to give the church one last go. And so between summer of 2000, you know, 2012 and 2013, we came to an understanding of each other to the point where after a year, he felt comfortable letting me return to full fellowship, he felt comfortable letting me baptize Winston, and I was back active in the church again.

Gina Colvin [00:26:44] Had you toned down Mormon stories throughout that period?

John Dehlin [00:26:50] Somewhat, but I think it was still. I think still some of my was during that time. But I did agree to not publish the Tom Phillips interview. That was right at a critical period of these talks with my stake president, where he basically said, without saying, if you publish that, you will likely face disciplinary.

Gina Colvin [00:27:13] Why is that? What's the sensitivity? I mean, I've listened to the Tom Phillips interview, but let's talk about why the sensitivity around that particular podcast.

John Dehlin [00:27:20] Just because he talks about the second anointing, Right. And he recounts his experience with the second anointing in the temple and the feeling Was. That's too sacred to talk about publicly.

Gina Colvin [00:27:33] Has Tom Phillips been excommunicated?

John Dehlin [00:27:35] No, not to my knowledge. And neither is Jeremy Runnels.

Gina Colvin [00:27:39] Okay. Okay.

John Dehlin [00:27:40] Totally left alone.

Gina Colvin [00:27:41] Okay, interesting. So by the time you get to. Then you have a change of ecclesiastical leaders from Mark Jensen to.

John Dehlin [00:27:51] To. To. To Brian Jensen. What was it Brian Hunt? No, Brian Hunt was my bishop. Okay, who was it? Was it Brian Jensen?

Gina Colvin [00:28:02] I don't know.

John Dehlin [00:28:04] Oh, man, I'm.

Gina Colvin [00:28:05] You can't remember the person who excommunicated you?

John Dehlin [00:28:08] Brian King.

Gina Colvin [00:28:09] Okay. Brian King.

John Dehlin [00:28:10] Yeah. Brian King. Yeah. So in. In the fall of 2013, Who's that general authority? The guy from California, the lawyer. Oh, my gosh. My brain is just completely f. Whitney Clayton. Oh, yeah. L. Whitney Clayton. Right. Okay. Yeah.

Gina Colvin [00:28:32] So sorry. Get me out of there.

John Dehlin [00:28:33] So you'll get Dan's.

Gina Colvin [00:28:35] Thea. No, I won't.

John Dehlin [00:28:37] So, yeah, that's Dan Witherspoon, everybody. So, yeah. No, no, no. Just cut that out and just say. Just skip the part where you forgot his name and just whole thing out.

Gina Colvin [00:28:49] I don't think so.

John Dehlin [00:28:50] So. Oh, Jesus. So. Okay. So, yeah, so Mark Jensen gets. So El. Whitney Clayton comes to our stake in, like August of 2013, and. And he gives this talk that I record that makes it sound like they're going to start going after people. And then later he reorganizes my stake presidency. He. He releases Mark Jensen, who did not. Who was not willing to excommunicate me, who I think had pressure to excommunicate me. And he. He declined. And they. And. And L. Whitney Clayton calls Brian King as the new stake president. And it was during this same fall that I had become upset about Elder Oaks, his talk in General Conference.

Gina Colvin [00:29:38] So can I ask, were you active at that time?

John Dehlin [00:29:42] Yeah, I sure was. I was active and I was. But I was also starting to get really upset. And by active, I mean attending sacrament meeting. I think by that point I found Sunday school and priesthood not productive for me to attend.

John Dehlin [00:30:03] My Elders Quorum president and some other members of my ward had started to spy on me and invest me and attempted to gain entrance into some of the private forums that I was entering. And this all came out and I got really furious and I felt like I was being spied on.

John Dehlin [00:30:23] And so at that point, I didn't feel welcome to go to Elders Quorum because these guys who had been spying on me without telling me were in the leadership there. And so. And so I would just go to soccer meeting with my family and that's. You know, that was True. Up through June of 2014, I was still actively attending soccer, meeting with my family, and letting my kids, you know, be raised in the church.

John Dehlin [00:30:48] So. But it was that fall. So that. So going back, it was the fall of 2013 where L. Whitney Clayton reorganized my stake and called Brian King and where Oaks gave that talk and where I just realized I couldn't stay silent anymore about the harm being done to LGBT people and women and minorities, et cetera. And so I gave my TED Talk that November. I wrote my Ordained Women profile that December, I think. And then I got called into the bishop that sort of. January, February of 2014.

Gina Colvin [00:31:22] Okay. And we're going to talk really quickly about the charges against you for your disciplinary council. What were they exactly?

John Dehlin [00:31:31] Oh, man, I'm not prepared to. Let me just see. So. When Brian Hunt, my bishop, called me in in late January, early February of 2014, he specifically mentioned my Ordained Women profile and my work on progressive Mormonism, which was a website I had created trying to encourage a brand of progressive Mormonism. And he basically just said, those things are a problem, and I'm going to start an investigation. By that point, I didn't have patience for another investigation.

