In Part 1 of this Mormon Stories interview, John Dehlin sits down with Noah Rasheta, a former Mormon who became a Buddhist teacher and host of the Secular Buddhism podcast, to explore his journey from a deeply Mormon upbringing to a life shaped by Buddhist practice and philosophy.
Noah was raised Mormon in Mexico after his parents converted to the Church when he was young. He descries growing up as one of only a few Mormons at his school, navigating Mormon expectations alongside Mexican culture, Catholic family influences, and his naturally curious personality. He eventually served a mission in Ecuador, where he began confronting some of the most rigid and troubling aspects of Mormon doctrine –including the idea that other religious traditions were fundamentally wrong.
After returning home, Noah attended university, married in the Salt Lake Temple, and began building a life within Mormonism. But questions about Church doctrine, Joseph Smith, his marriage, and the role of faith in his life eventually led him into a deep faith crisis. As his questions grew, Noah discovered Mormon Stories and began searching for answers beyond the framework he had grown up with.
That search eventually led him to Buddhism. Noah explains how Buddhist practice changed the way he approached suffering, relationships, certainty, and everyday life –and why Buddhism initially provided a way for him to remain in a mixed-faith marriage.
Part 2 continues Noah’s story and explores what happens after his marriage ended, how he rebuilt his life, and what he learned from the experience.
Episode Transcript
Full text · 41,200 words · 24 chaptersHost: John Dehlin · Guests: Margi Dehlin, Noah RashetaRead transcriptHide transcript
This transcript is machine-generated and lightly edited for readability. The audio is authoritative. Please excuse occasional errors in names and spelling.
Part 1 of 2 · Ep. 2205
Introducing Noah Rasheta
John Dehlin [00:00:00] Hello, everyone, and welcome to another edition of Mormon Stories podcast. I'm your host, John Dehlin. It's September 17, 2026, and today I am excited to announce the fact that I'm interviewing one of my favorite people on the planet. His name is Noah Rasheta. He is the founder of the Secular Buddhism podcast and he has been on Mormon Stories a few times and we've co led workshops together. But most importantly, he has a really amazing Mormon story. And Margi and I, him a dear friend. Welcome back to Mormon Stories, Noah Rasheta.
Noah Rasheta [00:00:35] Thank you, John. It's great to be back and to see you and Margi again.
John Dehlin [00:00:39] Yeah, likewise. And Margi, thanks for joining us.
Margi Dehlin [00:00:43] Yeah, I'm excited.
John Dehlin [00:00:45] So for those who are longtime viewers and listeners, you will have seen that I have interviewed Noah at least once in the past. Life happens and you know, I think. And also our video and audio quality have improved significantly. So I have no problem with more Noah Rasheta. It's kind of like number go up. More Noah Rasheta. That's how I feel. How do you feel, Morgan?
Margi Dehlin [00:01:12] I agree.
John Dehlin [00:01:12] Yeah, more is. More is better. So anyway, we are planning to have Noah tell his Mormon story for part one of today's episode. And what some of you won't know because most of you are newish viewers, is that after Noah had his Mormon journey, to the extent that it changed or ended or transitioned, he started a podcast called Secular Buddhism, which is probably one of the world's top podcasts on Buddhism. He also wrote a few books on secular Buddhism, and he's even writing a book now. And so he's kind of known worldwide as I would say an expert on Buddhism, but not Buddhism as a theology or as a religion, but as a practice and as a discipline and as a way of life. Now, Noah, what would you add, edit, or take away from my introduction?
Noah Rasheta [00:02:15] I think that's spot on.
John Dehlin [00:02:16] Okay. Yeah.
Noah Rasheta [00:02:17] Thank you.
John Dehlin [00:02:18] Okay. All right, so should we dive in?
Margi Dehlin [00:02:22] Let's go.
Growing Up Mormon in Mexico
John Dehlin [00:02:23] All right. So, Noah, where does your Mormon story begin?
Noah Rasheta [00:02:28] Okay. It begins when I was about three years old. My mom and dad were converts. So my dad came. He had been previously married. That marriage fell apart. And his. He had a friend he was living with at the time in the airport or. No, he had a friend he was living with who needed to go to the airport. And he took his friend to the airport. And while he was there, he saw my mom, who was just getting off of a plane coming up from Mexico with her sister. This was in Dallas shopping for the weekend. He got brave and got out of the car and went and talked to her, and that's how they met. And that became its own unique love story.
John Dehlin [00:03:13] Your dad was from where?
Noah Rasheta [00:03:15] My dad was raised in an orphanage in Michigan, and my mom was from Guadalajarajara in Mexico.
John Dehlin [00:03:23] And was she lds?
Noah Rasheta [00:03:24] No, neither one of them.
John Dehlin [00:03:25] Okay. Neither one of them.
Noah Rasheta [00:03:27] So when it was time to get married, he couldn't get married in the Catholic Church because he had been married before. So they started searching for a church where they could get married, and they settled on a Lutheran church in Dallas, got married, and then Nick and I were born. So I'm an identical twin. He and I were born, and my dad started kind of going through his own little spiritual awakening. Um, you know, he had a rough life with what he grew up with, and he wanted more stability for us.
Noah Rasheta [00:04:03] And one of his good friends had survived a motorcycle accident that almost killed him. That friend discovered Mormonism. So he starts talking to my dad about it. He's like, hey, this. This way of life is really healthy. It's clean. It's going to help you to get cleaned up. And.
Noah Rasheta [00:04:23] And my mom was a little skeptical of it, but also recognized this could be great. And my dad had the missionaries come over, and he started reading and following with everything, and he decided it was for him. He wanted to join. And at the time, my mom did not want to. She was very Catholic, from a very Catholic family and upbringing.
Noah Rasheta [00:04:45] And my dad kind of told her, like, well, this. It would be best for the family if we're on a unified front. So he kind of pushed her into, you know, really, look at this. And they both ended up converting. So I happened when I was about three.
Noah Rasheta [00:05:02] So I grew up within the framework of the LDS worldview with, I would say, with a connection to Catholicism. So I. I was born in Texas, but then grew up in Mexico, went to private Catholic school, middle school, high school. So I kind of always had.
Noah Rasheta [00:05:25] I would say I had the traditional Mormon upbringing, with the exception that this is in Mexico. So it's just slightly different outside of the country than it is in Utah, for example. So I didn't really know much about the pioneers or a lot of the church history stuff was just irrelevant.
Noah Rasheta [00:05:46] And then at school, I would have Catholicism, and I memorized the Lord's Prayer in Latin and would go to Mass every month with my classmates. So I kind of had both of those frameworks to work with. And then when I turned 19, it was time to go on a mission. And at the time, I didn't want to, but my twin brother did. And that kind of put the pressure on me. I went ahead and told my parents that I wasn't going to go, and he was. And the closer that day got, the more I started picturing myself as, maybe I'm going to be the black sheep.
Noah Rasheta [00:06:24] I don't want to be the black sheep. Maybe I do want to go on a mission. And then I decided to go. So I went on a mission. Nick and I left the same day, came home the same day. He served in Bolivia, I served in Ecuador. So that gave me more time out of the US So from Mexico to Ecuador.
John Dehlin [00:06:44] Can I ask a couple questions about your upright?
Noah Rasheta [00:06:46] Yes, of course.
John Dehlin [00:06:47] And this is great. So as you're being raised Mormon in Mexico, you know, there's the primary songs, there's the teachings about Jesus and God and Joseph Smith and the Book of Mormon. There's the way of life, there's friends at church, and then there's youth programs and mutual and dances and all that stuff. How were those experiences for you?
Noah Rasheta [00:07:16] Yeah, so I should say the early part of my upbringing was in Texas, where I was born. But before entering that stage of going to seminary or church dances or any of the more social stuff, we had already moved to Mexico. So my memory of growing up LDS in the US Very young was scouts and camps and things like that. Then we moved to Mexico, and there I think I maybe went to one church dance. The.
Noah Rasheta [00:07:49] The experience from on the social side was. Was very different than what I imagined it would have been had I stayed in Texas. And that's because the. My social life in Mexico was within the framework of family and Catholicism and private school.
Noah Rasheta [00:08:12] And then church felt like something that we go to on Sundays. And. And then we did do seminary and seminary back then was the early morning seminary, and Nick and I were the only ones who could drive and had a car. So we would go around and pick up everyone for our seminary class. So if we missed or if we were late, everyone was late. So we were pretty good and diligent about being there on time. So when it comes to the songs, like, I feel like the formative years where I would have had a lot of the social activity and, yeah, I guess the songs and stuff, it's like, I remember very young in Texas and the typical songs and then Mexico, where you had a lot of those same songs, but a lot of them you didn't.
Noah Rasheta [00:09:02] And I know that because later, after my mission and moving to Utah, I would hear certain primary songs and think, I've never Heard this.
John Dehlin [00:09:10] Yeah. The Spanish hymnic was different.
Noah Rasheta [00:09:11] Yeah.
John Dehlin [00:09:12] And there wasn't a children's hymn book for primary yet. In Spanish. Yeah. Yeah.
Noah Rasheta [00:09:17] Well, that makes sense. Why a lot of it was very new.
John Dehlin [00:09:20] Do you remember the hymn about brushing your teeth?
Noah Rasheta [00:09:22] No, I don't.
John Dehlin [00:09:23] The Spanish hymnal, Mistientes no me lava re unino exclamo. They had a. They. In the Spanish hymn book, they had a hymn about brushing your teeth.
Noah Rasheta [00:09:34] Wow. I do recognize the. That tone you're singing is familiar.
John Dehlin [00:09:41] They also had jolly old St. Nicholas in the Spanish hymnal, which I thought was weird.
Noah Rasheta [00:09:46] Oh, wow. Yeah.
John Dehlin [00:09:48] Mi querido, Santa Claus, Vinay escuchar. Anyway, I always thought that was interesting.
Noah Rasheta [00:09:54] That is interesting.
John Dehlin [00:09:55] You know what they would put in a Spanish hymnbook for kids, but not in an English hymnbook for kids. Okay. So as you're getting into high school, there's this theology. I don't want to say indoctrination, because that's unkind, but there's this theology that you absorb about, like, God. My parents and I were chosen before we came to the earth, and God sent us here to be Saturday's warriors to prepare the world for Jesus, and Jesus died for us. And I am a sinner, but through Jesus, I can have my sins forgiven, and I want to have an eternal family and go to the temple. How much of that theology, plan of happiness, plan of salvation, however you would have thought about it, did you even contemplate or absorb through your senior year of high school, let's say? Or not.
Noah Rasheta [00:10:43] I mean, I remember having all the typical teachings and the narrative that you learn within the church through seminary and going to church. But I don't think it stuck the way that it normally would because simultaneously at school, I had theology and philosophy, all from the Catholic framework. And I remember being able to reconcile the notion of opposing beliefs and room for the potential of multiple things being true. And I was experiencing that at the same time, culturally, because I identified as an American living in Mexico, but also a Mexican living the American experience. So I remember singing at school, singing the national anthem the way that you would and feeling a sense of pride for Mexico's national anthem.
Noah Rasheta [00:11:39] But I would feel the same when I would sing the US national anthem. So I think that same sentiment crossed over into my worldview at the time, and I held space for, yes, this is probably what this is. But then over here, yeah, this might be what it is, too. And it wasn't until I went on my mission that that solidified into one predominant worldview. Which was the LDS one for me.
Childhood, Personality, and Being a Twin
Margi Dehlin [00:12:06] How would you speak about your personality growing up as a boy? So maybe before high school, and also your experience of being a twin?
Noah Rasheta [00:12:17] Yeah. Oh, that's. That's a good. That's a fun one to think about. So I'll start with the twin, because that's a very unique experience to have another you and to be able to see yourself in someone else and to try to delineate what makes me me and what makes us us.
Noah Rasheta [00:12:38] And we were a very cohesive pair all the way till, I think it was our senior year in high school was the first time that I went through wanting to discover who I am. And I remember it started with a thought. And the thought was, we were very social. We had a lot of friends, people like us. And then I remember thinking, but do people like me?
Noah Rasheta [00:13:02] They like us, but is it, do they like him or do they like me, or do they like us? And I started to question, would I have these same friends if it was just me, or would these friends like me if Nick was no longer part of the picture? And I genuinely doubted. I thought, I don't know. I don't know if people would like me. So I wanted to somewhat figure out, who am I?
Noah Rasheta [00:13:29] And that was the first time in our lives that we really separated our friends. Like, I had a very close friend that became my friend. He developed a friendship with someone else that was like his best friend. And I think that lasted most of the senior year intensely, about half where it was like, I don't want to do things as us. I want to do my things with my friends.
Noah Rasheta [00:13:51] And that. I think that was an important formative experience for me. And it wasn't. So that ended when I went on a mission. And then that was the first time that I really was just me. There's no influence of me as a twin. And I remember on my mission in a home, we were talking with a family, and I was cracking jokes. And when I realized everybody here is laughing at something I just said, a part of me wanted to look over my shoulder, like, did I do that? Nick's not here. He didn't influence that. And that's when I started to realize that I'm fun, too, and that I would have friends, people would like me for me. So that's the twin part. And then the remind me what the other.
Margi Dehlin [00:14:38] It was your personality. Like, how would you describe yourself as a boy growing up?
Noah Rasheta [00:14:42] Okay, yeah. So my personality growing up. And for this, I would go back to the we a lot of times I speak in we. Because our personality was very similar, Nick and I, but very curious in nature, very fun. Like, that's something that I think a lot of our friends liked us because we were always doing fun things. Nick and I are super adventurous.
Noah Rasheta [00:15:06] We went to the zoo, and while we were looking at things, Nick and I went and talked to the dolphin trainer and convinced the dolphin trainer to let us swim with the dolphins. And then we'd go tell my parents and they're like, what? How did. What happened? I'm like, yeah, we befriended the dolphin trainer and he said, we can come on Saturday. And sure enough, that's what we did.
Noah Rasheta [00:15:26] Or we got into skydiving at 16. Or we would build these really intricate boxes, like a fort that's made out of boxes that's designed to jump off the roof and you can land in the boxes to absorb your fall. We're always doing super adventurous, crazy stuff.
Noah Rasheta [00:15:46] So people liked hanging out with us. We were fun to be around. And I do feel a lot of that was my personality, but it was also his personality because we're still both that way today. So, yeah, I would say curious by nature might be one of the most defining ways that I would explain my personality.
Margi Dehlin [00:16:09] I love that.
Noah Rasheta [00:16:09] Yeah.
John Dehlin [00:16:11] And along those lines, one more question about Mormonism. In your childhood and youth, was there any relationship, consciously or unconsciously, with. With a heavenly Father, with a loving God, prayer, a sense of worthiness, or a sense of like, hey, I need help with this or that, or I'm, I want to change this or that, or, you know, help guide me? Was there any form of that that you recall?
Noah Rasheta [00:16:39] Yeah, yeah, I would say there definitely was a very expected amount of that sense of, I know who I am, I know why I'm here, I pray regularly. I feel I'm being guided on my overall path and journey in life. At times, I would attribute the success of being able to start this or go do this other fun thing, because I prayed about it and it felt right, so I'm going to do it. I was very aware of what is typically taught as you have a loving relationship with a heavenly father who cares about you and is steering, you know, the direction of your life.
John Dehlin [00:17:26] So you were an I am a child of God or soy nihid idios Mormon. You know, he has sent me here. He leads me, guides me, he walks beside me, helps me find the way.
Noah Rasheta [00:17:36] Yeah, definitely.
John Dehlin [00:17:37] Okay, definitely.
Faith Fit in Teen Years Before the Mission
Margi Dehlin [00:17:38] I also have a follow up. Just in your teen years, especially before mission, how would you describe the overall fit of Mormonism? For you meaning like the lived part, the beliefs part, where. How easeful was it, as opposed to, like, this is hard work and it feeling like just a lot of effort to kind of do the things that are being asked of you. How would you describe that fit?
Noah Rasheta [00:18:10] Hmm. I don't recall it feeling like a difficult thing. I do recall. So in terms of the practice, how you practice being Mormon, because, for example, on Sundays we would go to the park like everyone else goes to the park. We would go buy a snow cone. And I never have had any thoughts of, I shouldn't be buying this. The one realm that I do remember was difficult for me was around the word of wisdom.
Noah Rasheta [00:18:44] Coffee, for example, is very common in the whole world. And in Mexico, the notion of not drinking coffee, it was extremely foreign. And there was a. A popular artist who had a song at the time that was popular. And in his song, he talks about, you know, Jesus is a verb, not a noun. And then at another part of the. Of the lyrics, he would say, and then there are these, like, strange beliefs, like Mormons who won't drink coffee because they think it's a sin, something like that in the lyrics. And I remember when that song was popular and friends would come up because, you know, I'm in a high school where there are two LDS kids, and it's my brother and I, and they would say, hey, and this song, Ricardo Arcona song, he mentions, you know, coffee.
Noah Rasheta [00:19:35] Mormons think coffee's a sin. Is that true? And I remember I never had a good explanation other than like, yeah, I guess it is. And they would immediately say, well, why? It's like, I don't know, because I knew. I knew at the time I couldn't say caffeine because other caffeine was okay, and I couldn't say hot drinks because hot chocolate was okay. So I just didn't have a way to answer it other than I kind of don't know. But I used to dread when that song was really popular. I dreaded the conversation. So that's one of the most huge
John Dehlin [00:20:08] on my mission in 88, 89. Jesus Verbo.
Noah Rasheta [00:20:13] You know the song.
John Dehlin [00:20:14] Oh, yeah. It was huge in Guatemala. And I didn't have good answers for that either.
Noah Rasheta [00:20:18] I know.
John Dehlin [00:20:19] Yeah.
Noah Rasheta [00:20:20] People would be playing the song. Someone's gonna ask me.
John Dehlin [00:20:24] Yeah, no substantive evil, huh? Yeah. Yeah. Fun. Okay. Yeah.
Noah Rasheta [00:20:30] I love that song.
John Dehlin [00:20:31] Oh, yeah, for sure. That was big. That was big on my mission. Okay. So, yeah, I was gonna make the comment that Mark Twain is famous for saying one thing, you know, that Travel is fatal to prejudice. And it's almost like your Catholic, Mormon, Mexican upbringing gave you an expanded worldview that was probably going to anesthetize you to some forms of Mormon ultra orthodoxy, you know?
Noah Rasheta [00:21:02] Yeah, I would agree with that. And then.
John Dehlin [00:21:05] Or inoculate. I should say inoculate, not anesthetize. Yeah.
Noah Rasheta [00:21:09] In my experience, it. That worldview was more open and more curious. And then I went on a mission.
John Dehlin [00:21:16] Yeah.
Noah Rasheta [00:21:17] And then that kind of tightened the window and closed it. And I do remember going through a phase of guilt, like, oh, I was not living right. And I started to close my worldview more. And on my mission, unfortunately, there were times I felt shame around my parents, for example, or I really looked up to my mission president. I still do. He was a really neat person, and we had a really special bond. He and I got along really well on my mission. I ended up being an assistant to him. And I remember thinking, when I'm done and I go home, I don't know if I want him to meet my family. Because I was ashamed that if he meets my family, he'll see that they're kind of more gray. Yeah. And by then I had adopted the. Your, you know, your. Your hot or cold, Right? No, lukewarm.
Margi Dehlin [00:22:15] You moved to more of the binary.
Noah Rasheta [00:22:16] I did, I did, yeah. Yeah.
John Dehlin [00:22:20] I made you a little bit ashamed of your parents.
Noah Rasheta [00:22:22] It did, yeah. Yep.
Serving a Mission in South America
John Dehlin [00:22:25] And what country again? You said in South America, right?
Noah Rasheta [00:22:27] In Ecuador. Ecuador, Guayaquil.
John Dehlin [00:22:30] And overall, how did you enjoy your mission?
Noah Rasheta [00:22:34] So I really enjoyed my mission experience. When I arrived, I saw the map in the mission office that had all the areas, and I knew that they were going to be opening the Galapagos at some point. And I remember feeling a very clear like, I'm going there. And when they opened that, I did. I was one of the two missionaries that got to go out there.
John Dehlin [00:23:00] That's what Charles Darwin did his stuff, right?
Noah Rasheta [00:23:02] Yes. The Charles Darwin Research Station is there on the island where we lived.
John Dehlin [00:23:07] Was your mission one of those Latin American missions that had hundreds of baptisms a month in the mission, it was
Noah Rasheta [00:23:14] right before the mission president, who was there while I was there, kind of stopped it. And I heard all these horror stories of, you know, filling the back of a truck with water. We're going to go play basketball. Any kid who wants to come join us here, get baptized first. You know, I heard of all those stories that had happened prior to the tenure of my mission president. And he cleaned all that up. And he really reinforced this idea of, we're Looking for the people who are genuinely looking for this, and it's not just a numbers game.
Noah Rasheta [00:23:50] And that worked well for me because that's how I approached it. When I was getting ready to leave, my aunt, my very Catholic aunt, said, good luck on your mission, but please remember, don't try to convert everyone. Only convert the people who are looking for this in their life. And that stuck with me because it made me realize, like, I don't want to go out there and approach this. Like, hey, everybody needs this. I believed that everybody needed it, but I didn't want to approach it with that mindset of, I'm going to force this on everyone I knew. Just like my dad had that happen in his life where there was a time in his life that this was a way of living that was going to be much more healthy and skillful for him. I wanted to find people like that, and that did influence a lot of how I approached my tactics on the mission.
Margi Dehlin [00:24:42] That's so valuable.
Noah Rasheta [00:24:43] Yeah.
Margi Dehlin [00:24:44] Yeah. I was curious if you had any type of resistance, like, what your experience was, moving into sort of a high control area, like a mission can be. Did you experience your mission as having a lot of control around when you went to bed, what activities you could do, especially kind of given your Mormon background up until that point. Do you remember that being a shock? Or how did you respond to, and did you even experience a high control mission? And if so, like, how did you work that through?
Noah Rasheta [00:25:23] Yeah, I don't recall having thoughts around this is controlling. I remember appreciating the discipline and the routine and knowing that I wake up at this time and we read scriptures from this time to this time. Like, I appreciated all that. And I never saw that as high control or it didn't conflict with me in any way. The one thing that did conflict with me was on my mission was the first time I encountered, through other missionaries, the idea that every other worldview is evil. And it was particularly around Catholicism. So this was.
Noah Rasheta [00:26:04] It was there during the turn of the century, or was it the century? Yeah, 2000. So I was there for the whole Y2K scare and all of that. But around that time was the Jubilee that was being celebrated in Catholicism with Pope John Paul ii. And he had a.
Noah Rasheta [00:26:25] So I was celebrating all this in school, right in high school, right before my mission, and he had a. A CD that came out with him singing the Lord's Prayer in Latin. And I loved it. It was one of the songs I listened to on my mission. And so I had, like, most Catholic People did at the time an affection for John Paul ii. He was like the, I don't know, the Gordon B. Hinckley of the Popes, you know, and on my mission, then suddenly other missionaries would talk about the Catholic Church is the whore of all the earth, and he's essentially, you know, being led by Satan.
Noah Rasheta [00:27:05] And it really offended me because I thought, no, no, no, this is like my, the sweetest woman in the world. My grandma loves this guy. I've listened to countless of his teachings and sermons. He's a good guy. He's a sweet, kind person.
Noah Rasheta [00:27:20] And I did not like that narrative that I was encountering among other missionaries that, hey, we're out here doing this super righteous work and we're, you know, really sticking it to the devil and his servant John Paul II and, and the church which is the whore of all the earth. And I would get very defensive of the Catholic Church to other missionaries and, and I would always explain, look, this person may be misled and maybe doesn't realize that, but this is not an evil person that's intentionally spreading evil.
