In Part Six of the Brigham Young Podcast series, we continue our discussion with historian John Turner about his book Brigham Young: Pioneer Prophet, returning to Chapter Five, “Prophets and Pretenders,” (on page 132) to explore one of the most controversial aspects of Brigham Young’s legacy: polygamy.
We examine how Brigham Young expanded plural marriage after Joseph Smith’s death, including his sealings to Joseph Smith’s widows and the challenges historians face in determining how many wives Young had and what those relationships involved. We discuss the difference between marriage and sealing, polyandrous relationships, the ages of Young’s wives, and how many of these women bore him children.
We also explore the theological implications of polygamy, including the belief that women needed to be sealed to men to achieve exaltation, the role of eternal family relationships, and the ways these teachings shaped early Mormon understandings of salvation and the afterlife. What was Brigham Young trying to build through plural marriage: a larger family, a new theology of kinship, or something else entirely?
Finally, we consider how polygamy affected the growth of the Church, how Young responded to growing opposition from the United States government, and how his approach to plural marriage compared with Joseph Smith’s. Could polygamy have strengthened Mormonism in some ways while damaging its ability to attract converts?
Join us as we discuss the historical evidence, the women whose lives were shaped by these practices, and the lasting theological consequences of Brigham Young’s polygamy.
Episode Transcript
Full text · 14,800 words · 9 chaptersHost: John Dehlin · Guest: John TurnerRead transcriptHide transcript
This transcript is machine-generated and lightly edited for readability. The audio is authoritative. Please excuse occasional errors in names and spelling.
Introduction to Brigham Young's Polygamy
John Dehlin [00:00:00] Hello and welcome to another episode of the Brigham Young Podcast, brought to you by Mormon Stories Podcast. I am your host for today, John Dehlin. It is September 23, 2026, I think this is part six of our series on the Brigham Young Podcast. You can go to brighamyoungpodcast.com to see the episodes and timelines and all sorts of cool documents. But the most important thing you can do is is by this book. Brigham Young Pioneer Prophet by John G. Turner. John, sandbag this book. To me, I think it's every bit as good as Joseph Smith the Rise of an American Prophet, if not better. Sometimes a creator's best work is their first major work. Now, is this your first major book, John Turner, or not? It's not. Right?
John Turner [00:00:47] It's not my first book. I don't know if I've had any major books. It depends how you want to define that. But this is my first Mormon history book.
John Dehlin [00:00:58] Okay. Well, it's a banger. And John Turner, I told you and Julia this beforehand. I woke up. I've read this chapter twice. I've spent 40 hours just on preparing for these past couple episodes. And I Woke up at 4am studying this stuff. And I got here late because I couldn't break away. So I am just going down a major Brigham Young polygamy rabbit hole. And it is all your fault, John Turner. I'm not apologizing. It is all your fault.
John Turner [00:01:28] I make no apology. I actually agree there. There is some wacky and just sheer, sheer fascinating stuff in this chapter about Nauvoo polygamy. Absolutely.
John Dehlin [00:01:46] Yeah. So really quickly go to the Brigham Young Podcast website and click on donate to become a donor. We're hoping to do as many of these episodes as John Turner will support. We pay him and Julia for their efforts. So please donate, become a monthly donor to this series to see it go all the way to the end. We're only on page 132, but this book goes much further. It actually goes to page 413, so we're only about a fourth of the way done, if I'm counting right. So let's raise the money to support John Turner, though, all the way through the book. So without any further ado, John Turner, last week we were covering chapter five up through the polygamy portion.
John Dehlin [00:02:34] And the polygamy portion begins at the top of page 132 in the chapter Prophets and Pretenders. But the rabbit hole that I went down with went down this morning was trying to get a grasp of the polygamy before you Know this, this post Joseph Smith Nauvoo period.
John Dehlin [00:03:00] And then to kind of get my brain around what was happening during the post Joseph Smith Nauvoo, Brigham Young polygamy period. But I think before we start, let's give some framework to that. And I'm going to let you start, but I want to add some things to the framework as well.
John Turner [00:03:21] Sure. Well, the first thing to know, I think, is that Joseph Smith did not leave a polygamy manual for Brigham Young that Brigham could pick up and consult after the martyrdom. So Brigham was sealed already to four, four women in addition to Mary Ann angel at the time of Joseph Smith's death. One of the first orders of business seems to have been approaching Joseph's widows and making arrangements for their well being.
John Turner [00:04:08] And Brigham and Heber were both sealed to a large number of those widows. So Brigham was sealed to eight of Joseph's widows, Heber C. Kimball, I think to seven. A couple of other men were sealed, I think to one.
John Turner [00:04:31] And one thing that I think listeners should know is that especially in Brigham's case, these ceilings are extremely well, extremely well documented. Brigham was keeping a handwritten journal during these years and he made notations in his journal on the date of those ceilings. So for instance, he would write me above a journal entry signifying married for eternity when he married someone who had not previously been sealed to a man. And he'd write MT above a journal entry when he was sealed to one of Joseph's widows.
John Dehlin [00:05:24] Okay, and do you have an approximate. Did he do all of Joseph Smith's widows kind of at one time? Were they present? Did he get their consent, and was it before he took on any actual wives later, while still in Naboo? And do we know if he immediately started living with, cohabitating with and or shacking up with the Joseph Smith polygamous widows that he took on that Heber didn't take? This sounds like distributing women as cattle, by the way.
John Turner [00:06:04] So great questions. And this will not, this won't shock you. The answers aren't super simple. So just to refresh people's memory, Brigham Young gets back to Nauvoo in early August of 1844 after the martyrdom, has his sort of public joust for leadership with Sidney Rigdon, and then in September, so about a month later begins being sealed to additional women, both including Joseph's widows and including simply other women.
John Turner [00:06:47] So I don't think it was an instance. It was definitely not an instance in which he and Heber C. Kimball and Willard Richards got Rounded up Joseph's widows and, you know, sort of made selections like, you know, choosing sides in a high school gym class. So I don't think it was like that. I think it was approaching women individually.
John Turner [00:07:13] And I think in some cases, the motivation was probably, I would really like to be. I would really like this woman to be among my wives. Some of the motivation may also have been, I'm going to take on the responsibility of providing for this woman economically. So I think there's a variety of motivations. Brigham does not assemble a polygamous household in Nauvoo.
John Turner [00:07:42] He does consummate some of these marriages, and he does have sex with an increasing number of women. We know that because several women bear him several polygamous wives bear him children in 1845 and early 1846. So we know their sexual activity.
John Dehlin [00:08:12] Okay. Okay. So. And that's with even Joseph Smith's widows, Correct?
John Turner [00:08:23] Correct. So he fathers a child with Emily dow partridge in 1845. I think she gives birth to Brigham's child late in 1845, and she was a widow of Joseph Smith.
John Dehlin [00:08:46] And it looks like she's the. She is. Is Elizabeth. Is. Is Emily Dow Partridge the first post, Joseph Smith sealing?
John Turner [00:08:56] It's possible. I actually. I actually don't remember. I know.
John Dehlin [00:09:01] I
John Turner [00:09:01] know. I know. In September of 1845, he sealed to Lisa Beaman, who most people believe is Joseph Smith's first polygamous wife. At least setting aside Fanny Alger.
John Dehlin [00:09:15] Yeah.
John Turner [00:09:17] It was probably similar timing for Emily Dow Partridge. I don't. I don't remember the exact order.
John Dehlin [00:09:23] No, that's okay. That's okay. All right. And. And just to. Just for me to get my brain right, and I didn't realize this. He came to Kirtland back in 1832 without a wife because Miriam had already died.
Counting Brigham Young's Plural Wives
John Turner [00:09:40] Correct.
John Dehlin [00:09:41] So Marianne becomes his second wife, but his only wife for a good eight years in Kirtland and Nauvoo before, in 1842, he takes his first plural wife, which is Lucy Ann Decker.
John Turner [00:09:58] Correct.
John Dehlin [00:09:59] And then he has basically. Is it four or five polygamous wives while Joseph Smith's alive?
John Turner [00:10:06] Four. So it's Augusta Adams.
John Dehlin [00:10:09] Yeah.
John Turner [00:10:09] Who's complicated and interesting case. And Harriet Cook and also Clara Decker.
John Dehlin [00:10:21] Right. And so Clarissa Ross becomes his first. Well, one, possibly his first post. Joseph Smith seal.
John Turner [00:10:31] Correct. Correct.
John Dehlin [00:10:32] Okay.
John Turner [00:10:33] And, you know, this is. I find this. I don't know. I don't know. Charming is not the right word. But in his diary, Brigham writes. And this is one that's noted with me married for Eternity. This day, I visited brother Isaac Chase. Brother HC Kimball was with me. Brother and sister Chase with their daughter Clarissy, a nickname for Clarissa, was at home. We had a good visit, a really good visit, because she became his plural wife.
John Dehlin [00:11:13] Yeah. And I just want to give an overview of why I went down such a rabbit hole. One of the stats that I kind of was realizing, but until I really did the math, I didn't realize it, so. So Brigham Young has 4.4ish plural wives in two years while Joseph Smith was alive. And then by my count, 34 wives in the 20 months after Joseph Smith died while still in Nauvoo. So 34 of Brigham Young's total 50 plus wives happen in like a less than two year period in Nauvoo before Brigham Young leaves. Correct?
John Turner [00:11:57] Yes. So what Brigham did is he, you know, he was taking notes during Joseph Smith's lifetime, and then he said, basically, anything you can do, I can do better.