John Dehlin [00:32:15] I said, you, Brian Hunt, can investigate me, but I will not be participating in that investigation. So this is when I wrote him and said, I will be attending sacrament meeting with my children, and I'll still remain a member of your ward, but for ecclesiastical reasons, you can just as well not consider me a member of the ward, because I won't be interacting with you anymore as my ecclesiastical leader if you're going to conduct yet another investigation after all the investigations I had already had.

Gina Colvin [00:32:48] So you're pissed off?

John Dehlin [00:32:51] Yeah, just tired. Just tired. And, yeah, I was angry. But the crazy thing is I was still committed to activity, so I was still raising my kids in the church, and I was still attending sacrament meeting.

Gina Colvin [00:33:03] Right.

John Dehlin [00:33:03] But I just. The investigations just really got to me, you know, just. You know, I remember a guy who lives on my street who is Elders Quorum president, would be, you know, home teaching me and acting like he loved me and my family. And then he'd be secretly gathering tweets and Facebook comments and trying to get into secret forums and then turning all that information in to try and get me excommunicated.

Gina Colvin [00:33:29] Right, right.

John Dehlin [00:33:30] So it was in that same Elders Quorum president told me his dad, his grandpa, had been excommunicated and that it was the best thing that ever happened to him and that if he ever had to excommunicate me or had to help contribute to my excommunication. He would consider it an honor to have played a part in that, because he would feel like excommunication at that point would have been God's will, and he would have been helping perform God's will. And he told me that himself. And that was just a really twisted, sick way to be my elders, quorum president and my ecclesiastical leader. From my point of view, I don't know where that left us, but that

Gina Colvin [00:34:09] left me thinking, you've got a lot of, you know, if you kind of imagine just lots of balls in the air at this point, like so many kind of trajectory, so many, you know, a number of discursive trajectories, all held in tension with each other and all sort of being railroaded to this moment where you're actually being socially shunned because they can't manage. My sense is that they couldn't kind of manage the scope of this conversation and so targeting you as a possibility to eradicate that.

Gina Colvin [00:34:41] Yeah.

John Dehlin [00:34:41] And I had had two personal lunches with Elder Holland where he had told me, we need more John de Lynds in this church and told me to keep doing what I'm doing and that he really, you know, really respected me and my work. I had had a private lunch with Marlon Jensen where he just treated me like the answer to the church's problems, where he asked me every possible question and told me, I'm going to go speak to the brethren and the Quorum of the twelve in the First Presidency. Give me all the suggestions you have on how I can help make the church better.

John Dehlin [00:35:14] And so I had been and I had helped the church do their study on disaffection that then led to the essays. So, like, I personally cooperated with Marlon Jensen and other members of church headquarters to gather the data that then they used to help decide to convince church headquarters to create these essays and to release them. I'm not saying I was the reason the essays happened, but I know for a fact that I was a part of why they happened.

John Dehlin [00:35:48] And so I don't think they knew what to do with me until Oaks. I wasn't really criticizing the Brethren publicly. I wasn't denying the church's truth claims. I was just saying I was struggling with them. And I'm just trying to interview people to reach more truth. And I think at some point I'd reached a listenership where they felt like they worried that coming after me could do more damage than leaving me alone. And I think a lot of the years I survived either through my personal relationships with Holland or Jensen or other insiders in the church, or just fear that if they did anything to me, it would really hurt the church.

John Dehlin [00:36:27] And at some point in 2014, 2013, 2014, whether it was my TED Talk or Ordain women or some of the interviews that I did or some of the public Facebook comments that I made, I think they just felt like I crossed a line.

Gina Colvin [00:36:44] Right. But nobody pointed that line out to you, said, hey, there's the line. Don't go over it.

John Dehlin [00:36:49] Oh, well, eventually my stake president did. That's. You know, that. That's what. That's what Brian. Brian King did starting in June of 2014.

Gina Colvin [00:36:59] Right. Okay. So do you think perhaps your disciplinary council was really a result of sort of a capriciousness at the local leadership level or maybe sort of, you know, the middling kind of general authority level, or do you think it was from higher up?

John Dehlin [00:37:15] I think when L. Whitney Clayton reorganized our stake, I think he put someone in that would take care of me, because the trainings that he was offering the members of my stake, from the rumblings that I heard, were very much hostile towards Internet activity, towards Internet activism, towards people questioning, people doubting publicly. It just. The rumblings were that L. Whitney Clayton was installing a stake president and training the leaders so that they would know what to do with people like me. And so it was by January of 2014 that my bishop, you know, who I had been very friendly with up until that point, his brother had been gay, you know, and he.

John Dehlin [00:38:04] I had helped counsel him about LGBT issues, and he had been really friendly to me. But by the time he was made bishop and got this training by Clayton, I think he was pushed to the point where he felt like he had no choice but to come after me.

John Dehlin [00:38:17] And so I think Clayton installed King so that Hunt would come after me, Brian Hunt, and then that would kick the ball rolling to make it look local so that then King could excommunicate me.