Noah Rasheta [00:27:54] And it would surprise me that other missionaries just didn't view it that way. They're like, no, every other system out here is evil. It's intended to lead people astray from the righteous path, which is ours. So that was, that was an area of conflict for me to genuinely believe, yes, I am on the right path, but the other path is not evil.
Margi Dehlin [00:28:16] Right.
John Dehlin [00:28:17] How did you, were you made aware? I mean, I'm pretty sure the Book of Mormon. It's been a while since I've read it, but I'm pretty sure the Book of Mormon says there's only two churches. The Church of the Lamb of God or whatever and the Church of the Devil. And then of course, the Book of Mormon, Joseph Smith incorporated a lot of the anti Catholic rhetoric of the early 1800s, such that any reasonable reading of the Book of Mormon, it calls the Catholic Church the great and abominable whore of all the earth. Kind of, you know, that's the rhetoric in the Book of Mormon that Joseph Smith wrote into it.
John Dehlin [00:28:51] And then there was Bruce R. McConkie's book Mormon Doctrine, where he literally said that the Catholic Church was the Church of the devil. Did you absorbed the first around the Book of Mormon and did you ever hear anyone talk about the second? And then did you have to reconcile that with your more compassionate feelings towards the Catholic Church?
Noah Rasheta [00:29:17] Yes, I did. I encountered Mormon doctrine on my mission. It was one of the books that would float around and it felt like, oh, if you spend time and read that, it just equips you with all the tools you need to be the most gung ho best missionary you can be. And I do remember encountering that thought and feeling like, okay, maybe that's true. I mean, it must be if that's what it says in here.
Noah Rasheta [00:29:43] But I was very opposed to, like, but we don't say that, especially to a Catholic person, because that's not going to help. So I do remember believing that. I guess it is, because that's what I'm being told. But I knew, like, well, I would never tell my aunt or my grandma or someone like that. I'm not going to tell them that. I would try to steer them toward the truth without insulting them.
Noah Rasheta [00:30:10] And that's what bothered me. The missionaries wanted to just come and be like, hey, guess what? You belong to the great and abominable. And I thought, no, that's just never going to work.
John Dehlin [00:30:21] There's that quote. Not all things that are true are useful. Full.
Noah Rasheta [00:30:24] Yeah, that's right.
John Dehlin [00:30:27] Well, that's. That's smart. Okay.
Margi Dehlin [00:30:29] I was going to ask you really quickly. How did you experience being separated from your brother during. Yeah, like, did you write letters? How was that for you?
Noah Rasheta [00:30:39] Yeah, so I mentioned right before going on a mission, we had kind of separated a little and we were trying to figure ourselves out when it was time to go on a mission. We had kind of come back together and we were super close and great friends. Then being on the mission, I think strengthened that because we were writing all the time.
Noah Rasheta [00:31:02] It brought a lot of comfort to me to know that he was out there experiencing a lot of the same things that I was. And in fact, we had a remarkable amount of similarities on our mission. We would usually find out within a letter or two that we were going through all the same experiences. Like, oh, I just became a district leader. Oh, so did I. Or zone leader, or even in the office as assistants to the president. Like, we mirrored each other in so many ways. I was the one who went out to the most remote part of our mission. Well, he did too, on his.
Noah Rasheta [00:31:37] To the. There's the one area that's in the jungle that you might go to. He went there. So we had a lot of very similar experiences and some fun twin moments before either of us knew that we were both in the office. I went to the airport to pick up a batch of missionaries that were flying in. And as they were walking towards us, I noticed they were all whispering to each other. And as they got even closer they said, elder Rasheta. And I was like, yeah. They're like, how did you get here?
Noah Rasheta [00:32:08] This is where I'm serving. And they're like, but no, you just took us to the airport. I was like, oh, where did you come from? Bolivia? They're like, yes. And they're like, how did you do that? And I was like, well, let me tell you, that was my twin. And then we're driving to the mission office, and they're like, you guys even drive the same.
Noah Rasheta [00:32:26] So we had a lot of those types of fun twin experiences that I think brought us closer in our friendship because we were having shared experiences.
Margi Dehlin [00:32:36] Yeah. Yeah.
Post-Mission Life and Getting Married
John Dehlin [00:32:38] All right. So that sounds like an amazing mission. So you finish your mission early, 2000s?
Noah Rasheta [00:32:44] Yeah, I came home. 2001. January of 2001.
John Dehlin [00:32:48] Okay.
Noah Rasheta [00:32:48] Yeah.
John Dehlin [00:32:49] And. Yeah. Did you go back to Mexico or something else?
Noah Rasheta [00:32:53] I went back to Mexico, spent a few months there, and realized both of us wanted to go to college in the US and at the time, we now knew friends and mission companions who lived in Utah and decided we wanted to come to Utah to go to school.
John Dehlin [00:33:13] So you came to where?
Noah Rasheta [00:33:15] So our. The original plan was to try to get into byu. We had a bit of a unique situation in the sense that we are American citizens who don't. We didn't have a high school diploma or ged. We have a Mexican high school diploma. So we were in this weird gray area where to use our school credentials and to meet the qualifications of an international student, you had to have a visa. You can't get a visa if you're an American citizen.
Noah Rasheta [00:33:45] So to get in as an American, you had to have your high school qualifications, which we didn't have because they were international. So BYU finally was like, you're kind of an odd case. Just go to another school, get a certain amount of hours, then transfer in. So that was our plan. And we went to UVSC at the time, which is now uvu, but then never left. Stayed there and really enjoyed that experience as well.
John Dehlin [00:34:10] Okay. And I'm assuming you started dating.
Noah Rasheta [00:34:14] Yes.
Margi Dehlin [00:34:15] There.
Noah Rasheta [00:34:15] Yeah. So in. In school, the first is the first day of living in Utah. The family we were living with, their youngest did ballroom, and she had a recital. That night we went to the recital, and I remember another couple dancing, an older couple, and watching them and thinking, whoa, what is this? And how do I meet someone like her? And suddenly I was very interested in ballroom. So I started taking ballroom lessons and classes. And then my entire college experience was influenced by that because I ended up getting on the Ballroom team and traveling competitively all throughout college, was on a scholarship. And all of my closest friends in my whole college experience are all my ballroom friends from those ballroom years.
John Dehlin [00:35:10] I remember BYU competed internationally and often won. So, I mean, I'm guessing UVU had a similar track record.
Noah Rasheta [00:35:18] Yeah, UVSC at the time was the other predominant force for ballroom.
John Dehlin [00:35:25] So when you see Dancing with the Stars or, you know, whatever.
Noah Rasheta [00:35:30] Yeah.
John Dehlin [00:35:30] Mormons be dancing.
Noah Rasheta [00:35:31] That's right. You know, a lot of the original dancers in the first season, those are friends of mine, choreographers that I had worked with or dance partners that I
John Dehlin [00:35:42] had, like, names people would recognize.
Noah Rasheta [00:35:43] Yeah, yeah, definitely.
John Dehlin [00:35:45] Who you want to share.
Noah Rasheta [00:35:47] Louis was one of the choreographers that would come do all of our team stuff. Ashley Del Grosso was her younger sister, was a dance partner on our team. I had several routines with her. Yeah, Several of those early dancers were people that I knew.
Margi Dehlin [00:36:09] I think it's so interesting to look at our stories and, like, moments like that that seem kind of serendipitous. The idea that, you know, first night you're here or really soon, and you end up going to a ballroom, and then that leads to a whole area of your life is born from that. That's just so fascinating. And a community, it sounds like.
Noah Rasheta [00:36:33] Yeah, yeah. My entire college experience was shaped by that one recital that I went to. And prior to that, I mean, I was the type of person that at a. At a social gathering or at a wedding or a party, you're not going to see me on the dance floor. I was too embarrassed. Like, you know, maybe at the end of the night for the last dance, I'll go out there for a little bit. But I, like most of my high school friends, later, when they found out, wait, you're doing ballroom and traveling? Like, what happened to you?
Noah Rasheta [00:37:03] It was a. It was a very formative experience, and I really enjoyed it. And it was through those social circles when I was leaving, so my last year of college, that through mutual friends, I met my wife, and she was just starting on the ballroom team. So, yeah, I mean, that was. That's how my whole marriage started. And so, yeah, it shaped a lot of my life.
Margi Dehlin [00:37:32] Wow. Yeah. I'm curious, too, like, how you experienced the church in America, like, the. How it felt. You coming back? Well, no. You arriving at UVU and experience, like, what. How did you experience it?
Noah Rasheta [00:37:50] Yeah, church culture. When I first moved to Utah and we were living with a family, their daughter is the one that did ballroom. That's a family that I had known for since my early childhood. So they felt like. They feel like family. In fact, one of the daughters of that family is who my twin brother is married to. So they our family now.
Margi Dehlin [00:38:11] Oh, yeah.
John Dehlin [00:38:12] Anissa.
Noah Rasheta [00:38:13] Yes. Anessa. A really fun family.
John Dehlin [00:38:17] Of Hendrix. No. What was the last name?
Noah Rasheta [00:38:20] Yes. Hendricks.
John Dehlin [00:38:21] Yeah. Yeah.
Noah Rasheta [00:38:22] And it was two blended families, so Hendricks and Thurmans, and then we sometimes refer to them as the Thermix clan. Just a really, really fun group of. Of people.
John Dehlin [00:38:33] And I'm realizing we. We interviewed Megan, Jake, Abhow. That was their name at the time. Earlier on Mormon stories.
Noah Rasheta [00:38:41] That's right. Y. Yeah. So then I started going to a singles ward. It was a BYU singles ward. And I remember encountering, again, some of that really orthodox doctrine that felt it started. It affected me even back then, even coming home from a mission where I felt like I'm about as orthodox as orthodox can be, and yet I would still encounter other frameworks or ideas that felt like, ooh, I don't know about that. Particularly around marriage or dating or things that you should or shouldn't do. And it was like, you don't need to be happy with who you marry as long as you share in common the faith. I remember the counselor in that ward was like, you guys should not be dating outside of this ward. Everyone here has someone here that's compatible enough, and you should all be getting married. Ideas like that. That I was like, I don't know about that.
Margi Dehlin [00:39:37] Yeah. That's so interesting, because I do feel like when we talk about sort of this identity that's created in the church, you have, like, a self. You have a self that differentiates in moments of being like, I'm not sure about that, as opposed to being fully merged. Do you know what I'm saying? Yeah. Even then.
Noah Rasheta [00:39:59] Yeah. And then I feel like some of the orthodox approach that I had adopted on the mission started to slowly revert back to a more nuanced approach because of my upbringing in Mexico. And, you know, Mexico, of all places is one of those places where, as far as the rigid rules of how things work, you. You do live in a gray world, you know, like, if you get pulled over by a police officer, it's easier to transact in the moment and bribe them than it is to take a ticket and all of the bureaucracy of going to handle a ticket. So things like that, that started to seep back in, where it's like, yes, there's the spirit of the law and there's the letter of the law, and it's really skillful. To understand both of those.
John Dehlin [00:40:52] Yeah. So you fell in love.
Noah Rasheta [00:40:55] I did, yeah. So I started dating, got married, did all of the, you know, the traditional path that you do. Married in the temple.
John Dehlin [00:41:06] Which temple?
Noah Rasheta [00:41:07] It was the Salt Lake Temple. Yeah.
John Dehlin [00:41:12] Nice.
Noah Rasheta [00:41:13] Yeah. I remember that day was stressful because I. I had secured the marriage license, but I didn't know I needed to take it with me. And I had family from out of town and from Mexico. Everyone was here for the day of. And we're standing in line to get checked in at the temple, and I heard the person at the front desk asking the couple in front of us, do you have your license? I remember thinking, I wonder why I need my driver's license for this. And then it occurred to me, oh, the marriage license. So that was a very stressful event. I had to get my older brother to get it and bring it, and it delayed our.
Noah Rasheta [00:41:48] We missed out on the room that we had assigned to us, and it ended up forcing us into a unique little room that isn't used. Like, they. They were able to squeeze us in, which later felt like, okay, that's kind of neat that it worked out that way. But it was a very stressful moment.
Noah Rasheta [00:42:05] And, yeah, went through the whole experience of getting married in the temple and. And having people from my side of the family that are not LDs, plenty of non LDs there. I remember that was difficult for me because I felt like you don't get to participate in this full experience, but you do get to participate in the celebration after.
Marriage, Temple, and Shared Mormon Faith
John Dehlin [00:42:29] So we kind of explain to never Mormons why some of your family members weren't able to attend your marriage.
Noah Rasheta [00:42:37] Yeah. So I had close family from Mexico coming to the wedding and not realizing until they got there. And we're talking that you don't actually get to be at the wedding if they're like, well, wait a second, why? And it's like, well, because you're not lds.
Noah Rasheta [00:42:54] And even if you were, like, you'd have to be. You'd have to, like, meet the requirements to enter the temple and have a temple recommend. And that. I remember that was foreign for them. They're like, well, but why wouldn't we be able to watch you get married?
Noah Rasheta [00:43:08] And I felt bad. It's like, I'm so sorry that, yes, I want you to be here, but you don't actually get to be here for the important part, but you get to celebrate with us after. That always sat wrong with me. Like, I always wished there was a way that close family members could be there for that particular part of the union of two people, you know?
John Dehlin [00:43:30] Yeah.
Noah Rasheta [00:43:32] So, yeah, that was still overall a great experience, I think. And then. And then had 20 years of marriage with its typical ups and downs, and then there were some pivotal moments in there as well. But then ultimately, before you get there,
John Dehlin [00:43:53] can I ask one question?
Noah Rasheta [00:43:54] Yes, of course.
John Dehlin [00:43:55] So when you got married, what plan or milestones were kind of what you agreed to kind of follow and pursue as a faithful Mormon couple?
Margi Dehlin [00:44:10] Just like, what was your map?
John Dehlin [00:44:12] What was the map?
Noah Rasheta [00:44:15] Yeah, that's a good question. I feel like it maybe wasn't discussed the way that it should be. Where it's like, well, what is your exact view on this or that? I think one thing that happens a lot in a shared faith is just the assumption that we're on the same page. And that was the case for us. So the marriage starts out, and then you start to iron out the little differences in how you approach the faith, but also the cultural differences in family dynamics, which can be quite different. You know, her family ecosystem and the way they operate is very different than my family and our ecosystem and how we operate.
Noah Rasheta [00:44:53] And then you rely on the shared part, which for us at the time was the faith. And it's like, well, I think we're going to follow this the way that we're supposed to. And then, sure, you encounter little things where it's like, but how do you interpret this particular thing versus how I do? And I don't feel that we had any friction.
Noah Rasheta [00:45:14] I feel like, for the most part, it was just working smooth. But maybe there were some parts of it that, unbeknownst to us at the time, weren't as skillful as they could have been. And I would say from, you know, looking back now, one of those, for me, would have been the overall belief that Heavenly Father is guiding my inspiration more so than hers. And at the time, you're taught, you know, in the temple that I look up to what Heavenly Father tells me, you look at me for what? Heavenly Father is guiding us.
John Dehlin [00:45:51] The husband covenants with God in the Mormon Temple, and the wife covenants to hearken to the husband.
Noah Rasheta [00:45:59] That's right.
Margi Dehlin [00:46:00] Not a direct line.
John Dehlin [00:46:01] As he hearkens to God, the wife hearkens to the husband.
Noah Rasheta [00:46:05] Yep.
John Dehlin [00:46:05] Yeah.
Noah Rasheta [00:46:06] And it's a patriarchal message. Yeah, it is. And unfortunately, that meant if we're discussing, like, where should we live, do we want to live in Utah, do we want to go to Arizona, closer to where my family might be, or career choices, we would discuss them. And if her opinion was different, than mine. Like, well, I want to live in Utah. For me, it was very easy to be like, well, too bad, because I feel like we shouldn't.
Noah Rasheta [00:46:34] And I feel like, as the head of the household, that, you know, that inspiration is more valuable or more authoritative than whatever you're feeling. And I mean, I hate to even admit that that was how I felt at the time, but it is.
Noah Rasheta [00:46:55] And, you know, those were unbeknownst to us, little moments of, well, that feels really crappy for the wife who's like, well, I really want this, but you won't even entertain it or give me the time of day to try to discuss it. And I didn't need to because I have been. I have felt that this other thing is what we should be doing.
Margi Dehlin [00:47:13] Yeah, that's really reflective, I feel like, of you. I'm curious if you'd be willing to go back just for a second and. And I'm. Because I would love to hear what you were looking for and, like, what was important to you in selecting a wife? Like, when you were thinking about partnership and what stood out to you? This is what I'm looking for.
Noah Rasheta [00:47:39] Yeah. Oh, that's a good question. I feel like, you know, I had been dating and there were people that. That I knew, friends that I liked. You know, you kind of. You're kind of getting a feel for what you want. And, and, and I didn't know it at the time, that the role that friendship would play in a relationship. You know, looking back, I would tell myself, you need to be. You need to have a solid friendship first, and then a relationship that's going to be healthy is a friendship on steroids.
Noah Rasheta [00:48:15] But I felt like friendship will happen. I've always been able to be friends with people, so the priority for me wasn't spend time and develop friendship. For me, the priority was, do they match? Are they LDs, and do they check all the boxes?
Noah Rasheta [00:48:35] So that was the primary one. And then, of course, attraction. So it felt like, well, if I'm attracted to this person, they're attracted to me. We're getting along. This is fun. We're both on the same overall wavelength of our belief system. Then there's no reason this isn't going to work.
John Dehlin [00:48:52] Really quickly, was there anything notable about the temple ceremony or your temple experiences that are worth mentioning, or were they not necessarily noteworthy for you at the time?
Noah Rasheta [00:49:04] So I do remember it was very odd. I didn't know what to expect. And I just remember thinking, wait, what are we doing? Why is this all so foreign to me? There's no hint of this in anything I've ever known or learned. So I do remember having that experience when I went through the temple, you know, to go on a mission.
Noah Rasheta [00:49:31] And then that was. It was just kind of like, okay, well, that was strange. But I'll just put that in the box of things I don't fully understand why we do them, and yet we do them. And then later, going through the temple for marriage, the. I don't really recall anything standing out other than feeling empowered in a way at the idea that, whoa, I am now the head of a household. Like, I have this tremendous responsibility that I need to live my life in a way that's always worthy because Heavenly Father is going to be steering me and through me, this family. I do remember feeling that sense of, my wife doesn't have to worry so much about this, like, but I do. I'm going to steer us in the right direction.
Margi Dehlin [00:50:20] Yeah.
John Dehlin [00:50:20] Yeah. Okay. So you're married. You decide to move to Arizona and to settle. Kind of settle in Arizona at first.
Faith Crisis and Struggles in Marriage
Noah Rasheta [00:50:30] Yes.
John Dehlin [00:50:32] I do want to explore because one of the things that's been remarkable for me about you is how long you lived in a mixed faith marriage. Because I've known you. When did you first. When did you and I first talked as you became aware of Mormon's stories? Because I remember I was a student at Utah State University. I was walking around the track and for some reason, you and I had a phone call.
Noah Rasheta [00:50:55] Yeah, I remember that call. That would have been 2011 or 12.
John Dehlin [00:51:02] Okay. So there would have been maybe a year or two or three that would have preceded that. So without needing necessarily to get into what. Well, what caused your faith crisis. I think what I remember is something happened, and we don't have to even go there, but something happened to make you question or wonder about whether the church leaders were deceiving you. Right, yeah. Do you want to talk about just picking up at that point of your story.
Noah Rasheta [00:51:30] Yeah.
John Dehlin [00:51:31] Or anything else.
Noah Rasheta [00:51:31] In fact, I'll go back a little just for context. So this is four years into my marriage where one of the dilemmas that we had was, where do we go? What are we going to do? I had selected at the time the career that I wanted to follow was flying helicopters. And I attended a flight school in Utah.
Noah Rasheta [00:51:54] And the flight school went bankrupt, like overnight. It was a national news thing. It was like a scandalous. Turns out they were running a Ponzi scheme type scenario. And all of the students at all of the locations nationwide, they robbed us of our money. Like we had prepaid for the whole flight training program.
Noah Rasheta [00:52:16] That was a really massive blow because my childhood dream was to fly helicopters. That was the time when I kind of realized, okay, this is a big thing. This is our first big hiccup that you encounter as a couple. Like, how do we navigate this?
Noah Rasheta [00:52:32] And again, what matters most, what I'm feeling, right? Everything that I feel Heavenly Father is telling me to do. I felt like we need to continue to pursue this path. And I'm gonna go to another flight school in Arizona and try to figure out how to keep this career going or this career choice and hoping that meanwhile, class action lawsuit, something's gonna help me with the dilemma that I'm in with this flight school.
Noah Rasheta [00:53:02] So we moved to Arizona. I do remember at that time also having the thought, in this family dynamic, I feel like I am a cog in a wheel. And the dynamic of this family, I'm just an addition to this ecosystem. And I didn't like that feeling. I thought, I want us to have our own traditions and build our own family dynamic and not feel like I just got inserted into this other larger family dynamic.
Noah Rasheta [00:53:34] So I thought moving away will do that. That's how we will develop our core identity as a family. So we moved to Utah. I don't remember. Or to Arizona. I don't remember if we talked in detail about that particular concern of mine. Actually, I do, I do remember mentioning that. And I remember her thinking, her saying, that's not what's going to happen. We are our own unique thing. And I was like, yeah, but I don't think that we actually are. Like, if you look at some of the other dynamics in the family, it feels like especially those of us who were the outsider marrying into this community, like we're the outsider and we just fit into your overall family dynamic.
John Dehlin [00:54:15] And if I can just tell you what, what I've experienced in Utah, and this may not be just a Mormon thing, I'm sure it's not. But like there are families in Utah where like everyone grows up in an area, all the kids go to high school in that area and then the kids all go off do their missions, get married, and then buy houses back in that same area and then raise their kids in that area. And all the cousins play together because they're all kind of neighbors and they all go over to the parents or the grandparents house on Sunday. And it's a very, I guess a more complicated way to describe it is an enmeshed family or an enlightened way would be to say it's a very connected and close family, but it's a very involved, interconnected experience where an individual, family unit and in laws could sometimes feel very absorbed or alienated or like you said, a cognitive machine.
John Dehlin [00:55:13] I don't know if I described your in laws, but I mean, I see that a lot in Utah. Is that in the universe of what you experienced?
Noah Rasheta [00:55:20] Yeah, that feels extremely accurate to what I was experiencing.
John Dehlin [00:55:24] Yeah.
Noah Rasheta [00:55:25] And I. So part of the desire to live in Arizona was to pursue my flying, but also to establish ourselves as a unique identity. So we moved there and everything seems to be working. And then I realized this helicopter stuff is more expensive than I would have anticipated. I don't have enough to, to pay for the program again, twice.
Noah Rasheta [00:55:52] It's looking like the way that the owner of this other flight school, he was very premeditated. I'm not going to recover anything. So my dream suddenly felt like I'm not going to obtain this dream. And at the time I didn't express that well or process it well with her, I wish I would have been more clear of, hey, I'm going through heartbreak because my dream is now on its final threads. And this is like devastating to me. But I was just hell bent on, I'll find another way. Maybe I'll join the Mesa Police Department. They have a helicopter unit. Maybe with luck I'll work my way into that.
Noah Rasheta [00:56:35] And I'm just like unilaterally making our decisions of what we're going to do. And at the time she's experiencing more and more discontent that I will not entertain the thought of moving to Utah. And she. So she was, she was unhappy.
Noah Rasheta [00:56:52] I was unhappy, but not in the marriage. I was unhappy with the way my career was going. I had no clue how unhappy she was. And in that ecosystem there's a violation of trust in the marriage. And that was devastating for me because I didn't know that things were bad. When I started to sense that she wasn't happy, I started to course correct, like, well, what is it going to take? Do we need. Is it about Utah? I thought it was all centered around we don't live in Utah. And that's the problem. And I immediately said, okay, then let's go up there this weekend, I will look for jobs and we will move there.