John Dehlin [00:12:09] Yeah, I have a stat. 19 of the 34 wives came during a three and a half week period.
John Turner [00:12:19] Yep. I had that. I might have had that at 18, but let's not quibble. And actually, I think. But that's an important point. So in the last
John Dehlin [00:12:30] nine, in two days.
John Turner [00:12:32] Right. In the last several weeks of the Nauvoo Temple, Brigham is sealed to 18 or 19 women. And I do think that is a somewhat different. I don't know, somewhat different meaning in a way or different dynamics than prior to that. Because there's this. There's this rush in Kirtland in January of 1846 to get all of this ritual activity done before the saints leave Nauvoo. And many of. Many of those ceilings, in many of those ceilings, in many of those instances, the women do not have ongoing relationships with Brigham Young. So in a way, they become part of his eternal kingdom that he's building. Their exaltation is assured, but it's sort of done in a rush. And some of those women simply stay in the east or don't become part of his household.
John Dehlin [00:13:46] Right. Very, very good. Okay. And just to kind of give a few more overviews, the total number of wives. We've talked about this in past episodes. I found at least three different numbers that scholars tend to settle on. Do you want to talk about those three numbers or do you want to talk about the numbers you feel like you want to talk about?
John Turner [00:14:13] So, I mean, My count was 55.
John Dehlin [00:14:17] Right.
John Turner [00:14:17] As I don't think I say it in this book, but as I said in something I wrote quite A few years ago. I think anything over 50 is pretty extravagant in terms of marriage. So some other people have counted 57. You know, there's, there's simply several debatable cases. You know, so I, I think this is actually one reason I didn't include a chart in the book is because there are some debatable cases. And I don't think, I don't think it matters greatly whether the final number is 55 or 57 for understanding Brigham Young.
John Dehlin [00:14:58] Totally.
John Turner [00:15:00] I do think, as is true for Joseph's wives, the stories of these individual women are remarkable. And I made as much space as I could in both the Joseph biography and in the Brigham biography to at least fairly quickly bring many of these women into the narrative.
John Dehlin [00:15:29] Yeah, and I want to talk about that in just one second, but tell us really quickly who this John J. Stewart character is. From a 1961 publication.
John Turner [00:15:38] John J. Stewart. I have no idea what you're talking about.
John Dehlin [00:15:42] He gave an original count of 53.
John Turner [00:15:45] Okay,
John Dehlin [00:15:45] I have you. Who's Jeffrey Ogden Johnson? That's a dialogue article of 1987.
John Turner [00:15:52] So he was a long time church history department employee, wrote a great essay that he published back in 1987. I think determining and defining wife partly in addition to trying to count and create a chronology for Brigham's polygamy, also reckoning with the fact that wife could mean a number of different things. It's a great article. He continued to do research on Brigham's family. Great researcher.
John Dehlin [00:16:30] And then Dean Jesse agrees with you and Jeffrey Ogden Johnson about the 55 number. I have Michael Quinn coming out at 56 because he wants to keep Maria Lawrence, I guess. Did you, did you, did you contemplate that?
John Turner [00:16:48] I contemplated. I don't have anything intelligent to say about it.
John Dehlin [00:16:54] Okay, that's fine. Okay, so now I just wanted to briefly discuss kind of Todd Compton and Brian Hales and Lindsay Hansen Park. And I know this is going to sound a little bit orthogonal or weird, but it's one of the reasons I rabbit holed this morning because one of my very first interviews ever on Mormon Stories podcast with Todd was with Todd Compton. He did this amazing book called. And a lot of our listeners won't know this, by the way. He did an amazing book called In Sacred Loneliness. Do you want to talk about that and what it was and what it meant to people.
Key Scholarly Works on Mormon Polygamy
John Turner [00:17:27] Yeah. So it's in Sacred Loneliness is a chapter by chapter biography, sort of group biography of Joseph Smith's wives, laying out all of the sources, but I think also telling the story of these women in a very compelling and engaging way. So if listeners have never looked at that book, it's also a great read. And I found, when I read it, I found myself simply getting lost in the weeds of each woman's story and life and being just fascinated by it.
John Dehlin [00:18:15] Kind of like I did today reading your book. But it's a legendary book. And I should add Fawn Brody included a list of the wives of Joseph Smith in her biography no Man Knows My History. So in some sense, she's a bit of an OG here from the Joseph Smith perspective. Talk about what Brian Hales did in relation to Joseph Smith's wives. And if you want to throw in Lindsay Hansen park there as well, because then I want to talk about whether, you know, the opportunities here for Brigham Young at the outset, because this episode is going to be dedicated to Brigham Young's wives. So
John Turner [00:18:53] sure. So Brian Hales has a three volume, three volume series of books simply called Joseph Smith's Polygamy. I think two volumes on the history, one volume on Joseph's theology of marriage. And he also goes through a lot of sources in detail, engages a lot of the questions that stir debate about Joseph's polygamy in terms of which marriages were consummated. How do we make sense of women who were sealed to Joseph when they were already married to other men? So, yeah, he's an important contributor to these debates and there's a ton of research in his books that I think is useful for people to engage whether or not they agree with his conclusions.
John Dehlin [00:19:57] And his website, have you ever checked that out?
John Turner [00:20:00] Yeah, it might simply be Joseph Smith's polygamy.com.org I'm not. I can't quite remember.
John Dehlin [00:20:08] Yeah. And it's basically just as much public documentation he can provide on his website. Right?
John Turner [00:20:15] Correct. There's a ton, there are ton of sources that are either listed or linked to. I find it very useful.
John Dehlin [00:20:26] And then, and just really quickly, we all know that Brian Hales lines up as sort of an apologist for the church and is a believer and that that causes some to not like him. He does thread that needle somewhat though, Right. Because you do consider him a scholar and someone you've probably learned a lot from and maybe even learned a lot from for your book. Is that fair to say or not?
John Turner [00:20:49] No, that's fair to say. And I think one of the good things about history is that ultimately, no matter where we're coming from, we do have the common ground in terms of the evidence that is out there.
John Dehlin [00:21:02] Yeah.
John Turner [00:21:03] And so I have a pretty optimistically capacious view of Mormon history, where whatever, somebody's ideology, church affiliation, whether they have an ax to grind in some way or not, I mean, ultimately their, you know, arguments rise or fall on the basis of evidence and debate.
John Dehlin [00:21:31] So, so history is the only domain where Sandra Tanner, Brian Hales and John Turner could all be in the same room and have a thoughtful, constructive conversation. In theory,
John Turner [00:21:41] yeah. And I, I, I, I will also say that in the world of Mormon history, I've met a lot of people from, you know, with various backgrounds and points of view who do engage in good faith debate.
John Dehlin [00:22:00] Yeah. Okay. And then have you checked out your polygamy podcast at all?
John Turner [00:22:04] I have. I can't say I've listened to all of it, but, but, yeah, I love Year of Polygamy. I love anything that Lindsay and Brian Buchanan collaborate on. They're great. It's also super engaging, which is one reason why I love it. And it's great history.
John Dehlin [00:22:22] And basically, do you want to describe that podcast? Just how it relates to this conversation?
John Turner [00:22:28] So actually, you know, I've, I've just dipped in and out of their episodes, and you might be able to
John Dehlin [00:22:36] fill
John Turner [00:22:37] in listeners. Let me say one thing is that in addition to one of the things I appreciate about their work is that in addition to polygamy in the Joseph Smith and Brigham Young era, they do a great job of emphasizing the long mark that this has left on the culture of movements that descend from what Joseph Smith started.
John Dehlin [00:23:12] Beautiful. And just to add, and I promise we'll leave this now and get back to Brigham Young. As I understand it, she started by following Todd Compton's book In Sacred Loneliness and doing an episode, at least one episode per wife. That's how it started. So it basically began as a podcast dedicated to the wives of Joseph Smith. And so the one of the vision, I occasionally have a theophany John Turner. One led to the Creation of Mormon Stories podcast. Another was when I started talking to you and thought, what if we did a series on Joseph Smith in your book and did like, I don't know, 10 episodes on Joseph Smith, maybe 20.
John Dehlin [00:23:56] That was a theophany. Of course, we did 41. And the theophany I had today was there needs to be a Brigham Young's polygamy.com website. It needs to list all his wives. There needs to be, it needs to have all the research provided. And then there needs to be a book, just like in Sacred Loneliness, but around Brigham Young's wives. And there needs to be a Podcast dedicated to all the wives of Brigham Young. Now, having swam in the documentation, John Turner, do you even think there's enough source material for that to be possible, or do we not know yet?
John Turner [00:24:34] It's a great question. So the answer is yes, and we'll simply know. We know more about some of his wives than others. Now, first of all, one can kind of cheat, because Todd Compton and Lindsay and Brian Hales also, as well as other scholars, they've done a lot of research on women who were sealed to both Joseph and then to Brigham. So Todd included didn't just trace these women's lives up to June of 1844. He kept going.
John Turner [00:25:14] And then there are other. Other wives who have a great deal of sources that allow us to narrate their lives. Augusta Adams is one of Brigham's wives in that category. And then there are others who. And I alluded to this when we talked about the rush of ceilings in the Nauvoo Temple. There are other women who were sealed to Brigham Young in the Nauvoo Temple, stayed in the east, didn't join his household, and in some instances, we know very little about them.