Gina Colvin [00:38:32] What about, how are you feeling about contemplating church discipline? Because you'd actually dealt with that, you know, you'd had to hold that, you know, that fear for, you know, 10 years now. So when it actually came to that point, were you resigned? Were you angry, or.

John Dehlin [00:38:49] I was everything. I was sad, I was scared. I was hopeful that it would go away. I was hopeful that I would be vindicated, that they would back down. And I was angry and vengeful and eager to burn it all down. Like everything, it was very schizophrenic for Me, it was not. It's all a lie and let's tear it down and let me figure out some scheme to burn it down. And. And it wasn't all, oh, no, you know, they're going to come after me. It was all of those things, you know what I mean?

Gina Colvin [00:39:24] Yeah. And in your disciplinary council, I know you've spoken recently about this. What's the general sense there, that this was an execution or that it was actually something a little bit more tender than that?

John Dehlin [00:39:38] There was no tenderness in my excommunication. It was cold, impersonal. People didn't want to look me in the eye. And it was clinical and antiseptic and, you know, really brutal in its impersonal nature, you know.

Gina Colvin [00:40:00] Yeah, yeah, yeah. And how did you expect that?

John Dehlin [00:40:08] Yeah, because I had met with King. I met with President King three times and. He was just. He was like a robot. He was just. He had his marching orders, it felt like. And he was going to go, you know, think about it. So I got the letter telling me, asking me to resign or there'd be a disciplinary council in June when I had never met him and never even had one conversation with him.

Gina Colvin [00:40:45] Aren't they responsible? Is it part of the process to actually meet with the, you know, the person in question?

John Dehlin [00:40:50] Well, that's what I thought, but it turns out the King felt like Mark Jensen's meetings with me met that criteria.

Gina Colvin [00:41:00] Okay.

John Dehlin [00:41:01] So he. I don't think he felt like he had to. And he told me that he met with Mark Jensen during the transition and Mark Jensen said, yeah, well, since the fall of 2013, John's become more strident, and this isn't the same John that I rehabilitated. And President King said that he and Mark Jensen sort of had this exchange where President King said to President Jensen, I don't think I could have had as much patience as you did to meet with John for a full year. And then President Jensen said back to President King, well, I don't think that I have the courage to do what you're probably about to do to John.

Gina Colvin [00:41:50] Oh, that's sad. That's sad.

John Dehlin [00:41:52] And so King told me about that exchange personally.

Gina Colvin [00:41:55] Okay.

John Dehlin [00:41:56] Almost like he was sort of nervous but proud of how he was being the strong one who was going to sort of solve the problem, you know,

Gina Colvin [00:42:06] and I suppose we go. We can circle back to your experience in Guatemala, that, that, that these problems or these issues within Mormonism can be solved with a. With a really meaningful, tender and compassionate conversations and thoughtful and mindful conversations rather than Just the petty politicking at the local level for, you know, I know whose balls are bigger, you know.

John Dehlin [00:42:28] Yeah. I mean, I guess. I guess there's a part of me that felt like I had truth on my side. Openness and integrity and people suffering. There was a part of me that felt like, well, I'm on a first name basis with Elder Holland and Marlon Jensen, and my brother works for church headquarters. And, you know, I helped the church, you know, with my study of why people leave the church. I helped influence the direction that they took with the essays. And, you know, when Daniel Peterson came after me, he had been slapped back by Elder Holland and the Maxwell Institute. And, you know, I just felt like I had enough support on the inside, you know, to where maybe they. They wouldn't do such a thing, you know, But. But yeah, but I think L. Whitney Clayton had other plans.

Gina Colvin [00:43:29] Right. And maybe that's one of the failings and the way the church operates is that personal. Personal feeling overwhelms moral judgment and the careful weighing of people's greatest sort of needs as individuals that need care. So. And it's disappointing. So you get excommunicated, you get the letter. Was that a surprise for you?

John Dehlin [00:44:00] I think I expected it, but I probably. There was probably a part of me that still hoped that it wouldn't happen. But I figured it. I mean, King was Just think about it. So we. In our first meeting in June, well, before we ever met, he's asking me to resign or face excommunication. Then I shame him through the New York Times into meeting with me at least once.

John Dehlin [00:44:25] He meets with me. And, you know, that transcript, I think that's the transcript that's been published. I mean, you know, it's just clear that he's not really sincerely trying to work with me, that he's irritated, he's impersonal, he hasn't thought deeply about these issues, and he's sort of just a man on a mission.

John Dehlin [00:44:46] And then in August, that August meeting, I'm not sure which one I released now if it was the June or the August meeting that we had. But in the August meeting, it was just, okay, nope, I'm ready to excommunicate you now. So that was our second meeting, but it wasn't that it was here. All these conditions, and it was like, you need to take down Mormon stories, take down any offensive episode. Never again do anything that could be considered questionable.

John Dehlin [00:45:15] I forget now all the conditions that he gave to me, but it was basically shut down Mormon stories and stop talking about These things and stop supporting same sex marriage and stop supporting, you know, women's ordination and, you know, go silent and retract everything that you've ever said. And that, that was just.

