Tags

Share this Episode

Comments 14

  1. Mr. Ritchie’s candor is very refreshing and I appreciate it. I do have some 1st hand experience with this gentleman that is noteworthy. About 7-8 years ago I attended a fireside in which this man was the keynote speaker. He spoke about the Mideast conflict. John D. referenced his work with Yasser Arafat in the introduction. What disturbed me greatly was Mr. Ritchie’s shameless heaping of praise on Yasser Arafat. I remember being dumbfounded that I was hearing this kind of talk in a chapel about a cold-blooded, murdering thug like Yasser Arafat. As many of you know, Arafat was terrorist that should have been at the end of a hangman’s noose instead of the receiving end of a Nobel Peace Prize. I, along with others present, were disgusted at the glorification of a terrorist by Mr. Richie. Just thought this should be known.

  2. Anybody who knows a shred of history about the Middle East knows that Arafat has a sordid past.

    However, the man was a symbol of hope for millions of Palestinians. Hope that one day the world would accept their right to exist side by side with the Israelis as sovereign, unoccupied people. Before Arafat, few if any cared or paid attention to what was going on the West Bank and Gaza Strip.

    So, I don’t condone some of Arafat’s past sins. However, I am equally disgusted when I hear President Bush or church members praise certain Israeli leaders of “men of peace” (i.e. Ariel Sharon). Try reading about Sharon’s role in the Qibya massacre of 1953 or Sabra/Shatila in 1982.

    The point is that all these men have blood on their hands. Terrorism is absolutely carried out at times by militant Islamic groups such as Hamas AND the Israeli government. I’ve seen it with my own eyes.

    So, my hope is that you are equally disgusted by all Middle Eastern (or any other) leaders who perpetrate acts of terrorism.

  3. John-
    Thanks for sharing this recording of Dr. Ritchie. It is amazing. I appreciate all the time and work you put into your podacasts.

  4. Bonner was one of my OD profs in grad school at BYU. He was a very interesting professor. He didn’t fit my Mormon stereotype of a Mormon, let alone a Mormon professor. I was genuinely impressed with his different approach. I wish I would have insightful enough to take advantage of the time that I had him as a professor. It was 16 years later before I came to my “crisis of faith.” I appreciate the access to this type of work. Thanks John.

  5. Wes,
    We should have learned reading/listening to this blog that that world isnt that black and white.
    Israeli-Palestine conflict is very complicated.
    Thanks for your comment though.

  6. Wes, this time period, in which Bonner Richie was praising Yasser Arafat, may have been the same time period in which Yitzhak Rabin was making the point that “you make peace with your enemies.”

    I’m not trying to defend Yasir Arafat. As I heard one person say, he succeeded as a symbol but failed as a leader.

    I’m just saying that sometimes people are optimistic and positive despite their knowledge, because they are trying to make the world a better place.

  7. Someone,

    I know the conflict is not black and white and I am by no means a black and white person. I learned through painful experience in Mormonism that everything is not black and white and the mantra “follow the prophet” can be dangerous. However, I have studied this issue in depth, ad nasuem, and know a great deal about it. I admit I probably don’t know as much as Mr. Ritchie does, but I know enough. And when it comes to the cold blooded murderer Arafat, who did not hesitate to murder or order to be murdered women and children, you have to call a spade a spade. Arafat was a revolting human being and to defend him or glorify him is incomprehensible.

  8. Perhaps the root message of Wes’ comment is that we should be wary of any wisdom we might gain from Bonner Ritchie since he demonstrated a flaw of some sort by advocating a position or person that we disagree with.

    In that vein, what happens when we apply that same kind of process to Brigham Young? For any faithful LDS who thinks they don’t disagree with BY, read his comments on blacks and the priesthood, and compare them to President Hinckley’s comments on racism in last year’s general conference.

  9. Wes,

    My concern w/ your comments it that you’re not seeming to acknowledge all that has been done on the Israeli side of the conflict. The assassinations. The collective punishment. The torture.

    Everyone I’ve spoken with say that it’s a 2-way street. So I’m cool w/ you denouncing Araft, as long as you acknowledge the terror and cruelty on the Israeli side as well. Is an F14 bomb more humane than a suicide bomb?

  10. I got halfway through this podcast on the bus in to work this morning and can`t wait for the day to finish to get to the other half.
    Theres a huge number of concepts and revolutionary thoughts in there thats going to take some serious processing.
    I had another of those increasingly common moments of realising my ignorance where I wonder how I`ve gotten to this stage in my life and have never heard of J Bonner Ritchie before!

    Does anyone know if there is a transcript available for this talk?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.