John Dehlin [00:25:50] Yeah. So it's a. It's probably a worthy project. Right. And an interesting project to do.
John Turner [00:25:58] I think It's a. It's a very worthy project.
John Dehlin [00:26:00] Yeah. The. I just Googled list of wives of Brigham Young. Other than Wikipedia, the only thing that came up was a Utah Lighthouse ministry listing from 2004, which borrows, I think, almost completely from that article that we just got done, referring to the Jeffrey Ogden Johnson dialogue article, which was published in 87. So this seems like a really cool opportunity that I just wanted to place out there to begin with, because your book inspired this idea and you thought about including a list of the wives in your book.
John Turner [00:26:44] I did. I even have a file on this will get you excited. But don't get excited. I have a file on my computer by wives, children. It's a chart. So I thought about it. One reason I didn't is because for me, the story was really what mattered to me.
John Dehlin [00:27:08] Sure.
John Turner [00:27:08] And it. It was a biography of Brigham Young, and so polygamy is an important part of that story. But once you start working on a chart, you would want to spend a couple of years making sure you are precisely correct in every detail, and particularly spending a lot of time on those uncertain cases that might affect whether you ended up with 55 or 56 or 57 wives. And I had a deadline, and I didn't. So I didn't I didn't quite have time for that. That, that work.
John Dehlin [00:27:49] Well, if there's a grad student out there, an undergrad, a scholar, an amateur, if there are listeners of yours out there that want to take something like this on and push it forward, I'm all ears. So anyway, thanks for your patience in me Just kind of throwing that out there really quickly just to kind of close off a couple of the other things that are often talked about. Remind us, by your count, how many of those marriages were polyandrous and that there's two categories of polyandry. So there's two different types of numbers. Remind us of that really quick, if you don't mind.
John Turner [00:28:33] So about 15 marriages involved women who were already married to other men. And you better ask some follow up questions, John.
John Dehlin [00:28:44] Yeah, and we almost want to call those ceilings not marriages. Right. So maybe 15 of those ceilings were Brigham Young being sealed to people who were already legally married to other men.
John Turner [00:28:55] Right.
John Dehlin [00:28:56] But there's a smaller number. There's a difference. Tell me if I'm right, John Turner. There's a difference that's often brought out between that number. Go ahead and tell us what that.
John Turner [00:29:09] So
John Dehlin [00:29:10] I,
John Turner [00:29:10] yeah, I think most people, if they hear about a woman having two husbands, well, is this a woman having sex with two husbands? Somehow that sounds more objectionable or zany than certain other scenarios. So let me just, let me just lay out some scenarios. So we've already mentioned Augusta Adams, who's married to a man named Henry Cobb in the Boston area.
John Turner [00:29:48] She converts to the church and isn't happy with her marriage to Henry Cobb, at least on some level, and decides to become Brigham Young's plural wife, moves to Nauvoo for that purpose. And at that point, she's separated from Henry Cobb. As far as she's concerned, she's now Brigham Young's wife for time and eternity. So that's one sort of polyandrous ceiling.
John Turner [00:30:24] Then there's a woman like Mary Rollins, who is married to Adam Lightner. She becomes one of Joseph Smith's polygamous wives. She's sealed to Joseph, but she continues to live with Adam Lightner. And apparently in contented fashion. They don't actually move to nauvoo. They live 15 or 20 miles away. Then she is sealed to Brigham Young for time. She's still Joseph's for eternity, but again, she continues to live with Adam Lightner. And in fact, they don't move to Utah until the 1860s.
John Turner [00:31:12] Now, without digressing too much, that makes it almost sound like these Ceilings didn't matter. But especially in the case of her ceiling, to Joseph it mattered a great deal to her. She lived into the nineteen teens. She was Joseph's last living polygamous wife. She talked about it before many audiences. It was of eternal spiritual significance to her.
John Turner [00:31:43] So that's, that's a different sort of instance. Then, if you don't mind me proceeding with a third instance, there's Zina Huntington, who marries Henry Jacobs, is then sealed to Joseph Smith while pregnant with her first child by Henry Jacobs, then is sealed to Brigham Young.
John Turner [00:32:12] She is then again sort of resealed to Young for time and Smith for eternity in the Nauvoo Temple while she is visibly pregnant with Henry Jacobs second son. At this point, I don't think we know or I don't think she and Henry Jacobs necessarily knew what this was going to mean for their future earthly lives.
John Turner [00:32:44] She eventually becomes part of Brigham Young's household and is sort of separated from Henry Jacobs by Brigham Young. So that's a third sort of instance. So there's a. Just a wide variety of experience and meaning within this category of polyandrous ceilings
Theological Implications of Polygamous Sealings
John Dehlin [00:33:11] and man. Just if we pause and think about the theological implications of those stories you just told us, what it leads me to conclude is no one understands the doctrine of eternal families. No one understands ceilings. No one understands the new and everlasting covenant. No one understands God. No one understands Mormon God. No one understands Mormon prophets. And no one understands Mormon revelation. Because there is no way to make sense of all that in the afterlife.
John Dehlin [00:33:43] You can't explain it by God needs to raise up a righteous seed. You can't, you can't explain it like God values the marriage between one man and one woman. Like none of it makes sense, or that God's the same yesterday, today and forever.
John Dehlin [00:34:02] And just, just this week we interviewed a transgender Mormon. And I think about like the work Taylor Petrie's done and just an example with like women in Mormonism not having the priesthood yet or gay people not having ceilings yet, or not knowing whether or not to give the priesthood to transgender people or, and, or to let them have their dominant get sealed or whether they get excommunicated or not.
John Dehlin [00:34:29] What the stories you just told me tell me is that Mormon prophets and Mormon God can pretty much almost do anything if they want to, because none of it has to make any logical sense based on what's in the scriptures or what the precedent is or what the law is or what makes sense. That was a rant I didn't plan on giving. But does it make sense?
John Turner [00:34:55] Do you want me to make it make sense, John?
John Dehlin [00:34:57] Please make it make sense.
John Turner [00:35:00] So I think from Brigham Young's perspective, this makes sense. So what he teaches is that becoming a God means being in possession of a kingdom and being an almighty man to that kingdom. And he is living out what Joseph Smith instructed people like William Clayton, which was to get all you can. And he says this very explicitly, and I've quoted this on prior episodes, I do not care how many are sealed to me, nor who. And so he is accumulating, accumulating wives as quickly as he can, or maybe not quite as quickly as he can. And he's also teaching that woman will never get back to celestial glory unless she follows the man back. So that does make theological sense.
John Dehlin [00:36:10] Number go up.
John Turner [00:36:12] Number go up. And for the women, be sealed to a man for eternity.
John Dehlin [00:36:19] Man, get all you can. Woman, attach yourself to a man.
John Turner [00:36:24] Exactly. I mean, to put it really bluntly. Right. And so, I mean, one of. One of the other instances that I haven't mentioned yet in terms of these polyandrus ceilings is he is sealed to, for instance, Phoebe Morden, who's one of his mothers in law, who's estranged from James Angel. That's Marianne Angel's mother. So in a way, what Brigham is doing there is he's providing for her eternal glory. He's also, I guess you could say he's building his kingdom there. But it's really. He sort of already has that line. Line covered. So, yes, it's. It's crazy, it's wild, it's hasty, it's rapid, but it's for. From the man's perspective, it's a matter of accumulation. From the woman's perspective, it's a matter of, you know, an assurance of celestial glory.
John Dehlin [00:37:42] Yeah. And we also have to note that that perspective, that. That perspective of Brigham Young's is not in play today in modern Mormonism. The. The church has flipped it so that one spouse is the ideal and just some of the old dudes, because we don't understand it. Got more. But let's just be clear. Polygamy suspended. DNC 132. Still in the scriptures, but polygamy suspended. And there's zero talk of it in the afterlife. So this idea of more glories and more power and more dominions and number go up for the men and women, attach yourself to the polygamous husband, that's suspended. So. So God, Mormon God changed,
John Turner [00:38:36] at least mostly. Right. I mean, I do think there are some echoes and whispers for those men who, for whatever reason, end up sealed to multiple women during their. During their lifetimes. But yes, yes, the church managed to preserve its, you know, elements of its theology of marriage while stripping polygamy out of it, at least for the most part.
John Dehlin [00:39:15] Okay. A couple other just analyses that I did that I just, I want to give by way of introduction in terms of ceilings, the types of ceilings that Brigham Young engaged in. I count 18 time and eternity ceilings, 10 ceilings to Brigham for time while those people were sealed to other men. Prior three eternity only, one for time only, and then about 23 that we kind of don't know. Now, how is that based on your count? Your count?
John Turner [00:39:52] I mean, that sounds about right. I don't have the numbers at my fingertips, but I think that's right. So most cases were time in eternity,
John Dehlin [00:40:02] and then about 20, there's decent evidence that he had sexual relationships with them. And about 15 where it's unlikely, and about 20 where we just don't know. Does that sound about right?
John Turner [00:40:14] That sounds about right. Yep.
John Dehlin [00:40:16] And then 16. This. This kind of blew me away. Apparently only 16 of the 55 women bore him children.
John Turner [00:40:26] That's correct. And I think perhaps 20. You already cited that number. About 20 were, in a meaningful way, part of his household, at least for some stretch of time.
John Dehlin [00:40:41] And I had 25, but, you know, somewhere between, let's just say 20 and 25 that we know of, lived with him in a household at some point. Is that what you're saying?