John Dehlin [00:45:36] I just couldn't do it, you know, So, I mean, so then he went silent forever. But, you know, I just figured the writing was on the wall, it was just a matter of when. And of course, it was really weird that we left with such certainty that, that I wasn't gonna.

John Dehlin [00:45:53] I wasn't gonna agree to his demands in August. And it wasn't until the following January, February, that actually. January, that he actually took action. So my guess is he wanted to see if I would hang myself with more rope. You know, give me more rope to hang myself. And I don't think I backed down that fall.

John Dehlin [00:46:14] And so I think it was just maybe, maybe either they wanted the Meet the Mormons movie to come out and they didn't want all the negative publicity to be surrounding the release of that movie. Maybe that's arrogant to say. I don't know, I'm just guessing. Or maybe he just wanted to give me more rope to hang myself, or maybe he just wanted to see if I would truly rehabilitate. But at that point, I wasn't willing to stop supporting same sex marriage, which was a condition. I wasn't willing to stop supporting female ordination, which was a condition. I wasn't willing to take down past Mormon Stories episodes, which was a condition. And so I just wasn't willing to meet any of his demands.

Gina Colvin [00:46:52] A lot of that's a nonsense anyway, isn't it? I mean, there are plenty of people, hundreds and hundreds of people that support both of those things without being disciplined for it, which is.

John Dehlin [00:47:02] Well, that was the most maddening thing is because in private, and I've got recordings of all these interviews, I've got transcripts, you know, I could release them if I want to. You know, in private, he would say it was all about Mormon stories and same sex marriage and feminism and speaking out. But then in public and in my actual disciplinary council, he wanted to say it was all about not believing in Jesus and God and Joseph Smith and the restoration in the right way. So he wanted to publicly pin it all on my lack of belief, but then privately pin it on what I think were the real reasons, which were my social activism and my. The effectiveness of Mormon stories in really generating awareness and interest in discussion on these difficult issues.

Gina Colvin [00:47:54] Were you sad to be excommunicated?

John Dehlin [00:47:58] Oh, yeah. It was devastating and exhilarating. Like it's you know, 10 years is a long time to be in such conflict and to be thrashing between devotion and commitment and anger and resentment and trying to please the believers, but then getting hit by, you know, disaffected and then trying to please the disaffected and getting hit by the believers and trying to navigate all this within my own family and with my own children and my own marriage and trying to make sense of it all. So I'm proud that I stuck it out for as long as I did. I don't think I did the things perfectly, but I think.

John Dehlin [00:48:40] I think I. I managed it in a way to. To bring maximum attention to the issue, to the issues and. And support and awareness. But by. By 2014, I was just frazzled and done. And so it needed to go. Either they're going to leave me alone or excommunicate me. And, you know, it needed to go one way or the other, and I thought they were going to. You know, by the time I'd met with Elder Holland twice, by the time I'd met with Marlon Jensen, by the time I had helped the church do the study and spread the word that led to the essays, I felt like maybe I was safe. But something turned when I gave my TED Talk and when I supported ordained women. Something about those two things really snapped the issue.

Gina Colvin [00:49:31] Well, maybe they were just excuses, so.

John Dehlin [00:49:34] Yeah.

Gina Colvin [00:49:35] Yeah. Okay, John, we're just about at the end.

John Dehlin [00:49:39] Oh, wow. Okay.

Gina Colvin [00:49:40] After three hours.

John Dehlin [00:49:41] Can't end on this.

Gina Colvin [00:49:43] No, we're not going to end on this. We're going to end on a more jovial kind of conversation. Now, 10 years you've been at Mormon stories, and, you know, it's been. Had a profound effect on the church, I think, and on thousands and thousands of people. And that has thrust you into the. Into the limelight somewhat. You. I know people talk about Mormon rock stars. You're one of them. What do you think has been your biggest gaffe, the thing that you could, you know, you just, like, cringe at?

John Dehlin [00:50:16] Well, for sure, my biggest gaffe was almost ruining my marriage. And. And then second to that was the way that I handled sort of 2012, where I retracted the communities and spoke openly about some of the fears that I had back in 2012 that left so many of the communities feeling like I had betrayed them.

John Dehlin [00:50:55] And I just. I made so many. I hurt so many people's trust and feelings. So, yeah, number one, by far is hurting Margi and almost having our marriage end. And then a distant second, but a very important second would be the way that I handled the Mormon stories, communities that left so many people feeling hurt and betrayed.

John Dehlin [00:51:23] And then a third, if I had to say a third, I would say it would be the fact that I wasn't able to maintain more patience and neutrality and diplomacy, you know, that I couldn't find a way to play at all so that it wouldn't end this way. You know what I mean? Ideally, for me, the ideal. I don't know if this is true now, but there's a part of me that feels like the ideal outcome would have been Mormon stories led to a.