Noah Rasheta [00:57:37] And that's what we did. And so we come to Utah that weekend, we're staying with her family and everything is working out. I do an interview and I get offered the job. All this happens within like three days. So again, I'M feeling like Heavenly Father is steering the ship. Like, this can't be a coincidence, right?
Noah Rasheta [00:58:00] And when I expressed the news that we're going to be moving to Utah, and I'm thinking, this is going to solve everything now. She'll be happy. She, she. I could sense she was like, well, maybe you can come up here and start working. I'll just wrap things up down there and then eventually work my way up. And I was like, wait a second. Like, I thought, you've been chomping at the bit to get here.
Noah Rasheta [00:58:22] So that was the moment that I sensed, something's off, something doesn't feel right. And unfortunately, through that exploration while we were in Utah came the discovery that things were not right. Something was going on. And that was devastating for me because that's. In the midst of. My dream of flying has collapsed. I didn't navigate that super well with her. I didn't share the depth of the pain I was in at the time. Then comes this, and then I feel totally blindsided and rejected. But also comes the insecurity at that point of, I guess I can't judge because I would have bet all my money, I would have bet my loved ones lives on if someone said, something's wrong in your marriage.
Noah Rasheta [00:59:12] Like, if someone from the outside could have said, here's some red flags. This is what's probably happening, I would have said, no, that's definitely not what's happening. This person would never do that. That's how certain I was of my reality.
Noah Rasheta [00:59:25] So to have that, that moment of the rug pulled out from under your feet was. Was devastating for me. And so. And I said, okay, well, we need to leave now. And we moved to Utah. It was like in a. In the span of a weekend. I rented a truck, we packed all of our things and we move and everyone in our.
John Dehlin [00:59:47] And were there kids at this point?
Noah Rasheta [00:59:48] Yes, yes. Our first. We had one child. He was one at the time. And so we decided, okay, we've got to leave Arizona. Which meant she had to quit her job, like, with zero warning. She just had to leave. I had to leave. We drive up here and at that point I thought, I don't think I can. I can't do this. I was very hurt. And I said, you go to your parents. I'm going to stay with this family that I had lived with when I first moved to Utah, Anessa's family. I said, I'll just move in there. And I want Raiko, our son. I want him with me.
Noah Rasheta [01:00:30] As I figure out what we're going to do. But again, he's really young, he needs his mom. So I stayed there one night. He cried all night and I cried all night. And I was like, I can't do this. I can't lose him too. It's like he needs her and I need him. So what do we do?
John Dehlin [01:00:54] So you need her.
Noah Rasheta [01:00:55] I said, so I guess we can try to make this work. And I remember thinking, I don't care if I'm in a home, that if this is a loveless marriage, then that's what it is until we can sort this out. But we need to be under the same roof.
Noah Rasheta [01:01:11] So that's what we did. After one day away, I moved back into the home with her family at her parents house. And the three of us are together again. And we're just trying to make it work. And we go through this, you know, it's a long process to recover and to establish trust and to feel safety again. And as we're going through that whole process, I started to internalize that this probably happened because I'm not righteous enough, because I'm not.
Noah Rasheta [01:01:43] I don't have the depth of understanding in the scriptures that I should and things like that. Which, you know, ironically, looking back, you think, well, that's not at all what it is. This wasn't. This isn't about you, right? This is about the person and where they are mentally and in their emotional and mental health. Like, this is not me. I didn't know that at the time. I was like, this is my fault. I need to. I remember thinking, I will only listen to church music from now on. I will not watch any TV, nothing of the world. It was like, absorb yourself 100% in church stuff.
Noah Rasheta [01:02:21] And I started reading all the books, revisiting books from my mission, Mormon doctrine, just everything I could get my hands on. I only wanted church stuff. And that lasted two or three months. And the deeper I went with it, the more I started. That's when I first started to really encounter frameworks and stories and ideas that I did not know about. And they were deeply concerning to me at the point. To the point where I really started to doubt everything at that point. And because of the sensitivity I had at the time around trust and marital fidelity, betrayal and betrayal. What I was encountering with Joseph Smith was very troubling for me.
Noah Rasheta [01:03:09] I had never really gone deep into why was there polygamy, how was it practiced? Because it was uncomfortable and I didn't need to know details. So I didn't. But then this Forced me. As I was trying to become super righteous and super knowledgeable.
Noah Rasheta [01:03:28] It forced me to look at things I didn't want to look at. And then I started to sense this. The animosity and anger that I felt towards people who are unfaithful, particularly men. I started to see it in Joseph Smith. And because I never knew this person well, that the violation of trust happened with.
Noah Rasheta [01:03:53] But I did knew Joseph. And so my anger got redirected. And then suddenly I found myself processing these deep emotional wounds, directing the frustration and the anger at Joseph Smith and Brigham Young and others who practiced polygamy.
John Dehlin [01:04:11] Because Joseph and Brigham Young both took on plural wives that were already married to other men.
Noah Rasheta [01:04:15] That's right. Yeah. And reading some of the details, like rough stone rolling around, some of those connections to me felt like, oh, that could have been getting caught in infidelity and then spinning the story, like Pharaoh. Yeah, yeah. And I didn't want to assume because, like, I don't know, but it sure feels like. And that was enough to feel all the feelings of my wound transferred onto this person. So then I would say that was the moment that it felt like, now the full, full rug has been pulled out from under my feet. Because the stability of my relationship that I relied on up until that point, feeling like this is 100% the right thing.
Noah Rasheta [01:04:59] This was. We were locked and loaded. You know, that turned out to not be what I thought. And then the church. And then I suddenly felt like I lost all ability to. To trust my view of reality. It's like, I know this person would never do that, and they did. I know the church would never.
Noah Rasheta [01:05:20] And yet it seemed like maybe they did. And I was just. I was genuinely stumped. Like, I didn't know where to go or what to do, but I felt at the time I no longer had something firm to stand on. Like, that rug has been pulled out from under. You're literally in free fall. Where do you go with that? What do you do? And that's when I started to just dig everywhere. Like, what's out there? That's when I encountered Mormon stories. And that's when I called you. And I remember I was sitting in my car, so I had an office and employees at the time.
Noah Rasheta [01:05:55] I had a company manufacturing smartphone accessories. And I didn't want anyone to know that I'm going to be talking to someone about things you don't talk about. And I was sitting in my car talking to you, and you were so kind and gracious to just hear me out, hear my story. And it felt like I'm talking to someone who understands a lot of these things, which now the focal point was my faith, what's happening with my faith.
Noah Rasheta [01:06:21] And it felt comforting to know, okay, there's a lot more out there, and there are people who are trying to navigate this, too. And at the time, the intent of all of it was, how do we make sense of this, to hold onto it? There was no intent to leave any of it. The intent was, how do I wrap my head around what I'm learning?
Noah Rasheta [01:06:43] I knew I couldn't talk about it at home because I felt like, well, now that's for sure the final straw that will end the marriage. We were already in a very precarious, sensitive space of we're trying to slowly recover from something that happened.
Noah Rasheta [01:06:59] So I don't want to add this as another thing to put on the table. Like, now we've got to address this. So I reached out to my twin brother. You know, who else knows me better than him? And he had a very strong aversion to the topic and immediately shut it down. Like, no, we don't, Anita. You don't think about that. Don't talk about that.
Noah Rasheta [01:07:19] And then I think I let another month or two go by, and it's just festering, and I'm just still consuming everything I can from everywhere, listening to every one of the podcast episodes that you had produced. And then I reached out to him one day, just emotionally distraught, and I was crying, and I was like, I have no one to talk to about this stuff. You know me better than anyone. I need you. I need you to be, like the person I can talk to. And he immediately shifted and was like, you're right. That's exactly who I am. And I'm going to help you. Let's navigate this together.
Noah Rasheta [01:07:55] We're going to find answers to all of the questions, and we're going to sort this out. And again, his intent and my intent at the time was we're going to make sense of this, and this will strengthen our resolve and our testimony in the long run, and we're going to be okay, because the core belief still is this is the true path.
Noah Rasheta [01:08:14] So I start sharing with him. He goes down the rabbit hole. And then after a few months of that rabbit hole and deep dive, he tells me one day on the phone, I don't think I want to have anything to do with this anymore. Yeah, yeah. And I was like, oh, no. I did not want that to happen. I felt this.
John Dehlin [01:08:36] That wasn't what you were Going for
Noah Rasheta [01:08:37] that was not what I was going for. And I felt guilty. And I felt like, this is why you're not supposed to talk about this stuff. Look what I've done. I've affected his testimony, and he's sharing with his wife, so they simultaneously decide this is not what they want in their lives, and they exit. And then my parents start calling and they're like, what's going on with Nick? And I was like, I can't tell you. You're gonna have to talk to him. Cause I knew I had all this guilt. Now I can't tell my parents, but Nick did talk to them. And then my parents were like, well, as they went down the rabbit hole as well, they said, well, I don't think this is for us either. And they all left me hanging.
Navigating a Mixed-Faith Marriage
John Dehlin [01:09:20] So your parents and Nick stopped believing in the Mormon Church?
Noah Rasheta [01:09:23] Yes.
John Dehlin [01:09:24] Oh, yeah. And you started it.
Noah Rasheta [01:09:27] I know. And then my wife's asking me, like, what's going on with your family? And I couldn't say in detail, everything. It was just like, oh, there's. I don't know, there's stuff happening. And I'm trying to tread lightly because again, I have this deep fear that that's going to end the marriage.
Noah Rasheta [01:09:46] And then there are aspects of it that aren't super relevant. But my mom, turns out she was like, I never really was fully into it. I've always been Catholic. And I'm like, what? That's its own story. And I can get to that later. But going to what you're asking with the mixed faith marriage. So this point comes to where I realize the key for a marriage to work is authenticity. You just have to be yourself.
Noah Rasheta [01:10:12] And at the risk of this ending my marriage, I'm going to be authentic and say, this is what I'm dealing with. This is how I view the world. And I don't know if any of this is what I thought it was, and I kind of come clean. Right.
Noah Rasheta [01:10:28] And that had the opposite effect of what I was expecting, because instead of being like, okay, well, then that means this is ending. It was almost like you stood with me at a time when things were really difficult and I did something very hurtful to you.
Noah Rasheta [01:10:48] I can stick with you while you navigate this and figure out what all this means. And for a moment, it felt comforting where I was like, okay, then I didn't expect to hear that. So thank you for supporting me. We're going to figure this out. With time, it turned into a little resentment. I'm like, wait a second. You're making it feel like these are the same thing.
Noah Rasheta [01:11:09] I intentionally did something hurtful to you by questioning my belief system. That's not the same thing. So as that evolved and we were, we learned to sort it out. It was scary at first, it was rocky at first, but I think it genuinely turned a page for us because then to a new extent, I could be me and she could be her, and it healed us. And we made it, you know, over a decade of having a mixed faith marriage where we were able to navigate and respect each other's differences and still allow each other's worldviews to influence the dynamic of the overall family. And that took effort, it took time to kind of shift from.
Noah Rasheta [01:11:58] It feels like mine is the second class citizen in the family to make it balanced and equal. That took time, but we did arrive there. And I'm very proud of how we navigated the mixed faith marriage. And I think in a lot of ways, the. The influence of an alternate worldview that I ended up bringing to the table in a lot of ways probably strengthened and helped her in her LDS worldview. And I can get to those details later when we're talking about worldviews, but I'll just say, as far as navigating the multi or the mixed faith marriage, I feel like we did a good job and I'm convinced that people can navigate that skillfully. There are ways to do that.
John Dehlin [01:12:48] Yeah. I've been doing this 21 years, and there are certain stories you hear that just never leave you. And yours was one. And part of it was just this. It's almost like a Chinese finger trap, because you would have never had your faith crisis if your wife hadn't had struggles, you know what I mean? Her struggles kicked off your faith crisis. But then when you had your faith crisis, there was a point where I remember you feeling like your marriage might be in jeopardy because she married a faithful Mormon and she and her family expected her to stay married to a faithful Mormon. And that blew my mind.
John Dehlin [01:13:30] And I really remember having a lot of empathy for that situation because in a sense, you're both victims. Neither of you are choosing all of this. You're just trying to make. Pick up the pieces. And you've got kids now, and so you're trying to, like, keep the family afloat, you know? Exactly.
John Dehlin [01:13:51] And that's. I think when you told me that, that's when you started reading about Buddhism because you were just desperate for a way to be okay in the midst of this Chinese finger trap. You were.
Margi Dehlin [01:14:04] Yeah, like, I was just thinking with grief and loss, if we're just talking about the area of. Of loss, like you had so many things fall, you know, in a small amount of time that really you were looking to in life, like your dream too. It sounds like that was something that was part of your kid brain, was this dream of flying helicopters, right?
Noah Rasheta [01:14:31] Yeah.
Margi Dehlin [01:14:32] So having that as the. And then kind of all. So many towers going down, including, you know, let's just say an existing existential tower of this idea of coming to a place where you realize, I don't know, reality, I don't know what I don't know and what that feels like. So I guess what my question around all of that grief and loss during that time is just, did you suffer? Were you in a place of how did it feel for you at that time? Because it feels like a lot listening to it.
Noah Rasheta [01:15:08] Yeah.
Margi Dehlin [01:15:10] How did you manage that? And did. And did it feel dark?
John Dehlin [01:15:14] It.
Noah Rasheta [01:15:14] It absolutely felt dark. It felt. That was the first time in my life that it occurred to me. Like, I think I understand why somebody could reach a point where they choose to not live. It made sense. I hadn't reached. I never reached that stage where it's an actual thought that I would entertain, but I did remember thinking, I can see why someone would entertain that, because it's painful and you just want the pain to end.
Noah Rasheta [01:15:43] So during that stage, and you have, like you said, these series of towers that are collapsing, I like to visualize them as, you know, in Indiana Jones where it's trying to cross the bridge and like, the different sections keep falling, and then at some point, like, that's it. Everything's collapsed. There's nothing to stand on.
Noah Rasheta [01:16:03] And it was a very painful place to be emotionally and hadn't had the chance to fully process or heal from, you know, from the previous one, let alone the one prior to that one, and let alone the one prior to that one. So going all the way back to like, your. Your childhood dream was just crushed.
Noah Rasheta [01:16:24] So during that stage, I do remember thinking, still believing there is a path and there is the truth out there. And I became determined to discover what that truth was. And I went into seeker mode and I started devouring books and podcasts in addition to what I was learning about my current belief system, Mormonism.
Noah Rasheta [01:16:53] I branched out and I wanted to understand the origins of Christianity and how the. The New Testament was written. And so I. As I start to go down this path, I. I continually find what feels like it's problematic at every junction. Every. Every worldview has Its, its issues. You know, I couldn't rely on Catholicism because for a moment I entertained that. It's like, that's even more problematic.
Noah Rasheta [01:17:22] Everything has its, it's ugly pieces when you look under the covers. And I, I encountered a. The, the great courses has a series called the Meaning of Life. And you, it's like, you know, the existential questions, who am I? Why am I here? What happens when we die? And what is the meaning of life presented by these major world traditions. And I remember listening through it was like a 15 hour lecture series.
Noah Rasheta [01:17:55] And it's just going through all the different ones. And I have a notebook and I'm literally taking notes, thinking I would encounter from this tradition, the answer is this. And then I'd be like, I don't know about that. It's like, okay, next. And I'm working my way down this list of lectures.
Noah Rasheta [01:18:12] And at the time, all I knew about Buddhism was like, quotes you'd see on social media by the Dalai Lama. Stuff like that always sounded, it sounded nice, but I didn't know what was the view underneath it. So in this lecture series, toward the end, I get to the presentation on Buddhism and I'll never forget, it opens up with, okay, we don't have the answers to these big questions.
Noah Rasheta [01:18:41] Buddhism is going to have you flip it on its head and sit with the question itself. Why the need to know? Who is the I that needs to know this stuff? And it was all about the questions, not about the answers. And I remember putting my pen in the notebook and just closing it for a minute because I was like, whoa, I've never thought about this from the perspective of not the answers, but let's look at the questions. Do these questions even matter? Are they relevant? Are they answerable?
Noah Rasheta [01:19:14] And that was the start of my, let's go down this rabbit hole. Like, I remember thinking, who thinks like that? Okay, tell me more. I want to, I want to know more about Buddhism. And as, as I learned more and more about Buddhism and understood like, the entire premise of it is that to understand the nature of suffering.
Noah Rasheta [01:19:37] And I, it just spoke to me and I was like, this is really healing stuff. I remember thinking, wait, why did I consider this a religion? This feels like this is human psychology. And what I'm getting to understand isn't external, the cosmos or a deity. It's like I'm getting to understand myself and the way the human mind works.
Noah Rasheta [01:20:01] So I just went down the rabbit hole and kept learning and kept reading. I think I read through about a hundred different books on Buddhism and parts that wouldn't make a lot of sense. Then I would read something in another book, and if you understand this concept, then this concept now makes more sense. And I just kind of connect. Kept connecting those dots. And then at some point felt like, okay, I think I understand the premise of what it's teaching. And it was simultaneously helping me at the time with my own internal pain and suffering.
Noah Rasheta [01:20:38] And I wanted to share it. The more I was learning, the more I wanted to share it with others. And I. Well, and I wanted to practice it. So that was the first part of it, is I want to adopt this as a. As a. A practice, a lifestyle, a philosophy.
Noah Rasheta [01:20:53] So I. I would host meditation classes, and people would come, and it's like, well, for this to really make more sense, let me explain where it's coming from. So then it was like meditation slash, a quick intro to Buddhism. And then with the intro to Buddhism was, well, tell me more. So the more I started practicing and discussing all of this, I. At some point, I thought, I'm going to just record all of this. Maybe I'll do a podcast. And the goal is to just kind of lay out the premise of what Buddhism is and what it teaches. At this point, I had been practicing it for probably three years. And I mean intensely. Like, it consumed me. It became everything that I did and read and studied was all Buddhism.
Discovering Buddhism After Mormonism
Margi Dehlin [01:21:41] Can I ask you a couple questions about that?
Noah Rasheta [01:21:43] Yeah, of course.
Margi Dehlin [01:21:44] So when you're talking about practicing it, what are some of the concepts that you remember? Just sort of first off that you translated into your daily experience you thought about differently, where you noticed less suffering, less pain? When I, whatever, think about a certain concept or. I just think it would be nice to have a snapshot of kind of early Noah within Buddhism. What are the things that stuck out for you in the beginning?
Noah Rasheta [01:22:16] Yeah.
Margi Dehlin [01:22:16] And what did you see?
Noah Rasheta [01:22:19] So for me, it started with meditation. You know, meditation is kind of the core practice. So I like to say that Buddhism has a set of perspectives and practices in the way that yoga has poses, and you encounter yoga and you start to learn to do basic poses. And yoga is something that you practice? Not necessarily. Would you say it's a belief system. Buddhism can be like that. And the core Buddhist practice that you would start with is meditation as a form of introspection.
Noah Rasheta [01:22:55] And I remember encountering this idea that how you interpret the sense of self is like, you're not what you think you are. And if you take the time to look closely at what's happening in the Mind. When you're looking at the mind, what you'll see is a process. And the sense of self is an experience you're having. That is, you're selfing. You're experiencing the sense of self.
Noah Rasheta [01:23:25] And what you will find is kind of going back to that Arjona song. It's not a noun. It's like a verb. It's a process that's unfolding. So with meditation as that core practice, when I would sit there and I would analyze. Okay, here's a thought. Oh, that thought just gave rise to an emotion. Oh, now I'm feeling that emotion, which triggers this memory. Ooh. The trigger of the memory is now either intensifying the emotion or it's given rise to a different emotion. And it's almost like you're looking at the sky and you're seeing clouds that just, you know, they start to form and develop. They're there.
Noah Rasheta [01:24:02] They could be big, they could be small, but they're shifting. Subtle movement. And then at some point, that cloud's not there. It's another cloud. At some points of the day, there are no clouds. And then suddenly, there are clouds. And so I started to observe this happening in my own mind. And what felt like just this solid, fixed place that exists, which is Noah's brain, felt like it's an experience that's unfolding. And I can see it, because just like with a cloud, if you look at it long enough, you see that it's not static. Well, the mind is the same. You start to look at it and you realize, no, it's shift, shifting all the time.
Noah Rasheta [01:24:39] It might be subtle, but moods, feelings, thoughts, emotions, even. Even your sense of identity, all of that is in flux. And as I started to observe that, you know, day after day, as you sit there and you practice, what I realized is there's so much you don't notice if you never pay attention. And if you do pay attention, what you start to observe is that's consistent, is everything has causes and conditions, everything's interdependent, and everything's impermanent. And that kind of became the foundation for what I would describe as the evolution of a new worldview that was taking place of.
Noah Rasheta [01:25:25] I don't think I can see the world the same anymore, because what I do see now is everything that is has things that make it what it is, and they're always changing. And I remember encountering the teaching from a Zen teacher, Thich Nhat Hanh, who's a Vietnamese monk. He's since passed, but it was a Very simple and beautiful teaching where he said, if you've ever looked at a flower and all you saw was the flower, then you've never truly seen the flower.
Noah Rasheta [01:25:55] Because to see the flower, you have to see the sun, you have to see the clouds, the rain, the storms that give rise to rain, the mud in the ground. Like all of the non flower elements are what make the flower.
Noah Rasheta [01:26:11] And as powerful as that felt at the, you know, at the moment thinking of, wow, that's this, that's true with flowers. Then I realized that. But that's true of everything. It's true of individuals, it's true of ideologies, it's true of things. You know, everything has its things that make it what it is, but none of those things exist independent or permanent because that's just the nature of reality. There is no flower without all the other things.
Noah Rasheta [01:26:44] And at the time that, that's what really healed me is. But there's no me at the center of this experience of suffering. That's fixed. It's like I'm a collection of all the experiences that I've had up until this point. Moments of hurt, whether it's physical hurt, like you hit your finger with a hammer type thing, or emotional pain from interactions with other humans, it's like I am who I am because of everything that I've been through.
Noah Rasheta [01:27:18] And who I am in this moment is not who I'm going to be in a year, or in five years, or in 10 years. And that sudden view and understanding of flexibility and constant change was the impetus for so much of the healing. Because it's like, oh, okay, this is going, this is going to, it won't always be this way. Like this too shall pass became like a very experiential understanding rather than just a, you know, it feels good to say that.
Margi Dehlin [01:27:49] Yeah. And at this point, would you say this is an internal journey that you're kind of having on your own? Or did you talk to your brother about it? Or like, is this pretty much, are you having this on your own?
Noah Rasheta [01:28:07] Yeah. So at this point, for years, this is a very internal loan. Not lonely. I would say a very individual experience. It's just something I was going through and I think I needed it to be that way because I didn't, I didn't know how to explain it or if this is even helping me. Like I, I didn't have.
Noah Rasheta [01:28:31] It was like this thing that's developing that I can't put a framework around it yet, but I know that it keeps helping me. So I just Went on that journey alone, reading, listening to lecture series and learning as much as I could. And then at some point, I want to say within a year and a half or so of really starting that deep dive, I felt comfortable to talk about it and explain. Like, by then I already could sense life has shifted. I don't feel how I used to feel. My interpersonal dynamics, even at home, have improved. Everything's improving.
Noah Rasheta [01:29:06] And I feel a sense of contentment and peace. That, yeah, what happens? What happened? But this is the moment, you know, like those, like you see in cartoons, like the Dragon Warrior, you know, it's like inner peace and just feeling like I think I'm starting to experience that to a degree, like, I'm okay, I'm okay with what happened. I'm okay with what is right now. I'm okay with not knowing.
Noah Rasheta [01:29:31] And that's when I started talking more about it. And that's like I mentioned, I started hosting meditation classes, started talking about it on, on the podcast. And that's when I decided I wanted to really formalize my practice. And I, I found a two year ministry program to, to become a Buddhist teacher. And then that was like the second part of my deep dive was to let's, let's take this more seriously and maybe formalize it. And I already knew I have no interest in another ism in my life, so I was very reluctant to share and talk about it because I just had an aversion to a label.
Noah Rasheta [01:30:13] I didn't want a label, but there was this movement that was growing around secular Buddhism. And there was a popular former Buddhist monk who had kind of left the order and thought, you know, we don't have to approach it the way that we've been approaching it. You can approach it as a philosophy. And he had a book called Buddhism Without Beliefs. His name is Stephen Batchelor, and he had a book called Confessions of a Buddhist Atheist. And both of those really spoke to me and resonated for me. And I thought, that's the framework that I'm comfortable talking about Buddhism. I don't want people to think that you need to be a Buddhist to benefit from these ideas.
Noah Rasheta [01:30:56] And then that became like the slogan of my podcast too, that you don't need to use what you learn from Buddhism to be a Buddhist. You can use it to be a better whatever you already are. And I genuinely feel like that is at the core of almost all of these teachings that you'll encounter in mindfulness traditions like Buddhism. You can take them and apply them to whatever worldview you have. Because as opposed to most worldviews, most worldviews are trying to give you the answers to the big questions. And then it feels like they're competing because this answer isn't compatible with another answer. But Buddhism doesn't have the answers.
Noah Rasheta [01:31:34] It's giving you all the tools to sit with the questions. So if you're someone who has an ideology that needs, that gives you answers, and you depend on those answers, you could add Buddhism as an alternate framework that now gives you tools to sit with the questions, rather than seeing it as it's not a competing worldview that's going to come in and say, wait, let's compare your answers versus our answers in this other tradition.
Noah Rasheta [01:32:00] So I think that's part of why it was so compatible as a framework in a mixed faith marriage too. Because we didn't necessarily have opposing views on specific topics. It's like we're approaching it in two different ways. One tradition says you need the answers and your sense of peace comes from having the answer. And the other tradition is saying maybe the question doesn't matter as much as you think it does. And if it doesn't carry the weight that you thought it carried, then not having an answer to the question is also a form of having peace.
Noah Rasheta [01:32:36] And that really spoke to me because that felt like nobody can ever pull that rug out from under me again. Because this is giving me a framework of having no foundation to stand on. That was the shift from being a truth seeker to just. I'm just a practitioner of peace. I'm trying to create and experience more peace in my life. And I don't need answers anymore. I'm not gonna look for answers. Cause so much of what life gives you are questions that can't be answered.
John Dehlin [01:33:10] Yeah. When Margi and I, you know, we lost our faith in 2001 and started Mormon Stories in 2005. And then we were trying to figure out. We found ourselves having to neutralize everything our kids were learning at church because we wanted to raise them in a tradition, but we also weren't really giving them a theology or a doctrine to live by. And we also didn't want them to become orthodox Mormons because we felt like there were harmful teachings there.
John Dehlin [01:33:48] So I remember when Oprah was doing her book club, towards the end of her show, she had Eckhart Tolle on and she plugged A New Earth by Eckhart Tolle. And I remember being around 2007, and I remember just it being earth shattering for Margi and I because I think of Eckhart Tolle as kind of popularized secular Buddhism in a new age kind of wrapping.
John Dehlin [01:34:17] And it really meant a lot to us to have the framework of be in the present moment. Don't get too attached to labels or stories or identities. Don't live in the past, don't live in the future, live in the now.
John Dehlin [01:34:36] You know, that stuff became really powerful to us. He talked about the ego and attachment and suffering. And then when I learned you were discovering Buddhism, I'd studied a little Buddhism, but not a lot. I think I had learned about it from my world religions class at byu.
John Dehlin [01:35:03] And I like this idea of life is suffering and attachment causes suffering. And then there's the Eightfold path that helps deliver you from being unduly burdened by your suffering, let's just say it that way. But I also never really gave Buddhism a serious consideration for the same reason I think many ex Mormons and or people who've left high demand religions haven't is because they immediately make the association between Buddhism and a world religion. And so many people who have come out of a world religion are allergic to anything that even sniffs of religion.
John Dehlin [01:35:43] And so that's always been a frustrating thing is that I don't think of Buddhism first of all, I don't think of it as religion and I more think of it as just positive mental health principles. But it's got that association that I think becomes a deal killer, possibly even for even if you stick the word secular in front of it.
Noah Rasheta [01:36:08] Yeah.
John Dehlin [01:36:08] And I just. Yeah. And so I really do feel like. And weirdly, Eckhart Tolle kept referencing Jesus and in a New Earth and he would say things like Jesus said consider the lilies of the field. You know, and that's a Buddhist move. It's just sit in the present moment and Jesus said, take no thought for tomorrow because evil is sufficient of the day thereof. Like, oh, that's sort of Buddhist. You know, he's saying pay attention to the now and don't worry about the future. The now is kind of all you have.
John Dehlin [01:36:42] And so I just realized that the principles of Buddhism are just sound mental health principles. And also at exact that time I was starting my PhD in clinical and counseling psychology and I was being trained in a form of cognitive behavioral therapy called acceptance and commitment therapy, which, you know, so it's known as ACT Act.
John Dehlin [01:37:06] And it was basically a PhD level psychotherapy researcher who had grew up during the hippies movement and was exposed to transcendental Buddhism and he just merged. What he learned from Buddhism into cognitive behavioral therapy. And it became a really efficacious form of treating anxiety and treating depression and treating post traumatic stress disorder. So all these worlds start converging for me, Eckhart Tolle, you acceptance and commitment therapy. And I just realized that there is something to this. And I'm annoyed that ex Mormons are gonna associate it with a world religion and for that reason alone, might not give it a second thought. Which is why I always loved how you start every episode and say those words again.
How Buddhism Shaped Noah's Worldview
Noah Rasheta [01:37:58] You don't need to use what you learned from Buddhism to be a Buddhist. You can use it to be a better whatever. You already are.
John Dehlin [01:38:04] Yeah. And that's brilliant. Yeah. Yeah.
Margi Dehlin [01:38:09] I mean, one thing I observe in your story that I really. I love this now, like, reflecting on where you are is just how you described yourself as a boy, as being curious. And I think inadvertently, what can happen when you're raised Mormon is that you overvalue this idea of what you know, what you think you know. And so the world becomes very stagnant, very, like, you know, everything. And so, and I've said this before on the podcast, but the world dies a little when you do that. If you walk around thinking you know everything. Right. There's no reason to really engage with it. So thinking about you saying I was a curious boy, I mean, Buddhism to me is like, the world is alive again.
Margi Dehlin [01:39:03] Like, you don't know. So you're always observing, you're always curious, you're always looking and feeling and, you know, and there's this real engagement there. And at the heart of it is sort of curiosity.
Noah Rasheta [01:39:17] Yeah, it really is. In fact, there's a Zen expression that I really love, and it says, with little doubt, little awakening, no doubt, no awakening, and great doubt, great awakening. Like, it's. It's at the heart of that is, like you said, curiosity. Yeah.
Margi Dehlin [01:39:37] We reference Eckhart Tolle before. Eckhart Tolle for me actually was Thich Nhat Hanh. I read Heart of the Buddha's Teaching was one of the first books I read. And I would bring it to church with me, actually, and read it in second hour, just sit out in the foyer. It came from this place of deep suffering. That's where the journey began. And it reminds me of just like that lotus flower kind of symbolism of needing darkness and the mud, and from that it gives birth. It needs that actually to find it. And it weaves its way up, and then you get this. This incredible flower right at the surface, but at the root, like, where you start is deep pain. Right. And that's what drew you to. And I just think that's, that's really interesting and I relate to it.
Noah Rasheta [01:40:27] Yeah, yeah. That expression, no mud, no lotus. And it felt like I, I had reached a stage in my life where it's like, ah, I've encountered mud. I don't want mud, I only want lotus. And it was like, well, let's look at the mud, because that's where the lotus comes from. And that is what healed so much of my relationship with the past, with what happened, or even with the church. So going back to just my Mormon story became a story of once it no longer made sense to me as a framework for myself, for my life. I was still in it for over a decade In a family dynamic where this is what my spouse believes, this is what my kids are growing up in, this is what my people that I love in my family in laws, this is what they all believe.
Noah Rasheta [01:41:20] How do I work within that framework where it's not what I believe? And I want to give you a couple of examples of where a Buddhist perspective helped in living in an ecosystem like that, a framework like that. And one was early on with, with the, when home teaching was still a thing. We had a neighbor who, he was the previous bishop, older gentleman, and he was, he would never miss, like I don't know if I was his project or if it really was that our family was assigned to him, but he would come share a message every month and he would reach out. And sometimes it was the one time it was the end of the month, I want to say it was literally the last day of the month and a Sunday.
Noah Rasheta [01:42:09] And he called and I remember it was kind of late in the day and as I answered the phone I said, oh, hi. And my wife realized who it was and she's on the other side of the room kind of doing this like, no, tell him we can't because now we've hit it's bedtime. And that's a tone routine with three kids, you know, and he was trying
John Dehlin [01:42:30] to meet his quota.
Noah Rasheta [01:42:31] He was trying to meet his quota. And I, as I'm looking at her saying all this, I said, yes, of course, come on over and hang up. And she goes, why, why did you do that? It's we've got to get the kids ready for bed and blah, blah, blah. And I said, well, just think about this from his perspective. He, he feels like he's doing his God given duty to come talk to us. I'm not going to rob him of that. And she kind of paused for a second. I was like, think of how happy he'll be to know he came, he did it, he'll go home.
Noah Rasheta [01:43:02] And it's like, I did it. I hit the quota, and I almost missed it. And I remember she was, like, taken aback. She's like, wait, that's how you've been approaching this this whole time? Because this is years of me, not even, you know, I'm no longer attending or anything.
Noah Rasheta [01:43:18] And yet if someone comes like him and he wanted to come, I'd always say, yeah, come on over. And I said, yeah, that's how I'm approaching it. I like him. I care about him. I don't want to rob him of the joy he gets from feeling a sense of accomplishment to his duty for coming and sharing a message with me.
Noah Rasheta [01:43:35] And it doesn't bother you that he comes and the message is always about, you're essentially living life wrong. Come back to this path. I was like, it could be whatever it is that doesn't matter to me. I'm content with where I am in my path. But if he needs to say that, he can say it. He can say whatever he needs to say. And I remember that was a big shift for her that I think helped her to be a better whatever. She already was. In this case, she was doing visiting, teaching, and it changed her perspective of, why are we doing the things that we do that can be its own thing?
Noah Rasheta [01:44:08] Why do we allow people to do what they're going to do that can be a whole different one. And in this case, I had a reason for why I allow him to come share messages with me. That's rooted in my compassion for him, and that's all that needed to be. That was an impactful moment.
Noah Rasheta [01:44:27] And then another one later had to do with something that was in a conference talk, and she was really wrestling with something that was said. I can't even remember the details. And I remember telling her, but does it matter if it's true or not? She was trying to have a sense of, I can comply with this thing that was said if I know it's true.
Noah Rasheta [01:44:53] And it evolved into a conversation where I helped her view all of it from a framework of, what if it's not true? What if there's this box right here and it would confirm if you open it that it's definitely not true? Would that make you not want to go and not be involved with it?
Noah Rasheta [01:45:10] And she said, I think I would still want to because these are my friends. This is my community. And I was like, so, so that's not about being true or not. Then don't get caught up in that. It doesn't, you're wrestling with something that you don't need to be wrestling with when the real, the real approach for you is, I like this, I like how it makes me feel when I go, well, then keep going. It doesn't have to be anything more than that. And I think that was another one of those milestones for her to feel like she could loosen the grip a little and just appreciate the fact that she does love going to church.
Noah Rasheta [01:45:43] She loves the people at church, she loves a lot of what the church gives her and does for her. And certainly there are a few things that she doesn't like, but it doesn't have to all hinge on, you know, it's either all or nothing.
Noah Rasheta [01:45:58] So those were just a couple of examples of how a Buddhist perspective influenced and shaped an LDS narrative inside of this mixed faith marriage where it's like, look, we're on the team of we're trying to make this as easy as we can for each other and follow what feels right. And then that in return that allowed me to be clear of like, the reason I don't go isn't because I'm standing in a place of certainty of either it's true or it's not. It's, I don't, I don't like how I feel when I go. It doesn't make sense to me. This is not about if it's true or not.
Noah Rasheta [01:46:34] It doesn't resonate for me and that's why I don't do it. There are a lot of things I don't do in life because they, I don't like, I don't want to do it. And there are a lot of things that I do do in life simply because I like how it makes me feel, not because it's the, the right thing to do or not.
John Dehlin [01:46:51] I'll just tell people as we come up on the two hour mark, we're going to do a part two where we're going to do an introduction to Secular Buddhism and it's a real special treat. And if you're struggling with mental health, with suffering, I can promise you you're going to find things that will be valuable. Let's close this first part with this final maybe question.
Making a Mixed-Faith Marriage Work
John Dehlin [01:47:17] So I was surprised after, you know, you, you know, we were friends and then you kind of, you know, you moved on from the Mormon stories kind of domain and started secular Buddhism. It was always Just really impressive to me. But also it almost didn't make sense that you were able to stay in your mixed faith marriage. Not because mixed faith marriages can't be made to work, but when worldviews start to diverge in such fundamental ways.
John Dehlin [01:47:54] That always stuck with me. It's like, I love Margi, but if our worldviews got too far apart, there would be a point where I'm not sure it would even be healthy or fun for us to try to stay together. So I was always watching to see, man, is Noah still married? And then. But the other part was, I know that you, I'm sure your in laws are amazing, but I always, because I knew your story, knew that you were living in this town surrounded by your in laws, where they were all, as I understood it, devout, and they were all in it. And you probably didn't really feel ever fully accepted or appreciated or valued when the world was honestly valuing you as a source of wisdom and guidance and truth.
John Dehlin [01:48:45] You're living in this small community where your family and community kind of views you as a disappointment. Like for me, the math said, I don't know how. I mean, the only way Noah's surviving all this is because he's practiced Buddhism. But in my mind also, I thought, I don't know how this lasts forever. I don't know how this can continue. So maybe we end with you kind of talking about, how did the Mormon mixed faith marriage last?
Noah Rasheta [01:49:15] Yeah. So I feel like the mixed faith marriage was never problematic in the sense of this shouldn't work. And in fact, a huge part of the motivation to keep making it work was to show people that it can work.
Noah Rasheta [01:49:35] Now, to her credit as well, I do think it takes a softening of the grip. You know, it is a worldview that is fundamental in the sense of it's the only right way and any other way is not. And if you hold that with a super tight grip, it's going to be very difficult for that person to be with someone who doesn't have the framework.
Noah Rasheta [01:50:01] And again, credit to her, she did not have that. She was okay with elements of uncertainty, like, what does this mean when we die? What does this mean about what? The promises we made in the temple, things like that she held space for. We don't know. That can be sorted when the time comes. And that's a huge part of why this worked as long as it worked.
Margi Dehlin [01:50:24] I can see that.
Noah Rasheta [01:50:25] Yeah. Now then the ecosystem is a separate thing. And it was difficult to feel like you're in an ecosystem where you're tolerated and you're welcome, no doubt welcome. Because like I said, the family, they're incredible. All of them are very capable, intelligent, loving people.
Noah Rasheta [01:50:46] But sometimes the worldview itself, unintentionally, without you knowing it is blinding you to, you know, what makes a good person good. In that framework, it might be, well, how obedient you are or how much you believe. And for someone like me in that ecosystem, it's easy to be looked at sometimes as well. You're a good, kind person, but just stay quiet and sit in the back. We don't want to. Don't share and talk about your worldview because your worldview feels threatening.
Noah Rasheta [01:51:20] So there were aspects of my life that felt like they're very subdued, like, I'm not going to just share. For example, when I became a Buddhist minister, that was an experience I went through that was very solo, like nobody was there when it was done. It wasn't like, hey, congrats, tell me about that. It's just kind of like, well, we're going to pretend that didn't happen. There were moments like that that feel difficult because you just kind of feel like, okay, I'll just.
John Dehlin [01:51:50] And the kid turns 8 and everybody goes bananas because they get baptized. Right. But you become a minister and it's like, that's awkward.
Noah Rasheta [01:51:58] Exactly. Yeah. And if it's happening on their side, you know, their kids are turning 8, their kids are going on missions, and I'm supportive and I'll celebrate and congrats or I'll go to the opening. You know, I don't believe in this and yet I can support your belief in it. Where I felt that was very difficult to receive the inverse of that.
Noah Rasheta [01:52:22] So that takes a toll. And then ultimately one of one of the things that happened towards the end, because you know where this is leading, we, after 20 years, we decided to separate and get divorced. So divorced now. And that was.
Noah Rasheta [01:52:39] It's been. It was difficult to navigate, and yet aspects of it have been, I think, healthy for both. And I do remember one thing that was pivotal for me. My in laws were going on a mission to Nauvoo. That's where they are now. And they're loving it. They're having a great time there. I'm. I keep up with what they're up to, but the. They came to our. Everyone came to our house prior to them leaving.
Noah Rasheta [01:53:08] And there was a moment where all of the siblings were expressing appreciation to the parents, like, oh, you're wonderful examples. We're gonna follow suit and do this one day too. And I remember thinking, this has to be kind of hard for Giselle. It has to be kind of hard for her to hear expressions of, oh, we want to do that too. And she's got to be thinking, I wish I could, but I won't be able to.
Noah Rasheta [01:53:33] And realizing like much of what I feel, that I can't fully be me because it just doesn't, it doesn't work for her system, her belief system. It happens both ways. And we had encountered it once before. She was really excited to try to go on trek and I didn't want to go on Trek and she couldn't go alone because the way that the people get to go on that is as a couple, right? So I went and mentioned it to my brother in law at the time, was, was our bishop and told him I, there's got to be a way that we can make this work.
Noah Rasheta [01:54:12] Like, what if, what if we are a support staff and I'm the one doing all the videography and I'll make a video for you guys at the end of it all.
John Dehlin [01:54:21] That's so nice.
Noah Rasheta [01:54:22] And he said, yeah. And I remember she was so excited. Like I could just see the genuine happiness and joy that she gets to go participate in this thing that she thought she'd probably never get to experience. And it was fine, we did it, you know, and I enjoyed the experience of trekking and filming. But also it's like, this isn't, this doesn't jive with me. This isn't my worldview. The messages that are being shared here don't resonate with me. But that's okay. I can approach this the way that I'm going to approach it.
Noah Rasheta [01:54:52] So moments like that and then, and then thinking to the future mission, like, I won't be able to make that happen. And there was this moment of, why are we doing this to each other? I love you enough to want what's best for you, even if that means maybe that's not me.
Noah Rasheta [01:55:09] And she expressed the same in return. Like, I love you enough to want what's best for you, even if that's not me. And it's the culmination of a lot of things, right? Because there's the catalyst of an initial very deep wound that's really hard to ever fully get over. That's its own thing. But that alone was not enough. There's the differences in worldview, which is also a very big thing. But alone not enough. There's patterns and understanding ourselves. And your pattern triggers my pattern and my Pattern in turn triggers yours. Right. Like, that is a huge thing, but in and of itself might not be enough, but the.
Noah Rasheta [01:55:51] The totality of all of it felt like, what if we're not the most skillful pairing that we could be for each other? Could you be in a dynamic where you would. We don't want to survive our marriage. We want to thrive in our marriage. And we tried really hard. In the last two years, we did a weekly marriage counseling course that we were in that was like, every week. Like, we read a very thick book. We've done years of work to try to make it work, and that's why it's as good as it's been. And I would say at many times, there were intense highlights of a really good, happy, healthy relationship.
Noah Rasheta [01:56:35] And then, of course, there are the moments where very painful and hurtful experiences that have happened in our marriage. But the lowest lows weren't the defining and the highest highs weren't the defining. It was just the totality of all of it. What if we want to? What if we're two good people who just aren't right for each other going forward? Going forward.
John Dehlin [01:56:59] Yeah.
Noah Rasheta [01:57:01] And when we celebrated our 20th, because by then we already knew this is the end. And we did it like the end of Survivor where it's like, you go back and revisit all the highlights. It's like, what are your 20 favorite memories of our past together? And like, it felt like a moment of mourning and genuine celebration of everything that we did that we can be proud of, and we let it go with that. Like, we did something incredible that we're both proud of and we really both want what's best for each other moving forward.
Noah Rasheta [01:57:34] And it felt like a very healthy, amicable way to say, the story keeps going. This is a book, but that chapter's over. And I don't regret those chapters. I cherish everything that those chapters were. But the stories shifted, and there's the excitement of I don't know what the story has for the future, but no resentment or regret for the past either. That's kind of how we ended that.
Margi Dehlin [01:58:02] So meaningful.
John Dehlin [01:58:04] Yeah. I think more marriages need to end when they end with celebration.
Margi Dehlin [01:58:07] Yes. And that's right.
John Dehlin [01:58:10] Yeah. So with that, I hope you've enjoyed part one of our interview with Noah Rashada of secular Buddhism. The website is eightfoldpath.com is that right? And we're going to talk about that next episode. But, you know, like, subscribe, follow donate@mormonstories.org donate support Noah as well. Go to eightfoldpath.com and there's a lot of cool stuff he has, including an Ask Noah kind of AI engine where you've imported all of your wisdom and your writings into a automated AI bot that can actually serve as kind of a guide and a counselor. Is that right?
Reflections and What Comes Next
Noah Rasheta [01:58:48] Yeah, that's right. If you want to learn about Buddhism, you can listen to the first five episodes of the podcast, or you could read a book about it, or you could ask questions, and the chatbot will guide you through it.
John Dehlin [01:58:59] Yeah. But most importantly, if you are being mired in suffering and. Or someone you love and you want to learn the beginnings of an approach to mental health, dealing with anxiety, depression, trauma in a way that's also empirically supported, come back right back for part two, where we're going to do an introduction to secular Buddhism. And you don't join part two to become a Buddhist. You join part two to become the best whatever it is you are or want to be. True.
Noah Rasheta [01:59:34] That's right.
John Dehlin [01:59:35] All right. So thanks, Noah.
Noah Rasheta [01:59:36] Thank you.
John Dehlin [01:59:37] Thanks, Margi.
Margi Dehlin [01:59:37] Yes, absolutely.
John Dehlin [01:59:39] And thanks, Brooklyn and Julia. And we'll see you all again for part two. Be good to each other, Be kind to each other, and come back for part two on Mormon stories. See everyone.
Part 2 of 2 · Ep. 2206
Introduction and Episode Overview
John Dehlin [00:00:00] Hello everyone and welcome back to another episode of Mormon Stories Podcast. I'm your host, Sean Dehlin. It's September 17, 2026 and we're here in part two of our interview with Noah Rasheta. He's the founder of the podcast Secular Buddhism.
John Dehlin [00:00:13] He's got a couple books under his belt. His website is eightfoldpath.com we just spent part one doing his Mormon story. We talked about his Mormon journey and his mixed faith marriage, his faith transition, how he got into Buddhism. And what we promised is for part two, we were going to give you an overview of a life philosophy and a set of tools or skills that can really help you navigate life and suffering and healing and growth skillfully. And I think it's a particularly useful framework for navigating a Mormon faith crisis transition and or if you're a Richard Rohr fan, it's a really great toolkit to navigate from first half of life to into second half of life.
John Dehlin [00:01:04] And so if you or loved one is struggling with suffering, I think this next hour and 57 minutes could be transformative for you. So before we jump into the content for today, first of all, I'm pleased to be joined with my co host, Margi.
Margi Dehlin [00:01:26] Hello. Welcome back everyone.
John Dehlin [00:01:28] And Noah, welcome back to Mormon Stories.
Noah Rasheta [00:01:31] Thank you.
John Dehlin [00:01:33] Anything you want to say? I mean, I mentioned eightfoldpath.com and secular Buddhism podcast. You've got a couple books maybe. Let's just, if someone didn't listen to the past couple hours, anything you want to say by way of introduction as to why someone would want to listen to you? And I know that's a loaded question,
Noah Rasheta [00:01:55] I would just say quickly, I come from an LDS background background, having grown up with that went through some life moments that put me on the path of exploring techniques to deal with pain and suffering like meditation. And then that took me down the rabbit hole of studying Buddhism as a philosophy and then wanting to share these concepts and ideas with the world. Because what I found is a lot of what you encounter in this particular worldview are skills and tools that could benefit anyone. And like they say, anytime I'm going to share anything about Buddhism, you don't need to use what you learned from Buddhism to be a Buddhist. You can use it to be a better whatever you already are.
John Dehlin [00:02:44] So for someone who is either ex Mormon or is left a high demand religion, who's allergic to all things religion, is Buddhism a religion or not? And what does secular Buddhism even mean?
Noah Rasheta [00:02:59] Okay, yeah. So the answer is yes and no. And get used to that.
John Dehlin [00:03:05] Get used to all those answers? Yes.
Noah Rasheta [00:03:08] I mean, you'll find Buddhism listed on any list of religions to choose from on any form. And yet it can be practiced as a philosophy or as a worldview, because what you'll encounter when you start to study it or learn about it, it's not the same as a lot of worldviews that give you answers to life's questions. It gives you a toolkit and skills to understand the nature of the question. Is this something. Why do I want to know this? Who is the me that actually wants to know?
Noah Rasheta [00:03:42] So in that sense, it's very different. It's also a non theistic tradition. There's not like a creator deity that sits at the heart of all of. Doesn't have commandments of things that you're supposed to do. It's almost like a framework that you can take. And it's a matter of living skillfully or not. How do I live a life that minimizes or reduces unnecessary suffering for myself and for others?
John Dehlin [00:04:10] Yeah, and that's a great segue because people might say, ha, I want to meditate, or I want to learn about Buddhism because I want to eliminate suffering. So maybe let's begin there. Yes. How's that for a goal?
Noah Rasheta [00:04:24] That's a great goal.
John Dehlin [00:04:27] Is it to eliminate suffering or is that the problem? We'll get into it. Yeah.
Margi Dehlin [00:04:31] First arrow, second arrow.
Noah Rasheta [00:04:32] That's right. So the Buddha was not a God, just a person who went through what people go through in life. You have experiences that give rise to certain feelings and emotions. And then he went on a journey to discover the nature of suffering. So the core dilemma that he was faced with was like, I'm living life with doing all the right things. Why is there this existential angst, this suffering that kind of permeates underneath everything, even when everything seemed to be going right?
John Dehlin [00:05:10] Do you recommend the book Siddhartha as a first read? Cause that was my first introduction.
Noah Rasheta [00:05:15] Yeah, Siddhartha's a good one. And then Karen Armstrong has a book that's really good as well.
John Dehlin [00:05:21] What's that called?
Noah Rasheta [00:05:23] I think it's called the Buddha.
Margi Dehlin [00:05:24] Yeah, I think it is.
John Dehlin [00:05:26] Okay. Yeah.
Noah Rasheta [00:05:27] Okay, those are good. And then if you want like a really in depth long one, Thich Nhat Hanh has Old Path, White Clouds. And that's like the whole story of the Buddha. That one can be pretty long. And I think that one might make more sense if you have at least an understanding of some of the core concepts and ideas from Buddhism.
John Dehlin [00:05:47] Okay, yeah, yeah. Okay.
The Core of Buddhist Teaching and Suffering
Noah Rasheta [00:05:49] So the Buddha goes on this journey and the heart of his teaching, everything centered around what you would call Buddhism is the understanding of this topic, of suffering. The word that's used in Pali is a word that can be translated as unsatisfactoriness, anguish.
Noah Rasheta [00:06:10] It's more than just what we think of suffering, but it's the idea that in life you encounter difficulties. And at the heart of this moment, for the Buddha in his journey, was the realization and the understanding of what's going on. Here's what's going on. So some people will talk about this moment and this journey that the Buddha goes on. It's like he becomes the doctor. Like, if you go to a doctor with an ailment, you're there for a couple of things. Four things, right? One, what is it? What are we dealing with here? Two, what's causing it? Three, what's the prognosis? Is this?
Noah Rasheta [00:06:48] Can it be healed? And four, what's the prescription? How do we get rid of it? So in Buddhism, that's what you encounter. And it starts with the understanding of, here's what we're dealing with. Life is hard. In life, you're going to encounter difficulties, sickness, old age, death. These are things that we can't escape. And we go through life thinking, I must be doing something wrong, because there's just uneasiness. There's this unsatisfactoriness that's there underneath everything.
Noah Rasheta [00:07:21] And that's what he says is, well, that's the first thing is, yeah, that's what it is to be alive, to be a human being. And to be alive will entail unsatisfactoriness. Then he gets to the second part. What's causing it? It's craving. It's wanting things to be other than how they are.
Noah Rasheta [00:07:39] There's natural and unnecessary suffering. Like natural suffering would be, you stub your toe. Yeah, that hurts. It hurts when you stub your toe. Oh, a loved one died. Yeah, it hurts when you lose a loved one. But then there's unnecessary suffering that we add to things, and that's the suffering that arises from unskillful views or beliefs.
Noah Rasheta [00:08:00] And that's where he's saying attachment is at the heart of this type of suffering. The craving for things to be other than how they are. Then you have the what's the prognosis? What can we do about it? And he says, understanding that you can eliminate craving is how you reduce suffering. So there's something we can do about it is essentially what that is all about. What is it that we do about it? You can live Your life in a way where you're very intentional about what you say, how you live, how you make a living, the effort you put into gaining wisdom through concentration or meditation.
Noah Rasheta [00:08:40] There are things that you can do that will ensure that you live your life with more contentment and peace, or you can make things worse and unintentionally make everything worse. So there's something you can do. And that's what Buddhism calls the path, the Eightfold Path. So that is, in a nutshell, what Buddhism is all about. The understanding of suffering. What are we dealing with? Can we do anything about it? And what can we do to minimize that for ourselves and others? And that's at the heart of any Buddhist school or tradition.
John Dehlin [00:09:14] Okay, and is it in that part of the introduction, where do you tell the story of the farmer or the second arrow? Or is that within the eight steps? Because I want to definitely get to some of those core stories that you like to tell secular Buddhism.
The Four Noble Truths Explained
Noah Rasheta [00:09:34] So we'll start with just these four. What are considered the Four Noble Truths? And that would be the understanding that life entails. Difficulty arises because we want things to be other than how they are. We can do something about that. We can pay attention to, what is it that I'm craving? Why am I after this?
Noah Rasheta [00:09:53] And the other side of the coin with craving is aversion. There's things that you're running toward because you want them, and there are things that you're running away from because you don't want them. And you need to understand that. And that's not knowing what compels you to run, whether that's toward or away from something that's called ignorance in the Buddhist framework. And then all of that leads to the path, right? And the opening part of the path is how do we view reality? And this is called right view, or probably more appropriately, it should be called skillful view.
Noah Rasheta [00:10:29] And the idea is that we go through life viewing it a certain way and viewing ourselves a certain way. And we typically view ourselves as separate, independent entities. There's you and there's me, and we're not the same thing.
Noah Rasheta [00:10:43] And skillful view comes in as a. As the step. As a step into the path where you start to look. But if we look really closely, what do we see? What's really there? And I mentioned this in part one, but it's worth saying again here. Thich Nhat Hanh, the Zen teacher, talks about, if you've ever looked at a flower and all you saw was the flower, then you've never truly seen the Flower, because to see the flower, you have to see the sky and the clouds and the storms and the rain and the mud and all the non flower elements.
Noah Rasheta [00:11:14] That's at the heart of the understanding of skillful view is that everything that you look at in life is interdependent. There is no thing that exists without it being made of its parts, its causes and conditions, and that's applicable to anything you look at. I often say a very easy one to start with is look at your car. You take your car, disassemble it into all of its parts, and once it's disassembled, there's not a single one that you can go pick out as the car. The car is the totality of all of those parts and we're the same. If you were to really start to look at, well, what makes me me, is it my memories?
Noah Rasheta [00:11:56] Is it my body, my genetics that's inherited? Is it my thoughts and emotions? Is it the awareness I have of all of this unfolding? And you'll conclude again, it's you're the totality of this experience that you're having. But there's not one part of you that could be extracted or extrapolated, and that's you. That's the essence of you.
Noah Rasheta [00:12:21] And in the Buddhist framework, that's a really important milestone to recognize. You're interdependent and impermanent. And I think that's at the heart of skillful view or right view is those two I's of wisdom, of impermanence and interdependence. And then once you start to see yourself in the world in that framework of those two things, the way you see things starts to change. Nothing that feels permanent truly is permanent. And that comes into play with things like notions like good or bad. And that's the story of the farmer and the horse, for example, because we go through life and it's like this thing happened. Well, that's bad.
Noah Rasheta [00:13:04] Oh, now this thing happened. Oh, that's good. And we ascribe meaning, inherent meaning, to those moments when the reality is as things are unfolding. It's part of a much bigger picture and you don't see the whole picture. So the story of the farmer and the horse, for example, it embodies that in a very beautiful way. And the way the story goes, there's a farmer who one day a horse arrives and his neighbor comes running over and says, oh, this is great, you have a horse. And the farmer just says, well, who knows what is good and what is bad? Or in some Versions of the story just says, maybe.
Noah Rasheta [00:13:44] And then the next day, the horse runs away and the neighbor comes running over. How unfortunate for you. Your horse ran away. He's like, well, maybe. And then the horse comes back with additional horses, and the farmer comes running over the neighbor, right? And. Oh, this is great. He's like, who's to say what's good, what's bad? And the story keeps going. Then his son starts to ride the horses, using them to plow in the field. Well, that's great. But then he falls off and breaks his leg. Oh, well, that's bad.
Noah Rasheta [00:14:12] And then the army comes into town, and they're conscripting the youth into the army, and they can't take him because of his broken leg. Oh, that's great. And at that point in the story, it's just, who's to say what is good and what is bad? And it illustrates in a very powerful way, we just don't know what's coming next. And when we. If we could zoom out and see the totality of the whole story. Just like any good story, if you think of your favorite book or movie, the first time you encountered that story as it's unfolding, you're like, oh, I think I know what this means.
Noah Rasheta [00:14:44] But then a good story has a twist where you're like, oh, that's not. I didn't see that coming. So you don't want to get stuck at these moments thinking, well, this is good or this is bad, because you just don't know.
Noah Rasheta [00:14:56] I think that's a really powerful way of observing life. And I think another way that I've explained this that I think is really powerful is we go through life thinking we're playing a game of chess, and it's like, I can see the whole board. If I just knew the moves or I studied hard enough, I could get 20 steps ahead. And this is something that you can win. Life is a game that you can win or a test that you can pass or fail. And the Buddhist perspective is that life is not like chess. It's a lot more like the game of Tetris. And you don't know what piece is going to show up.
Noah Rasheta [00:15:31] And the only move that you ever really have is, what do you do with the piece that now fell into your lap? And at times, I think that really resonates. You know, when I didn't see that coming, something happens in life, a betrayal job. You get, you know, let go.
Noah Rasheta [00:15:50] And also with good things. We talked about this earlier, how you can be going through your Whole life. And then you go to a recital and you watch something like, what is that kind of dance? And now you're on a trajectory to learn a whole new style of dance. And that becomes the junction point for a new chapter.
Noah Rasheta [00:16:08] So from the Buddhist perspective, we're always playing in that realm of uncertainty. You don't know what piece is going to show up next. And that, I think is really at the core of what you would say is the Buddhist worldview compared to other frameworks and other worldviews, is that you're playing a game of Tetris and you don't know what's coming next. There is no game to win.
Noah Rasheta [00:16:32] It's an element of uncertainty and skill. What do I do when that piece arrives? How skillfully can I maneuver and use it, knowing that another piece is coming and none of them are good or bad. They are just what they are.
John Dehlin [00:16:49] Yeah. And you talk about suffering. I think I remember you saying how what would it be like if the missionaries for Buddhism knocked on the door and said, we have a special message for you today. Our message is that life is suffering. I mean, that doesn't sound like a very compelling pitch, but as someone who's worked in the mental health field, it turns out that trying to eliminate suffering, or the expectation that suffering can be eliminated from. From life, can and often does become its own source of suffering. Right?
Noah Rasheta [00:17:33] Absolutely. So I would say it's.
John Dehlin [00:17:36] It's.
Noah Rasheta [00:17:37] So that's the distinction between what's natural and what's unnecessary and suffering. Life is hard. Thinking that it's not supposed to be hard is part of what makes it even harder now.
Margi Dehlin [00:17:48] That's right.
John Dehlin [00:17:48] And it's unbearable. Right. Yeah.
Margi Dehlin [00:17:50] Which that reminds me of. Second arrow.
Noah Rasheta [00:17:52] Yeah.
Margi Dehlin [00:17:52] Right. Because. Which. That was my lead in.
John Dehlin [00:17:55] Yeah. That's your segue.
Margi Dehlin [00:17:56] I don't know how. Yeah.
Noah Rasheta [00:17:57] So one of the core teachings in Buddhism is a story of the first and second arrow. And the first arrow is whatever life hits you with. You know, I'm stuck at a red light. I don't want to be stuck at a red light. That discomfort, that's the pain of a first arrow. Sickness, old age, death, all the things that life can throw your way in the form of surprises. Those are first arrows. And then you have the second arrow, which is, how do I handle the pain of the first arrow? Because now I'm looking at that pain thinking, why did this happen to me? I don't deserve this. I've been doing this and avoiding that. And now that's a whole new element of Suffering.
John Dehlin [00:18:36] And so. And so doesn't have that arrow that I have. And why did they not get the arrow? But I have the arrow that I have.
Noah Rasheta [00:18:43] Exactly right. Yeah. And that's a very real distinct form of suffering. It's real, but it's also unnecessary. If you could handle the pain of the first arrow skillfully, you don't need the pain of the second arrow. But we unintentionally do that to ourselves all the time. And Buddhism comes in as a tool that's trying to help you understand and distinguish between what is the pain of a first arrow versus the pain of a second, or, let's be honest, third, fourth, fifth, sixth arrow that you pile on. And it really does get more painful, but it's unnecessary. You could just stick with the pain of the first arrow. One way is knowing, like you said, an analogy that I've used before.
John Dehlin [00:19:28] If.
Noah Rasheta [00:19:29] If you were getting ready to go on a hike and I warned you, hey, on this trail, there are people dressed in bear costumes and they love to jump out and scare you. Well, now you know, and you're on your trail, and still someone will jump out. It'll startle you, but then you're like, okay, knew that this would happen. And you can deal more skillfully with that fear you're experiencing if you didn't know that at all. You're just on this trail, and every now and then someone jumps out to scare you. And in that moment of panic, you run and you trip and you fall down the ravine, and now you broke your arm, and, like, you're making it all worse because of how you're handling the fear.
Noah Rasheta [00:20:04] So that's one way to think of this. Like the Buddha's coming and saying, hey, life is like this journey you're on where things are going to jump out and they're going to scare you.
John Dehlin [00:20:12] So.
Noah Rasheta [00:20:13] And you thinking that that means something's wrong. Because I should be on this journey and nothing should ever scare me. Everything should go my way, and I shouldn't be experiencing any suffering. That's part of what makes the suffering so much more unbearable. I like thinking about that. Because then the next thing, next time this happens, and you listening now, one of you, somewhere, statistically, boom, you have a flat tire and you're going to smile and be like, I knew this might happen. That's the nature of reality. Things happen. What do we do with those things when they happen? That's the essence of the toolkit that Buddhism's trying to give you. It's like, let's look at the toolkit and the skills that can help you to navigate those moments more skillfully.
John Dehlin [00:20:59] Yeah. Yeah. I'm thinking of, like, you. The power goes out, and your alarm doesn't go off, so you're late for your flight, but because you're so distressed and late for your flight, you start driving crazy, and then you get pulled over. And so the first arrow was the fact that your power went out and you got up late, but you added the suffering to that by freaking out about it and then allowing yourself to engage in behaviors that actually just compounded the pain and suffering and made it worse. Yeah.
Noah Rasheta [00:21:36] I like to think of it. It can be as simple as, no matter what you're going through right now in life, you could make it worse.
Margi Dehlin [00:21:44] Let's not do that.
Noah Rasheta [00:21:44] Let's not make it worse.
Margi Dehlin [00:21:46] That's right.
Noah Rasheta [00:21:46] And that's where you can pause and say, well, how could I make it worse? Okay, I'm gonna avoid all the things that could make it worse.
Margi Dehlin [00:21:52] And resistance. I feel like resistance to the first arrow, suffering is such a basic way that I. Second arrow is just resisting the first arrow. It's like, okay, where did that happen? Okay, I'm not gonna do that thing again that led to that thing. You know what I mean?
John Dehlin [00:22:12] Or.
Margi Dehlin [00:22:12] I don't know. I think for me, resistance is as opposed to just leaning in for a moment and just accepting, like, oh, no, this is what's happening right now. This is what it feels like to live this moment right now. And I can be skillful, you know, but if I'm choosing to be skillful about what to do about that thing, it's in. It is. With acceptance first. It's not reactive, trying to get rid of it.
Acceptance, Reality, and Living with Uncertainty
Noah Rasheta [00:22:41] Yeah. And acceptance is not resignation.
Margi Dehlin [00:22:44] Right.
Noah Rasheta [00:22:44] And it's also. It doesn't mean you like it either.
Margi Dehlin [00:22:46] That's right.
Noah Rasheta [00:22:47] It's. Acceptance is saying, this is what is.
Margi Dehlin [00:22:50] That's right. Reality.
Noah Rasheta [00:22:51] My alarm didn't go off. I'm going to be late for the flight. Now how do I deal skillfully with what's next? That might mean be careful to not speed, because I'll get a ticket if I do. So. Yeah. I love acceptance as the understanding of what am I actually dealing with. And let's not be delusional about it, you know, because sometimes we. We make the mistake of thinking acceptance means I have to like it, or acceptance means I have to. I'm giving up and just whatever life throws my way. No, no, no. There's a. There's a. A skillful engagement with whatever happens next. Because life never pauses. So it's like, here's what happened. Let's acknowledge this is what is. That's acceptance. Now what do we do?
John Dehlin [00:23:33] Yeah. And, and then I, my, my critical brain says, oh, but if you go through life just expecting there to always be suffering, then you're, you're just viewing life as a bad thing. Because all life is the suffering. And, and that's where we started with life is the lotus flower, is everything. But let's flip it. Let's just say you hate the mud and you're tired of being in mud and you think mud is gross. And then you look up and you notice, well, look at that beautiful flower growing out of the mud. Right. Life isn't just the mud. No, but. So it's okay to say life has mud. Absolutely, because life also has the pond and the lotus flower. And you don't get the lotus flower in the pond and the scenery without the mud.
Noah Rasheta [00:24:22] I think it's a matter of training the mind to see, yes, this is what is. And what else is there? What do I not notice? That's where the magic happens. There's so much happening right now that you would be very grateful for, but you're just not aware of it. Like, I don't have a toothache. Did you think about the fact you don't have a toothache? No, probably not. Because I'll think about that when I do have the toothache and then I'm grateful that the toothache went away. But what about all the time that right now you're not experiencing a toothache? That could be the impetus for gratitude that I don't have a toothache, or I'm glad I'm not in prison, or I'm glad, you know, and that can happen in spite of the discomfort of what you are dealing with.
Noah Rasheta [00:25:01] Like, I woke up late, my alarm didn't go off, now I might miss my flight. Yes. All that's happening, that's inconvenient, that produces feelings of anxiety and fear. What happens if I miss my flight? Those are all natural, normal things to experience under these circumstances. But what else is there? Well, at least, at least I'm able to. I have a job that's giving me the opportunity for this flight to. I don't know, I don't know where we're going, if this is vacation or work, but at least if I do make the flight, it's a flight and not a six month buggy handcart journey. Or, you know, there's always more to it that through awareness, then you start to feel, yes, I feel this, but also, what else is there?
Noah Rasheta [00:25:50] That's very important because we're not trying to suppress or replace any feelings and emotions. We're trying to increase our awareness and realize there's just much more to it.
Margi Dehlin [00:26:02] That kind of reminds me, too, of the idea of, you hear a lot. The truth, singular, the truth. Or this is reality. And I really love what this is bringing out, which is like, this is a reality, right. One reality, but it's simultaneously. There are all these other realities. Like, my leg's not hurting, I'm eating a really good banana and I'm late. Or, you know what I mean? And same with truth. This is a truth I may be feeling, but there are also a lot of other, like, truths at the same time that are occurring simultaneously and sometimes are opposing, may seemingly oppose. Does that make sense?
Noah Rasheta [00:26:46] Yeah, absolutely. I feel like the. It's holding space for multiple things being true at once. Like you said, my legs hurt, but I'm enjoying the flavor of the banana.
John Dehlin [00:26:59] It's.
Noah Rasheta [00:27:00] Parenting is difficult, but I love being a parent. It's. I'm going through a divorce, and that's very hard. And yet I'm grateful for all of the beautiful memories we created. I'm wrestling with doubt about my belief system, and yet gratitude for the memories I have growing up in that belief system. It's like there can be multiple things can be true.
John Dehlin [00:27:27] Yeah.
Margi Dehlin [00:27:29] So
John Dehlin [00:27:32] one final thing about acceptance, and I can look at it from the acceptance commitment therapy lens. There was an ACT researcher and therapist who came out with a book called the Happiness Trap. And a lot of ACT research is around anxiety disorders, scrupulosity, obsessive compulsive disorder, post traumatic stress disorder.
John Dehlin [00:27:52] And a lot of those conditions can develop or become exacerbated simply by thinking that the purpose of life is to be happy. And so I was thinking about when you had your rupture in your marriage that you talked about last episode. Everyone go back and watch Noah's first episode to get the most out of this episode.
John Dehlin [00:28:15] I thought it was curious that at one point your reaction was, well, I need to be the best Mormon I can be. Because if I become the best Mormon that I can be, I'm clearly slacking. But if I really dial up my Mormonism, well, then I'll have the marriage that I want, and then I'll be happy. But that's a trap, because no matter what. Well, tell us why that's a trap. Why happiness can become its own trap. Pursuit, the pursuit of happiness becomes its own trap.
Noah Rasheta [00:28:41] Yeah, well, at the heart of it is it's, again, you think you're playing chess and life is a game to be won. And how do you win it? By being happy and avoiding suffering. But that's just not the nature of the game that we're playing. Tetris pieces will show up. We're all going to experience moments of joy and happiness, but also moments of sadness and loss. Every single one of us is going to lose our loved ones at some point. We're all going to experience the full range of emotions that humans can experience and realizing that that's the nature of this game that we're in.
Noah Rasheta [00:29:18] If we even want to call it a game, or the journey that we're on, or the ride, the roller coaster, however you want to think of it, what do we do with that? How do we navigate it skillfully? I think that's a much more useful framework to look at it like, okay, you're on the ride.
Noah Rasheta [00:29:36] Whatever your belief is of why we're here, we're here. There's no denying that we're here. What do I do with this time? We know that it's short. Do we know what happens after? I mean, you might think, you know, but there's an element of uncertainty. What if you're wrong? The point is, what we do know is how are we handling the time that we have while we're here? How can I live this skillfully? And I think it's really useful to stick with that overall perspective of stuff is going to happen.
Noah Rasheta [00:30:06] How do I handle the piece when it does show up? Are there skillful or unskillful ways? Ways I could make things better or make things worse? Yes, absolutely. And then try to navigate that skillfully. So something I wanted to go to with suffering.
Natural vs. Unnecessary Suffering
Noah Rasheta [00:30:26] It's important to understand there are different kinds of suffering, like an oversimplification. We could say natural and unnecessary or unnatural. The suffering. In Buddhist terms, you've got three. You've got the suffering of suffering, which is pain. You stub your toe. Yeah, it hurts.
Noah Rasheta [00:30:45] You break a limb. It hurts when you break a limb. Then you have the suffering of loss, the loss of your hopes and dreams, career, loss of a loved one. It hurts. When you experience loss, that's natural as well. Then you have all pervasive suffering, which is there's this underlying something doesn't feel right, that one you can look at and often identify. It's there because of an unskillful view or belief. So going Back to what you started with the. In my case, it's like, oh, I need to be a more devout believer. That's the root.
Noah Rasheta [00:31:24] That is a whole new layer of suffering that's there because of the belief that this happened in the first place because I wasn't righteous enough. That is a form of suffering. It's going to be all pervasive because as long as the belief is there, the suffering will be there. I didn't do enough, or I didn't do it right, or I'm not good enough, or whatever the belief is.
Noah Rasheta [00:31:46] And that's the one that I think we really want to spend time with as practitioners on a path like this. Like, where did that come from? Where's that view coming from? Where did. Who gave you that belief? Why is it there? Why haven't you questioned it? What if that's not how life works? And as you sit with that process of.
Noah Rasheta [00:32:04] I like to call it curiosity, but you could say that process of questioning, what you might find is, maybe this isn't how things are. And as the belief morphs, then the suffering that was attached to it morphs. And again, on a very oversimplified analogy here would be if you're someone who believes in ghosts at night, when you hear sounds in your home, the fear that you have that this might be a ghost, that's a very real fear, but it only exists because you're afraid of ghosts. If you were to take the time and study and understand the nature of how wood reacts when humidity and temperature changes at night, like, oh, the creaking in the house is.
Noah Rasheta [00:32:49] My 1908 house creaks. Maybe it's not ghost. The fear of ghosts goes away because I don't believe in ghosts. That's, again, oversimplifying it, but the connection of a belief and the suffering attached to the belief. We have a lot of beliefs.
Noah Rasheta [00:33:07] A lot of them are very unskillful. And I'm not talking big supernatural beliefs. I'm talking what do you believe about yourself? How you should or shouldn't be, who you should or shouldn't be. Those are beliefs that lead in a very real way to forms of suffering that might not be necessary. Suffering.
John Dehlin [00:33:26] What it means to be a good person, what it means to be a man, what it means to be a woman, what it means to be a success in the world, Right?
Noah Rasheta [00:33:33] Yes.
John Dehlin [00:33:34] Those things can be chains, right?
Noah Rasheta [00:33:36] Yes. And that is the realm where I feel a lot of these tools that you'll encounter in Buddhism are extremely beneficial for the average, ordinary Experience of being a human like we all are, a collection of our beliefs and views and opinions, and that view that we have of ourselves and others can lead to a lot of unnecessary suffering.
John Dehlin [00:34:02] Yeah. So in that vein, acceptance, commitment, therapy has this idea of diffusion where labels and stories and even emotions are all potentially fraught with baggage. And we tend to think my story's real or my feelings are true or this label of who I am or who I think I am or who I was told I should be, that's real. And what we need to practice in skillful living is trying to either hold those things loosely or to even develop a distance between your conscious, observer self and these labels and stories and emotions that you feel really invested in. Because they might be the chains that are holding you back.
Noah Rasheta [00:35:02] Exactly. Yeah. Who you are and how you are are two different things. And we often make the mistake that how I am is who I am. And in my own. In my own journey, one of the most painful experiences that I went through was the collapse of my company and having to file bankruptcy.
Noah Rasheta [00:35:23] And as I was going through this whole process, I was having panic attacks. And then I had to get medicine to help with the panic attacks. And then I had anxiety about the potential of another panic attack. And it was a very difficult stage. And I remember thinking, why? Why is this so painful? We're not dying. We're all going to survive this.
Noah Rasheta [00:35:44] And through Buddhist practice and really sitting with introspection, what I came to understand is, oh, I fused my sense of identity with the label of I'm an entrepreneur. So I'm right now failing as an entrepreneur. My company is failing, which means I'm failing because my sense of identity had
John Dehlin [00:36:02] been fused with that label or that you're a failure.
Noah Rasheta [00:36:05] Yes. You're a failure. And of course, if you feel you're a failure, you're going to have existential angst and anxiety attacks and all the things. And it wasn't an instant fix. I mean, I still went through this process of all the inconvenience and difficulties of a collapsed business and bankruptcy and all that that entails.
John Dehlin [00:36:27] I remember as your friend, when you were driving a school bus.
Noah Rasheta [00:36:30] Yes.
John Dehlin [00:36:31] After your business failed. Yeah. I'm like, no, Rasheta. Whoa, man. I'm so. You know, I always respected you, so I didn't pity you, but I'm just like, dang, that's kind of cool. That, like, he's. And you had a really good attitude about it, in my opinion. I think you really enjoyed that.
Noah Rasheta [00:36:47] I did. That was actually a Very intentional choice. Because when I realized, oh, my sense of identity has fused with this label, I'm an entrepreneur. Well, what does that mean? Well, oh, I have all these beliefs around what an entrepreneur is, what they do, what they don't do. And I was able to identify almost in a. It's embarrassing to even admit, but, like, I had this worldview constructed around what that means.
Noah Rasheta [00:37:14] And I thought, well, I wouldn't drive a school bus. Cause at the moment, that felt like, well, here's a quick fix. We're going through all this until the dust settles. Keep doing something. It's like, ooh. But an entrepreneur doesn't do that. And I remember thinking, that's the view right there. It is. That's the unskillful belief I have. So I thought, well, then I'm going to do it to prove to myself and make it public.
Noah Rasheta [00:37:40] This is just what I do. It's not who I am. And that was a very deliberate choice. That, again, I'm almost embarrassed to even have to admit that my ego thought, you shouldn't do this. It's like, well, then I'm going to do it.
Noah Rasheta [00:37:56] And I did, and I enjoyed it. And it did get us through that period of time where once the dust settled, and it's like, well, what do you want to keep doing with your life? I didn't want to do that.
Noah Rasheta [00:38:06] So I was done doing that, and I moved on to other things. But then it was. It was different. From that moment on, I realized that who I am and what I do are two different things, and I can do anything.
Noah Rasheta [00:38:19] If the configuration of life in that moment is, I'm going to drive a school bus or I'm going to whatever, I can do that. Because that's just how I am right now, not who I am. And that actually helped me moving forward into other entrepreneurial ventures. Later, the fear of failure was gone because I realized, well, I. I didn't fail that particular business model or that product or whatever that failed. And that's okay. But I didn't fail. I'm. I'm the. I'm. What I do not.
John Dehlin [00:38:51] That's.
Noah Rasheta [00:38:51] You know what I mean?
John Dehlin [00:38:52] Yeah. We had this super gnarly lawsuit a few years ago that cost half a million dollars and two and a half years of deep anguish. And to be honest, I listened to secular Buddhism at nights when I was ruminating and I couldn't sleep. I would listen to secular Buddhism as just a way to try and stop my rumination, but also to get, you know, to learn tips and tricks to more skillfully navigate. And this is after I'd absorbed Eckhart Tolle. But I just needed the practice of remembering these principles and.
John Dehlin [00:39:30] And applying them. So I. So this is like gifts being exchanged between friends without even friends knowing. But anyway, my point is, I'm. I'm in my basement listening to secular Buddhism, suffering about this lawsuit that I'm in. And I remember thinking, well, there is one.
John Dehlin [00:39:52] There's one possible silver lining, and that's that now that I. Now that I've been through it, if I ever get sued again, I don't think it's going to be quite as bad the second time. And sure enough, the church chose to sue us this year. And everybody's like, are you okay? Are you okay? And, you know, it's never fun to be sued, but it's a totally different world having been through a lawsuit where it's just like, oh, yeah, we'll be all right. We've been through way worse than this. Yeah, it's true. I'm not trying to minimize. You know, it's serious. We want to win. You know, it's.
John Dehlin [00:40:26] It's expensive and inconvenient, but it's a totally different ballgame. And that's why we think we might be doing ourselves a favor by avoiding pain or suffering or challenges or difficulty. Or even worse, we think we might be helping our kids by removing from them discomfort or even pain or failure. When sometimes pain or failure or significant discomfort is the gift.
Noah Rasheta [00:40:57] Exactly.
John Dehlin [00:40:58] Right.
Noah Rasheta [00:40:58] Yeah. Yeah. I think our inability to sit with discomfort is the root of a whole lot of unnecessary suffering. And if we could just realize that, yeah, life entails difficulty. Sometimes it's you're stuck at a red light. Sometimes it's your business failed, Sometimes it's you're being sued.
Noah Rasheta [00:41:17] Sometimes it's your marriage collapsed or whatever it is. Life happens. And that's not to say, well, then I'll just float through life and let whatever happens happen. This is going back to Chess and Tetris. It feels like there's a little combo of the two, because I understand I could make everything worse if I go try to rob a bank right now and then I'm in prison, it's like, well, I shouldn't have robbed the bank. Right.
Noah Rasheta [00:41:47] And not just on the negative side, but there's positive things. I could go do this. I could go plant a tree. Well, that tree might then start to provide fruit. Right? Like, yes, we have stuff that we can do. We can navigate life skillfully making skillful choices or unskillful choices. But overall, there's no way to escape suffering. Life will entail an element of suffering or dissatisfaction or unsatisfactoriness. However we want to phrase that.
Noah Rasheta [00:42:16] And just knowing that can be all the difference. So that when that Tetris piece hits, instead of, why me? You could just be like, this is a Tetris piece. That's what I'm dealing with. It won't be like this forever. One day this lawsuit will end and I'll look back on it. I remember the first time I had an experiential understanding of that. Like, for years, I had been thinking, okay, that's how it works. I've already had a big Tetris piece.
Noah Rasheta [00:42:42] I didn't have the tools back when that happened. So that was really hard. Now I'm going through another one. That was the bankruptcy, right? And then the next one that hit, that was another big one, was when my dad passed away. He had cancer, and it was his last few days. We knew it's imminent now, and I got to go spend that time with him, with my brothers as well.
Noah Rasheta [00:43:04] And watching the process of someone dying is a precious experience if you allow it to be. And as we sat there with gratitude for all of the memories and all of the good, and you sit there with this unmeasurable amount of love that you have for this person, and then the moment comes and they're gone, and you have this heaviness and weight. That's it. That's the end of the chapter. That particular person is no longer part of my story. And that's heavy and it's sad. And I remember feeling all the weight of the loss of a loved one and crying.
Noah Rasheta [00:43:41] But I felt no aversion to what I was feeling. And that's when it occurred to me, that's what these teachings are hinting at. It's not saying, you're not going to suffer, but you don't have to make it worse by experiencing what you're experiencing while not wanting to experience what you're experiencing. And in this case, I had no aversion to the discomfort of loss. Like, yeah, I lost my dad. Of course I'm crying. This feels horrible. I wish he was still here. Like, but what I don't wish is that I wasn't feeling this. I felt like I could be unapologetic. Sometimes we feel heavy emotions or we get sentimental, and what's the first thing we do?
Noah Rasheta [00:44:18] Oh, sorry. Sorry to put you through the discomfort of seeing the real me here. And in that moment, it was like, this is what is acceptance, right? Like this is what is. And it carries all the weight and heaviness that I would expect it to carry. Because I'm losing a loved one and I'm. And what else is there? And I'm so grateful for the time and the memories and the inside jokes and all the things right? And there was room for both.
Noah Rasheta [00:44:47] And the gratitude and happiness didn't replace or minimize the hurt and the sorrow. It just, it's like the room suddenly got much bigger. Yes, I'm feeling all this pain and suffering and there's a whole lot more in here. And ever since that experience with my dad, carrying into other life moments, including my divorce, it's like there are moments of heaviness and yes, all these feelings are here, but what are the other feelings that are there? It's, it expands the room. The only way I can describe that, that to me is like the real benefit of a practice. Like what you would gain from Buddhism as a practice is that's where you feel it in real life.
Noah Rasheta [00:45:32] Because real life is happening and real life happens in moments of loss and heartbreak and joy and love and newness, like it's all of it. And expanding the room to notice and appreciate everything that's happening at any given moment. That to me is the real beauty of it.
Mindfulness and Meditation Demystified
John Dehlin [00:45:51] So this is something I want to bring you in on, Margi as well. I want to introduce the concepts of mindfulness and meditation. I have a racing brain and part of how I've always managed that is by just staying really busy because if I'm sitting alone with my thoughts, they become kind of tyrannical and I get really uncomfortable. So once I was told, oh, you need to meditate to be healthy, I would sit there and say, okay, well I want to be healthy, so I better meditate. And I would do it with this idea that I'd see the picture of someone achieving some Zen state under a tree while they meditate.
John Dehlin [00:46:28] So I'd sit there thinking that if I do it right, then I'll achieve a Zen state. And what really happens is my brain just gets full of noise and I get frustrated because I'm not feeling anything. But instead I'm trying to clear my brain and achieve a Zen state and kind of like the happiness trap. The more I try and be serene and clear minded and, and peaceful, the more disruption it feels. And then I feel like this sucks and I hate it and I don't meditate, you know, but once I was learning act, I was realizing that it's not. And I'm just. This is just a kickoff.
John Dehlin [00:47:06] And Margi. I know Margi meditates for 30 minutes, an hour a morning, every morning, and I want to hear Margi talk about that. But the one thing that I remember learning in act is that, okay, if thoughts can be changed and labels can be changed and stories can be changed and emotions can be chains, well, then how do you create distance from yourself and those things so that you don't become them, you don't become fused with your identity or fused with your anger or fused with your story, you know, whatever.
John Dehlin [00:47:40] And that's what meditation is supposed to be. Developing a sense of your conscious self and who you are so that you can start to create a distance between you and your emotions, or you and your thoughts, or you and your story, or you and your labels.
John Dehlin [00:48:00] So that's a kicking off point for you, helping us understand what is the role of mindfulness. What is mindfulness? What is meditation? If it's not trying to achieve a Zen state through sitting quiet, what is it? And how does it help? And then, Margi, I would love to hear your story about how you started meditating and what it's come to mean for you. Great, yeah.
Noah Rasheta [00:48:28] Do you want me to start with, from my perspective, before Margi's story? Okay. So in the, in the Buddhist tradition, mindfulness is one of many skills and mindfulness is one of many forms of meditation. In the west, we've kind of. We use them interchangeably, like mindfulness meditation, Zen.
Noah Rasheta [00:48:51] But if you were to look at these through the tradition, they're. They're different sets of skills. Mindfulness is the non judgmental observation of the present moment. It's the ability to notice what's happening and not get carried into the story of what that means.
Noah Rasheta [00:49:09] At the core of Buddhist meditation, meditative practices, you have two overall approaches. And I would explain or describe them. Like imagine a flashlight, the kind of flashlight that you can twist and adjust the beam. One beam is broad and wide and it illuminates more space, and the other one is narrow but intense, and it really illuminates whatever you're shining at.
Noah Rasheta [00:49:35] Those are kind of the two overarching techniques. And then within that spectrum, you would have countless techniques, right? But they're usually doing one of those two things. So if you now picture your mind and your mind is kind of this space that a lot of experience is happening at any given moment. For example, like I mentioned before, the non toothache is an experience that you're having that you Might not be aware of unless someone tells you, hey, you're, you know, oh, that's right, I'm not experiencing a toothache. But then there's experience that you are aware of. I'm dealing with the loss of a loved one or whatever.
Noah Rasheta [00:50:10] The thing is, when your attention gets hyper fixated on the thing that's that you're experiencing and is not aware of everything else that's happening, that's where the technique of the wider flashlight, that technique of meditation might be what's useful for that person at that stage of life. Like, yes, but what else is there?
Noah Rasheta [00:50:34] Then you might have someone who maybe your mind races a lot and it's always jumping from one thing to another and you struggle with the ability to sit with one particular feeling long enough to gain any insight from it. And I do want to preface this by saying there's nothing wrong with whatever the configuration of your mind is. The mind is doing what the mind does the way the heart does what the heart does. And if we were to approach the heart and be like, oh, I want to control how much it beats, like, that's not the role here. Right? The heart does what the heart does.
Noah Rasheta [00:51:05] But you may have the need to implement a medicine or something to slow it down because it's always racing. The mind is the same. The mind, there's not a wrong configuration. There's just your configuration. And when you understand what yours is, then you can work with, how do I work skillfully with my mind?
Noah Rasheta [00:51:30] So I say that because sometimes people will approach these meditative practices and think, well, what this person's doing that's working for them, that must work for me. And that's not how it works. It's first you try to understand yourself and then you can have your series of skillful behaviors or techniques that are for you because you know you.
Noah Rasheta [00:51:54] So with the racing mind as the example, and let's say what you're trying to develop is the ability to sit with a thought a little longer than you normally would. Then that meditative technique might be the flashlight that's intense, narrow beam that's saying everything's racing. But I want to focus on this one thing for a moment and sit with it long enough to see, is there anything insight I can gain from that?
Noah Rasheta [00:52:20] And again, we don't need to do that with everything. But sometimes think of the scenario of someone who's dealing with loss and their propensity is, let's immediately push that under the rug and move on and stay busy. They might never gain any clarity or insight from the experience they had of that loss because they just can't sit with the discomfort of it long enough.
Noah Rasheta [00:52:42] In that case, that person might need the technique where let's just sit and observe your breath for a moment, like really pay attention to it. And then when your mind wanders, you come back to the breath. And the whole point of the technique is not that you stuck with the breath, it's that you came back. So if for you that took in 10 minutes, I got distracted 10,000 times, well then the repetition was 10,000 times, you came back to the breath. That means that's great, I love that.
Noah Rasheta [00:53:11] And what you would gain with that particular practice over time is if you can continually come back to the thing you're trying to focus on. Then when you have a mind that's always racing and you want to be able to stick with one particular thing, you can come back to it. And it might, maybe it was 10,000 times and then over months now it's a thousand times and it can get better. But the fact that you would always have a racing mind, you'll probably always have a racing mind because that's the configuration of how your mind works.
Noah Rasheta [00:53:43] So but that kind of starts to give you an idea of there are different techniques, they're not all for everyone. And understanding yourself is a huge part of the puzzle here because then you might want to focus on a technique that's going to be skillful for you instead of just saying, here's one particular practice, mindfulness, for example, and oh, I guess I need to sit and be mindful. That might not work for a whole lot of people because that's not the technique that was going to be useful for you. Does that make sense?
John Dehlin [00:54:15] So the plain definition of mindfulness is
Noah Rasheta [00:54:19] mindfulness is the non judgmental observation of the present moment.
John Dehlin [00:54:25] And then meditation is.
Noah Rasheta [00:54:27] Meditation would be the larger definition of the series of practices that you put into place to be able to see reality more clearly. And there are different ones, different names for the different techniques. Mindfulness is a form of meditation.
John Dehlin [00:54:45] Beautiful. And then, Margi, are you comfortable sharing a little bit about your dad's passing and your beginning of your practice of meditation, what it meant to you then and what it's come to mean for you now?
Margi Dehlin [00:55:01] I mean, I am comfortable doing that, but can I. I also wanted to ask Noah a couple questions really quickly and add something. So a meditation teacher I really like, his name's Jeff Warren, he co wrote a book called Meditation for Fidgety Skeptics.
Noah Rasheta [00:55:20] Anyway, I Like that title.
Margi Dehlin [00:55:22] Yeah. When you were talking about this idea of coming back to your breath and people can view it as a failure, that they are distracted. But you were saying, but you could reframe that, that you came back to your breath, all that. He has a meditation. And he talks about this experience that he has around his meditation teacher, recognizing his brain. He has adhd. His brain is like kind of all over the place. He experiences adhd, but he. And he noticed he was on a walk with her, and when he would really be listening, she'd be like, there you are. And so for a meditation, there's that idea of, like, when you come back round, or, you know, because we all have thoughts and amidst meditation, but when you come back, that's what you say.
Margi Dehlin [00:56:11] It's just so endearing. There you are. But you're saying it to yourself, oh, there you are. So I thought that was just a sweet way of kind of what you were saying too. A little phrase.
Noah Rasheta [00:56:20] I like that.
Margi Dehlin [00:56:22] When you find yourself kind of in our. Aware of yourself again. Okay, so you had asked me about a grief meditation.
Personal Journeys into Meditation and Grief
John Dehlin [00:56:32] How you started meditating, why you started meditating, and what you have gained from it and what it means to you now.
Margi Dehlin [00:56:44] Okay, well, how about I do a bit of that and then I ask Noah some, because I'm really curious also about your practice. But I did. I said, I really relate to your story. And I started meditating at a time when I was feeling incredible suffering. A number of towers of mine, including my dad's death, all kind of were going down at once and I needed help and I started reading books. I got into, let's see, I. Tara Brak and Thich Nhat Hanh. And I started doing yoga and was kind of really at the heart of it, just trying to manage suffering.
Margi Dehlin [00:57:29] But what I did immediately, and I had started before my dad's death a bit. But, you know, my dad was a beautiful being, really important to me in my life. Sorry, I always cry when I talk about him.
Margi Dehlin [00:57:45] But I also was able to watch him die. And I'm grateful for that. But he left, you know, a lot of love, a lot of suffering, a lot of loss right on the other side. So I started. I was already meditating, but I started doing grief actual meditation. It was the first time I actually tried to have an intention just because I was feeling so many things and I didn't quite know what to do with it. So anyway, for about a year, I would say, after his death, I did different forms of meditations. They weren't all the same, but it was kind of around processing the loss of a physical person that I really loved.
Margi Dehlin [00:58:35] And that was really valuable to me. And it was a place where I could really feel and be alone. And it changed so much for me, just that sitting sometimes. I also did a meditation that I think Desmond Tutu had brought up where you create a space and you go, and it's like an imaginary place in your mind, and you go and you see your person, you imagine. So I would imagine my. My dad walking into a cabin, and I can tell you everything about the cabin. And I had it smell a certain way, and he would come out and I would talk to him in my mind, like he was real about what I missed about him or, you know, and it was so beautiful.
Margi Dehlin [00:59:24] It was just. I think it really helped me process in a super tangible way. And there were other ways I had to process too. But I think what resulted from that processing, of course, leaning into something, suffering, not being averse to it, was that it had space in my day, and it allowed me a space to honor a reality and a process that was truly happening, you know, but it also, for whatever reason, also helped me with the rest of my day.
Margi Dehlin [00:59:57] And that was just, you know, not that I wouldn't cry or do other things, but it gave this space for feeling that then in the end, I was able to kind of live in a way that was unexpected for the time. It didn't remove the pain, but because I had processed and given it space, it didn't, like, rear its head in ways that I don't know.
Margi Dehlin [01:00:20] And it also just changed. It changed a lot about me. It changed the way I lived, how I spent my time, relationships I had. It was like a clarifier, that grief in that time, which was unexpected. So that was.
Margi Dehlin [01:00:40] That's my experience of sort of a particular type of meditation after my dad died. So. But I was curious for you if, like, is there, do you practice meditation? And if you do, is there, you know, is there a type that works well for you, like what your personal experience is in practicing meditation just with your brain?
Noah Rasheta [01:01:09] Yeah.
John Dehlin [01:01:10] Can I say that was beautiful. So thank you.
Margi Dehlin [01:01:12] Yeah, thanks.
Noah Rasheta [01:01:12] Yeah, that was very beautiful. Thank you for sharing. And those moments of sharing things that are authentic and vulnerable have ripple effects. You know, anytime anyone is willing to show vulnerability of this is what I'm feeling, and I'm feeling it as I'm expressing it carries those ripples go out and makes everyone else feel like, I know, okay, we can do this. Yeah, we're all going through the experience of being humans, and that entails all of the emotions, including the suffering of loss. So thank you for sharing vulnerably.
Margi Dehlin [01:01:55] You're welcome.
Noah Rasheta [01:01:57] The. The most impactful form of meditation that I've done is also the meditation on death. I read early on in my entry into Buddhism. I read the Tibetan Book of the Living, and I remember a line in there that mentioned something to the effect, if you haven't thought about death often, then you're not truly living, or something to that effect.
Noah Rasheta [01:02:24] And I remember thinking, man, death is one of those things we don't want to think about, especially our close loved ones, our kids, our spouses. Like, we don't want to think about that. And it feels like we shouldn't. Like, oh, that's bad juju.
Noah Rasheta [01:02:41] But through that practice, I realized, you know what? I do want to think about it often. So it's difficult at first. And as you get used to it, it really does unlock something new because you gain this tremendous appreciation for the fact that it hasn't happened yet, because everything, everything is going to end. Everyone that we love is going to die. There's a story that I really love about a Buddhist monk who had his favorite mug. And someone asks him, like, well, that's your favorite mug, right? Yeah, that's my favorite. Are you afraid of what'll happen if you ever drop it or it breaks? And he says to me, this mug is already broken.
Noah Rasheta [01:03:24] That's the beauty of this mug, is I know it's going to break. I know that it'll either break before I die or after I die. At some point, this mug will be broken, and I'm appreciating that it hasn't yet. And then he uses his mug and
John Dehlin [01:03:42] he has some coffee.
Noah Rasheta [01:03:44] Yeah. And I thought about that one often with correlating it to this idea of thinking about death. Everything will end. Every relationship that we have will end your marriage. No matter how incredible and happy it is, it will end whether it's through death and old age or the chapters come to a close for one or both of you.
Noah Rasheta [01:04:06] And the beauty in it is recognizing. But today, it's what it is, and I'm happy with what it is. So I appreciate it for what it is, like the mug. And I've tried to carry that intention with me in my hobbies. Like, I like to paraglide. I won't be able to do that my whole life, but right now I can. So when I do it, there's this deep appreciation that I Get to do this.
Noah Rasheta [01:04:32] I remember feeling that in my relationships. My dad passed away, but my mom's still here. My mom has since remarried. In a way, I have another figure there that it's like, this is something new that I didn't. I never thought I would have another person that I've never known before, and yet now this is someone I love. You know, with my kids, that's probably the more difficult of the practice, like, to really think through. It could happen. It happens to people all the time.
Noah Rasheta [01:05:04] And for me, just sit there thinking, I hope it doesn't happen to me, but it could. Like, well, what would life look like if that happened? And you sit with that and the intensity of those feelings day after day. Because I've done this practice for years.
Noah Rasheta [01:05:21] And the result of it is every moment that I do have with them is like, this is great. Sure, there's still the discomfort of we're dealing with homework that should have been done earlier, but now we're all staying up late because, you know, there's all the things, but there's. Underlying all of that is the. My mug is not broken yet, but I view the mug as already broken. I view the relationship as already ended. I view people as already dead, but not yet.
Noah Rasheta [01:05:53] And we can forget it at times. But the longer you practice this particular technique with thinking about death, I do think it becomes an underlying feeling that's just always there reminding you that this could end any moment. Is this how you want this moment to be? If this was the last.
Noah Rasheta [01:06:11] And I can't tell you how many times that's shaped my relationship to the moment and allowing that moment to just be beautiful because it's still there, it exists. And like I said, it's not. Replacing it doesn't make that difficult moment of the frustration we're dealing with because homework wasn't done, that's still what that is. But underneath that, there's the. I get to deal with the frustration of homework. One day I won't get to deal with that because they grew up and they don't have homework or they died.
Noah Rasheta [01:06:41] And it's been a very powerful way to just experience a lot of appreciation for the present moment. So that's that one technique. Now, I would say in my personal practice, my meditative practice has evolved. I actually have on my website a course that's like 30 different meditation techniques. And the goal is sample them all and see what resonates for you with where you are in life right now.
Noah Rasheta [01:07:08] And for me, that's evolved over time. For A long time I sat with the very basic, like, bringing your awareness back to what you're paying attention to. And once I felt like I had a decent foundation of being able to bring my awareness to the object I'm trying to pay attention to, then I could start to explore things sitting with discomfort, those types of techniques, like, well, now let's go back and pick an event in life that I don't want to think about, but let's think about it. What led to that and being able to see what role did I play in that rather than just, here's something that happened to me.
Noah Rasheta [01:07:42] It's like, well, did I play a role in that? I don't know that I would have been able to analyze and study that if it wasn't for building up these different techniques. And then I've gone through multiple. Another one that's been super impactful for me that I did while I drove the school bus during that stage of time, was trying to always see not the thing, but what are the things that make the thing the thing. So the flower. Right.
Noah Rasheta [01:08:09] What are all the non flower elements? And I have had two super intense moments of. One was sitting in my living room and looking at the coffee table thinking, what did it take for this coffee table to be. And as I thought through the processes and I wonder where the tree grew and who cut that. I wonder who invented the glue that they use or the nails and then hammers. Like, suddenly my mind was thinking of.
Interdependence and the Eightfold Path
Noah Rasheta [01:08:36] It took all of space and time for this table to be sitting here in my room. And I've never paid attention to it. And I felt this deep connection to all things because I was looking at my coffee table. And then I had another experience like that.
John Dehlin [01:08:49] Most people have to take mushrooms to get that experience.
Noah Rasheta [01:08:52] Yeah, yeah. Meditation can do it. Um, another time I experienced that was in the school bus. And there's a period of time that you're waiting for the right time to start the first stop, because otherwise you're ahead or behind.
Noah Rasheta [01:09:07] And as I'm sitting there, I'm looking at all the buttons. I remember it was in the winter, so it was cold, and I had the heaters going. They're warming up the seats and I'm thinking about what? You know, this is a moment that's very overlooked in the. In the kids day. It's their first time on the bus and their interaction with me, if I'm smiling and I say good morning and call them by name, like that makes a difference.
Noah Rasheta [01:09:31] So I'm in that mindset of interdependence. Like, every connection matters. And then I start looking at the instrumentation panel and thinking of the levers that I just pushed to make the heaters work and how, because the bus is warm, they. They get to get on a cozy bus before they go sit in school. Like, and then the button, for whatever reason, as I thought through, what did it take for this button to be. And who invented the heater? And, like, where did the button come from? Like, that whole process took me. And this is short, right? I was, like, five minutes waiting to start my route.
Noah Rasheta [01:10:05] But in those five minutes, I had this deep sense of feeling interdependent and connected with the whole world and countries and cultures where all of this technology and pieces came from. And then in that, you know, I almost got emotional, and I was like, oop, sorry. Hit the microphone. As I, like, wiped the tear away. Like, okay, now it's time to drive the bus.
Noah Rasheta [01:10:29] I went and started the first route and opened the door, and the kid gets in. And I was like, I was just feeling so connected to every kid I picked up that day and to my bus and every button on the bus. And that was a neat experience that lasted for a while.
Margi Dehlin [01:10:44] I love that.
John Dehlin [01:10:46] Beautiful. So I don't know. Your website used to be secularbuddhism.com and then I think you rebranded to eightfoldpath.com and there's the Eightfold path. I'm guessing we've already started talking about some of the elements of it, but maybe with the time we have left, let's at least touch on a few of them that seem really useful. Is that okay?
Noah Rasheta [01:11:14] Yeah. So everything that we've talked about would fit somewhere within the framework. And if you still go to secular Buddhism.com that will land on the podcast page of the Eightfold Path. But the.
John Dehlin [01:11:27] And I can prompt you if you want prompts. Just tell me.
Noah Rasheta [01:11:30] Okay.
John Dehlin [01:11:30] Yeah.
Noah Rasheta [01:11:31] So with the Eightfold Path, we started with View, you also have your intent. Like, why do I do what I do? Why do I say what I say? Then you have what falls under ethical conduct, and that would be what you say. So speech, action, your livelihood.
Noah Rasheta [01:11:51] You have elements of wisdom and concentration, which would be mindfulness is one of those. Concentration, effort. Effort's one I'll stop on real quick. Because effort kind of correlates to something we talked about previously, and that is doing or not doing something is part of the puzzle. But how hard do you try? That's a whole nother part of the puzzle, and that's where effort kicks in. In the Eightfold Path, there's a whole section of the path that's just about understanding effort. Am I trying too hard or not hard enough? And there's a teaching that I really like about an instrument called the lute. So think of a stringed instrument.
Noah Rasheta [01:12:38] And the Buddha was asking for someone who was saying, how do I know if I'm trying too hard or not hard enough? And he talks about, with an instrument like this, you have to tune it. There has to be the correct amount of tension on the string. If it's just right, it plays music and it sounds great. If it's not, it doesn't sound good. Or if it's too tight, it could even break the strings.
Noah Rasheta [01:13:01] And that's how we're to view effort. And there's this notion in Buddhism called the Middle Way. And it's like, not too far this way and not too far the other way. But it's not a fixed answer. And I like the visual of a stringed instrument, because with a stringed instrument, it depends. You can play the song and then you put the guitar away, and then you take it out tomorrow. What do you have to do? Retune it, right? Like, you're always adjusting. Never too tight and never not tight enough, and you're never done. It's a process of introspection when you think about yourself and the effort that you put into how you're living your life.
Noah Rasheta [01:13:40] Effort in terms of your marriage, effort in terms of your career. These are all dynamics that you need to be exploring at all times. Am I trying too hard or not enough? And you never adjust it and think, now I'm done. It's like, okay, that's what's working for now. Let's revisit it this afternoon when we're all hungry, or tomorrow when some new Tetris piece showed up. You're always being introspective about trying too hard or not hard enough. And another way to think about that is if you ride a bicycle, mountain biking, for example, you're gripping the handlebars. There's the right amount of grip, right? Hold it too too tight and get too rigid.
Noah Rasheta [01:14:19] Your arms start to hurt, your hands hurt. But also letting go might not be the answer either. It might work for a little bit, but then you could haul off the bike. There's the right amount of grip, and it's constantly adjusting. It's different on an uphill. It's different if you're going off a jump. It's different if you're on a flat stretch.
Noah Rasheta [01:14:39] So that conversation around effort, I think is really useful with the Eightfold Path because effort correlates to every other aspect of the path. Meditation, for example, you might be in a stage of life where you're trying too hard. Quit trying to meditate, you're trying to stop your racing mind, and that's part of the suffering you're experiencing. So quit trying that. Don't do meditation, try something else. Meditation is one particular aspect or practice of the Eightfold Path. There are entire Buddhist traditions that don't even practice meditation. So I just wanted to speak to that with regard to effort and the middle way.
John Dehlin [01:15:20] Talk about. Right. Resolve.
Noah Rasheta [01:15:23] Resolve I'm not familiar with. So I know resolve is usually synonymous with either effort or intent. Because they're listed, the words might be slightly different in one tradition.
Margi Dehlin [01:15:39] Yeah, that term I haven't heard either.
Noah Rasheta [01:15:40] I don't think I've ever heard of.
Margi Dehlin [01:15:41] Right.
John Dehlin [01:15:42] Okay. Okay. Yeah. So there's different flavors.
Noah Rasheta [01:15:44] I'm guessing it could be intent.
Margi Dehlin [01:15:46] Yeah.
Noah Rasheta [01:15:46] Maybe just another the resolve of like, why are you doing what you're doing? So if it's intent that it's talking about with intent, again, it's having skillful action. What you do or you don't do, that's one thing, but another layer of it is why. Why are you doing what you're doing?
John Dehlin [01:16:05] Because it says, this explanation says cultivating wholesome and ethical intentions.
Noah Rasheta [01:16:12] Okay, so it is intention. Yeah. So let's just say if you were to think, be friendly, be nice as an action, but that doesn't always make sense, you know, Are you being nice? I'm being nice to you because I'm hoping to get something out of you. Well, now I realize there's nice action, but there's unskillful intent behind it. So intent correlates with action. You want to have action that minimizes suffering, but also motivated by intent. That's wholesome. Because sometimes you could have an unskillful intent that's driving what seems like a skillful action.
John Dehlin [01:16:55] I mean, I'm thinking about Mormonism, obviously. And it's like, don't drink caffeine or don't drink coffee or don't touch someone's breast before you're married. You know, it's very rules based.
Noah Rasheta [01:17:07] Yes.
John Dehlin [01:17:08] And this is a totally different way of looking at life. It. You may. You may end up deciding not to drink coffee or to touch someone's breast before you're married or whatever, but you get there in a very different way.
Noah Rasheta [01:17:24] Yes. So in Buddhism, you don't really have the notion of right and wrong in the moral sense of this is always right, this is always wrong. It's skillful means is the term and things are skillful or not skillful in context. Let's just say lying, for example. Yeah, you probably shouldn't lie. But if I'm back in time and I'm hiding a Jewish family in my attic and the Nazis come knocking and they say, are you hiding anyone? No, I'm not. I just lied.
Margi Dehlin [01:17:58] Right.
Noah Rasheta [01:17:59] But what is the intent behind it? So to just give it a blanket, it's always good or it's always bad. You always do this, never do that. It's just non existent in a world that's constantly changing. Interdependence and impermanence. So yes, I think skillful means and understanding intent. That's why intent has its own whole category. Like why are you lying in this case? Well, I'm lying to save a family hidden in the attic. Okay, then it's probably okay to lie at that point. Does that make sense?
Margi Dehlin [01:18:33] I was going to ask really quickly. It feels like there for me. I love practical and some of the ways that we've spoken today. Like, let's see the question around. Second arrow for me. Like am I second arrowing myself right now? How am I adding an arrow right now? Or you saying the question that prompt, what else is here? What else is here? Okay, so I'm having this experience of pain. What else is here? At the same time, are there prompts like that for eight? Like what's the practic? How do you make the Eightfold path practical? I guess. Are there ways that you implement, I guess or remember that are kind of like some of those prompts with Eightfold
Noah Rasheta [01:19:21] path or no, I'm sure there are. I'm not sure I could like just recall what they are because the Eightfold Path, they're like topics, Right. So you have these eight or eight domains that you want to be aware of in your life. And then within that domain it might be a whole collection of other teachings and ideas and some of those prompts. There might be many prompts that all fall within the realm of having more skillful view or right viewers. And I'm sure if I went through each one, I could probably identify a particular practice or a prompt that's relevant to that domain. But I'm inclined to think that most of them are probably centered around right view.
Noah Rasheta [01:20:05] Because the idea is if you can see clearly what's really there, then everything else will start to kind of fall in place and make more sense. That's why it's the starting point. Because if you can't see it clearly, everything else that you're dealing with at that point is blocked by your inability to see clearly. So let's say I'm wearing glasses that are a yellow tint. Everything I see is with the yellow tint. And you're experiencing a different reality. And it's like, until I can realize that I'm seeing. I see yellow because of how I see it. So it's not what I see, it's how I see that's the starting point.
Noah Rasheta [01:20:43] Like, well, of course I keep choosing this particular thing because I see everything as yellow. So it all starts with, well, how do you view? How do you see? What do you see? And that goes back to impermanence and interdependence. So a lot of the prompts are trying to get you to see the world as interdependent and as impermanent.
Margi Dehlin [01:21:06] I see. Yeah.
John Dehlin [01:21:08] What would you say to, let's just say an orthodox Mormon or religious person that's like, look too squishy. There's right and there's wrong. And by the way, the code I live by was delivered to me by a divine being who is all powerful and all knowing.
John Dehlin [01:21:29] Who's the divine being behind the Eightfold path? You're not even claiming a divine being is behind it. Who's to say it's right? And it sounds squishy. And it sounds like everyone gets to just make up whatever path and way that feels right to them. And, well, maybe I'll be kind of honest and maybe I'll be kind of committed, but maybe not. And what if somebody says this path, it doesn't have the certainty, it doesn't have the divine inspiration, the authority, the absoluteness, the truth with a capital T. It's an inferior way of living because it misses what's most important, God telling me what I should be doing, you know, to get to where God is and where I want to go.
Noah Rasheta [01:22:20] Yeah, yeah. You're not going to find that here. The absoluteness and the authority.
John Dehlin [01:22:27] So how is it not trading down?
Noah Rasheta [01:22:30] Well, you could stay on the realm of absoluteness and then you have the exact scenario which we have, which is look at every other path that has absoluteness, authority, and it's this way and no other way. Why don't they agree? Why can't they agree? Because it's too rigid and there's no bending, there's no squishiness to it.
Noah Rasheta [01:22:51] And that's not the answer. I'M not saying there even is an answer, but it's like you can keep trying that. The thing is, it works for some people in some dynamics. It works. The moment that it doesn't work, then what do you do with it? And that's where it becomes problematic. So if you think of any relationship, no one can come along and say, this is how your relationship dynamic has to work.
Noah Rasheta [01:23:17] The partner A has to be like this, partner B, that dynamic, it's always. It depends because people are different. Well, now we're talking about the relationship.
John Dehlin [01:23:27] Situations are different.
Noah Rasheta [01:23:28] Yeah, situations are different. Personalities are different. So in the same way that we wouldn't say, well, this is, you know, your relationship that works like this, that can't work in any other one. We recognize that no relationships are unique. Your relationship to the divine or to the unknown, the cosmos, God, however you want to frame that, that's a relationship. If there's something there that's coming from there to you, that's one direction. The other direction is not even taking into account the first one, just the direction towards you, towards anything bigger than you, that's its own direction.
Noah Rasheta [01:24:05] What is that relationship? Is it working for you? Is what you're doing working for you, I guess is at the heart of that question. And if that means you're experiencing more inner peace and wanting to make the world a better place and it's less producing, less suffering for you, keep going, then that path is working. That's okay. If it's not, then you got to look at it and say, why isn't this working? Maybe, maybe it's a problem where the system is the problem, but maybe not. Maybe the problem is this just doesn't work for me.
Noah Rasheta [01:24:40] So, yeah, there could be truth to what you're saying of like, well, under your circumstances and your particular conditions, that rigid way of making the relationship work, work is, if it's working, okay, we'll keep doing it. Doesn't mean you have to force it on everyone else. We know that that doesn't work because that's why there's so many worldviews in the world.
John Dehlin [01:25:00] And holy wars.
Noah Rasheta [01:25:01] And holy wars. Yeah, but what if you could offer that flexibility to at the very least say, well, that doesn't work for me, but what works for you, maybe you should explore that path. That alone would alleviate a lot of unnecessary suffering. Because Buddhism isn't coming along to try to say, hey, we need to replace every other worldview with Buddhism. But is your path doing that? Because if your path is saying, hey, all of you would be better off having my worldview. That's why the world is what it is right now. Because you're not the only one who thinks that. So does the neighbor who has another intense, strong worldview. That's not working. So, yeah, that's how I would approach that.
Buddhism as a Practical, Non-Dogmatic Framework
John Dehlin [01:25:51] There's something so powerful and I would say un, Mormon or unorthodox about just like, hey, I've got something I want to share. Oh, no, I know the truth and I'm in it. And you're like, oh, cool, great, keep doing that then. And it's almost disarming because a person might expect them to be challenged or to get in a fight about it, but you're just like, oh, wait, this is working for you. Oh, well, then please keep doing what you're doing. A philosophy that would have the grace or the wisdom to say, hey, I. This is. Only if this is of use to you, great. If it's not of use to you, do it.
John Dehlin [01:26:27] Do what's useful. Having a philosophy that's got that built into it. Number one, it's refreshing. And number two, I think there's some reverse psychology in that, because when you're telling somebody you're wrong and you're broken and I've got it, it's all right. That can create resistance. But if it's like, oh, don't worry about it. If this isn't for you, you just keep doing it. I'm just doing what works for me. That almost invites curiosity.
Noah Rasheta [01:26:53] Yeah, absolutely. Yeah. I remember we spoke about this and the first time we ever did the interview and you brought up the kites, the kite analogy.
John Dehlin [01:27:05] Like,
Noah Rasheta [01:27:08] what if you're on a kite or you're a kite and you're on a string? And I think it was like the gospel is the string, and it's a disservice to the kite for you to come along and cut that string.
Noah Rasheta [01:27:20] And I remember saying, well, yeah, that's because the nature of a kite is to be attached to a string. It doesn't fly without the string. The mistake is assuming everyone is a kite, because a bird might not need the string and the bird tethered to a string. That's a sad sight. But it's also a sad sight to see a kite flying beautifully and someone cuts the string.
Noah Rasheta [01:27:41] And I feel like with worldviews, what we should approach is, well, what are you like, what works for you? Does your worldview work for you? I don't want to come cut your string. It's working for you. You're Flying. But maybe it's really struggling and you look at it or it looks at itself and it's like it's because I'm trying to flap away. I'm a bird. Well, now that's a whole different thing. We just don't want to make the mistake of everyone's either this or they're that.
Noah Rasheta [01:28:08] That's what I love about Buddhism is it's a very introspective path. It's not about what something is, it's about understanding yourself. And I might realize that for me, the way I'm living my life, I would benefit from meditation. Or I might realize I wouldn't. That's not going to help me. I'm going to experience more suffering. Oh, well, then don't do it. There's not a way to be or not be. It's all about tools. And all of the tools are just meant to be literally that. They're tools. Meditation is one of many tools. And if you walk into your garage or you open the toolkit, which tool do you grab?
Noah Rasheta [01:28:46] It depends. What are you trying to do? Rather than thinking this is the tool, that's the end all, be all, it does everything. That's just not how the world works. And I like to think of Buddhism as it's one of the tools of many tools, and inside of it, it has a whole bunch of other tools. And some might work, some might not work. And who is it for? It's for whoever needs that particular type of tool and didn't even know that there was a tool that did that. How would you know? You gotta be curious and see if it works. That's the final thing that the Buddha taught before passing away was essentially that, like, don't take my word for it.
Noah Rasheta [01:29:22] Try this, test this stuff. If it works for you, then do it. If it doesn't work for you, then don't. And that's what you would say to someone who's looking for a tool. Try that one. Did it work good? Did it work? No, Try this other one until they find the one that works. But it's never been about, this is the tool. It's always this.
Margi Dehlin [01:29:44] I was gonna say one thing I also love about it, and I would like add is just what you believe may be working for you. And I love the phrase do no harm about Buddhism because I think your belief system could be working for you. Does it do harm to others, though? Does it? And it's. And so I love that piece of Buddhism around, sort of. Do I have that right? That's Part of is just this idea of do no harm and adding, you know, whatever you believe may be working for you, but does it harm others to have you believe that thing? And are you thrusting it or in some way placing it? So I was just going to add that things can be working for you.
Noah Rasheta [01:30:33] Yeah.
John Dehlin [01:30:34] Or is the organization you're supporting harm doing harm to others, even if it's helping you?
Noah Rasheta [01:30:39] Yep.
Margi Dehlin [01:30:40] So the do no harm kind of aspect, I love that as kind of. Yeah. Holding that as well.
Noah Rasheta [01:30:47] Yeah. And with. Tied with curiosity, because that's the way to even approach that topic. If, let's say, you could talk to someone who has a very orthodox or strong view and just using the example of maybe they have a child that's gay. And then you could say, what does your belief say? How do you think that feels for this person? And never about, is this wrong or right? It's just about understanding and shedding light and being curious. Like, where do you think that comes from? Why do you think that matters? Why do you think this person feels? And somewhere in that introspection, they might realize, you know what?
Noah Rasheta [01:31:24] That's not skillful. In our family, we're not going to. We're not gonna do that. The way I experienced growing up where, you know, you don't buy anything on Sunday. And in our family's like, we will. We are gonna do that because we live in a culture and in a society where we go on Sunday to walk as a family in the park and we buy snow cones. Like, we did that our way.
John Dehlin [01:31:44] If.
Noah Rasheta [01:31:44] If you could do that at a. At the family level or at the individual level or at any level, it would. It would just be such a more healthy, skillful way to approach it.
Margi Dehlin [01:31:56] I was going to ask also. So you kind of shared the meditation on death. Right. With us as being something that has really. You found a lot of value in it. Are there other things within Buddhism that we haven't talked about yet that you have found a lot of personal value yourself as you've practiced or grown in awareness or learned about?
Noah Rasheta [01:32:22] Yeah, yeah. I'm sure there are. Trying to think of something that may be a concept or idea that we haven't mentioned.
John Dehlin [01:32:30] I have one I want to ask about.
Margi Dehlin [01:32:31] Oh, okay.
Noah Rasheta [01:32:31] Oh, yeah, please.
John Dehlin [01:32:32] Can you talk about right. Livelihood.
Margi Dehlin [01:32:34] Oh, rightly.
John Dehlin [01:32:35] And that might. I think that might apply to you.
Margi Dehlin [01:32:37] Yeah.
John Dehlin [01:32:38] Is that okay?
Margi Dehlin [01:32:39] Yeah, that's great.
Noah Rasheta [01:32:40] Yeah. With livelihood, it kind of comes to this notion of no harm or trying to minimize harm. Think of it like the. Somewhat like the golden Rule. Right. You can be really introspective about what you do, whether that's your actual role within an organization, the job that you have, the company that you work for, the industry that you're in. And look at it through this lens of is this causing more harm or less harm at the individually and collectively?
Noah Rasheta [01:33:15] And it can get tricky because a lot of what we do in a lot of industries might not be super noble when you think about it. I used to sell photography accessories and manufacturers like, do we really need those?
Noah Rasheta [01:33:32] No. But it wasn't enough to think, well, I should quit this industry, but you might be in an industry that you do, and you look at it and you're like, oh, yeah, I am manufacturing arms, or I'm a drug dealer. That's an obvious one. There might be things that you could look at where you're like, I don't think I want to do this anymore.
Noah Rasheta [01:33:54] I worked for a company at one point. So when I moved to Utah after Arizona, I took the first job I could get. And it was a company that sold supplements, nutritional supplements. And as I started working, I was the head of marketing. And I realized one of our tactics, or not one of, like, the primary tactic is get people to subscribe for the trial of this supplement. And the whole business model is. And then it's really hard to cancel your free trial. So they ding you for three or four months until you finally figure out how to cancel it.
Noah Rasheta [01:34:30] And I started to get really uncomfortable when I realized, wait a second, I don't know how I feel about that. The product is fine, it's a supplement, and that it might actually be beneficial for people. But the way the model was being run, I was not happy with.
Noah Rasheta [01:34:45] So that became a moment of, how long do I want to do this? What is the price I'm paying for this? Is it causing unnecessary suffering to people? Yeah, it is. Is it creating beneficial use for me and my family? Yeah, I have a paying job and it's keeping a roof over our heads. But I had to sit with it and at some point decided, I don't want to do this again.
John Dehlin [01:35:08] And also, what is it doing to you and your character to really become and internalize what your organization's doing? Right. Was it do your soul or your morals or your ethics?
Noah Rasheta [01:35:25] Exactly.
John Dehlin [01:35:26] Your temperament?
Noah Rasheta [01:35:27] And that's a very personal choice because some people might be completely okay in an industry or in a role where someone else might not. And again, I hate to apply, like, there's not a rule, like, it's this. And it's not that. It's not. This is where the mushiness comes in again of, it's you, you're the one who has to sleep with yourself at night. Can you sleep with yourself? If you can, okay. And that's not to say then it's okay. That's just that speaks to you and your ethics. But I wouldn't be able to. So then maybe that's enough for me to say that I'm not going to do that. So with livelihood, that can steer a lot of the decision making of what you do or don't do.
The Afterlife, Death, and Groundlessness
John Dehlin [01:36:13] What does Buddhism have to say about the afterlife?
Noah Rasheta [01:36:16] Buddhism is famous for not entertaining the question of an afterlife. There's a, a popular famous discourse where someone asked like point blank to the Buddha, you know, is the essence of reality, is it eternal? Is it like he wanted to know the existential questions and the Buddha just refrained. He didn't say yes and he didn't say no, and he just didn't answer it. And there's another teaching that connects to this where someone is shot with a poisoned arrow. And as he, as he's there dealing with the pain of the poisoned arrow, he, he's offered, well, we can go, we can do something about this. You don't have a lot of time left.
Noah Rasheta [01:36:56] Here's what we can do in the time that's left. And he's like, no, I want to know who shot the arrow. What kind of feathers are these? Why did they choose this kind of wood? All these irrelevant questions to the situation at hand, which is, you're dying, you've been shot with a poisoned arrow. And that's another story that illustrates the Buddhist perspective to questions like what happens when we die?
Noah Rasheta [01:37:20] They're irrelevant. It's not that there's a yes or a no from the Buddhist perspective. It's we're not going to waste time on something that is irrelevant because what we do know is we're alive. You're experiencing life for a short amount of time. How do you deal skillfully with the time that you have while you're alive? That is the core of the Buddhist approach. It's not going to entertain what happens after, because when after becomes the present moment, then I'm sure there will be Buddhism there. But Buddhism is not going to dive into the realm that's outside of the present moment. If it's irrelevant, then it becomes speculative.
Noah Rasheta [01:37:57] And I've really appreciated that approach because for me, personally, as a curious person, I'd love to know what happens when I Die. But do I have to know? Turns out I don't actually have to know. And it's perfectly okay to say I don't know.
John Dehlin [01:38:14] But religion sets it up to where this life is a test. And if you don't get baptized, then your endowments in temple marriage and then endure to the end and get your covenants and serve in the church, then when the judgment comes, you don't get to go to the Good Place because you didn't do all the things in your life that you were supposed to. If you wait. And I'll live in the present moment and just love who's around me and live each life to its fullest and then die. What if you get to the end and the guy at the gate says you didn't pick the wrong church, you didn't get all the check marks, you don't get to go to the Good Place?
Noah Rasheta [01:38:47] Yeah, well, unfortunately.
John Dehlin [01:38:48] Why are you laughing?
Noah Rasheta [01:38:50] If that's how it is, then you've got bigger problems because it's also which version of the belief system is it the fundamentalists approach and that's just inside of Mormonism, or is it Catholics or is it Jehovah's Witnesses if you stick within Christianity or is it outside, is it Islam? It's like you've got a bigger. You have a much bigger dilemma on your hands if that's the case, because you have no way of knowing. Are you going to go and experience and try out every religion possible so that you can decide which one is correct? Because that's what you should be doing if that's what you genuinely believe. And at the end there's that test and someone's going to ask, did you get the answers right? Then you better go understand every answer out there by every other worldview.
John Dehlin [01:39:40] Unless you're just lucky enough to be born into the true church and then you don't have to go look because you're in it.
Noah Rasheta [01:39:45] Yeah, that could be an incredible amount of luck for the zero point. What 01%, 001% of the world's people who have lived.
John Dehlin [01:39:57] But even this energy is about trying to prove the case of Buddhism. And I just love that Buddhism doesn't care to prove itself as true. You know what I mean?
Noah Rasheta [01:40:09] Yes. The notion of true or not true is just non existent in the Buddhist worldview, which I found to be very refreshing. That's why for me it was that that was a pivotal moment of shifting from being a truth seeker to just a person who's practicing living skillfully and whatever that Means.
Noah Rasheta [01:40:30] Yeah. So if you think about questions, let's say I have a. I'm holding a box here, and I tell you, inside this box, it's the most incredible thing that I've ever come to discover about life and the universe. But. But it's in this box. Like you, you know, do you want to know what's inside?
Noah Rasheta [01:40:51] You might like, if you're a curious person, I, yeah, I want to know what is it? But do you need to know? No. Because whatever this answer was, it was my answer. With existential questions, the reason they matter so much is because we think the question matters, but the answers are different. Tradition A says this, Tradition B says that. Tradition C says this other one.
Noah Rasheta [01:41:14] If I anchor my sense of peace to having the answer, and I pick an answer, the one I was born with or the one that I, you know, maybe you're a convert and you're like, no, I've studied and I picked this one.
Noah Rasheta [01:41:26] There is a real sense of peace for you because you do have the answer. So that existential angst around that question is alleviated because of the answer, but all it takes is someone else coming and questioning that, introducing doubt. And now your foundation starts to shake a little bit because your sense of peace comes from the answer. Buddhism comes along as a tradition that's saying, let's look at the other side of the coin. You have the question. Does the question matter? What if you didn't need to know? And as you sit with these tools of introspection and doubt, not around the answer, the doubt is around the question.
Noah Rasheta [01:42:05] And you realize, maybe that's not knowable, or maybe I don't even need to know. When the question dissolves, you have the same sense of peace that the answer person has, but yours is rooted in not needing to know that one can't be taken.
Noah Rasheta [01:42:21] You could have a hundred different traditions come, tell you what their answers are, and like, okay, maybe because it's okay, it doesn't matter. And that's the peace that you experience from a path like this, where the relevance of the question goes away, the need to know dissolves. And the sense of peace that you have comes from uncertainty and from not knowing.
Noah Rasheta [01:42:45] And to me, that's a much more skillful way of seeking peace, because you can't pull the rug out from under someone who's not standing on a rug. And the other approach of the answer, then the answer is your rug, and it'll work for you as long as that rug doesn't get pulled out from under you. But the moment. It does. I've got bad news for you. And if you anchor it to a different rug. Okay, that one's fine too, until that one gets pulled out from under you. Buddhism said, let's just look at all of the rugs and say, what if we didn't need a rug?
Noah Rasheta [01:43:16] What if we didn't need a firm foundation to stand on? And that's its own concept in Buddhism called groundlessness. And you have nothing to stand on. And I found that to be very liberating. Because if you have nothing that you need to stand on, that's actually much more relatable to what the experience of life is. It's constantly changing and it's interdependent. And what might make sense now might not make sense later. You know, whatever was relevant for the dinosaurs, that doesn't matter to us. Humans are here now. And this is different.
Noah Rasheta [01:43:48] Just the whole experience is one of constant change and adaptation. And that resonates more with me, with my worldview. So for me, it wouldn't even be that I'm like, oh, yeah, Buddhism is true. No, Buddhism works for me. It just makes sense to me. And another one, another ideology. I wouldn't say that it's false. I would say it just doesn't work for me. It doesn't make sense to me. It doesn't work for me. And that's all it has to be. I don't have to prove it right or wrong, true or false. It's just, does it work for you or does it not? And only you can answer that question.
John Dehlin [01:44:24] And sounds like you're genuinely happy. If somebody finds a path that worked for them, you're not going, okay, well, I'm glad that works for you. But you're not on the right path. You don't have that condescension or judgment.
Noah Rasheta [01:44:36] Judgment, right, yeah. No, if that works for you, that's great. Where you do run into friction points might be, now you're trying to get me to get on your path. That's different. Or you're trying to create laws and regulations that are adapted to your path. But I'm not on your path. Don't force that on me. That's its own thing. But now then you can deal skillfully with that when that's what you're dealing with. But that's where I would see friction points, not in terms of your belief. You can believe whatever you want to believe.
John Dehlin [01:45:04] I think one of the most intoxicating things about Mormonism is the sense of certainty. And I think Margi and I both. Your episode on groundlessness was transformative because I think that's one thing that Mormons experiencing a faith crisis end up grieving and missing most is they just really liked the certainty. And it's hard to ever explain to an orthodox Mormon that you can actually find as much comfort or more in not just uncertainty, but in groundlessness than in certainty. I don't think people can even wrap their brain around that sometimes.
Noah Rasheta [01:45:42] No, again, it's like the question answer analogy. It's like telling someone who's deep burning desire to know the answer to the question, telling them if you didn't have the question, you're gonna have the same amount of peace to them. It's unfathomable. How could I not have this question? So, yeah, it's like there are people who don't have the question and they are enjoying the same amount of, well, I would say the same amount of peace, but less potential anxiety because nobody's coming and threatening the answer. There is no threat.
John Dehlin [01:46:19] So wild. Because when I went to the MTC the first time to become a missionary, they played the, the video Our Heavenly Father's Plan and they frame life with three questions. Where did I come from? Who am I now? And where am I going? And that seems so simple and so innocuous and almost so intuitive for a human to think about those questions. Who am I? Where? Where did I come from? Where am I going? But just by framing those questions and then telling people those are important questions and they're knowable, and let me tell you what we think the answers are. You can gain a whole lot of control over people just by starting out by telling them that those questions are very important. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Noah Rasheta [01:47:09] Certainty produces a tremendous amount of peace. Yeah. And you think on a smaller scale, then you see how unhealthy it is. Like you wouldn't tell a 12 year old, hey, by 12, you need to know what your career is going to be. Because if you don't know, like this is really important, you need to know we wouldn't do that. Like, we understand that. Well, that might change, that might evolve. You don't have to be this career, this other one, like, figure out what works for you. But I don't know why we do that with our religious views. There suddenly it's like, no, there's only one and it has to be the right one.
Noah Rasheta [01:47:49] And your choices are, first of all, what's available today in your society. Let's just disregard the thousands of others that have come and gone. What if one of Those was right. Like, why do we do that? Instead of approaching it with uncertainty? That seems so much more skillful to be. Like, there are things that we just don't know. You don't know if you're going to get a flat tire on the way home. What if you anchored your entire sense of happiness and peace on knowing that you're not going to get a flat tire? And then what happens when you do? You're all bent out of shape.
Noah Rasheta [01:48:24] But that's what we do in our lives. Like going around trying to establish certainty at every possible place. And one of those has to be at the existential level. Who am I? Why am I here? What happens when I die? You have to have those answered or you're not going to be at peace.
Noah Rasheta [01:48:41] What if it's not that? You know, I often say, genuinely speaking genuinely, let's say today the skies open up and it's not Jesus, it's a blue elephant creature from Hinduism. How many people would be like, oh, that's what it was. Okay, boom, Shift and adapt. They wouldn't. Right? There's always the mechanism that's going to make you say, well, no, this is a test. That must be the devil. People aren't going to convert based on what reality is presenting to them. Well, the same thing would happen if it's, let's say it is Jesus. Do you really think that all the other traditions will be like, well, I guess it was Christianity, they'd be like, no, in Hinduism they'd be like, it's Shiva or whatever.
Noah Rasheta [01:49:24] There's one that can morph into whatever shape that person needs to be. That's who it is. Or everyone's got a mechanism to, to stick with what already feels right to them. So it feels like the only logical approach would be stay curious and stay open minded. Because I know that when reality presents itself, if some moment like that happens, I'll be like, oh, this is what it is. Okay, we're adapting. That's how I approach life day to day too. It's the Tetris analogy. It's like, oh, this is the piece that showed up. Let's adapt. This is what we're doing now.
John Dehlin [01:49:56] Love it. Well, I can say it's brought me a lot more peace. It's been, these principles have been really useful in helping me rebuild a new life that feels way more healthy and happy and at peace. And I feel like I feel better in my skin. I hope Margi would say that our, our marriage has improved since we both tried to incorporate these principles. And I think we're trying to apply it as parents and just in every aspect of life. So anyway, that's. That's why we love having you on, Noah. So let's say somebody said, sold. I want to become a good Buddhist. I want to become the best Buddhist. What are some ways people can start on the path? I mean, I know you've got a whole website and a podcast and books, but give people some tips on how to start.
How to Explore Buddhism and Closing Reflections
Noah Rasheta [01:50:48] Yeah, Honestly, for anyone who's curious in these frameworks, this overall worldview, start with books. There are plenty of books out there. I have some basic ones. No nonsense Buddhism for Beginners. That's a Q and A format book. That's a good one. But there are plenty of other good books out there. Like just type in beginner Understanding Buddhism or Beginner Buddhism, and you'll find something that's going to start steering you in the direction of what these concepts and ideas are. I would say don't approach it trying to be. You don't need to be a Buddhist. And I know that I say that in the podcast, but I mean, genuinely speaking, the deeper you get into Buddhism, the more Buddhism is going to steer you against the label anyway.
Noah Rasheta [01:51:36] So don't identify with it. It's going to try to steer you away from identifying with it anyway. Just understand what is this. Visit it with curiosity, and then you could go visit a Buddhist temple where you are. And they're all different. The Japanese schools, the Thai schools, the Tibetan schools, they're all quite different in the way that in Christianity, if you're learning about Christianity for the first time and someone's like, well, just go check one out, your experience will be very different if you go to a Jehovah's Witness temple versus a Catholic or lds. It's the same in Buddhism, except the underlying doctrinal understanding is still similar, that of uncertainty and all of these frameworks, but the flavor might feel very different.
Noah Rasheta [01:52:23] Go check them out, see what you think, talk to, listen to podcasts, and then just kind of allow yourself to what seems to work or what makes sense. Follow that and learn more about it.
John Dehlin [01:52:37] How many episodes do you have?
Noah Rasheta [01:52:39] 226, I think.
John Dehlin [01:52:41] And they're what, 30 minutes each?
Noah Rasheta [01:52:42] Roughly 30 minutes each. So my podcast, the first five episodes are designed to lay out the basic fundamental understanding of core Buddhist teachings. So you could start there if you do the podcast format instead of wanting to read a book.
John Dehlin [01:53:00] And then you used to lead groups. Do you still lead groups?
Noah Rasheta [01:53:06] Yeah, I have a Sunday call every Sunday with with podcast supporters. So that's podcast listeners who end up joining the community. That's something that I do there. So it's like a zoom call.
John Dehlin [01:53:20] You're there with a bunch of other people and they can ask questions or.
Noah Rasheta [01:53:24] Yeah, okay. But if you're the type of person who wants to learn this by asking questions, that's what I designed, the AI tool.
John Dehlin [01:53:32] Talk about that.
Noah Rasheta [01:53:33] Go to eightfoldpath.com and you'll see an interface immediately that you can chat with. Anyone can chat with it.
John Dehlin [01:53:40] Ask it how did you program it?
Noah Rasheta [01:53:43] So it's trained on all of my podcast episodes and my three books that I've written. And then it's. Yeah, so it has context of everything I've ever taught and my courses as well, because I have three courses on the website. One is Intro Buddhism, one is meditation, and then there's like a more thorough kind of everything, like a more in depth look at the whole path. And that one's called the Inner Peace Roadmap. But the AI is trained on all of that. So you could just start it by asking questions like, well, what does Buddhism teach? Or why does this matter? How does this apply? And give it context about your. Whatever you're going through in life, it's really useful to you.
John Dehlin [01:54:34] Could say I'm struggling with parenting, or I'm struggling in a relationship, or my job, my boss is mean, or whatever. Or I'm addicted to something or whatever.
Noah Rasheta [01:54:42] And it'll help you. But through a Buddhist informed overview.
John Dehlin [01:54:48] Nice. Yeah, nice.
Noah Rasheta [01:54:50] And I've had so many people reach out to say, this is incredible. Thank you so much. It's a powerful tool.
John Dehlin [01:54:56] Anything you want to say about your future uncertainty? You're single.
Margi Dehlin [01:55:01] Yeah.
John Dehlin [01:55:01] You're single.
Noah Rasheta [01:55:02] I am, I am. I'm kind of at that junction right now of like, deep appreciation for what was. Excitement about what might be. And here I am at the crosshairs of the, you know, of. Of those two, the present moment. And there's. Yeah, excitement. I don't. I don't know what the future has in store. I know the overall direction and intention that steers me in what I do and why I do what I do, but the exact outcomes to be seen. And I'm excited about it.
John Dehlin [01:55:40] I know my friend Bo and my friend Ben, they went on a trip with you to Tibet or something, right?
Noah Rasheta [01:55:46] Yes.
John Dehlin [01:55:46] Do you do that every year?
Noah Rasheta [01:55:48] I was doing it every year, and then I took a few years off and I probably bringing it back starting next year. And that's like mindfulness trekking. So it's trekking, but with a mindfulness component to it. That's a lot of fun. We've done Everest Base Camp Annapurna, several of the circuits in the Himalayas. I've done humanitarian trips in the past. Now I'm doing just a weekend mindfulness retreat. I just did one a couple weeks ago, last weekend, actually. In Colorado. In Colorado. And I'm getting ready to do a new format that's like, an introduction to Buddhism and meditation in a mindfulness a weekend retreat format. So all of that will be on my website as I post it.
Margi Dehlin [01:56:35] That's terrific.
Noah Rasheta [01:56:36] Yeah. I'm excited to see where life takes me and what Tetris pieces show up. And we'll just keep going one day at a time.
John Dehlin [01:56:45] If someone wants to ask you out on a date, how do they reach. How do they reach you?
Noah Rasheta [01:56:50] Probably my social media would be the easiest.
John Dehlin [01:56:53] Just Noah Rochetta.
Noah Rasheta [01:56:54] Yeah, Noah Rochetta on Instagram and Facebook could reach out there. I'm also on the dating app. Someone might find me there.
Margi Dehlin [01:57:04] Look at you.
John Dehlin [01:57:04] You're saying slide into your DMs is what you're saying.
Noah Rasheta [01:57:07] Yes, I guess.
John Dehlin [01:57:09] Margarita funnel questions?
Margi Dehlin [01:57:11] No, just. What a pleasure, as always. Yeah.
Noah Rasheta [01:57:14] Well, thank you both for the time and the opportunity to talk about these topics. These are topics I'm very passionate about, and I enjoy talking about it because they've been so impactful and meaningful for me. And I know that others, when they encounter a lot of these frameworks and ideas and stories, it makes a difference for them. And I want to keep sharing that.
Margi Dehlin [01:57:39] Yeah.
John Dehlin [01:57:40] I'll just say thanks for being my friend and thanks. Julie's right. I've mentioned you a gazillion times on Mormon stories, and I'll continue to do it. But that's not just because I know who you are and have enjoyed getting to know you over the years, but your work has been meaningfully helpful to me and to Margi and to other members of my family and to friends. And so I know it's. It's helpful stuff. It can be very helpful. And so I just want to thank you for providing some puzzle pieces to the people I think we all care about, which are people navigating life and navigating sometimes a faith transition. Thanks for helping provide a few pieces to that puzzle.
Noah Rasheta [01:58:22] Well, thank you. I feel the same. Thank you for your friendship and all of the support and work that you've done that's helped me as well.
John Dehlin [01:58:31] Well, beautiful. All right, so eightfoldpath.com if you value this episode or the series you want to see it continue, you can go to mormonstories.org donate and become a monthly donor. Like subscribe Share. We really appreciate that. We love your feedback@mormonstoriesmail.com if you want to apply to be on the show, MormonStories.org apply. Most importantly, be skillful. Be mindful. Right speech, right action, right thoughts. Life is suffering and accept it. And yeah, deliverance comes from accepting the
Noah Rasheta [01:59:09] suffering and then not making it worse.
John Dehlin [01:59:13] Not making it worse and gaining some skills along the way. Anyway, be good to each other. Be kind to each other. We'll see you all again soon on another episode of Mormon Stories Podcast and on Secular Buddhism. Take care.
Transcript © 2026 John P. Dehlin. All rights reserved. Brief quotations are welcome with attribution and a link to mormonstories.org; all other use requires written permission.