John Turner [00:40:50] Correct. And I believe you didn't include this number. And it's possible I'm not remembering the number accurately, but I believe he issues or gives divorces to around eight women.
John Dehlin [00:41:05] Yeah, I think I have 10, but I could be wrong. And then ages. The youngest. Do you have the youngest and the oldest age of the wives he married?
John Turner [00:41:16] The youngest, I think is 15.
John Dehlin [00:41:19] Okay.
John Turner [00:41:20] Clara Decker.
John Dehlin [00:41:22] I have 16, but I don't know. You'd know more than me. 15, 16. Ish.
John Turner [00:41:27] The oldest I'm thinking was 65, but maybe it was even older.
John Dehlin [00:41:33] I think I have a 70. Oh,
John Turner [00:41:34] you have a 70. Okay.
John Dehlin [00:41:36] And then I have a median of 27.
John Turner [00:41:40] I love it. I love it. Statistical analysis.
John Dehlin [00:41:45] And then the. The widest age gap I have between Brigham Young and his wife is. Do you have. It's a 43 year age gap between him and one of his wives. He's older.
John Turner [00:41:58] And one. I. I believe he was 70 at his last ceiling. I don't know if you, if you look that up, but I used to my.
John Dehlin [00:42:09] Yeah,
John Turner [00:42:10] my. My dad died at age 70. So when he was in his late 60s, I was working on this book. And, you know, my dad wasn't in great, great health at the time, but I would. I would joke with him and saying, look, you're not even 70. Brigham Young got married for the last time at age 70.
John Dehlin [00:42:31] Yeah. Yeah. That's great. As far as. Okay, so let's just say divorces are around 10. I was dying to know how many documented wives, ex wives or ex wives of Brigham Young ended up leaving the church or losing their faith. And I was super frustrated to only find one known case of someone who left the church and lost their faith. Now, there's a bunch of unknowns, but I can only find 1 out of 10 divorces, only 1 that it's known to have left the church and lost their faith. And I'm sure you know who that is.
John Turner [00:43:14] So that's Ann Eliza Young, who publicly sued Young for divorce in the mid-1870s. So she's a famous case. I have to just also say I'm sure we'll talk about her in a later episode. It is a little bit sad when you write a book called wife number 19. 19 and you're not number 19. She didn't have. She wasn't privy to all of the research that. That we are. No. But there. I. I haven't tied it up, but there are a number of instances that we could document of women who maybe we can't definitively say lost their faith, but left the church or were no longer actively affiliated with.
John Dehlin [00:44:01] You're thinking there's more than one?
John Turner [00:44:03] Definitely more than one.
John Dehlin [00:44:04] Okay, good. Well, that's something I'd love to learn about. Julia wants me to make the point that the Book of Mormon has this exception about God will allow polygamy to raise up a righteous seed. Is it worth mentioning why Brigham Young's is not a good example of that?
Wives, Children, and Documentary Records
John Turner [00:44:23] Well, yes. So you sort of just stated that only 16 of his wives had children. Now, some of them were past childbearing age at the date of their sealings to him and a couple of his wives. I think Emmeline Free had a large number of children, and there's a few others who had at least a sizable number of children, but many of them didn't have very many children. And so, yes, this was not an ideal arrangement for raising up. Up seed. I. And I. I mean, part of that is because his number of wives is so extravagant that, you know, I think perhaps there is quite. Only. Only so much he could do.
John Dehlin [00:45:24] And he wasn't. He was kind of a busy guy, Right.
John Turner [00:45:27] He had other responsibilities.
John Dehlin [00:45:30] I mean, frontier imperialist monarch is. Is kind of a busy day job, right?
John Turner [00:45:37] Yeah, I think that. I think that's true.
John Dehlin [00:45:42] 1. One stat that kind of blew me away. If this is right. I wanted to know how many of the 55 wives left diaries or memoirs or autobiographies or whatever. And I had 15 of the 55 left memoirs or diaries or letters or affidavits or testimonies. Does that sound about right?
John Turner [00:46:10] I think that is about right. So there are some, such as Zina Huntington, Eliza R. Snow, Emily Dow Partridge, who were prom. Particularly Eliza and Zina, who were. They were prominent Mormon women In the late 1800s, published rather widely, didn't necessarily write at length about the nature of their marriages to Brigham Young, but we know a lot about them. I actually, one thing that surprised me when I worked on my biography is that there was quite a bit of material on some of the, at least at the time, less known wives. So there's correspondence between a woman like me, Mary Woodward, who probably almost none of our listeners have heard of. There's correspondence between her and Brigham Young. There's a lot of correspondence between Augusta Adams and Brigham Young that previous historians hadn't made use of. So I found a lot in the Brigham Young papers about quite a few wives.
John Dehlin [00:47:27] Yeah. And then there are five that were written about, but. But. But we have nothing from them. And then 35 of the wives. There's not really any. Anything that I could find in terms of substantive records or, you know, records, records by or about them. And that makes it hard to do the Todd Compton book. But I'm wondering, if most of these wives came later, why do we have more from Joseph Smith's wives than we do from Brigham Young's wives in terms of extant records?
John Turner [00:48:03] Well, I would say we know a fair amount about those wives who became part of Brigham Young's polygamous household. So that had an ongoing attachment to him and his family. The women who were sealed to him during those last several weeks of Nauvoo Temple activity but then did not go west or become attached to his household. We know a lot less about them. I would surmise that future diligent researchers would no doubt be able to learn quite a bit more about at least many of these women. So it is. It would be very worthwhile for other researchers to try to reconstruct their lives.
John Dehlin [00:48:53] Okay, so that's a viable opportunity for historical development or research.
John Turner [00:49:03] Let's just say it's always surprising how much one can learn when one starts poking around and it's easier than it used to be. Whether it's census records that one can look at, online newspapers that one can search. There's been a lot of advances in research tools over the last 10 or 20 years. So I think, yeah, if you know where somebody lives or might have lived or have some sense of family trees, you can often find out quite a lot.
John Dehlin [00:49:39] How much microfiche did you consult in either of your Mormon books? John Turner.
John Turner [00:49:45] So a lot of microfiche.
John Dehlin [00:49:47] Really,
John Turner [00:49:48] A lot? Well, microfiche. Mostly microfilm. Some microfiche. A lot of microfilm for the Brigham Young book. And that was before the church history library was built on North Temple. So it was in the downstairs of the old church office building. And it was rather, I don't know, it was rather dim in that microfilm room. And I would often, you know, you would think as a historical researcher, you'd be so excited about this material that you would never get drowsy. But microfilm that could do me in. And I would fast walk over to the old ZCMI CMCI. I always get it wrong.
John Dehlin [00:50:34] ZCMI
John Turner [00:50:36] ZCMI. And they had a McDonald's in the basement where I could get a quick cup of coffee and be restored.
John Dehlin [00:50:43] Wait, can you drink coffee while you're doing Mormon research? That doesn't feel right.
John Turner [00:50:46] Not while you're doing the research. You could take a coffee break,
John Dehlin [00:50:50] I guess. Brigham Young told pioneers to bring coffee so his historians can also drink coffee. I think that's. I have 27 of his 55 wives outliving him. Four of those who outlived him were divorced. So. So I have. I and Johnson have 23 surviving wives, eight of which remarried after Brigham Young died. Right.
John Turner [00:51:16] That. That sounds right to me.
John Dehlin [00:51:18] Okay. Okay. Anyway, that's enough analysis. But I thought, is it a kind of interesting new kind of an analytical overview of his wives?
John Turner [00:51:27] Oh, absolutely. Well, so I surmise that Brigham Young was the most oft married man in 19th century America. Now, maybe you can find other cases. I
John Dehlin [00:51:41] don't know. More than Heber.
John Turner [00:51:43] More than Heber.
John Dehlin [00:51:44] Okay.
John Turner [00:51:46] There were one or two, and it may have included Heber, may have been John Taylor. There were a couple who had more children than he did. But I think he had the most number of wives sealed to him during his lifetime. And I'm not aware of any non Mormons who had more wives.
John Dehlin [00:52:03] Nice. All right. I love it. And we're not Even including the dynastic ceilings. Really quickly, what is a dynastic ceiling? And how many men do we know of having been sealed to Brigham Young? If you know, I have a number, but I don't know if it's right.
Dynastic and Polyandrous Marriages Explained
John Turner [00:52:20] Yeah. So just to be clear, sometimes writers and researchers use the term dynastic marriage. For instance, when Heber C. Kimball wants his daughter to be sealed to Joseph Smith to sort of cement the ties between those two families. But I think you're referring to the law or ordinance of adoption, as it was
John Dehlin [00:52:55] not. Is that not accurately described as a dynastic sealing?
John Turner [00:52:59] Oh, no, I think it is. I just, you know, listeners may have heard of the, of the other instance.
John Dehlin [00:53:04] Okay,
John Turner [00:53:05] so, but the ordinance of adoption is something that was, as far as we know, not introduced during Joseph Smith's lifetime, but that was introduced in the Nauvoo Temple under Brigham Young's leadership. And it was the ceiling of, usually actually of couples to high ranking church leaders, sometimes simply a man. I don't know if there are ever any women who are singly sealed through that ordinance or not.
John Turner [00:53:41] I'm, I don't know if I have the exact numbers handy. But Young, on a number of occasions, adopted a large number of couples. The rationale was that not everyone had a father who held the priesthood. And so this was sort of grafting men and women into a chain of priesthood that was understood to stretch back to Adam.