John Dehlin [00:51:52] I don't know, it was the glasnost or perestroika, some sort of like, openness in Mormonism that led to a renaissance, that led to openness, where it all ended happily and the church became more progressive and tolerant and there was a place for people like me and we all sang Kumbaya like that would, you know. So I wish I could have played it to where it would have been that end. But instead, I got angry, I got bitter, I got frustrated. I lost my neutrality and I alienated a lot of people, I hurt a lot of people's feelings, and it all ended catastrophically with my excommunication and, you know, a bunch of people being grateful, but a bunch of people being really angry. And I wish I could have played it more diplomatically to where everything was happy, but it didn't work out that way.

Gina Colvin [00:52:42] Perhaps not in your lifetime or in your church lifetime, but, you know, I was sitting with a bishop, he was over several weeks ago, who was contemplating. And even my stake president has said there are shifts and changes, things are happening. And I think that's largely to do with the kind of work that, you know, people like yourself and others are doing to take away the toxicity or the fear of different. Of these hard conversations. So I don't think the story's over. Your story's not over.

John Dehlin [00:53:14] Oh, thank you. Well, I hope it all ends happy for the church, for its members, for the ex members, for me, for my family. I hope it all ends blissfully, happily.

Gina Colvin [00:53:26] Well, I don't know about happy, but, you know, functional would be good. So what have been your greatest pleasures?

Meaning, Legacy, and Reflections on Ten Years

John Dehlin [00:53:37] You know, I. I think I've always had this hole inside of me where I needed to feel like I was living a meaningful life and. And contributing to the world in a positive way and alleviating suffering and bringing joy. Like all my early job turbulence was over me trying to find a way to make a difference in the world.

John Dehlin [00:54:00] And, you know, I just. I've been able, you know, tens of thousands of people have told me that I've saved their marriage, you know, helped heal them from depression or anxiety, helped them find a way to stay in the church, helped them find a way to leave the church in a healthy way, prevented, you know, LGBT people from suicide, or helped, you know, family members and friends become more understanding or supportive of people doubting or.

John Dehlin [00:54:31] Or people who are gays, feminist intellectuals, and people of color and all that. From what people tell me, I feel like I've been able to make a really big difference in alleviating suffering and promoting a discussion that has led to positive change, and that has led a lot of people to become more awake in their lives and to live a life that is more meaningful to them.

John Dehlin [00:55:02] And I don't say that to be arrogant, but I mean, that's. I have got this insecurity where unless I'm helping others, I don't feel happy with myself. And lots of people have told me over the years that I've helped them either saved a marriage or prevented suicide or helped their transition out in a healthy way or help them stay.

John Dehlin [00:55:26] And I just can't tell you how deeply gratifying it is to play a part in people's lives in a way that they tell me is so important and meaningful. I mean, it's everything I could have ever hoped for. And I wouldn't. You know, I wouldn't make any change to what I've done. If it were to take away what I've been able to be a part of, I wouldn't make a change now. I would do different things if I could, but I wouldn't change the outcome.

John Dehlin [00:55:58] I wouldn't change what I was trying to do or the positive things that have come about as a result. Because just to this day, people tell me all the time I've helped them find more joy and meaning in their lives, and that's incredibly rewarding.

Gina Colvin [00:56:16] If you could put a life lesson on the back of a posted stamp, what would it be?

John Dehlin [00:56:27] Yeah, it would be. It's sort of the song Brave. You know, if people are suffering in the world, if you notice that they're suffering, stand up and fight to alleviate the suffering. Stand up for those who are. Who are being mistreated.

John Dehlin [00:56:47] And even though it's hard and painful, it's completely worth it, because obviously it's going to be hard to find someone who's been villainized and beat up is me, right, in 2015, sort of on the Mormon Internet. And I can Tell you, it's been amazing.

John Dehlin [00:57:11] I've loved it. The past 10 years have been excruciating and. And blissfully exhilarating, and I wouldn't trade it. And, you know, to love another, you know, Les Miserables ends by saying, to love another person is to see the face of God. And as much as people might malign or be frustrated with me or suspect my motives, if I were to say, well, my motives have always been it's been to alleviate suffering and to promote joy.

John Dehlin [00:57:44] And I feel like, as humbly as I can say this, I feel like I've done this with Mormon stories and with all the efforts that we've done, and I feel like the work is continuing. And there's nothing better than that. I mean, other than having a healthy, intimate relationship and being a good father. Those things are number one for me now. I neglected those things for too many years trying to save the world. But. But now that Margi and I are very, very healthy and happy, now that my kids are doing very, very well, I feel. And our family is in a very healthy.

John Dehlin [00:58:21] In a safe and a secure and a thriving place, I can say that the very next most awesome thing in the world is to alleviate suffering and bring joy to tens of thousands of people. And I do feel like I've helped do that.

Gina Colvin [00:58:39] And so family, when we talk about where to from here, family is central to that.

John Dehlin [00:58:46] Yeah. Margi and the kids and then my extended family, sort of secondary is the most important thing. Yeah.