John Turner [00:54:26] So, for instance, on one particular day In January of 1846, Young adopted eight couples, including John D. Lee, who many people, if they're familiar with 19th century Mormon history, they will have heard of a number of other apostles and sometimes other prominent Mormon men also adopted ritually adopted children.
John Dehlin [00:55:04] Yeah, and one of the things that surprised me So I got 66 people adopted to Brigham Young, and I have no idea if that Number is right. 34 of them were grown men, but we only know the names of six of them. How can we know that there's 34 men but only know the names of six?
John Turner [00:55:23] I think we know we know more. We
John Dehlin [00:55:25] do. Okay.
John Turner [00:55:26] I don't have, I don't have all 66, 34 handy, but no, it's, it's, it's definitely more than that.
John Dehlin [00:55:33] Jonathan Stapley, the go to guy for, for this type of stuff.
John Turner [00:55:37] Jonathan Stapley is the go to guy.
John Dehlin [00:55:40] Okay, okay. And
John Turner [00:55:43] I'll just say there are some, you know, in terms of this ritual reordering of families, there are some interesting cases. So Young, in one, one instance, he ritually adopted a couple named Robert and Hannah Pierce. They were the parents of his plural wives, Margaret and Mary Pierce. So Young's in laws were also his spiritual children. I know this is going to make everybody's head spin, but. And
John Dehlin [00:56:29] I don't want to call that spiritual incest. That's probably not right. Right,
John Turner [00:56:33] let's. I wouldn't do that. In another instance, Young ritually adopted a couple named James and Mary Woodward. And then two days later, Mary Woodward was sealed in marriage to Brigham Young. So there's.
John Dehlin [00:57:00] Yeah, he had. He had women. And we're going to talk about this. So he had women sealed him first as daughters and then as wives later.
John Turner [00:57:09] At least one instance.
John Dehlin [00:57:11] Yeah.
John Turner [00:57:11] Yep. And so again, there's all of this, just this rush of ritual work, particularly in. In December 1845, January 1840, 46. It isn't clear to those involved what it's going to mean for their earthly lives. And it's only after the Saints leave Nauvoo that Brigham Young begins to reorder his family and reorder the community in a way that reflects at least some of this ritual activity.
John Dehlin [00:57:57] Yeah. And then just a final number. If we add up all the adults sealed to Brigham young, spiritual wives, plus the law of adoption, people, is it like 121 people, adults sealed to Brigham Young? Does that sound rightish?
John Turner [00:58:14] That sounds rightish. So it is a pretty large kingdom, which did make Brigham a pretty almighty man.
John Dehlin [00:58:24] Number went up.
John Turner [00:58:25] Yeah.
John Dehlin [00:58:25] Brigham Young, one. Do you. Do we think Joseph has more people sealed to him than Brigham in terms of total number? In terms
John Turner [00:58:34] of
John Dehlin [00:58:35] biggest number?
John Turner [00:58:36] Well, we also going to have to deal with posthumous ceilings. So women to Joseph and ultimately women to Brigham. So that's a very complex question.
John Dehlin [00:58:50] Yeah, yeah, yeah. All right. Well, it's kind of absurd at some point, but it wasn't absurd to Brigham Young.
John Turner [00:58:57] It wasn't absurd to Brigham Young. And I would also want one thing that I think is perhaps worth knowing if we want to think about his mindset, is I don't know exactly what he was thinking In January of 1846, when he had those 18 or so women sealed to him in the temple in short order. But when he began the work of expanding his family In September of 1844, a few months after Joseph's death, he definitely found it spiritually exhilarating.
John Turner [00:59:34] So when he is sealed to Louisa Beaman, he writes, great is the work of the Lord in these last days. And then the next day, he writes in his journal, the Lord is with me continually. So I read that those are Simply his private comments. He feels that God is with him in this work. He's doing what God wants him to do. And he feels exhilarated. You know, he's sort of on spiritual fire as he expands his family.
John Dehlin [01:00:17] Yeah, Yep. He was super stoked by all this ceiling and, and marriage and polygamy and polyandry activities. Kind of like a rooster crowing in the, on the, in, in the, in the barnyard, you know,
John Turner [01:00:34] a little bit like that. And I think it'd be fair to mention also that for some women, this was also spiritually exhilarating. So there's a woman named Clarissa Blake who was already married to a man named Lyman Homeston at the time of her ceiling to Young, which was in October of 1844.
John Turner [01:01:02] She, after the ceiling, she wrote Young an acrostic poem and a love letter. And she wrote, my heart is like a bird let loose from a long and close confinement and soars aloof on joyful pinions. Onward to guide us to celestial joys.
John Turner [01:01:27] Upward thou will rise and we will follow on. So, you know, we, we alluded to, or I think we discussed in the brig in the Joseph Smith podcast, Helen Mark Kimball describing her life in Nauvoo as that of a caged bird.
John Turner [01:01:51] So for Clarissa Blake and I think also for Augusta Adams, at first this was exhilarating and there was, there was something liberating about choosing Brigham Young and. As opposed to their first husbands.
John Dehlin [01:02:16] Yeah. And yet. And you have to kind of feel for the husbands, right?
John Turner [01:02:23] Yeah, for sure. So, you know, the most, I think, well known example of that is Henry Jacobs, who is Zina Huntington's husband. So when Brigham is resealed to Zina in the Nauvoo Temple, Henry Jacob stands as a witness and the temple clerk records Henry B. Jacobs expressed his willingness that it should be so. And you know, I think listeners should stop and think about this.
John Turner [01:03:00] So Zina Huntington is there. She's pregnant with Henry Jacobs child. She's visibly pregnant. So this is obvious to everyone. Henry is standing there maybe feeling, and I'm speculating a little bit, but I think feeling a little bit coerced into giving his approval.
John Turner [01:03:29] And I don't think he yet knows what this is going to mean for his marriage to Zina. But this is a ceremony that makes Zina Zina. This sort of reaffirms that she is Joseph Smith's wife for eternity. And then there's this strange, strange fact that she is now Brigham Young's for time.
John Turner [01:03:59] I don't think Brigham has explained to Henry, and perhaps not to Zina either, what that's going to mean. So at the very least, this, this must be on some level spiritually wrenching for Henry Jacobs.
John Dehlin [01:04:21] Yeah, absolutely. And, but, but also there's a, you know, we know how fundamentalist polygamy plays out in kind of the Warren Jeffs era, where basically Warren Jeffs gets to like to the people that obey him, to the people that make good money, to the people who are powerful, to the people he wants to please.
John Dehlin [01:04:41] He gives more and more wives to the downtrodden, to the less powerful, to the disobedient. He gives no wives, kicks them out and, or even takes their wives away and reassigns them. Like, that's some of the most horrific examples we have of polygamy playing out in people's lives.
John Dehlin [01:04:59] But at least this idea of the most special leaders get rewarded with the most wives, that was very much, you know, what, what Joseph and Brigham were kind of thinking in those early years. And that's what my own grandmother told me. Polygamy was for the most righteous men and women. Is that fair?
John Turner [01:05:26] Well, I think that's fair. And I think Joseph doesn't teach this explicitly as well he may have taught it explicitly. We don't have a, we don't have explicit evidence of this. But the logic of Joseph's polygamy is that the extent of a man's eternal glory hinges on the extent of, of his family. And so the more wives, the more glory. So there's a strong theological motivation for men to get as many wives as they can. And it makes sense in a hierarchical church for the very top leaders to set the standard.
John Dehlin [01:06:22] Yeah, and, and it really is. It just, you know, oftentimes prophetic motivations are reduced to sex, money and power. I know you don't like to frame things that way, and I'm not framing it that way either. But this does go along with the money empowered influence. Polygamy went right along with the money and the power kind of dynamic that all societies have, frankly. But it certainly was interwoven in those elements of society. Prestige, money, power, influence in that early century.
John Turner [01:07:04] Well, and I pointed to the fact that for some women, this was spiritually exhilarating. And there's a clear theological motivation for a woman like Clarissa Blake. You know, she's saying, onward to guide us to celestial joys. But there's also a strong motivation in the case, you know, for women who need economic support. There's a strong motivation for them to attach themselves to men like Brigham Young who are the wealthy and powerful members of society going forward.
John Dehlin [01:07:51] Yeah. The whole primate alpha male dynamic, it's all throughout nature, not just with primates. The whole alpha male thing of women want to mate with the alpha male, because I guess evolutionarily, hypothetically, best genes, it's kind of just almost like a prehistoric, uncivilized vestige in our culture.
John Turner [01:08:21] Yeah. So, I mean, I think it definitely helps explain the motivations on both sides.
John Dehlin [01:08:30] Yeah. All right, so just to kind of close out this kind of overview of Brigham Young's polygamy, I. I'm gonna have you. I'm gonna have you complete a sentence or answer kind of a sentence, and this will be kind of how we close out this episode. And I'm calling an audible. We're just gonna end this episode and start up a brand new one. You'll get paid extra. But I think this needs to be kind of its own episode of just like an overview of Brigham Young's polygamy, because we're talking about much more than just this period of Nauvoo, and I don't want this period of Nauvoo to get lost in the broader framing.
What Brigham Young Was Doing With Polygamy
John Dehlin [01:09:07] So hopefully that won't affect you at all. But I do want to have you finish kind of a thought that I'm going to read. So between Joseph smith's murder in June 1844 and the exodus in February 1846, about 19 months, Brigham Young went from four plural wives to roughly 40.