Gina Colvin [00:58:55] And in terms of your continued activities, where to from here?

John Dehlin [00:59:01] Yeah. So it's just, you know, I'll keep Mormon stories going as long as people are willing to support it. And there's this new initiative that I'm a part of called Mormon Transitions that I haven't really launched yet, but I'm in the planning stages where my goal is to help provide resources, information services, community support for people who are struggling with the Mormon transition. So this whole Mormon spectrum that was released In August, in 2015, that wasn't me, but that came out of a strategic retreat that I held in February where the amazing Allison Udall and the amazing Steve Holbrook and. And several other amazing people got together, inspired by the conversations at this retreat, got together and decided that they were going to make Mormon spectrum happen.

John Dehlin [01:00:07] And they did. And now we've got over 120 thriving communities that are being supported all over the world where people are going to get support, better support than they ever have for their Mormon transition. Whether they stay in the church or out Mormon Spectrum is this amazing resource that is now bringing community to people who need it.

John Dehlin [01:00:32] I was going to do that if Allison and Steve didn't do Mormon Spectrum, but because they did, I don't have to worry about that as much. And I'm so happy to see them do such an amazing job with that. And for all those who think it's me behind the scenes, that is all Allison and Steve and their own work. But I'm thrilled and I can say that I was there at the beginning where we talked and brainstormed on making that happen. And so I hope Mormon Spectrum thrives because community is a big part of what I think the future needs. We need more face to face community for liberal Mormons, progressive Mormons, questioning Mormons and post Mormons.

John Dehlin [01:01:13] And so community is going to be a huge thing. I'm going to do everything I can to support those communities, to help them thrive. Even as much community turmoil as we've had. Some of my proudest accomplishments are starting the Phoenix Open Mormon Community that now has over almost a thousand members. And it's super thriving. And the one in London and the one in Houston and the one in Boston and the one in, you know, all over the place, New York. We've got over 100 of these communities of progressive and post Mormons thriving. And that's not even to talk about the post Mormon communities and the ex Mormon communities and the meetups.

John Dehlin [01:01:51] So community is going to be the focus going forward, obviously. Mental health services. I'm so proud of Natasha Helfer Parker who started the Mormon Mental Health Association. Again, that was Natasha, but I helped her and we kind of did that together at first at least, and now it's independent and it's her own thing.

John Dehlin [01:02:11] And I'm so thrilled to be a part of helping people like Natasha and Jennifer Finlayson Fife and Kristi Money and, you know, so many other amazing therapists are going to start providing mental health services to Mormons in transition or post Mormons. And I'm thrilled about that. And now that I have my PhD, you know, in psychology, I might provide some coaching or some counseling services as well, although that's going to be limited because I feel like individually my best efforts right now, I think are more on a scale of one to many than on a scale of one to one. So I want to see some clients, but right now I think it's going to be few clients that I see.

John Dehlin [01:02:57] I'm more interested in creating podcast content and books and seminars and conferences for Mormons in transition to help them find community to help them save their marriages, to help them find mental health, to help them get the tools they need to navigate a healthy transition.

John Dehlin [01:03:20] And so that's what Mormon Transitions is all about. It's about creating community, creating content, and providing services to people who need support in their transition. And even now, even though I've been excommunicated, if people feel like they want to stay in the church and make it work, I'm still with stale DS, with a thoughtful faith with Mormon Matters. I am 100% excited and supportive of people staying in the church. And I validate that decision and wholeheartedly defend and stand by that decision. But I also am super excited to create content and materials and resources to help people transition either to a place of progressivism or out of the church, if that's the path that they're going to take.

John Dehlin [01:04:06] And so look for podcasts and books and retreats and workshops and communities all about supporting people in their transitions. And that's what mormontransitions.org is going to be all about.

Gina Colvin [01:04:22] Fabulous. So there must be, I'm hearing lots of pleasure in, in seeing people step up to make this conversation really sustainable across time.

John Dehlin [01:04:35] Yeah. Like, Gina, I'm so thrilled and in awe of your amazing work at A Thoughtful Faith. I thought a thoughtful faith was going to die after Micah and Sarah felt like they couldn't do it anymore. And I love what you're doing. I love what Dan Witherspoon's doing with Mormon Matters.

John Dehlin [01:04:55] I'm just super excited about Facebook and all the amazing groups out there. I'm thrilled with the church's essays. I'm thrilled with the way slowly the church is making changes for women, changes for people of color, changes for LGBT individuals. I think those changes are excruciatingly slow and minimal. But it's great to see the church moving in a positive direction. And, and it's great to see, you know, even though I've been struck down, so to speak, it's exciting to see you step up. Dan Witherspoon, step up.

John Dehlin [01:05:31] You know, Natasha Alford Parker, step up. You know, Alison Udall and the Mormon spectrum step up. I'm excited to see all the ex Mormon and post Mormon communities out there thriving. You know, I'm even excited to see apologists, you know, Fair and Farms and the Maxwell Institute are completely different animals in 2015 than they were even in 2007.

John Dehlin [01:05:58] You know, Daniel Peterson's not there anymore. Greg Smith has been disempowered. Fair has become nicer. Fair has become more diplomatic and more affirming. I'm thrilled to see Terrell Givens and Fiona Givens and Richard Bushman all achieve very high levels of prominence within the church. And you know, when I first interviewed Terrell Givens, Deseret Book wouldn't even publish his books. They wouldn't even make his books available for sale.

John Dehlin [01:06:24] That's what before. I interviewed Terrell Givens, after. Terrell Givens is now publishing books through Deseret Book. And that's tremendous change. I think the essays are amazing and I'm just super excited about all the positive change that the past ten years has wrought. And even though it's been a bumpy ride and a lot of people are upset at me, I think the church is making positive changes. And honestly, I think post Mormons are coming out of the closet. They're gaining respectability, and I think non traditional or post Mormonism or ex Mormonism is gaining attraction and credibility like never before. And I'm, I'm thrilled to be a part of the ex Mormon community, even though I still consider myself Mormon culturally. And so I, I think the future is super bright.

Gina Colvin [01:07:15] I was going to ask that. You sound like you still feel Mormon.

John Dehlin [01:07:19] Yeah, I'm still culturally Mormon. I'm, I'm just like a Jew, a secular Jew. I, you know, I'm, I'm a, I'm a secular Mormon.

Gina Colvin [01:07:28] Right.

John Dehlin [01:07:28] You know, so I still believe in spirituality. I still, I still, I still have faith and hope in some things, but it's just, it's very alternative and sort of New Agey. But yeah, I still feel very Mormon at heart. I don't think they could take that away from me.

Gina Colvin [01:07:45] Final question. Has it been worth it?

John Dehlin [01:07:48] Oh, not only that, aside from the incredible amount of pain and suffering I caused my family at times, and aside from all the people that I've hurt when I've made mistakes, which is tens of thousands of people, the rewards of what I've been a part of have given me a sense of fulfillment and accomplishment and joy.

John Dehlin [01:08:16] You know, it's like it's all the stuff that Christ taught coming true. There's nothing more rewarding than alleviating suffering and promoting joy. And as controversial as I might be, as much as I have so many enemies on so many different sides of the equation, I know that the people who are grateful for what we've done outweigh the detractors by at least a factor of 10 to 1. And the joy that people, the amount of suffering that we've alleviated by advocating for LGBT individuals, feminists, intellectuals, people of color, you know, the amount of suffering we've alleviated and the amount of joy and happiness that we have encouraged by helping the church change, but more importantly, by awakening people to their sort of sleep and empowering them to get the information they need to then take control of their lives and make the decisions that they feel like they need to find joy and happiness and health and well being and liberation and empowerment.

John Dehlin [01:09:25] There is no greater work. So it's almost like all that I was taught as a Mormon in terms of serving your fellow man and loving everybody, it all came true. I just happened to have a really bumpy ride and kind of get excommunicated along the way. But it is true that there is no greater joy on earth than alleviating suffering and promoting joy. And that's how I look on the past 10 years, in spite of all the difficulties. And I could die today.

John Dehlin [01:10:01] I could fall over dead, cancer, bus hit me, somebody shoot me, and I will feel like the luckiest Mormon who ever walked the face of the earth.

Gina Colvin [01:10:12] So you've had your Kumbaya moment.

John Dehlin [01:10:15] Oh, and as long as I'm alive, I'm going to have 10,000 more.

Gina Colvin [01:10:18] John de Lynn, it has been an absolute pleasure. Thank you so much. And I wish you the best.

John Dehlin [01:10:23] Oh, and Gita Colvin, you're a hero of mine and you inspire me and I mean that. And keep, keep carrying the torch. And I'm going to be right there alongside with you for as long as you'll be willing to stand in in the same room as me.

Gina Colvin [01:10:38] Thank you, friend. Thanks for joining us today on a thoughtful faith podcast. To discuss this episode with others, please visit athoughtfulfaith.org and don't forget, if you'd like to support this podcast, please consider a donation. Music for this podcast was generously provided by Chellan Hunt and the Lower Lights. Thanks for listening. Hey Konara.

Gina Colvin [01:11:10] Even though it be a cross that raised me still all my song shall be Nearer, my God to me near, my God, to thee near to thee. Though like the wonder the sun gone down Darkness beyond me My rest a stone yet in my dreams I'd be Nearer, my God, to thee Nearer, my God, to me Nearer to the. Sat Thou sendest me in mercy angels to be Nearer my God to me Nearer my God to the Nearer to the Nearer, my God to the near to the.