John Dehlin [01:09:27] And the question the whole episode turns on is. And we're going to be talking about this next episode, but I think this really fits to a question about what was Brigham Young doing with polygamy? And here's the question.
John Dehlin [01:09:39] What was he actually building? And here are some options, and I think you're going to know the answer. John Turner. A harem, a welfare system, a dynasty, a loyalty machine, or a theology of kinship that nobody involved fully understood. And John Turner, what's your answer to that?
John Turner [01:10:06] So I think there were five options. I'm going for a bit of a blend of C and E.
John Dehlin [01:10:13] Oh, I thought you were going to say all of the above.
John Turner [01:10:16] Well, okay. So I think. Well, I thought I was supposed to choose, so.
John Dehlin [01:10:24] Oh, no, no, no. Harem. Did you not like harem? I guess
John Turner [01:10:27] I'll tell you the reason I don't like harem, because when you think of a harem, I think you have to have a household. And he doesn't have a household yet.
John Dehlin [01:10:37] Okay.
John Turner [01:10:38] So he's definitely making. In Nauvoo, he's still making like Joseph did. He's making clandestine visits to wives.
John Dehlin [01:10:47] Okay.
John Turner [01:10:47] If you have a harem, you don't have to be clandestine about it. Right.
John Dehlin [01:10:51] I like. I love that. Okay,
John Turner [01:10:53] so I'm going to say not a. What was option B?
John Dehlin [01:10:56] A welfare system, taking care of the widows.
John Turner [01:11:01] So I guess a bit of that. But honestly, I don't know to what extent he undertook financial provision, say, for Joseph's widows. I do think I. I do think there is some of that, but I don't think in other instances he necessarily anticipated financial support.
John Dehlin [01:11:25] Okay, so that may be giving him too much credit.
John Turner [01:11:28] Correct.
John Dehlin [01:11:29] Because a lot of women weren't necessarily. And not just in Brigham Young, but broader. I know in my. The example of my polygamous great grandmas, a couple of the early ones felt neglected towards the end as my great grandpa moved on to some of the younger later wives.
John Turner [01:11:47] Yeah,
John Dehlin [01:11:47] it happened quite a bit. Right.
John Turner [01:11:48] Terrible dynamic.
John Dehlin [01:11:50] Yeah. Okay, so we don't want to equate Mormon polygamy with the caring and feeding of all the wives and children involved.
John Turner [01:11:59] All right. And as we'll see in future chapters, there were plenty of women who felt insufficiently supported, despite the fact that Brigham Young could have supported them more.
John Dehlin [01:12:11] He did have some money.
John Turner [01:12:13] Yeah.
John Dehlin [01:12:14] How about dynasty? Is that fair?
John Turner [01:12:16] Absolutely.
John Dehlin [01:12:17] Okay,
John Turner [01:12:18] so. And the law of adoption, the ordinance of adoption is definitely significant here. There is, especially when it comes to. Comes time to organize the exodus to the west, the apostles in particular, with their expanded families and spiritually adopted children, that they have this idea of functioning almost as tribes. Wilford Woodruff refers sometimes to the tribe of Brigham. So there's definitely a sense of creating, you know, dynasties, priesthood, kingdoms.
John Dehlin [01:13:09] Okay, so yes, on the dynasty. What about, what about the idea of a loyalty machine? Is that, is that unfair?
John Turner [01:13:20] Oh, no. Tell me what you have in mind there.
John Dehlin [01:13:22] Just like rewarding the people who are obedient and do your bidding.
John Turner [01:13:28] Okay. So in a sense, if. If, let's say John D. Lee is a loyal foot soldier to Brigham, then he's going to be rewarded with wives.
John Dehlin [01:13:41] Yeah,
John Turner [01:13:42] no, I think that that is definitely an important part of 19th century Mormon polygamy in that people are not supposed to be freelancing in the acquisition of wives. So just as doctrine and Covenants 132 teaches, there is one man appointed on the earth essentially at a time who holds the sealing power. And initially that's Joseph, and now it's Brigham. And he may delegate some of that authority to trusted associates like Heber C. Kimball and Willard Richards. But he doesn't even want apostles like Parley Pratt going around freelancing polygamous ceilings. And so there is a sense of control and reward. Also, as we go forward into, say, the 1850s, into the 1860s, there's an expectation that in order to attain positions of leadership within the church, say, to be the bishop in a particular community or something like that, that a man should enter into the patriarchal order of marriage, as it was sometimes called.
John Dehlin [01:15:16] Okay, so that's kind of a yes, right?
John Turner [01:15:21] That's a yes.
John Dehlin [01:15:22] Okay. And then the last one is the theology of kinship that nobody fully understood or does today.
Comparing Brigham Young and Joseph Smith's Approaches
John Turner [01:15:30] Yeah, that is absolutely the case. I, you know, my own spin on that is maybe just a little bit different. So Richard Bushman has a nice line in Rough Stone Rolling in which he says that Joseph wasn't so much that Joseph sexually lusted after women as much as he lusted after kin. Now, I take some issue with that because I wouldn't make it quite so tidy.
John Turner [01:16:08] But I also wouldn't simply say that Brigham lusts after kin, that his goal is to expand his kinship, because in a way that sounds familial and friendly, as if he, you know, he wants to assemble this enormous, happy family so that, you know, he can sit around the campfire at night, you know, telling. Telling stories with his extended family. I think it's. I. I do think for him, it is an expansion of his kingdom. And for him that makes him an almighty man on earth and for eternity.
John Dehlin [01:17:06] Yeah. Fascinating. Well, John Turner, I want this to be its own episode, and that doesn't mean we can't now immediately go on in the very next episode today to talking about post Joseph Smith, Brigham Young, Nauvoo polygamy. But I. I just think this overview could be really interesting and useful to people, and I really appreciate your willingness. Any other final things you want to say just about Brigham Young's polygamy overall? I was going to ask you if. If Joseph Smith had lived to see polygamy play out into the Utah years, would he have been okay with it? Would he have said it strayed from what his vision? Would he have been excited at the innovation, you know? Anything else you want to add about an overview of Brigham Young's polygamy?
John Turner [01:18:01] I think Joseph mostly would have. Him would have approved because to a large extent, I do see Brigham Young following in Joseph's footsteps initially. I think the big difference is we just have to make a dividing line between before February of 1846 and afterwards.
John Turner [01:18:28] So Brigham Unlike Joseph, he fathers children even before then. But for the most part, you know, polygamy is still hush hush. And there are all of these ceilings. And the people involved, I think, probably have not been told how this is going to play out in their lives. Once the Saints leave Nauvoo, they can be given living polygamy openly and rearranging their earthly lives in accordance with these ceilings. And that is a huge shift. Would Brigham, would Joseph Smith have done it the way that Brigham did it? We don't really have any way of knowing, but I don't think he would have. I don't think he would have objected to what Brigham did.
John Dehlin [01:19:23] And really quickly, Brigham Young, what would his view have been about the eternal nature of polygamy on the earth and in heaven? Did he ever contact, did he ever get pressure to end it while he was alive? Did he catch some of the early anti polygamy heat that ended up taking down Wilford Woodruff polygamy during the Wilford Woodruff time? Did he have statements about whether it would ever be taken from the earth, whether it was a requirement for exaltation in the hereafter? I think that's probably a pretty important thing to include in a wrap up.
John Turner [01:19:59] So great comments. So, yes. Well, first of all, he took a lot of heat from the US Government. So the Congress passes an anti Bigamy act in 1862. There are efforts to. And I think one of the ways that Brigham Young responded to it was by getting married again.
John Turner [01:20:25] So he wasn't one for backing down. There are some attempts to prosecute him, particularly in the 1870s. The federal authorities haven't really figured out how to sort of put the screws on Mormon polygamists during Brigham Young's lifetime. You know, the pressure really intensifies in the, in the 1880s.
John Turner [01:20:58] But yeah, the, the pressure is there. And Brigham Young has meetings with federal representatives in which they tell him really bluntly, you know, if you want statehood, you're going to have to abandon polygamy. He's not prepared to do so.
John Turner [01:21:19] So there's pressure, but he's able to resist it in terms of whether polygamy is a requirement for exaltation. Was that one of your questions, John?
John Dehlin [01:21:34] Yeah.
John Turner [01:21:36] So not strictly. I mean, the thing about Brigham Young is listeners might have heard of the Journal of Discourses, which is this enormous compilation of sermons, discourses, talks of church leaders, not only Brigham Young, but he's the most included individual. So unlike during Joseph Smith's lifetime, Brigham Young has people who are making transcripts of his sermons and addresses all the time. And he will frequently get up and speak his mind on any number of subjects. And he does engage this question on a number of occasions. And he will essentially, I think he gives himself a little bit of wiggle room, and he will say that, no, I mean, you don't absolutely need to be married polygamously. But there's very strong pressure on Mormon men, particularly Mormon men who have any positions of authority to do so.
John Dehlin [01:22:58] I remember a lot of people making hay, and I haven't really dug into this, of how vehemently early Mormon prophets and revelators insisted that polygamy was a requirement for exaltation in the highest degree of the Mormon celestial kingdom and that it could never be taken away, ever, from the heavens or the earth.
John Turner [01:23:23] Yeah, well, so certainly John Taylor was very much of that mindset. I think Wilford Woodruff was of that mindset until he wasn't of that mindset. So, you know, there are. There are some stretches at which. And we'll get into the nitty gritty of this in future episodes. There are some stretches in which Brigham Young applies a tremendous amount of pressure on church members who have been reluctant to go ahead and take plural wives.
John Turner [01:23:57] There's a time known as the Mormon Reformation in the mid to late 1850s in which there's intense pressure. Like, if you're going to live your religion, living your religion means taking one or more plural wives. And there's so much pressure that the supply of marriageable women, or girls, if you will, is dwindling. And that pushes the average age of marriage among Mormon women down quite a lot. So there are some stretches of intense pressure. The reality is, at the same time, there are roughly the same number of Mormon men and women in the mid to late 1800s. And so there simply aren't enough women for everyone to be a polygamist.
John Dehlin [01:24:58] Yeah, because the numbers don't add up.
John Turner [01:25:00] The numbers absolutely don't add up.
John Dehlin [01:25:02] They collapse,
John Turner [01:25:03] and they can't go out and convert, you know, another 20 or 50,000 women to make it work.
John Dehlin [01:25:10] I mean, they wouldn't mind it.
John Turner [01:25:12] No, they wouldn't have minded, but
John Dehlin [01:25:14] they probably tried.
John Turner [01:25:16] That was. That was not possible.
John Dehlin [01:25:21] Yeah. And ultimately it is taken from the earth. But as we've covered in other episodes on Mormon Stories, some believe that John Taylor was okay with the practice continuing, even if Wilford Woodruff eventually was going to end it. Correct.
John Turner [01:25:39] Oh, that. I mean, so Taylor's revelations and statements all point to no surrender on this issue. I think it's also pretty clear that when Wilford Woodruff backs down in 1890 and tells church members to obey the law of the land, that is not tantamount to abandoning the principle or even the practice. That it's really only when you get to the middle of the first decade of the 1900s that Joseph F. Smith really reckons with stamping out additional plural marriages.
John Dehlin [01:26:38] Yeah. It's true that by my count, the first eight Mormon prophets and presidents were polygamists. And it wasn't until David O. McKay, 40s, 50s, that we had the first Mormon prophet president who wasn't a polygamist. Right.
John Turner [01:26:55] That's correct. I forget exactly what year he becomes church president.
John Dehlin [01:27:01] Yeah, yeah. And DNC 132. Joseph Smith's polygamy revelation remains in the canon to this day. What does that mean? John Turner, tell us what that means doctrinally and theologically for Mormons.
John Turner [01:27:17] Well, that is a huge question. I don't know if I'm. I'm the best person to opine on that. I certainly think it would be simpler if at least everything after verse 20 or 21 wasn't there.
John Dehlin [01:27:36] What do you mean?
John Turner [01:27:38] So. Well, what I mean is the early part of section 132 teaches that marriage being sealed in marriage, is what's necessary for a marriage to persist beyond death and beyond earthly life, and that being sealed in marriage is a key requirement for exaltation and becoming gods. So the earlier part of the revelation basically confines itself to that, although it starts with the question of, you know, why was it that these figures in the Old Testament had multiple wives and God apparently considered that righteous? And then after 20 or 21 verses. I forget. Exactly. Then there's a shift to discussing some of these biblical examples and then ultimately. The really mandate for men to take additional wives and for women to be okay with that, specifically for Emma Smith to be okay with that.
John Dehlin [01:29:10] Right. If somebody were to conclude today, oh, you know, polygamy was something they did a long ago, but it was never meant to be permanent. It was just meant to be something early on to help build the church. Is that consistent with the history?
John Turner [01:29:31] So that's a great question. So I believe down to the present day, on those occasions in which the contemporary church explains or justifies 19th century polygamy, it is generally defended as a temporary expedient for the raising up of seed and the preservation of the Mormon people and shaping, you know, shaping their cohesion and identity. So it has been defended as a temporary expedient in recent. In recent Decades. I definitely don't think that was the intention of Joseph Smith or Brigham Young. They didn't introduce it for those reasons. Well, Joseph introduced it and Brigham continued it. The rationale in my reading was theological in a non temporary way.
John Dehlin [01:30:43] In a non temporary way.
John Turner [01:30:45] I hope I said that clearly enough. The rationale wasn't, oh, we need to have polygamy so that we can increase our population or for any other reason of expedience. It was, as Brigham Young put it, and I'll return to this quote again, becoming a God meant to be in possession of a kingdom, and that makes him an almighty man to that kingdom. I think that was Joseph's rationale. That was Brigham's rationale. That wasn't a temporary thing.
John Dehlin [01:31:18] Okay. And if somebody wanted to conclude, I know you don't. You're not in the business of arbitrating belief. But if somebody came to you and said, I just concluded polygamy was a big mistake, that Joseph and Brigham and the first day prophets just kind of made a mistake. But then sometimes God lets you make mistakes. Does that. Can a historian even say anything about that type of conclusion as it relates to what the evidence of the documents might show or not show?
John Turner [01:31:56] Well, you know, I sometimes think of making a mistake as sort of like leaving and leaving the waffles in the waffle iron too long and then they're burnt, right? Like that's an oops. And you know, you can do that repeatedly sometimes or forgetting to put the oil in the, in the, in the batter or something like that.
John Turner [01:32:23] So I would say mistake sounds like, that sounds like an easy breezy thing. But I get the point. Like, I do think this was, I would say, a tragic decision on Joseph's part. And when I look at the, some particular instances like that of Zina Huntington and Henry Jacobs, and it had, it had terrible consequences for somebody like Henry Jacobs in particular.
John Turner [01:33:02] And I'm not saying that everybody's experience with polygamy was miserable or miserable all of the time, but I do think the basic dynamics were, were not good. And I realize I'm not saying that in a particularly sophisticated way. Would I, if, if I could go back in time or, and recommend to Joseph Smith, yeah, don't do this, one's enough. I would, I would definitely, definitely have done that.
John Dehlin [01:33:44] So here's a really, really hard question. And I'm just thinking of these as they come. And I really appreciate you taking them free form. You know, how like you could argue that Zion's camp strengthened Joseph's Mormon movement. Even though it could technically be viewed as a disaster, could it be argued that, you know, and I've also heard some people say Joseph Smith's martyrdom, that Mormonism might not have survived Joseph smith living to 80, but his martyrdom helped strengthen the foundations of Mormonism.
John Dehlin [01:34:20] This is probably an impossible question to answer, but is it possible that as problematic as polygamy was, it helps strengthen and forge the foundations of Mormonism to make it the 300 plus billion dollar global largest and wealthiest and most powerful church ever to come out of America in the world? How do you separate its strength and wealth today from its first polygamous 50 years or 80 years, depending on how you count?
John Turner [01:34:55] So that's a great question and the premise of the question is quite interesting because some of those other things that you mentioned, even though they are either temporary disasters or tragedies, I do think you're right to suggest that they contributed to the cohesion of the movement in the sense more generally that opposition from other Americans did.
John Turner [01:35:32] And so polygamy then absolutely stokes opposition to Mormonism for the rest of the 19th century. And the Saints very much band together to defend themselves and their principle. And even some women, such as Augusta Adams, who privately have strong objections to the way they and their husbands have lived out polygamy, that they nevertheless defend it publicly. So there's something to that. But I would also counter that a bit by saying polygamy for the most part tanks Mormon conversion rates both in the Eastern United States and, and in Europe. So Mormon missionaries, I don't know, this might be parley Pratt, might be somebody else, maybe Orson Pratt.
John Turner [01:36:40] They refer to polygamy as a bone in the throat. Once, particularly once the church publicly acknowledges its practice, it becomes much harder to get European Christians or Eastern American Christians to take seriously Mormonism as a religious option, if that option includes polygamy.
John Dehlin [01:37:08] But John Turner, did polygamy forge the purity of the metal and separate the dross from the gold? In the foundations of early Mormonism and in the Mormon leadership, there's that quote, think not when you gather to Zion the gold from the dross purify. You know what I'm saying?
John Turner [01:37:32] Yeah, I hear you. I just think we might quibble about, well, we might not, but I might quibble with some people about what's the gold and what's the dross.
John Dehlin [01:37:44] And then if I know we can't do this, but if we were to do like a 19th century survey of Mormon men and Mormon women and even Mormon children who are involved in polygamy if you had to guess satisfaction ratings on a Likert scale from like 0 to 5, highly satisfied to extremely dissatisfied, where do you think on average, men, women, and children would have placed polygamy on their average Likert scale? I bet no one will ever ask you that.
John Turner [01:38:13] I mean, if I could do that survey, I would. I would move heaven and earth if I could in order to undertake that survey. And I want it all to be anonymous, of course, so I get really good data. Right.
John Turner [01:38:30] So I have two comments. Number one, people who write about Mormon marriage in the 19th century are correct to warn us to remember that monogamy was not a bed of roses for many women in particular in the 19th century. So, you know, married women across the board, through marriage, women gave up a lot of legal rights and often found themselves in situations in. In which they were neglected and abused. And it's true that for some of those women, polygamy was an escape hatch.
John Turner [01:39:18] So I think Parley Pratt's last polygamous wife left and as far as we know, an alcoholic and abusive husband who eventually shot and killed Parley Pratt. But you can find quite a few instances in which polygamy gives women, provides women with a measure of agency to make a new choice if they're.
John Turner [01:39:50] It wasn't always a first choice, just a first husband whom they may not have had any choice in the matter. It gave them a measure of agency, and I think that that is important to recognize.
John Dehlin [01:40:05] Some Mormon women became doctors, some, they would help each other with the household duties.
John Turner [01:40:12] Sure.
John Dehlin [01:40:13] You know, they could take turns, child care, whatever. Right,
John Turner [01:40:17] right. So someone within Brigham Young's household referred to the female family, sort of, you know, that sisterhood of plural wives. And so I do think it's important to start with the recognition that monogamous marriage was not Utopian. Right.
John Turner [01:40:38] So that is significant. And some of the defenses that Mormon hierarchs gave for polygamy was, you know, that I can understand the logic of every woman deserving a righteous husband and look at the rest of the country with its high rates of prostitution and abuse and so forth. Okay.
Polygamy's Lasting Legacy in the Church Today
John Turner [01:41:07] I just wanted to start with those qualifications. I do think this was fundamentally a hard system for people to live out, in part because it was a polygamous enclave within a Victorian society that generally valorized monogamous companionship. And I don't know, I can't quantify.
John Turner [01:41:39] I don't have a great answer to your survey question, but if you read through journals, yeah, you can find examples of contented women and men, but you can also find countless examples of women who experienced anguish and betrayal when their husbands married younger women or simply other women.
John Turner [01:42:04] And you can also. I also mentioned the Mormon Reformation in which men are getting pressured to take polygamous wives. And some of those wives are 13 years old. You know, that's. And I'm aware that there were some 13 year old girls who were, you know, sort of forced to marry monogamously. But that's a terrible, just a terrible dynamic, I think.
John Turner [01:42:33] And I think for a lot of men like Brigham Young, even at first, you know, right before he begins practicing polygamy, he has a note in, he has an entry in his journal in which he says he's home with Marianne. It's the first time they've been alone at home by their fireside for years.
John Turner [01:43:00] We enjoy it greatly. He wrote, I think partly because I'm a really contented monogamist. Despite what I said earlier, I, I do valorize that companionship and loyalty. And, you know, polygamy was, was, was pretty antithetical to that.
John Dehlin [01:43:26] Yeah, I remember talking to my grandma before she died, Karma Parkinson Benson. She was the child of a third wife and she was just like, oh, yeah, we just were so happy and the wives got along and we all played together as kids and we all helped out and we just have happy memories. And she was like in her 80s and 90s. You know, when she's sharing this with me, she didn't tell me about the fourth wife who, you know, my, my great grandpa kind of left and neglected the first two or three to marry her when she was super young.
John Dehlin [01:44:00] And they, they went off for a while and kind of disappeared and then came back and then she lived somewhere, but she lived super poor. And eventually they had fights and eventually he ends up in jail and eventually they have a public dispute and a public divorce. I think she gets injured and gets addicted to laudanum and ends up just moving back to Oregon and having a crappy final years before she dies.
John Dehlin [01:44:34] There are horror stories, and I'm reminded of when Rod Meldrum came on Mormon stories and he was like, there are black slaves who really liked it. They said they were glad to live on the plantation. And sometimes it seems like the church wants to use that type of apologetic. We have accounts of polygamous Mormon women who really loved it and bore their testimonies and angels testified to them that it was what they should be doing. And they have great stories. And so I always want to try and sift through. And the truth is it's probably all of that, right?
John Turner [01:45:10] Yeah. No, I think that's true. I think some of the negatives that we've talked about on this episode, they are hard to avoid within this system. Sort of the, the alpha male issue, the hierarchical nature of this. Also the downward pressure on the marriage age of women. If there's an expectation that men marry polygamous, polygamously, the. I think also I'll just say as a Protestant Christian, I don't have that hierarchical view of the afterlife in which some people are going to have a huge kingdom and other people are going to get a little bit of glory. I'm way more egalitarian when it comes to our eternal destinies. So, you know, I have some, I have some theological objections to that system that Joseph and Brigham introduced.
John Dehlin [01:46:23] Is your Christian God gendered, John Turner, or not even gendered?
John Turner [01:46:28] I would say not gendered.
John Dehlin [01:46:31] Okay. Yeah, I think that's probably more common.
John Turner [01:46:34] I mean, I think functionally, I think most Christians on some level problemat problematically think of God in male terms.
John Dehlin [01:46:44] I guess Jesus said Father when he prayed. Right,
John Turner [01:46:47] Right. But you know, Christian, most Christian theology at least officially has a non gendered God.
John Dehlin [01:46:57] Yeah. Despite
John Turner [01:46:57] the gendered language. It's a tricky thing.
John Dehlin [01:47:00] Yeah. I want to add, as we conclude, that Carolyn Pearson's book on the ghost of eternal polygamy is a great resource to understand how polygamy harms Mormon men and women today, active Latter Day Saints today, in very significant ways. And that doesn't even necessarily address the way that fundamentalist Mormon polygamy has become a scourge for child abuse and spousal abuse and poverty and pain and suffering for a lot of people who also would tell us that it was the best thing ever, I think, also.
John Dehlin [01:47:35] But the final thing is, as we see the Church of Jesus Christ Latter day Saints in 2026, hemorrhaging, I think it's fair to say, in the United States, even in Utah and in the developed world, it has to be that the decline or the declining growth and, or the decline of the Latter Day Saint movement in the past 20 years has to at least in part be attributed to the broad awareness of Joseph Smith's polygamy and Brigham Young's polygamy and the details of the polygamy and the polyandry and, you know, the existence of it still in DNC132, the fact that that's never been really reconciled with and dealt with directly, that so many people felt deceived and betrayed for not having been taught that this Polygamy ever really happened.
John Dehlin [01:48:27] I got into my early 30s before I really knew that Joseph Smith was not only a polygamist, but that was when I first learned the term polyandry for the first time. That's three decades in the church before I even learned that. I think all of that is a scourge to church growth in the 21st century and to the church's retention of even its members who were raised LDs and who are of pioneer ancestry. That's just my opinion.
John Turner [01:49:00] Well, I think a good starting point. And we. We really started the episode with this. There's so much contemporary debate about Joseph's polygamy in particular, to some extent, then also Brigham Young's polygamy. There are, you know, there's a lot of.
John Turner [01:49:25] A lot of questions out there. Who introduced this system? What was the nature of these marriages? Were they sexual? Were they ceremonial? How do we reckon with Joseph and Brigham being sealed to women who are already married? What about wives who were 14, 15, 16 years of age? There are all sorts of questions out there, and those questions often have moral components, I think it's fair to say.
John Turner [01:50:07] How could I understand someone as a prophet if he engaged in this behavior that I find really objectionable? Or is there a way to rationalize this, that or that behavior? I think the best starting point before engaging some of those questions is simply looking at the evidence that's out there, both for Joseph Smith and for Brigham Young. There is a ton of evidence that scholars like Todd Compton, Brian Hales, myself, to some extent, there's a lot. There's a lot of evidence out there that.
John Turner [01:50:51] Reputable. I hope I'm putting myself in that category. Reputable historians have identified and analyzed, and I do think it's a good idea. While it's a good idea simply to go to the evidence, to become familiar with not just the lives of Joseph Smith and Brigham Young, but the lives of their wives and all of the men and women who began living this out in the 1840s and then going forward.
John Dehlin [01:51:33] Brilliant. Well, John Turner, I think another. Yet another episode where we really probably didn't even begin to cover all that you prepared to cover today. But I loved it. And I'm mostly. I'm just really grateful that you're so gracious and generous with your knowledge and with your time. I would say you're a pretty reputable historian. I mean, at least pretty reputable.
John Turner [01:51:59] Thanks, John. That means a lot. I kind of feel, you know, I once had this. Maybe I've referenced this before. I once had this plan. The first time I was going to read the Book of Mormon, I was going to read it in 15 days. I wasn't going to be like parley Pratt and read it all in one night, but I was going to read it in 15 days. And I said, there are 15 books, so I can do a book a day. And then I got to Alma and it's like, oh, I got stuck. And I feel like that's what we've done. In chapter four or five of Biography, we were cruising and. But now we got got into a, you know, a sort of thick chapter.
John Dehlin [01:52:45] I don't think we're stuck. I think we're, we're becoming exalted in your insight.
John Turner [01:52:52] Yeah.
John Dehlin [01:52:54] Well, I appreciate it, John Turner, thank you so much for today. And just so folks know, we're still on chapter five and next time, I swear to all of Brigham Young's wives and his law of adoption adult ceilings as well, and all the posterity worlds without end that we will actually cover Brigham Young's polygamous marriages starting on page 132. His. His Naboo Post Joseph pre Pioneer polygamous marriages.
John Turner [01:53:31] Sounds good. Sounds like a plan.
John Dehlin [01:53:33] Okay, thanks for joining us, John Turner. Please buy the book. The book is Brigham Young Pioneer Prophet by John G. Turner. The website is Brigham Young podcast dot com. If you want to support John Turner or Julia or these types of academic or histor episodes, you can click on the donate button. To become a monthly donor, please email us@mormonstoriesmail.com Please like and subscribe and share. We love your comments, corrections, additions, no mean spiritedness. But other than that, we love feedback. So please share it on YouTube, Spotify and wherever else you consume our stuff. Thanks again to Julia and Brooklyn for all they do in post production. Be good to each other. Be kind to each other. Thanks, John Turner, and we'll see you all again soon on another episode of the Brigham Young Podcast and on Mormon Stories podcast. Take care everybody.
Transcript © 2026 John P. Dehlin. All rights reserved. Brief quotations are welcome with attribution and a link to mormonstories.org; all other use requires written permission.