Part 1 of 3 · Ep. 561Download MP3Listen on Spotify Part 2 of 3 · Ep. 562Download MP3Listen on Spotify Part 3 of 3 · Ep. 563Download MP3Listen on Spotify

A supporter is worth a thousand followers

Your generous donations ensure we can continue to provide support for those transitioning. Help us keep these essential discussions alive and accessible to all by making a donation today.

similar episodes

8 Responses

  1. I have been listening to you for a few years now and have wanted to make contact with you regarding your mission. I served in the Guatemala City North mission from March 1990 to July 1991. I was there at the end of President Romney’s “service,” and had a horrible start to my mission. I witnessed all the things that you have talked about. As a brand new missionary I was devastated and wondered what church I was representing that would con people – especially children – into getting baptized. The APs would come to our area asking to see our contact list and demanding that we take them to their homes. At one point my companion and I had to literally help a little old lady escape out the back of the chapel so the APs would stop terrorizing her into getting baptized. I also went to President Romney and also was scolded for not having faith. I even quoted scripture to make my point and he just threw it back in my face, telling me that my concern was unwarranted and that all would be sorted out in heaven. Things got A LOT better when President Frischknect came a few months later, but those few months at the beginning of my mission scarred me for life and forever damaged my view of the church. If communication had been what it is now, I definitely would have called my parents and asked them to bring me home, but phones were few and far between. I did write them about it, they called Church Headquarters and were told that Romney was on his way out anyway and that I should basically just be patient. I, too, was sent to an area far from the city. The people of Guatemala, however, made everything worth it! They are the most humble, sincere people I’ve ever known. Happy despite all that they lack. They taught me so much more than I ever could have taught them. I don’t remember how many people I baptized, but I can still see the faces of the children running to greet us and jumping into our arms. Pure joy! Thanks, John, for all that you’ve done over the last ten years to enlighten us, entertain us, and enrich our lives!

  2. Great interview!
    John, mostly I appreciate the work you’ve done. I stumbled across you during the insanity of the Prop 8
    campaign. Thank you for providing an oasis of sorts, an opportunity to grow through hearing about other’s personal experiences.

    Isn’t it ironic–hypocritical–that you are the one who gets ex’ed while leaders like Pres. Romney (and others)
    move forward in the church, seemingly unscathed? Power corrupts.

    All the best to you and your family.

  3. Guatemala Quetzaltenango Nov 1989 to Nov 1991 checking in! Yes kiddy baptisms were the norm. When I refused to do it as a new Senior companion, I was sent to another area “on splits” so leaders could find someone last minute to baptize. Can go a month without all companionships in the zone baptizing! Loved Guatemala, but hated my mission president and much of went on in the mission.

  4. My husband and I are late to the party. The Race and the Priesthood Essay set us on the course of study, discovery, disappointment and anger. I really believe there is a second wave of dissenters just like us. I hope there will continue to be a place for us to hear stories of likeminded folks as we process the facts and try to negotiate a “new normal.” We’ve already seen 3 young couples resign in our ward (taking 8 COR with them) since the beginning of 2015. We are under the radar for now, and have real anxiety about coming out to family and “friends.”

    Mormon Stories and Year of Polygamy have saved our sanity. A big thank you from California! Keep up the good work.

  5. As interesting and enlightening as anything in the entire body of Mormon Stories interviews. Gina drew you out, John, with incisive, thoughtful questions. No one outside your family and friends can say they have any substantial insight into you or Mormon Stories until they’ve listened to this interview. I was reminded of the observation at the end of your recent Sunstone interview with Lindsay Hansen Park where a historian thanked you for the large collection of first-person stories you’ve compiled through Mormon Stories. Add your own story to that collection When you write your life story at some point, come back to this interivew.

    In the face of the beat down the corporate hierarchy has handed you I truly admire your vision of loving and helping and moving forward. Do persist. I know you don’t put much faith in the Book of Mormon but it claims that the folks that gave you the boot (the gentile church) will self destruct under profound condemnation in the last days. If that’s the case they may have done you a favor in throwing you off The Good Ship Zion because, it, not you, is in apostasy and is sinking. Holland to the pump room: “Got any more pumps to bring online?”

    As a thought experiment it would be great to hear you interview L. Whitney Clayton, Gina. Here is a person on the short list to be one of the next apostles, using dominion and compulsion to finesse John (and others) out of President Uchtdorf’s claimed big tent of Mormonism. According to D&C 121 Clayton may come to occupy one of the chief seats but end up lacking the priesthood to give it meaning. I think you could match wits with the guy; I would double-dog dare him to be as forthcoming as John. It was great that you left in Dan Wotherspoon’s contribution to the interview. Suddenly out of the ether, a voice of reminding and clarifying! It reminded me of Radio Lab.

    Please continue your interviewing. In the words of B.H.Roberts, “It [Mormonism] calls for thoughtful disciples who will not be content with merely repeating some of its truths, but will develop its truths; and enlarge it by that development. Not half—not one-hundredth part—not a thousandth part of that which Joseph Smith revealed to the Church has yet been unfolded, either to the Church or to the world. The work of the expounder has scarcely begun.” I see you, John and the ethereal Dan as expounders.

  6. Thoroughly enjoyed this interview and learning so much about your story! I loved the version of song playing at the beginning and end of each episode and would love to find it but am unable to understand the name of the artists. If anyone knows let me know.

    Thanks.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *