Left Pentecostal Christianity to Fight Christian Nationalism – Kevin Crowe | Ep. 2218

Welcome to Exvangelical Stories, a new series under the umbrella of Mormon Stories Podcast exploring the experiences of people who grew up in evangelical Christianity, questioned their faith, and found their way beyond the religious worlds that shaped their lives. 

In this episode, we sit down with Kevin Crowe to explore his journey from growing up in the Evangelical church to becoming an ex-Christian and creating content about religious deconstruction. Kevin describes his childhood in the Church of God, where church was a regular part of life, and his eventual immersion in an intense religious culture filled with speaking in tongues, being “slain in the Spirit,” spiritual warfare, and the fear of hell. 

Kevin shares his experiences with the production Heaven’s Gate and Hell’s flames where he watched people getting dragged off the stage and into hell. He discusses what it was like to witness to others and carry the eternal fate of others in his own hands. We explore how Kevin tried to discern God’s will and how he explained questions about the Bible, including Noah’s Ark.

Kevin shares how a conversation with a form pastor changed his entire life.  Kevin also reflects on the aftermath of leaving Christianity in 2009, the loneliness of deconstruction, the lingering fear of hell, and the realization that belief can disappear faster than the fear associated with it. We discuss cognitive dissonance, why people that leave religion because they want to sin is a misunderstanding of the experience of losing one’s faith.

Finally, Kevin talks about creating Jesus Unfollower, joining the deconstruction community, navigating social media as a former believer, and choosing comedy over rage in his commentary. He offers advice for those questioning their faith: stay curious, ask questions, take your time, and give yourself permission to investigate what you believe.

If you’d like to support Exvangelical Stories, click here: https://donorbox.org/exvangelicalstories

Join Decon/Recon, Todd’s private, protected online community for people questioning Christianity, actively deconstructing, or rebuilding after faith. Find honest conversation, real connection, and support without evangelizing, pressure, judgment, or debate.

Episode Transcript

Full text · 22,200 words · 13 chaptersHost: John Dehlin · Guests: Kevin Crowe, Todd Phillips

This transcript is machine-generated and lightly edited for readability. The audio is authoritative. Please excuse occasional errors in names and spelling.

Introducing the Ex-Evangelical Stories Series

John Dehlin [00:00:00] Hi everyone. Welcome to another edition of Mormon Stories podcast. I have a quick introduction. Some of you may know that recently I interviewed Todd Phillips, an ex evangelical megachurch pastor, to talk about his leaving Evangelical Christianity. And after that interview was over, I talked to Todd about the fact that the Evangelical Christianity space needs a Mormon Stories equivalent to. Todd is looking to break into social media to provide a similar function to evangelicals as I and others have tried to provide in Mormonism. So here's the deal. I struck a deal with Todd that Mormon Stories will sponsor five episodes of him interviewing ex evangelicals and we would release those on Mormon Stories podcast.

John Dehlin [00:00:50] So that's what this is. This is one of five of those episodes. It'll be a limited series. We hope you enjoy it. At a minimum, this is going to provide you all with great ex evangelical narratives because we know you value exit narratives or faith transition narratives across all high demand religions. And Todd's great. So we hope you enjoyed this one of five episodes. At a minimum. Todd is going to be launching his own Evangelical Stories channel that that you can all enjoy. And I'll feel good that we as a community helped support Todd in that effort. There's also a possibility that if you all like this series enough on Mormon Stories that this can be an ongoing series even here on Mormon Stories.

John Dehlin [00:01:39] So what we've done is we've created a donor box link for you to donate to if you want to see more of these exvangelical stories on Mormon Stories. So you go to donorbox.org/exvangelical stories and that's the way you could sign up for a monthly or a weekly or some regular frequency appearance of Todd interviewing ex evangelicals on Mormon stories. Again, donorbox.org EXVangelicalStories we'll have a link to it in the comments. If y' all sign up for that, we'll do more than five. If you don't sign up for that to donate to a more regular series, Todd's going to just, you know, go do great things.

John Dehlin [00:02:23] And we're going to be really excited as the Mormon Stories community to have supported Todd and ex evangelical brothers and sisters. Anyway, thanks for joining us. Enjoy this episode with Todd Phillips and we'll see you all again soon on another episode of Mormon Stories podcast. Take care.

Todd Phillips [00:02:41] Welcome to exvangelical stories. I'm Dr. Todd Phillips and this is a new series in partnership with Mormon Stories. It's built around long form, open, honest conversations with people whose lives have been shaped by specifically evangelical Christianity. The process of deconstructing from that religious faith and really what comes afterwards. So the goal here isn't to convince anyone to believe or not believe anything, religiously or otherwise. It's just to give people first a space to tell their own stories. Like, you'll see today what they believed, what changed, what it cost them, and what life looks like now. But it's also to allow the viewer to really understand that they're not alone if they're going through the same circumstances.

Todd Phillips [00:03:22] So my guest today is Kevin Crowe. Many of you may know him from his work as Jesus Unfollower and more recently, Kevin Crowe comedy. He grew up around Christianity. Eventually, he became deeply immersed, and we'll talk about this in the Pentecostal Church of God movement, and later lost his faith. And today, he uses comedy primarily as satire to push back against a couple things. Religious extremism on the one hand and Christian nationalism on the other. So, Kevin, I'm really glad you're here.

Kevin Crowe [00:03:50] It's great to be here. Thanks for having me.

Todd Phillips [00:03:52] Yeah, yeah. I'm excited about this. So for people who've encountered you online as Jesus Unfollower or Kevin Crowe comedy more recently, you know, they. They know the funny side of you. But what I want to do is I want to go all the way back. I want to go back to your childhood, and I want to talk about really how all this came to be in the first place. So take me back, and this is before the Church of God. We'll get to that in a minute. But take me back to your childhood. What was. What was religion like in your house growing up? You know, were your parents deeply religious? Was Christianity just assumed to be true? What. What did that look like?

Kevin's Casual Christian Upbringing

Kevin Crowe [00:04:25] Yeah, I would say that I didn't grow up in a very strict Christian household. It was one of those things where, like, yes, you know, we believed in the God of the Bible, we believed in Christianity, and we didn't ever, like, read the Bible at home or, like, pray before meals or any of that stuff, but we would go to church almost every Sunday. We would go to different Baptist churches because I was born in Michigan. We moved to the south when I was 5. And we were always trying to find a home church. And mom would always say, I want to have the kids in church.

Kevin Crowe [00:04:58] I want to raise them in church. And so we would just kind of bounce around between different Baptist churches trying to find one that felt like home, and we would settle on one and stay there for six months to a year. And, like, I don't know if this is really the place. And so then we would go to another one. But, yeah, I went to public school and stuff, so I wouldn't say that I had a very strict religious upbringing.

Todd Phillips [00:05:19] Okay. Did you assume. Did you just assume Christianity to be true?

Kevin Crowe [00:05:26] Yeah, I. I didn't know that there were any other options. Like, I had never thought in my life of the possibility that there might not be a God or that the Christian God wasn't the real one. It was just like, yeah, that's just the norm. Like, God is there, Jesus, you know, that was it Christianity. There was no other option. I had never, like, heard, really, of other religions or atheism or anything like that as a kid.

Todd Phillips [00:05:51] Yeah, it's quite remarkable, especially in certain areas of the United States, that I found where you really are surrounded from all sides. I mean, you're inside a bubble of kind of Christian ideology, if nothing else. So let me ask you this. Were you afraid of. Were you afraid of hell as a kid?

Kevin Crowe [00:06:07] I really wasn't because, you know, we would go to church, but the. The messages weren't like hellfire and brimstone type messages. It was just like, oh, you know what? We just read from the Gospels or something and just do a little sermon. Everybody's looking at the clock, waiting on noon. So then we would just, you know, leave and go eat lunch and stuff. So it wasn't like a. I didn't have that fear as a child.

Todd Phillips [00:06:30] Did you think of yourself as quote, unquote saved? And for people watching this that don't have the same religious background that you and I both come from, Evangelical Christianity, the idea is that you pray and ask God to forgive you through Jesus, and then you're saved. You're now in the family of God, and then you're protected and you're going to heaven. That's where the relationship with God starts in evangelical Christianity. So did you think you were saved when you were a child?

Kevin Crowe [00:06:56] I never really thought about it, I guess, which is kind of weird. But there wasn't like this salvation moment. It was just kind of like, God is there, and. And I go to church. It was more. Church was more of just like kind of an event. We just went, listen to the music, listened to a sermon, and then just went home. There wasn't, like I said, there wasn't that fear and stuff, and there wasn't. I didn't feel any, like, compelling reason to like, give my life to Jesus or anything. It was just like.

Kevin Crowe [00:07:23] I thought it was like, stuff for older people, you know, kids, we're just there at church. We're just doing our little activities, going to Sunday school, whatever, like getting saved and like reading your Bible and living for God and all that stuff. That was just something that you kind of did when you got older. I think that's kind of how I thought of it as a kid.

Todd Phillips [00:07:41] Yeah. So I mean, Christianity, that's this point sounds clearly, it's not part of your identity. It's. It's a thing that you did and it's something that your family was part of and you went to the events and functioned within that world, assumed God was there. But really this is not at this point driving your life or your decisions or your sense of eternal destiny in any way?

Kevin Crowe [00:08:02] No. My life was like playing baseball outside in my neighbor's yard as a kid, playing video games, staying outside from sun up to sundown, and then going to church on Sundays. But it wasn't like a huge part of my everyday life at all.

Todd Phillips [00:08:19] Yeah, okay, so. So in light of that. Right. So something changes in your teenage years pretty radically, and we're going to talk about that. Somewhere in your teenage years, something radical changes and you end up at specifically this church called the, the Church of God. Do you remember, let's take back to this day where you walk in. Do you remember walking into that environment for the first time? The very first time? And if so, what was that first experience like?

Joining a Pentecostal Church of God

Kevin Crowe [00:08:46] Oh, I sure do. So we got invited to a church of God by some, a co worker of my brothers. And so we went and this was so different than any church I had ever been to before. Like, I walked, we were a little bit late, like probably like five minutes late for the service or something like that. And I was like, oh, yeah, we'll just walk in, sit down. Well, we walk in and there's like music blasting as soon as we open the doors. Because they shut the doors as the service is starting. Right. To the, to the sanctuary. So we open the doors and like their music is blasting.

Kevin Crowe [00:09:20] There's drums, there's electric guitars, there's people dancing around, like in their seats up at the altar. There's people waving giant flags around. And we're just looking for a spot to sit down. It's a packed house. We finally find a spot to sit down. And then something I'll never forget is the keyboard player just completely stopped playing. She was just right in the middle of a song and just did this and just stopped playing and started running laps around the church, like around the inside of the church. And I was like, what is going on? Here I am, I think I was 14 or 15. I can't remember how old I was when we started going there.

Kevin Crowe [00:09:58] But it's like, what is happening? She's like running around, kind of like singing, praising, and apparently it was the Holy Spirit. But at that time, I didn't know what the heck was going on.

Todd Phillips [00:10:09] So does it make you. In that moment, does it make you uncomfortable? I mean, are you going, wow, this is weird. I want to get out of here. Was it a curiosity? I wonder what's going on. Maybe I want to be a part of this. What's going on in your head at that time?

Kevin Crowe [00:10:20] I didn't really want to be a part of it. I don't think I was just. I was more confused. I didn't know what in the world was happening. I was like, why is she running around? It didn't make any sense. Like, I didn't. I didn't understand the concept of the Holy Spirit at that point. The most I had seen was like, in my Baptist church is like somebody just slipping their hand up in the back during a song or something, during a red back Kindle song. And this was a shock to the system, I guess you could say.

Todd Phillips [00:10:48] Yeah. So these are called Pentecostal churches or charismatic churches. These are the terms that are used often for these kind of very, very emotionally driven. Emotionally charged. Holy Spirit driven is what they would call it. Congregations. Right. Where everybody is. There's terms like slain in the spirit, speaking in tongues, laughing in the spirit. Let's talk a little bit about this. I really want to paint the picture because. Because a lot of people have never seen this. This kind of environment before. And it's. It's quite astonishing. The first time you walk in. I walked in the first time as an adult. I can't imagine what that. That would have been like as a teenager. So talk about tongues. So people speak in tongues. What does that look like? What does that mean? How did you experience that the first time?

First Encounters With Tongues and Revival Drama

Kevin Crowe [00:11:31] So, like, the keyboard is running around the church was bad enough, and then suddenly somebody in the middle of the church just starts yelling in this. What doesn't even sound like a language, you know? And I'm like, what is that? Then everybody in the church was kind of like, get quiet. And then the pastor would interpret what this guy was allegedly saying in tongues. That was. This happened almost every service at this church. So there was. All this was going on in my very first time going to this church. The. The flag waving, the running around the church, the speaking in tongues. People like laying hands on other people and them falling down and like convulsing in the altar and like somebody walking around, covering up, covering them up with a blanket, you know, because they couldn't be indecently exposed or anything.

Kevin Crowe [00:12:16] Just like, just. And it was bizarre. But yeah, the tongues thing, man, it was, I didn't know what, what that was. And it was just completely normal for everybody there. It was like, oh, just there's a select like two or three people in the church. It seemed to always be them. That would be the person who started just speaking really loudly in tongues, like right in the middle of a sermon or something. And then the pastor would like stop. He would receive whatever that was and then he would interpret it to us.

Kevin Crowe [00:12:45] And it just so happened that a lot of times it was the exact same thing every time. I think you just had like a, probably a go to list of like interpretations. I don't know.

Todd Phillips [00:12:54] Wow. So. So it sounds like if I'm an understander, it doesn't sound like a language. It just sounds like. It sounds like gibberish, doesn't it? I mean, I've watched this happen and then, and then someone supposedly interprets what's coming out of this person's mouth.

Kevin Crowe [00:13:06] Yeah. Even the pastor would joke about it. He would say like he was going around saying, tie my bow tie, tie my bow tie. Or like these little phrase, there's these little phrases that you can say that kind sound like you're speaking in tongues. Like I should have bought a Kia, but I bought a Hyundai is a good one. And that's what, that's what it sounds like, you know, it's just that kind of language. And it's just, it's wild how quickly that stuff becomes normal. Because there I am, 14 years old, going to this church and all this is completely new to me. But like, not too much later, I was just going to this church every week and this stuff just became part of my normal everyday life. Just seeing this kind of stuff happening in church.

Todd Phillips [00:13:44] Yeah. So very, very strange, Very unfamiliar. Not sure what's going on. Levels of confusion, watching people fall over and convulse on the ground, speak in these supposedly, you know, spirit led languages. And then all of a sudden, how soon, how soon does it move from wow, I don't know what's going on here to yeah, this is normal. How long did that take?

Kevin Crowe [00:14:06] Not long. I mean, probably like, I don't know, three to six months maybe. Because like, maybe after a month I was like, okay, you know, I Kind of knew what to expect at least. But then, you know, just get a few months down the road, it was just like, oh, yeah, I'm going to church. And this is completely normal. This is just the way things are. That's just how God moves. That's how the Holy Spirit moves. And, you know, he's. It's more powerful than us. It's bigger than us. So, like, speaking in tongues, that was God showing up, you know, or the Holy Spirit, people falling down at the altar. Was God showing up during the service. And it just became so normal so fast. And thinking back on that is just. It's strange, I think, how. How quickly I was like, oh, yeah, that's. That's normal.

Todd Phillips [00:14:49] Yeah, it's. It's interesting, the tribal mentality and how. How tribal we. We really are. Right. Our tribe defines truth and helps us understand what is a chaotic moment and puts order to it just by explaining that it's from God and God can do anything. It's really remarkable to me because I. I fell into the same. The same trap in. In different environment. I was in a Southern Baptist church primarily and didn't see a lot of Pentecostal activity, you know, inside that church. It was quite the opposite. But I've been to Pentecostal churches and seen what you've. What you describe here. You mentioned to me at one point, and I remember I went to these as well.

Todd Phillips [00:15:20] It was called Heaven's Gate, Hell's Flames, I believe. Is that right? Yeah. So it's a. It's a play that's. That's put on in lots of different churches. In my Southern Baptist church, it happened every summer, and it went on for, I think it was four or five nights throughout an entire week.

Heaven's Gates and Hell's Flames

Kevin Crowe [00:15:38] Yeah.

Todd Phillips [00:15:38] And I want you to take the. The viewers there. Let's. Let's describe the scene. What is Heaven's Gates, Hell's Flames? What does it look like on stage? What's the purpose of it? When did you first experience it? Let's talk about that.

Kevin Crowe [00:15:51] Oh, man. So Heaven's Gates and Hell's Flames is like. It's like the best way I can explain it is like a traveling play or like a drama. You know, they. Well, they have this traveling team of actors, and they have this. These whole sets where they construct that make it look like heaven, Hell, the gates of Heaven. And they will go around, travel around to churches, and they will use people from the church as actors in this play also. So they will take people from the youth group at our church. So the first time I saw this. I think I was 16.

Kevin Crowe [00:16:27] I was going into being a senior in high school, so Maybe I was 17. And they would. They came to the church like you said it was. I think it was maybe two or three nights, but I didn't know anything about this. They were like, oh, yeah, we're having Heaven's Gates and Hell's Flames. Everybody come. And it's weird because they didn't really even discourage bringing children. It was just like, you know, parents, use your own discretion. If you want to bring kids to this thing, it's fine. And so they would have these skits, basically, where one of them that I vividly remember is. It's four teenagers.

Kevin Crowe [00:16:59] They're driving their fictional car, drinking beer, you know, and driving. And then they get in a crash. They all wake up and they're at the gates of heaven. And the whole bit is like, do I get in Jesus? Do I get into heaven? I believed in you. And then it's like this voice comes up and says, depart from me. I never knew you. You know. And it's then these, like, people in. Dressed in black run up onto the stage. Like, the background turns to fire and flames, and these demons run up on stage and they grab the people and pull them off the stage, signifying that they're going to hell.

Kevin Crowe [00:17:38] Okay, you're not getting into heaven because you were drinking and driving as a teenager. They pull them to hell. And it's wild because then some people would get in, some would not. It just depends. And they would have, like, four or five different little skits. And it was just scare tactics, you know, and that. That was the moment that I got saved. That was the moment that I really gave my life to Christ because I was like, oh, my God, I can't risk leaving this church. What if I go? What if I get in a car accident? What if I, like, had said a cuss word or was thinking impure thoughts or, you know, whatever.

Kevin Crowe [00:18:14] And, like, what if I die on the way home? Then that's going to be me. I'm going to wake. I'm going to, like, be like, at the gates of heaven, like God, I, you know, do I get in and then I'm going to be dragged to hell? So that was just. I gave. I gave my life to Christ out of fear, really. And it was terrifying.

Todd Phillips [00:18:33] Yeah. So let's talk a little bit about the manipulation of that. Right. So when I watched it, it was very similar. I had. I had just become a Christian, and I'm maybe months into my Christian Experience. I'm at the Southern Baptist Church and I experienced what you did. What was interesting about it for me was it actually had some impact, some, some significant impact on me really becoming passionate about evangelism.

Todd Phillips [00:18:57] Right. I mean, I can't let, I, I'm, I'm saved from that. Thank God. Literally, right? Thank God he's taken me out of that situation. So now I need to go tell people about it. But I remember thinking that the, the presentation was really remarkable because when they dragged people off, I mean, they were screaming and they would, they would fall to the ground and these demons would just pull them, literally kicking and screaming, across the stage back into this fiery furnace, right? And I was like, it did the same thing to me. It was just a, it was this very frightening moment. And I remember how many kids, like you say, how many kids, junior high, elementary kids, high school kids were inside that and they would come back every night, five nights in a row. It just, it's remarkable to me. And you talk about, you know, fear is what got you to go, yeah, I'm in.

Kevin Crowe [00:19:46] Yeah, right?

Todd Phillips [00:19:47] Not, oh my gosh, it's going to be exciting to get to heaven. It's. Man, I don't want to go there. Is that accurate?

Kevin Crowe [00:19:53] Yeah, that was like the driving force. And I remember one of the, one of the skits inside of this heaven's gates, Hell's Flames play was that it was a, a parent and their child. I think it was a dad and his kid, like a 40 year old and a teenager. And the kid was like passionate about Jesus, gave his life to Christ, lived for God and the parent was like, oh, you know, I'll do that later in life. Then they die. I think it was another car crash. I think that, I don't know why they were so obsessed with car crashes, but I think that's what happened.

Kevin Crowe [00:20:25] And then like you see the child going to heaven and the parent going to hell and it's this weird, like the child is like happy to see Jesus because like every time somebody goes to heaven in this play, Jesus, the guy dressed as Jesus comes out. Which is kind of hilarious when you think about it, because I've seen skids online where like, they didn't even give the Jesus long hair. It was just a guy with a buzz cut. But that's another tangent.

Kevin Crowe [00:20:51] But like, so they, they'll go hug Jesus, like, yay, I'm going to heaven. But it's like, how happy can you really be if you just saw your parent get dragged to hell? Because that was the order, it was like the parent went to hell and then the child gets into heaven and they're like, yay, Jesus. And they like, hug him and stuff. And I'm like, did you not just see your dad get dragged to hell a minute ago? And there's that, like, feeling that. And, and so it's like, oh, yeah, you know, I want to be an eternity. This should be like. It's a message for parents and for young people. It's creating a lot of fear. Like, you don't want to be separated from your parents forever, do you? It was wild.

Todd Phillips [00:21:26] Yeah. Just manipulation on so many levels.

Kevin Crowe [00:21:28] Yes.

Todd Phillips [00:21:29] And, and I, I. Let me ask you this. Let's just go back into one piece of that for just a minute. Did you, did that ever come up in your mind at that time? It's like, well, you know, I'm probably going to be really sad in heaven because all my friends are in hell that don't know Jesus. Or did it just, did it just kind of wash over you at the time? Because it did with me. I was, I'm surprised, looking back, how I just didn't allow myself to think too much about that.

Kevin Crowe [00:21:52] Yeah, I think I was just more scared for my own soul than anything else. And I was so scared because I went at least the first two nights and I got saved the first night. And then I rededicated my life to Christ on the second night, AKA I went right back up to the altar and like, confessed all my sins, even though I just the day before confessed all my sins, said Jesus, I accept you into my heart as my Lord and Savior. The very next night, I'd had so much guilt from watching this play again that I, I, like, went up to the altar. It, like, dropped to my knees and was like, asking for forgiveness. And, you know, please, I want to make sure. It's like, you know, double checking that I'm going to get into heaven at that point.

Todd Phillips [00:22:31] Isn't that something? You know, because I talked to so many people and certainly experienced that in my own life, where you rededicate your life. That's what it's called, rededicating. So you, you've already been saved. You already thought you were saved, and then maybe you might not be. And you just want to make sure. And these kinds of situations make you want to do that. It's like, man, I just, I, I want to cross all the T's, dot all the I's. I want to do everything that I can possibly do and say as many times as needed. To avoid hell.

Kevin Crowe [00:22:55] Yeah. Because what we believed at that church of God is that you could backslide. So I know a lot of people believe, like, once saved, always saved. Meaning if you confess once in your life that Jesus is Lord, that even if you mess up, even if you sin, that you're still going to go to heaven because you gave your life to Jesus. At one point, you accepted him as your Lord and Savior. Well, at that church, that wasn't really ever the message. It was like you could lose your salvation because you could if you gave your life to Christ, but then you didn't live for him, then you're not getting into heaven.

Kevin Crowe [00:23:27] Like that verse, Matthew 7:21, I think it is, where it's like, many of you will say, lord, Lord, have I not done wonderful things in your name? And then he says, depart from me. I never knew you. That verse right there scared all of us in that church. And the pastor would recite that a lot. And there was always that fear of, I could mess up and just lose this.

Kevin Crowe [00:23:48] And so then you. That's why you would see so many people, like, going to the altar and rededicating their life to Christ. It seemed like every week or every other week, because it wasn't guaranteed that you were going to get in.

Todd Phillips [00:24:01] Yeah, you never know. You never know for sure. Yeah, I. My church was eternal security. Once you got saved, you were always saved, and you couldn't lose it. I remember saying this from stage when I started preaching. Look, you. When you're. When you're born from your mother's womb, you can't be unbirthed.

Todd Phillips [00:24:17] You know, there's no way that's silly. In the same way, when you're birthed into God's family, you can't be unborn. Right. So that was our theology. And yet you talk about another opposite theology, which is you can lose your salvation. And it was primarily on that one verse. So there are entire denominations, it's important, I think, to talk about this like yours was one of them. Their entire denomination is built primarily on the fact that you can lose your salvation. You can never be sure, and you need to live your life with this level of uncertainty because you never know for sure. And so there's a tremendous amount of fear and manipulation that comes from that, where you're kept in line. Why? Because you could lose this free gift that you got.

Kevin Crowe [00:24:56] Yeah, it was kind of like, to us, it was kind of like a ridiculous notion that you could get saved, give your life to Jesus, and then just go do whatever you want. But I guess the feeling is that you're not going to do that. If you truly give your life to Jesus, you're not going to want to live that way. But on a technicality, you could, you know, start believing, confess your sins and then just, you know, do whatever you want after that. And we were like that. Just, that doesn't feel like true Christianity to us. It's. You could, you could lose that. Nothing's guaranteed.

Todd Phillips [00:25:29] Yeah, you and I both experience what, what I now term is just high control religious, you know, culture where there's a lot of control built into the system. There are very high walls built up of control and behavior modification and behavior control that, that drive your life from that point. And a lot of it's very fear based and it's a real thing. And it, once you're in it, well, let's just talk about you getting in it. So you go to this process, you, you accept Jesus as your Lord and Savior, you're all in because you're afraid of going hell. Now you've saved yourself at least for a time because you don't know if that's permanent at this point. What does it look like to go all in? How often are you at church? What ministries were you involved in? Yeah, tell me about this.

Kevin Crowe [00:26:17] I was temporarily saved, you know, saved with an asterisk because you could lose it at some point. I was all in, man. I would go Sunday morning, Sunday night, Wednesday night, Friday night. We had Friday Night Fire, which was mainly. It was mostly worship music that they would just play like the best worship songs and they would have like a short message and a lot of times it was given by like the youth pastor or the associate pastor or something like that. But I got involved with the youth worship band. I was on the drama team. So at various points in my church career, I played Jesus Christ.

Kevin Crowe [00:26:56] So. So I have been Jesus Christ and I've also played the soldier whipping Jesus Christ walking down Main street in my city dressed like a soldier and I just have this giant whip and I'm like whipping the ground. I'm trying not to actually whip the guy.

Kevin Crowe [00:27:14] So I was involved with all that. I was also involved in the puppet ministry in the children's church. So I had a pretty good little array of puppets and I would get on my computer and I would print off different puppet scripts. I would find like these Bible puppet scripts online, print them off, tape them behind the wall, and I would just. Sometimes I'd be both puppets just going back and forth. And sometimes I Had this grandpa puppet that would do, like, a rap song, and the kids loved it. And it was like, grandpappy can rappy. I can't remember the words. I wish because I would totally wrap it for you right now, but I can't remember. It's been such a long time, but I was heavily involved.

Todd Phillips [00:27:50] Wow. So let me ask you this. Did you. Did you ever speak in tongues? Were you ever slain in the spirit? Did you. Did psychologically, how did this impact you? And did you. Did you buy in completely and experience some of these things as well?

Fully Bought In: Spiritual Experiences and Evangelism

Kevin Crowe [00:28:03] I bought in completely. I was slain in the spirit multiple times. Although looking back on it now, I'm like. I just got caught up in the moment. You know, it was such a weird feeling in your body. It's like this really warm feeling when you would. So everybody would be up in the. They would do the altar call. Everybody would come to the altar at the end of the service. Like, the pastor would say, are you. You know, is something on your heart? Like, did God speak to you during the sermon? Or if you need to get up here and confess your sins? So everybody would go up there.

Kevin Crowe [00:28:33] Like, half the church, at least, would go to the altar. People would be raising their hands, and then, like, the pastor's coming around, and he's laying hands on people's foreheads. Some of them are not falling down. Some of them are falling down. And the first time that that happened was strange, too, because, like, and every time after that, I would still get this really weird, like, warm feeling of, like, oh, man, they're coming. Like, they're almost here. They're getting to me. They're going down the row, and they would lay hands on you, and then you would just, like, fall down. Sometimes you would not fall down.

Kevin Crowe [00:29:01] It really felt like they wanted you to fall down, though. So, like, a lot of times they would just lay their hands on your head for, like, as long as it took until you finally fall down. So. Or fell down. Fall is not a word. And so I did that multiple times.

Kevin Crowe [00:29:16] But, like, in my brain, even at the time I was. I would be, like, trying to convince myself, I think, that that was God. Like, yeah, you know, the Holy Spirit went through me, and I. I fell down in the altar. And then you would lay there for a while. Some people would lay there for, like, 30 minutes. And then some people would get up quick as far as speaking in tongues. Unfortunately, I did that one time, and it was in my bedroom at home, which is weird. And I think it's because I felt so much pressure at church of I felt like I was falling behind people because I would see my friends speaking in tongues and I had never done that before or whatever.

Kevin Crowe [00:29:54] And it felt like, man, they really are closer to God than I am. And so I'm just there in my bedroom one night and I'm just like, praying to God. And then like, I have one of those shoulda bought a Kia, bought a Hyundai moments where I speak in tongues for like, literally like 10 seconds. And then it was over. And I was like, wow, I just spoke in tongues. But then I'm. You're like, questioning, was that real? It was not. And of course, looking back on it now, I know it's not real. I know it's just emotion, guilt and. And that feeling of I'm not where I need to be, and like, maybe doing this thing will get me closer.

Todd Phillips [00:30:27] Yeah. You know, they've done a lot of study on group dynamics and peer pressure and how that affects our psychology and. And the just amazing way the brain responds to peer pressure and that kind of stimuli. Right. So you felt like. And I. I've experienced this with others as well, and I certainly. Did you. When you don't experience those things. I remember a friend of mine telling me he spoke in tongues. And. And I was at a Bible church and we just thought we were cessationists, meaning that we didn't believe the spiritual gifts, you know, existed past the apostles. That's one way of dealing with that issue in certain denominations.

Todd Phillips [00:30:56] And so I was always going, well, maybe we're wrong about that. And these people seem to have a real passion for God. And maybe I just don't know what it means to be fully, you know, fully sold out to God or I'd speak in tongues. And I remember sitting in a car with a guy and he just prayed for me to speak in tongues for like 45 minutes, and he spoke in tongues and it just never happened for me. And I remember leaving the car going, either he's an idiot, or I'm just never, ever, ever going to know God the way he does. And I.

Todd Phillips [00:31:24] And I couldn't resolve that. I got out of the car going, it's one of those, but I just don't know which one it is.

Kevin Crowe [00:31:29] Wow.

Todd Phillips [00:31:29] It's amazing when you say you don't believe that anymore. So speaking in tongues, being slain in the spirit. These are all these terms we've been talking about. You understand that now as these kinds of things, I'm talking about just the psychology of religious belief, how the Brain looks for patterns and belonging to. And peer pressure can be a very powerful thing. But all those things, I want to stress this. All those things felt very real at the moment. In the moment.

Kevin Crowe [00:31:59] 100%. Yeah. It felt so real in the moment. And now looking back on it, it's like, oh, yeah, it was just, you know, groupthink, dopamine hits. Yeah, the group psychology, it's easy to see once, or at least for me, like, once you step out of it, to look back and say, oh, man, I was really caught up in that. But, you know, a lot of people are still caught up in that and still believe it. And maybe some of the people who, I guess people who leave never think that, oh yeah, that was real. But then, then you got people saying like, oh, well, you never really a believer. Then if you left and then you're looking back and like. But no, like you said in the moment, I 100% believe that all this was real.

Todd Phillips [00:32:37] Yeah, you felt, you felt these were genuine experiences. And your church and your community, your group was identifying those experiences and connecting them with God. This is God moving. This is God speaking. This is God using you. Right. It's. They're defining the experience for you and giving you the origin story for that experience. Yeah.

Kevin Crowe [00:33:01] And it's how like, so many churches believe so many different things because, like you said, like, some, some churches, like, yeah, you know, speaking in tongues, that's a sign of the Holy Spirit. That's God. He's doing that. And then you have other denominations saying that, no, that's not what, that's not how it's supposed to be. And you have these, all these conflicting denominations of what is God, what's not God, what's okay, what's not. And when you're wrapped up in it, you don't really. You just think you're right, you have the right answers. Oh, yeah, my church, you know, we, we have the right version of this. They just don't understand. And they're thinking the same things about you.

Todd Phillips [00:33:39] Yeah. I remember talking to many of my friends, I didn't think quite this extreme, but they would say, you know, that's Satan speaking in tongues is Satan disrupting and moving a church in a direction away from God? I mean, just, again, it can never be psychology. It can never be just wrong. It has to be God or Satan. It's the powers and principalities, you know, that are in charge behind the scenes. Right. That's the kind of stuff, you know, people, I don't think people who have not been in these environments fully understand just how. How enmeshed we become.

Kevin Crowe [00:34:11] Yeah, well, Satan is the author of Psychology Brother, in case you didn't know.

Todd Phillips [00:34:16] Yeah, that's right. That's exactly right. Wow. Okay. So you told me one time you went to. You used to witness to people a lot. I did the same thing. So witnessing what. What is when you say I used to witness to people. What is that term for people that don't know?

Kevin Crowe [00:34:32] The best way I can describe it is you're just. You're letting people see Jesus in you, right? So you're spreading the gospel. You're going and telling people like, your life would be so much better with Jesus in it. And Jesus came to save us all, so give your life to him. And you just think that, you know, people aren't living right. You want people to see Jesus in you, really. And so, yeah, we would go around to the outlet mall. My very. A very vivid memory for me is going to the outlet mall when I was in high school, you know, I was probably 16 or something, and going up to people and just, you know, asking them if they believe in Jesus, telling them that Jesus loves them and stuff.

Kevin Crowe [00:35:12] I'm sure we probably had some little gospel tracks that we hand out that says, has the whole deal, you know, like, are you saved on the front? Here's what you need to do. Here's instructions. And so I walk up to this guy who's standing outside of a store. He's smoking a cigarette.

Kevin Crowe [00:35:27] I'm a teenager, so to me, he looks like he's 60. He was probably like 30, you know, at the time. Like, everybody's old. So I go up to him and I'm like, sir, like, my voice cracking, probably. Sir, do you know about Jesus Christ? You know? And he's just looking at me with disgust like, what do you know about life, dude? Like, your. Your biggest problem is algebra 2 or something, you know, And I'm like, to asking this guy, I'm acting like I know I have all the answers to life because at that age, you think you know everything anyways. But then when you sprinkle on top of it that you have the answers to the universe, basically in Jesus, it just adds an extra layer of arrogance on top.

Todd Phillips [00:36:09] How often were you out there witnessing to people? Was that. Was that a regular part of your life?

Kevin Crowe [00:36:13] Not a lot. Not a lot. And then, of course, then you would get convicted, as they say in your heart, about that love. Like, you would feel like anything that you're doing that is not. That is like A waste of time or something. It got to the point where I'm like, oh, if I'm sitting at home playing video games or something, I could be witnessing to my friends or to strangers. And there's this heavy burden that you carry always. And it breaks my heart really, because I see a lot of people at church still, like people that I used to go to church with and stuff, still haven't. Carrying that heavy burden.

Todd Phillips [00:36:49] Yeah. The sin of idleness, not doing the things that you're supposed to be doing at all times. Right?

Kevin Crowe [00:36:54] Yeah. Responsible for the souls of every person around you. And if they die and they, you didn't tell them about Jesus, their blood is on your hands. I don't know if you guys use that phrase a lot, but that was a common phrase in our church is like, you know, their blood is on your hands. If you don't tell them about Jesus and they die and they go to hell, that's on you.

Todd Phillips [00:37:14] Yeah. Let me ask you this. How did that play out? And just in just normal relationships with co workers and stuff? Because I think once you build that framework that you just described, so everyone's salvation, it's up to God. But God is calling me to share this with them. And if I don't, their blood is on my hands. If I. They don't accept Christ and they end up in hell and for all eternity, I'm going to be responsible for that in some way, shape or form. So I did it. And it must have. I, I think, I think this is a little bit of a leading question, but it. Did it create an agenda in all your, in all your relationships? I know it did. With me, it there. I could never just get to know somebody. I had to find out very quickly if they were saved or not. How did that affect you?

Kevin Crowe [00:37:51] It's gross to look back at it, right? It's gross because you just felt like you were on this mission at all times. And so one of my best friends in high school, like, we hung out all the time, every, every week. You know, we would hang out, play video games, I'd go spend the night at his house or vice versa. And we just, we would spend a lot of time hanging out. And it got to a point where I felt like I need to tell him about Jesus because his whole family, none of them believed, like none of his family were Christians. And I was like, this is on me.

Kevin Crowe [00:38:22] This is what God is. You know, I'm here for a reason. Like, I. He placed me here in this guy's life for A reason. And so then I would start telling him that he's living wrong because he had Insane Clown Posse posters on his wall. I would told him that he was idolizing them and that he needed to live for Jesus. And it's just. Is sad to think about and kind of gross to look back at too. And then also I would carry my Bible to school with me, and then after I graduated, I would take it to work and then my co workers would like, laugh, like, what do you do?

Kevin Crowe [00:38:53] I remember one time one of my co workers was like, what are you doing? Because I'm standing there, I work in the shipping department of this warehouse. And I'm like standing there with my eyes closed, just like praying as the boxes are coming down the thing. And he's like, what are you doing? And I was like, I'm praying. And they just laughed about it. And then so of course I'm like, yo, I'm being. I'm being persecuted for my beliefs. Like, this is a good thing and reading my Bible in the break room at work and stuff. But it, it affected a lot of my relationships. Because you always felt that pressure to, to tell them about Jesus.

Todd Phillips [00:39:30] So let's. I want to hang there for just a minute because I. I think I'm curious to see what you're going to say about this. So every relationship had an agenda. Every relationship had an eternal destiny on the line, right? Whether if they were saved, then you could relax and know they were Christians. If they weren't, then the entirety of the conversation and the prayer that went between the lines and your prayer before and after those conversations all driven around my responsibility for that person's salvation. How do you compare your relationships back then with that, with all that. That the weight of the world on top of those relationships with your relationships now without an agenda? Compare the two. Let's talk about that a little bit.

Kevin Crowe [00:40:14] It's so much different. It almost feels like you can relax your shoulders now, you know, after you get out of it. Because it's just this feeling of, oh my God, I have to tell them about Jesus. Like, you can't just have. It's not just an organic relationship with somebody.

Kevin Crowe [00:40:28] There's always that other motive. There's always that if I left my friend's house and I didn't tell him about Jesus, the whole drive home, my heart's beating fast, you know, because I felt that guilt of like, you didn't do it. You didn't do what you're supposed to do. And it would be like that with all of my friendships and stuff. For anybody who was like, maybe not as Christian as me, in my mind, was like, oh, you know, I should have told him. And now it's like, you are who you are. I am who I am. And we just have conversations like normal people. And it's, you know, different faiths are okay, and it's okay if that.

Kevin Crowe [00:41:05] That person doesn't believe the same way that I do. It's completely different. Everything back then was like spiritual warfare. You know, that's a buzzword that a lot of people use. It's like, there's always something going on in the spirit realm of, like, demons trying to attack people or Satan trying to influence people and. And, you know, people praying on. On their behalf and praying. A hedge of protection around you, that was another big term was like, pray a hedge of protection around. It's like. So I guess like when you drive down the road, Jesus is like holding you like this, like, oh, nothing's gonna happen to you because that.

Kevin Crowe [00:41:38] That hedge of protection was prayed over you. But it was always that, that. That feeling of you're not doing enough. And now it's. It's. You're just you, I'm just me. And this is just like our relationship just is what it is. It's organic.

Todd Phillips [00:41:54] Yeah. I mean, the amount of pressure that when I listen to you and it just takes me back to my own experiences, the amount of pressure that primarily high, high, high control religious environments. Pentecostals, Southern Baptist Bible churches, the more literal they see the Bible, the more aggressive many times they are about the evangelism and the eternal destiny issues and things like that. The fear of hell. It's. It's. It's shocking to me how pleasant and kind and the conversations and relationships I'm building are now. And just looking back at the pressure

Kevin Crowe [00:42:33] cooker that we lived in, it's nice to not have a supernatural agenda. Right. Like there you don't have some external force that's compelling you to live a certain way or you have to do this, you have to talk about this, you have to tell people this. And if you don't, you're a failure. It's just. You just are. And you just, you know, have relationships with the people who, you know, maybe have some of the same values that you do. But it's not like they're the enemy or Satan has influence. Like, they're. They're under the. The Satan's control and, and all this kind of stuff. There's no. There's no. It's not supernatural chess. It's just people.

Todd Phillips [00:43:14] That's a very good way of putting it. Supernatural chess. Okay. Anyway, I want to hang out there a little bit because it just reminded me of some of the experiences I had before and just the fact that I can be fully present now in a, in a, in a relationship with you as you and I are building a friendship, just without any agenda. So. All right, let's talk about marriage. Let's fast forward to that. So you got married from your perspective, very young. So how old were you and how much did this all in Christianity? I'm guessing it played a lot, a big role. But how much did that contribute to the decision to get married?

Early Marriage and Deep Pentecostal Commitment

Kevin Crowe [00:43:45] Yeah, So I was 22. 22 years old. And it was just kind of what you do. I mean, it's kind of in southern culture, people. A lot of people get married young anyways. A lot of people married their high school sweethearts. But like, when you go to church, especially a church like I went to, there was just this extra layer of like, you don't want to have premarital sex because then you know that then you're putting both of you, you in jeopardy of hell. So. And then you feel like God is leading you to, like, marry a certain person based on, you know, you might read Bible verses and interpret them a certain way and like, oh, you know, that, that, that makes me feel like, yes, this is the person I'm supposed to marry.

Kevin Crowe [00:44:26] And then you have other people in the church telling you, like, yeah, you know, God told me that you two were supposed to get married and supposed to be together. And thinking back on that, is. Is pretty, pretty wild. But everybody was getting married, young people. That's just what you did. People get married in their early twenties. Why wait? You know, if you feel like God, this is the person for you, says the man upstairs. What's the point of waiting? You might as well just go ahead and get married and live your happy life and then get divorced at 30.

Todd Phillips [00:44:59] Yeah. So it really is a. It's interesting because there, there are different denominations that, you know, believe that there's basically one right person that God is, has out there for you. And your job is to find that person and to discern when you've met that person. And basically it's a 1 in 8 billion chance. And you're supposed to figure that out. Right. That. Talk about a needle in the haystack. Right? But you. So you. So premarital sex is a problem because you were potentially damning you both to hell if you guys engaged in that and chose, you know, against God's plan for marriage. According to your denomination, you believed.

Todd Phillips [00:45:34] You said you believed God had chosen this person and that people around you were confirming that. So they were also saying, yes, this is the person for you. And these were people that you respected, you saw as men and women of God who had the right to speak into your life. Would that be right?

Kevin Crowe [00:45:48] Yeah, literally. The youth pastor of the church told me this. He was one of the people and there were a few that was like, you know, I just. When I see you together, it really. God, it's just. I know that it's meant to be. You know, God told me that he's going to bless your marriage and stuff like that. But, yeah, the youth pastor was one of the people.

Todd Phillips [00:46:08] You know, when I look back on that as. As a person that was in ministry, it's remarkable. And I will use the word cavalier, how cavalier I think we were about those kinds of conversations and the effect it would have on another person's entire life, you know, for them to be comfortable to tell you that you felt. They felt that that was the person for God had for you. What, what a. What a bold statement.

Kevin Crowe [00:46:33] That is a great term for that, saying that cavalier. Because it was like you would just. You just do things on a whim because you felt like God was instructing this. And it could be the wildest things there was. I know that there was a couple from my church that sold all their stuff and moved to Africa because they felt like God was telling them to go start a ministry there and stuff. And I think, you know, that they didn't stay very long there. But it's just people will change their entire lives or uproot their entire lives and everything for what they think God is telling them based on feeling. God telling them something, the Holy Spirit moving or scripture interpreted a certain way, or other people at church telling them that they had a vision and so. So cavalier.

Todd Phillips [00:47:17] How did you. So speaking of God's will, right, because you felt that was God's will. You said God's will to marry this person. How did you determine. How did you determine God's will? How did you do that?

Kevin Crowe [00:47:29] I think it was just a combination of all those things. It was me praying and feeling like God was telling me a certain thing. It was reading scriptures and say, and applying them to my life. Because when you read the Bible as a Christian, a lot of people will say, every time you read it, you get something different. Or the verses speak to you in a Different way than they did last time. And it's like. It's the living, breathing word of God. Right? So everything you read in there can speak, literally speak to you different ways. And so it was just a combination of that and then other people at the church telling you the same things that you're already thinking, you're kind of in alignment, and then you think, oh, yeah, boom, boom, boom. This is God because of X, Y, and Z. Like all. All the. The pieces are lining up.

Todd Phillips [00:48:11] Yeah, I like the way you say it. Lining up. I used to. When I preached, I used to talk about, how does God speak to us? And I would always say this. I mean, this was a thing I just said constantly and believed it with every fiber of my being. God speaks to us through the Holy Spirit or by the Holy Spirit, through four things, and it's in this order. I used to say this all the time. The first way God speaks to us is through the Bible. So the Bible is God's word. And you're going to find answers in the Bible. And then if you can't find the answer clearly in the Bible or you're looking for validation, then you pray to God.

Todd Phillips [00:48:43] But if your prayer doesn't line up with the word of God, your prayers are wrong, because the Bible is the key. And then if you still can't figure things out in prayer, you go to the people of God, the church, and that's what you did with your youth minister. And then finally, if this is all lining up, you also look for circumstances to validate those things. Right. So strange things that you didn't plan on. Oh, my gosh. I ran into the same girl at the store that validates my pastor telling me I'm supposed to marry her. Plus my prayer, plus those two passages I read last week.

Todd Phillips [00:49:13] And I used to. I used to believe that I was giving people, I don't know, bumpers on both sides of the trail, so to speak. You know, you just. This is how you. You stay in God's will. And it sounds like that's just the way you were naturally doing it anyway.

Kevin Crowe [00:49:31] Yeah, so that's interesting. I've never heard it put that way, but it's kind of like a checks and balances system of, like, oh, this one didn't line up. So you got to go back to that one and make sure that. That's super interesting. But, like, I never heard it explained that way, but I would say that's very true about how our church behaved or believed. Like, they kind of. It was the kind of the same thing. Like if all the, all that stuff lined up, it's God, it's just an equation.

Todd Phillips [00:49:55] Yeah. And it's just. And then you can have confidence. Right. And then you can move forward. Okay, so let's talk. Let's move forward and talk about where the cracks start to show, what starts happening. You're, you're this passionate, engaged, married, you know, excited about this reality. Feeling that the eternal destinies of souls around you, your friends and co workers, are in your hands. The blood is on your hands if you don't share Jesus with them. I mean, you are swimming in the deep end. You've got two tanks on the back and you are down in the deep end of this Pentecostal Christian environment. So if you can remember, what's the first, maybe the first question that genuinely started to destabilize your faith? What was that?

Cracks in Faith and the Long Road to Doubt

Kevin Crowe [00:50:43] I'll take it back a little, a little further. Like the very first, I would say, like a little crack that I put duct tape over was in middle school. This was the first time that I ever heard the word atheist. My friend Justin, eighth grade, said he was an atheist.

Kevin Crowe [00:50:59] And we were at the track one day and we were sitting in the bleachers and he. I don't know why, he just kind of. He liked to talk about religion and stuff a lot and how he just didn't believe any of it.

Kevin Crowe [00:51:10] But he was talking about Noah's Ark and he was like, that couldn't possibly have happened. You know, I think, I don't know if he knew that I was a believer or not. And I don't, I guess at that time I wasn't like a strong believer or anything. But he was saying that couldn't possibly have happened. That doesn't make sense. There's no way that all these animals got on a giant boat. The entire world was flooded. It just didn't happen. And I was like, you know, what he's saying makes a lot of sense.

Kevin Crowe [00:51:37] But, you know, then it was just sort of like, I sort of like just backtracked and was like, well, you know, God can do whatever you, you hear all these stories in the Bible. Like, of course our, with our natural brains and like with the, the world that we know that stuff's not. Not going to happen. But God can do anything. God can perform these miracles. Jesus literally walked on top of the water and stuff. So, like, who am I to say that all these animals just didn't march up onto a boat and live there for a while? And, and then you Know, repopulate the earth or whatever.

Kevin Crowe [00:52:09] Who am I to say? And so I just sort of like filed that away, like, you know, yeah, it seems, it does seem far fetched. But God, it's like, God can do it all. So that was the first like little crack. But then I just sort of chalked it up to God can do anything. And then, you know, I don't know, a few years later, there I am going to that Pentecostal church and stuff. And so the first major crack.

Kevin Crowe [00:52:35] Well, what started the crack, I'll say is we had kind of a church split. And I think this happens a lot, especially where I'm from. Like, it seems to happen a lot where somebody will either have a disagreement with the pastor or there's something that they don't agree with. And like, you know what, I'm going to go start my own church. But this was like the youth pastor and the pastor had a falling out. And so the youth pastor started going to this other church. I was closer to the youth pastor because I played in the band. I was friends with his kids and him and like went over to their house a lot.

Kevin Crowe [00:53:05] And so I was like, I'm going to start going to that church. And so I left the main church that I had been going to for years and I started going to this one over here. And then it was like, you know, they, they moved locations to like, further away. It was literally across town, so it wasn't that far. But I stopped going every Sunday. I would go more sporadically and then I would think. Then I started thinking back on the things that I saw in church A over here and thinking like, because like church B had some of that stuff, but not all of it.

Kevin Crowe [00:53:34] And so it's like you start comparing and you're like, wait, you know, this is different. Why are they like this? Do I really believe what happened at that first church that I used to go to? And so then you start like slowly, slowly chipping away in that way. So I would be going to church less and less and I would be staying at home and I would kind of be starting to doubt things a little bit. And then what was the, the big crack for me was at my job.

Kevin Crowe [00:54:03] So I would, I worked in the shipping department at this warehouse and I would go for walks sometimes during my breaks because it was a really stressful job. I wanted to get out of the building. I wanted to remember that there's life outside of this stressful 9 to 5 that I have, or more like a 7 to 6. I think at that time. And so I would just go for walks. And I noticed that every time I would walk around the building, there was this guy out there smoking a cigarette. And I don't know if our brakes lined up or if he was just literally always outside smoking.

Kevin Crowe [00:54:33] Maybe he didn't even work there. Maybe he just was a guy who just smoked. No, I'm just kidding. He worked in the front office, so I didn't see him that much. But I would see him sometimes on those walks, and we would usually just. I would walk by just like, hey, how you doing? It would just be like a brief, hey, what's up? Every day. Then it got to be a little bit more than that. And then we got to talking about. For some reason, I don't know why people in my life would just, like, start asking me these random things about God. Maybe. Maybe it was a sign.

Kevin Crowe [00:54:59] But he. He asked me if I believed in God. And at that time, you know, I did, and I was still going to church. There were maybe. I was maybe starting to, like, think a little bit. Like, is all of that stuff that I experienced in that first church real?

Kevin Crowe [00:55:13] But then he asked me that, and I said yes. And then he said that he used to believe in God and he used to actually, like, be a preacher that would travel around and speak at all these different churches and stuff, but that he didn't believe at all anymore. He said that people at the church that he used to go to, like, told him not to go to college, he wanted to go get a higher education, and they told him not to go to college. That, like, that was the. The devil's playground or whatever. You know, the liberal professors are going to try to make you not believe and stuff.

Kevin Crowe [00:55:45] Well, he went against their judgment, and he went anyways. And he started taking a world religions class, learning about all the different religions of the world. And he realized that people in different parts of the world largely believe in different gods, different religions.

Kevin Crowe [00:56:02] And that was like a light bulb moment for me, right then. I was like, oh, my God. Like, why is my God the right one? Why is my religion correct and all the other ones are wrong? Like, what if I were born in India? What if I were born in China? Would I still believe the same way? Or even if my parents believed in a different God, I would, too. I totally would. And so for me, I was like, whoa, there's no right. I was like, there's no good reason for me to believe these things that I've been told. I only believe them because I was told to believe them.

Kevin Crowe [00:56:32] And so it was a pretty quick deconstruction, I guess, for me to be like, whoa, there's no good reason for me to believe in any gods.

Todd Phillips [00:56:41] Well, so I find that remarkable. So you and I talked about the length of time that I went through deconstruction. It was a long, you know, multi year, very painful process. Excuse me. You found yourself having a significant conversation with a, I guess a former pastor, right? Yeah. So he's a former pastor. At this point he was basically saying, look, if you, if you live somewhere else, you believe something else. So it's just, it's. Your religion is based on your geography. And that's really what, that's really what. That, that, not. That didn't just crack the armor, that just blew it wide open is what you're saying.

Kevin Crowe [00:57:17] Yeah, it really did. It was a while before I like completely abandoned my faith or like called myself an atheist or anything, but at that moment it was like, whoa. I think I drove home and I was just like thinking about everything in life because you go from living for something that you're so certain about to just, whoa, I don't think I believe this anymore. But I wasn't ready to give up on it. So it would be months of me praying, asking, God, please, I don't want to not believe. That's the thing is so many people think that you just like, you want to give up on your faith, that you want to stop believing.

Kevin Crowe [00:57:54] It was never that for me. I just, I would pray every night to God, like, please, you know, give me a reason to believe. Show up, tell, like, talk to me. Some, anything, literally anything, just, I don't want to stop believing. But I couldn't make myself believe anymore. And so, I don't know, after probably six months or so, like, I was calling myself an atheist, which is crazy because not that long before that, there I am getting slain in the spirit at church. Wild times.

Todd Phillips [00:58:24] Yeah. So let's talk a little bit about that. Those six months, right? So you, you are. Because a lot of people that I talk to that are still Christians and maybe watching this right now, you know, they, they, they're looking for reasons for people like you and me to leave the faith. And it, and it, it's almost invariably church hurt. They wanted to sin, Satan got a hold of them. They wanted to be the, the ruler of their own life. They wanted to take over the throne from Jesus. You know, it's anything, anything, literally any other reason. Then I investigated these claims, I began to doubt and I'm no longer convinced.

Todd Phillips [00:59:07] And, and I find it interesting that, and I think it's worth spending some time here. You, at that point, you didn't want to not be a Christian. You wanted to still be a Christian. And I want people to hear this. This is very important because this is a sincere. And they can take it however they wish. Right. They can say, well, he's not being genuine or whatever, if they're still in the Christian, from a Christian persuasion and believing that you're not being honest, which is what I get quite often on my social media channel. But I know you to be genuine and sincere. And you're telling me this is what you went through when you started praying to God, similar to what I did.

Todd Phillips [00:59:43] God, I'm having doubts. This guy's conversation, this former preacher got to me. I mean, I can imagine the, I can imagine the conversation with God. If. Let's, let's dive there a little bit more. God help me, this is messing me up.

Todd Phillips [01:00:00] I can't move past it. Let's. What are those conversations with what you believe was God? What are they like, what are you saying? Let's just dive into that for just a moment because I want people to hear the level of desperation that you really did experience there.

Kevin Crowe [01:00:13] Yeah, it was God. Please, you know, talk to me. Give me a sign. Reveal yourself. Show me something in the Bible that, you know, give, like literally anything. Give me a sign while I'm driving down the road. Please just let me know that, that you're here, that you hear me. I don't want to leave. Like my friend. Like, I had so many friends at church. I had, like, a lot of close relationships, and that was just my life. Like, I was tethered to this thing for a decade. And you get to a point where you're just calling out to God and there's never an answer back.

Kevin Crowe [01:00:51] You don't hear anything. And yeah, people are so quick to tell you, well, you were just never really a Christian. If you, if you can just walk away, then you were never really a Christian. But I think a lot of that comes from. They just want to be able to dismiss our experiences so quickly. And I think that that is also rooted in fear of. They're afraid that they might start asking themselves those same questions, like, if this person who believes so strongly can leave, then, you know, whoops, maybe I could leave too. And I don't want that. And so I think there's this thing, they put this mental block up, like, oh, you must have left because you wanted to sin or you never truly believed, or that whole thing of like, you know, if you really were a Christian, you wouldn't walk away because you have this relationship with Jesus.

Kevin Crowe [01:01:41] But it was every night for months of me in my bed praying, hoping that I would wake up and feel differently, hoping that I would wake up and like, you know, that God would come in a dream and show me that he's real or anything, but I just, I never got any of that.

Todd Phillips [01:02:02] Yeah. And so you're praying, God help me with my unbelief. There's a passage in the Bible about that. Right. So, so let's, you know, when I think about that, one of the things that I've discovered, I wanted to get your opinion on this. I now believe, I now have come to.

Realizing Belief Cannot Be Chosen

Todd Phillips [01:02:18] To the understanding that you actually cannot choose what you believe. You can. You're either convinced or you're not. Belief is a passive response of your brain to evidence that convinces you. In other words, you're either convinced or you're not. Like, I couldn't say, Kevin, you know, just believe for the rest of this interview that you're a Muslim.

Todd Phillips [01:02:40] I mean, yeah, you just can't. Or any Christian that might be watching this, just believe you're a Muslim, believe in the Quran, believe in Allah, believe in. It simply cannot happen. You cannot choose belief. And so what I find interesting, and I wanted to get your perspective, you know, if we can't choose what we believe, first of all, do you think that. And number two, if we can't, then it seems to me that at least from the Christian kind of Bible perspective, the Christian God is holding us morally accountable for something we cannot choose. What are your thoughts?

Kevin Crowe [01:03:12] Oh, man, that's a great point. I, I completely agree with that. I, I don't think I would have in the past or when I was a Christian, but now, like, after leaving the faith, I definitely believe that you don't choose your beliefs. You don't actively choose your beliefs. You either believe something or you don't. And like, you gave a great example right there of like, and maybe I'll start using that of like, going to Christians and be like, hey, why don't you try being, you know, a Muslim for a while? I'm believing all this. You, you just can't actively choose it. I think you're convinced or you're not convinced. What was the second part of your question? Sorry?

Todd Phillips [01:03:47] Oh, well, no, just. I mean, I just wanted your perspective on it because it's something I've thought about a great deal. And, and I find it interesting that if we really can't choose our beliefs, then from a Christian perspective, or at least a, an evangelical Christian perspective, then the God that I was, that I believed in for so long was really holding us morally accountable for something we can't choose.

Kevin Crowe [01:04:08] Right? Yeah, then, Yeah, I guess then you start getting into, like, determinism or like, if you can't, if you can't choose these. It's like if God knows everything that's going to, Everything that has happened, everything that's going to happen, you start getting into those conversations of like, he knows that certain people are never going to believe. That starts getting into a real gray area.

Todd Phillips [01:04:29] I think when you go, that's very strange. But I just, I, I just, I found it interesting when you said. It just made me think when you said, yeah, I just wanted to believe God helped me, me, you know, I want, I want to keep believing, but I don't believe anymore. You know, something has happened and I'm waking up with a different belief system. Real, real quick, going back, what would you say to a Christian who might have said when you had that discussion with the preacher about, you know, geography determines your religion or your belief system, what would you say for a Christian going, well, that's the genetic fallacy.

Todd Phillips [01:04:57] You know, that, you know, you, what you're saying is what I hear you saying, Kevin, this is a Christian talking to you. What I hear you saying, Kevin, is that because it's geographically determined by. And that you're saying Christianity is wrong. Is that what you're saying?

Kevin Crowe [01:05:12] That's not what I'm saying. I, I say that there's a strong correlation. It's not necessarily a causal thing. It's not cause and effect, but there's a strong correlation that can't be denied. That the, the surroundings that you're, that you grow up in, your parents, the, the region of the world, there's a, there's a strong correlation with what the beliefs are. Now, that's not. There are exceptions. That doesn't mean anything. It doesn't mean you're definitely going to believe that or not believe this.

Kevin Crowe [01:05:39] It just means that there's a strong correlation that can't be denied. And I get that one. A lot, a lot of people will say that to me, like, that's a fallacy. That's the genetic fallacy. And I'm like, I'm not saying that somebody is necessarily definitely going to believe this thing. I just think it's a strong, there's a strong chance that they will share those same beliefs if they're from a certain part, from a certain country or if their parents are of a certain religion. But you'll always get the people who are outliers, like, well, both of my parents were atheists and I love Jesus. Of course.

Kevin Crowe [01:06:09] Of course there are plenty of people who come to the faith when their parents aren't or come to the faith later in life, go to a different religion. I know that there are people in China who are Christians or people in India who are Christian. I know all that. But, but the correlation is still there. It's. And it's strong.

Todd Phillips [01:06:27] Yeah. The single most, the single greatest factor in determining someone's religious belief is geography. And again, and I want to say this just real quickly, the genetic fallacy is that you. The fallacy is a person who believes because it's geographically based, it therefore is wrong.

Todd Phillips [01:06:45] I think certainly from my perspective, sounds like, from yours, it's an evidential question. In other words, what would we expect if there was an eternal truth? We would expect that eternal truth to cross borders and, and to eventually bleed into other cultures aggressively to where we kind of, we kind of all culminated on that ultimate eternal, non cultural truth. But that's just not what we find. I think that's a very important distinction between the two because I know you, you get that a lot. I get that a lot. And I think it's important to clarify. So you told me something earlier when we talked about your story that I haven't forgotten.

Todd Phillips [01:07:17] You described reaching this point where you're, you know, essentially saying, you know, I, I don't believe in God. While another part of your brain, if I remember this right, another part of your brain was saying, did God hear me just say that? Take me to these kind of cognitive dissonance moments.

Kevin Crowe [01:07:37] Oh, that is like the epitome of cognitive dissonance right there, isn't it? It, Yeah, I was on my front porch.

Todd Phillips [01:07:43] I experienced it too. Sure.

Kevin Crowe [01:07:45] Yeah, I was on my front porch. And I'm like, for the first time I said out loud, I don't think I believe in God. And at the same time I'm terrified because I'm like, oh, God, did God just hear me ask, say that out loud? Is that going to get me? Like, is that going to make it harder for me to dig myself out of this hole? Like I'm. If God is real, obviously I want to, to know that. But saying that out loud, it's just, it's wild because I'm literally saying I don't believe and at the same time, like. But God might be sitting there, like, with his arms crossed, like, oh, really? You know, you got it all figured out. You don't believe. It's a. It's so interesting to think back on.

Todd Phillips [01:08:30] Well, it's interesting too, and I think this is important for people to hear. You know, belief can eventually disappears. A belief in a specific. Whatever that belief system is before the fear does. You know, I can't tell you.

Todd Phillips [01:08:43] Did you experience this? I. I got to a point where I no longer believed hell existed. But for a. It was quite a while. I'm talking. It must have been over a year or two. I mean, it may have been longer than that. Where I knew intellectually, I understood the. From my perspective, how the theology of hell developed in the Old Testament and further into the New Testament, and that the conceptual framework we understand in evangelical Christianity is not very, very close to that many perspectives on hell in the afterlife within the. Within the 66 books of the Bible. But every time I would bring it up and I would say, I don't believe in hell, like, my body would respond.

Todd Phillips [01:09:23] Like, I'd fear the. I'd feel the fear and the trepidation and the, like, it just, it just. It would just. It would just tweak me a little bit. Did you feel that?

Kevin Crowe [01:09:32] Yeah, I feel like. I feel like we probably messed up our nervous systems a lot during our. During our Christian days because of stuff like that. Just feeling all this guilt, feeling this fear and stuff. And I think for me, I didn't carry the fear of hell for that long. It was less than a year, I would say, although I guess I would have the occasional flare up, if you want to call it that.

Kevin Crowe [01:09:55] I would. I didn't believe in hell anymore. But still, sometimes you would see something. Like, you'd see something on the news talking about they're gonna put, you know, chips under somebody's hand or something. It's like, is that the mark of the beast? Because in Revelation you're always thinking, like, all these things are going to happen toward the end times that are going to signify that Jesus is coming back soon and there's going to be judgment. And so then, like, you'd see something like that and think, oh, man, is that. Is that something that's ushering in the end times or something?

Kevin Crowe [01:10:26] But for me, I was able to release that fear of hell by putting myself in the shoes of other religions, like, and. And realizing they don't fear the Christian hell. Like Hindus don't feel the Christian hell Muslims don't fear the Christian hell, so why should I? And I was able to finally kind of exhale and release that fear. But, you know, it did linger for a while and I, I was able to let that go. And now I don't ever have that fear come up anymore. But for a while, yeah, there would be some, like, every now and then there would be something that kind of like makes your heart flutter, makes you think, oh, man, you know, I don't. That's a, That's a big gamble to take.

Todd Phillips [01:11:08] It is.

Kevin Crowe [01:11:08] You know, when you think, when you think about it, like, you're risking your eternity on this, and so you better be right. And so those. I think there's that heaviness of it all of like, these are eternal consequences that you're dealing with. And, and there's this. Even if you're. Don't. Even if you don't believe, even if you're not convinced, there's still that 1% part of your brain that thinks, what if I am wrong?

Todd Phillips [01:11:30] No, it's a great point. I, I did a lot of research on the psychology of religious belief and kind of neuroscience and how belief patterns build it. It was remarkable to me. It helped me when I learned this that, you know, over time, as you hear hell is a potential eternal destiny. It. It builds grooves inside your synapses in your brain. It builds patterns. You know, the neurons that fire together, wire together, and they wire very, very concretely. Right. And build those grooves in your belief patterns in your brain. So even when you intellectually think now differently, the feelings, the responses of your brain are built into that pattern.

Todd Phillips [01:12:04] It takes quite a while for your brain to build new pathways with those new belief systems. And they still emotionally affect the, the chemicals are released when you talk about that subject, even though intellectually you no longer believe it. I just found that fascinating. I really did.

Kevin Crowe [01:12:19] That is fascinating and it makes a lot of sense because especially I. I feel like the people who are in that world for longer, those grooves are probably more worn in deeper.

Todd Phillips [01:12:31] Yeah. And.

Kevin Crowe [01:12:32] And so that fear lasts longer. Luckily for me, you know, I didn't really get into that church and, and be. I wasn't a heart. I would call. I call myself a hardcore Christian from like 16 to 26, you know, but luckily, you know, some people are in it from before they can walk. And, and so those, those patterns and those grooves are really like drilled into their head and it's harder for them to walk away even if they logically work it out of like, I don't know if I believe this, that fear is still there. It's still. And then you have like, depending on the church, you have the, the preachers every week talking about hell.

Kevin Crowe [01:13:11] And like there's a real chance that you go there, your loved ones might go there if they don't believe and like that every Sunday. And if you're like me every Sunday, Wednesday, Friday, over time you hear that so many times. It's just going to be something that just lives in your brain for a long time.

Todd Phillips [01:13:30] Yeah, it really is crazy. I tell people all the time that, that are going through deconstruction, you know, just because you're feeling it, those feelings don't mean that it's true because we associated the feeling with the truth of the feeling, you know. Now intellectually they understand different, but they're, they're going back and going, well, I'm feeling that so strongly. Maybe it is true. It's not a sign that it's true. It's a sign that you've been thinking and believing that for 22 years.

Kevin Crowe [01:13:54] That's a good point. It's like uncoupling that.

Todd Phillips [01:13:58] Yes.

Kevin Crowe [01:13:58] Because when you're in church, so much of it is feeling, or especially in a Pentecostal church like I was in, there's so much that goes off of feeling. And you're feeling the spirit, you're hearing God talking to you, you feel like this or that. And so that makes sense that the people who are really starting to deconstruct and start questioning, they have, they're going off those same feelings. You know, it's like when I was, you know, thinking that God might have heard me say that he's not real. It's that same kind of like, oh man, it's just like an emotional response or like this built in feeling that you have.

The Cost of Leaving the Faith

Todd Phillips [01:14:34] So let's, let's talk about. So you've, you've finally kind of identified yourself as no longer Christian. I want to talk a little bit about the cost of that. What did you actually lose? Relationships, community. What were the things that, that felt most difficult and, and most costly to you?

Kevin Crowe [01:14:58] Yeah, a lot of relationships, friendships with people. It was mostly like my church family and stuff because I was very involved. I played music. That was one of the things that I missed initially too. It's like playing music in the band with my friends and, and seeing the same people every week and like fellowshipping with them, which is just, you know, talking with them before and after church, going to eat lunch with people at Cracker Barrel or Wherever after church and. And just losing that sense of community was tough because I went from that every week to that never. And just being like, I still luckily had.

Kevin Crowe [01:15:41] I had some friends that were not part of the church that. So I still had my friends and stuff, but 90 of my friends were there were at church. And when you leave, like, I mean, sometimes people will, like, check on you, see how you're doing and stuff. But it's more like when you give up those beliefs, those people don't see you the same way anymore, or a lot of them don't. And so just losing that sense of community was the hardest part.

Todd Phillips [01:16:10] And where. Where are we? What year is this where you're finally just going, I'm not a Christian any longer.

Kevin Crowe [01:16:16] This was 2009. And so there. I felt very alone at that time because, like, I didn't really know many other people who were atheists or didn't believe or even were questioning. Everybody in my life was so certain about their faith and stuff. And. And there weren't like, Facebook was barely off the ground. Instagram wasn't a thing yet. TikTok was 10 years away. Like, there were some atheist YouTube channels and stuff, but I really didn't even know about them at the time. It was just. I felt incredibly isolated during that time. That was 2009. I mean, that. It's hard to even remember back that far now, but there was.

Kevin Crowe [01:16:55] There wasn't anything like there is now back then. There wasn't anybody that I could like, just go online and. And have these conversations with or consume content. It was just a different world. 2009 was a different world. It was pre. So many things that we have now that. That help people.

Todd Phillips [01:17:14] Yeah. Because it certainly has helped me. I can. I can imagine how difficult it would be going through that process without any, I don't know, any virtual or otherwise engagement with maybe new friends or new connections that were outside of your loop. So let's talk about that a little bit. So you lost that community. There's a lot of friends that you lost through this process who knew at that time that you had become agnostic or. Or an atheist or not a Christian anymore who didn't know. How are you making those choices?

Kevin Crowe [01:17:39] Very few people knew. Very few people. I think I told my sister and I told the drummer in our youth band at church, because I think he was kind of on the same wavelength as me. He's still one of my best friends to this day.

Kevin Crowe [01:17:53] And so those are probably the main two people that knew. People knew that I wasn't really going to church anymore, or at least that church. I don't know, people might have thought I was going to a different church. There's that whole, like, if there's a church split and some people go here and some people go there, these people think you're over here, these people think you're over here. And so like, you know, they might have. People might have thought I was still just as Christian as I was before or that I was going to another church or something.

Kevin Crowe [01:18:19] My parents didn't know. My parents didn't know until 10 years. From 10 years later. Most, most people in my life didn't know until 10 years later. Maybe some still don't know, but back then it was a very select couple of people.

Todd Phillips [01:18:33] Okay, so it sounds like you spent a really long time, you know, not talking publicly about the changes in your beliefs. Why?

Kevin Crowe [01:18:46] I was just indifferent to religion for a long time, you know, from 2009 until I started making content.

Todd Phillips [01:18:52] Really?

Kevin Crowe [01:18:53] I mean, maybe a little bit before I started making anything, making videos and stuff, but I was indifferent. I was like, you know, if people. I don't believe, other people do believe and that's fine. If they believe, that's cool, whatever. It's not a big deal. And so I was just kind of. I didn't feel like I had any reason to really talk about. It was just my personal lack of faith.

Kevin Crowe [01:19:14] And most of the people in my life were Christians. And so it's not like I was just gonna go make a post like, hey, I'm an atheist, because, like, what was the point of that? There was no point in me doing that because it would just, you know, cause some sort of disruption in my life or jeopardize some friendships that I had or family relationships or whatever. So I just kind of kept that close to the vest because I didn't feel like there was a point.

Coming Out as an Atheist and Finding Community Online

Todd Phillips [01:19:39] Yeah, you mentioned Jesus unfollower. We're going to get that in a few minutes, but let's. I want to. You were telling me kind of how you, you, you kind of fell into the process of Jesus unfollower. It's years after you left Christianity. I think if I remember it right, you ended up dating a Seventh Day Adventist, which is a specific Christian denomination. How do you, in your new or. Or your lack of belief in Christianity, how do you get involved in a, In a relationship with a, With a woman who is very steeped in a. In a. I would consider also another high control Christian denomination.

Kevin Crowe [01:20:19] Yeah, it's strange, isn't it? I. So one of my best friends set me up with her. Like, he was friends with her for a long time, and obviously one of my closest friends. And he was like, you got. You guys should go out. And so I got set up, like, that way. And in the beginning, she and I both naively thought that we could see past these differences. She knew that I didn't believe. I knew that she was a Seventh Day Adventist. In my brain, I'm like, you know, I'll probably. I can go to church with her sometimes, even though I don't believe. It's not that big of a deal.

Kevin Crowe [01:20:49] And then, you know, sometimes I won't go. That was a very naive thought for me, because as time went on, like, after I went to church several times with her, I'm like, this is weird, because I'm in this building. Everybody's worshiping God, a God that I don't think is there, and I'm just watching people sing to four walls. And I'm like, this is interesting and strange. And then as time went on, it was very clear that our just. Our future visions weren't gonna align because, like, if we ever had kids, she was gonna want to raise them in church. And Seventh Day Adventists meet on Saturdays.

Kevin Crowe [01:21:24] I love college football. I don't want to spend my Saturdays at church, especially if I don't believe. And, like, she's a great person, but I just wasn't in the cards for us to stay together. And I think we both saw that eventually out of our. Even though in the beginning, we naively thought that it would work out well.

Todd Phillips [01:21:43] Speaking all the way back to that first conversation you had about the guy that said noah's ark can't be real. You actually told me that she. I guess you had a conversation with her about Noah's Ark and that she literally believed Noah's Ark happened the way the Bible explained it. Yeah. How did that affect the conversation, the relationship?

Kevin Crowe [01:22:04] That's kind of a full circle moment, isn't it? Like, I had this conversation when I was in eighth grade about Noah's Ark. Circle back to 2019, and she and I have this conversation about Noah's Ark. I don't know. Remember how it came up. We were driving, driving down the road, and she said something about Noah's Ark. And I said, you don't literally believe that that happened, do you? And she said, yes. And I was like, whoa. Like, that really had made me take a step back, and, like, this might not be. This might not be right for me.

Todd Phillips [01:22:35] Yeah. So you're in a situation where you realize that the religion, her. The depth of commitment that she has to the religion and the lack of that in. In your own life actually contributed to the ending of that relationship. What did that, that whole process kind of awaken in you? You talked about that kind of being somehow the seeds of your social media and online presence as Jesus Unfollower. How did that happen?

Kevin Crowe [01:23:01] It was like, it made me think, like, there have to be other people out here who think like me, right? Like there I. This religion was basically the reason that our relationship didn't work out. And so I was like, you know, that really sucks. And a lot of things about religion can kind of suck. And so I wanted to be able to talk about it and have an outlet for that, but I didn't want to post it on my personal social media pages for the same reasons I said earlier. Because, like, I don't know, like, I was just wasn't ready to have those conversations with people that I knew.

Kevin Crowe [01:23:33] And so I started this Instagram account, called it Jesus Unfollower because it's like a play on Jesus follower. A lot of Christians have that in their bio. And I'm like, oh, you know, I used to follow Jesus, now I don't. Makes sense. So I started like creating these memes and stuff. And like the. The first one was about. It was some fake Bible verse that I made up and I called it like brain washikus522 or something on the thing. And just like. And then like people started liking it, commenting on it, and. And it's like, oh. And then as you make more posts, more people start commenting and sharing your stuff and saying, like laughing at it and saying, I relate to this.

Kevin Crowe [01:24:12] And then you start seeing other accounts pop up and then deconstruction becomes a popular term. I'd never heard that term before. Never really thought about deconstruction or anything. And that term starts emerging and I see all these deconstruction type accounts popping up or like ex Christian accounts. And I was like, whoa, I think I've kind of found my people. And then like, they share your stuff, they follow your stuff, and it just sort of grew from there. And then TikTok came along and like the reemergence of short form content because I was on vine back in the day. Not a lot of people were. Well, I guess a lot of people were, but a lot of people were not.

Kevin Crowe [01:24:51] I loved vine, but it died. And so then TikTok comes out and. And then Instagram, of course, copied it with reels and then YouTube shorts and. And so I start making some short videos and stuff, and apparently it's like, really resonating with people, and it just lights this fire in me to start giving people a reason to kind of laugh about stuff because it's so heavy. Like, religion is so heavy. My experience with it was so heavy. And, like, leaving something that's so close to you is hard. And, like, I've always liked humor and being funny and being silly and. And so, like, a lot of my content would reflect that, and it would just be a way to kind of make people be able to exhale at the end of the day or just kind of laugh at something that they could relate to.

Kevin Crowe [01:25:37] So I'm always trying to make, like, relatable stuff. But that relationship ending and, like, it really just ignited this curiosity in me. Like, I went down the rabbit hole of YouTube and, like, watching the atheist experience and watching debate channels and what, like, call in shows and watching people's deconstruction stories on YouTube, and I was like, man, like, this community existed that I had no idea about. When I, you know, when I left the faith, all I had was religious, you know, which at the time was very helpful to me.

Todd Phillips [01:26:10] Oh, Bill Maher. Yeah, yeah.

Kevin Crowe [01:26:12] Which, you know, you might. People have different opinions on him now, and so do I. But back then, like, that. That documentary, like, mattered a lot to me, but that was, like, mostly what I had was that, like. And. And now fast forward a decade or 10, 12 years, whatever, and there are these flourishing online communities and. And all this. This content that I can consume where I feel not so alone seeing people answer questions that maybe I've had or, like, how would I answer that? And then you see somebody on YouTube answer a question a certain way, and it's like, gives you all these new tools to be able to use in conversations. And it was. It was just really cool, man. It was just so needed for me.

Todd Phillips [01:26:56] That's exciting to hear. So, I mean, one of the reasons I've just, you know, working with Mormon stories to do this X vangelical stories podcast, this mini series and have you on is because, you know, one of the things that really impacted you and me both were these deconversion stories from other people on YouTube, which is in part one of the reasons you decided to do this interview, to share your story, I would guess, kind of as a. As a pay it forward, you know, for other people that have already done this for you.

Kevin Crowe [01:27:25] Yeah. One of the first podcasts that I remember listening to was. It was, I don't even know if it's a podcast anymore, but it was called Voices of Deconversion or something like that. And like that was the first podcast that I ever found that was like ex Christian or like people losing their faith. And I used to listen to that every day on the way to and from work.

Kevin Crowe [01:27:45] Just like consuming that. It's like, oh man, like this person, they had the same doubts that I did. They had the same, they left the same religion that I did. And it was, oh, it was, it just like made you feel like there are other people like you. When, especially where I live in the Bible Belt and stuff. Like it's sometimes it's really hard to, to find people who don't believe or that it's down here. It's just kind of like it's assumed that you do believe until you state otherwise. Everybody just kind of assumes everybody's a Christian until otherwise stated, I guess.

Todd Phillips [01:28:23] Yeah. You know, and one of the, you know, obviously because you're part of our community, the Decon recon, the online private community, you know, to help give people a safe space to have these conversations when a lot of people really don't have anywhere to turn or certainly feel like they don't have anywhere to turn. Can I ask why did you. Because you're well past your deconstruction phase, right? And, and you're still making content and you're, you're walking through this process. But what was it about Decon Recon that, that wanted you to join Because I'm going to have you on live. You know, we're gonna, we're gonna connect you with, with, with the community that way. But just being a member, what did that do for you?

Kevin Crowe [01:29:02] It's so I'll say this social media is awesome, but it's like a seven out of ten because like you can see consume a lot of content a lot of times. It's a one way street though. I mean you can like, you can make connections in the comments or DMS or even Facebook groups and stuff, but those things can like get infiltrated. Like trolls will show up, people come in and validate your experiences.

Kevin Crowe [01:29:28] And a place like Decon Recon is great because there's that wall that doesn't let the trolls in that it's a safe space for people. Like there are so many people that have DM'd me that have said I love your content but I can't follow you because so and so sees what, who I follow My pastor sees what I like, who I follow. My partner who is still a Christian and I'm not will see that I follow you like all this stuff.

Kevin Crowe [01:29:55] And so having a place where they can go that is not out in the open for everybody, to have them under a magnifying glass seeing what they're doing online, seeing. Oh, did you see that? So and so like this post. I can't believe that they said this. Like having a private space to do this is crucial. I think it gives people the ability to, to breathe, to question without judgment, to be able to, to say something without immediately being invalidated by some random troll who doesn't even know anything about them at all. And I just think it's special to have something like that that's like, you can get a lot of the stuff, a lot of resources, a lot of like relatable content and stuff on social media, on YouTube and Stuff.

Kevin Crowe [01:30:41] But an actual community is just the next level because you can ask questions. It's a two way street. Content is like kind of like a one way street. Like they might see my video and I'm just talking to the, to whoever's watching. Same with your videos. Like yes, they feel a connection. They're like, oh wow, Todd said this. I totally relate to that. Maybe they comment something, maybe it gets lost. Maybe they like it, you know, or maybe, maybe somebody else comments under their comment and says you were never really a Christian to begin with, but they know that they could come to a place like this and say the same thing without being seen or judged by the people that they don't want around.

Todd Phillips [01:31:20] Yeah, it was really cool to see in, in the membership, you know, just in there with us and I don't know, I. These are the kind of things, the kind of relationships, the one I'm building with you and others in and out of the community, in and out of decon recon, that, that were the authentic kind of relationships I really wanted my entire life, you know, and I'm starting to have those in my life now, which is really encouraging. So we'll have the decon recon link in the description if someone wants to come hang out with us. So let's get back to Jesus. Unfollower. Did you.

Todd Phillips [01:31:49] Because this is, it happened with me. So as a social media content creator, have you felt, because you've been doing this longer than me, have you felt a pressure to become like more angry or more in your face? Because that, that kind of content tends to perform. Because I watch all these debate channels and Stuff. Kevin, I gotta be honest, I, I've decided not to get into the debate scene. I'm just not going to do it. It's not, it's just not where I want to be. But man, they get a lot of followers and there's a lot of content there and so did you ever feel pressure to get kind of go that route and have you ever done that?

Kevin Crowe [01:32:21] I relate to that so much because I've always known if I wanted to like grow my channel, I, you know, do debates, do call in shows. Like that's what you do if, if you're a creator in this space, get on those shows, you can, you'll be able to cut a thousand clips to go on your social media. But I'm like you, I don't have that interest in debating people. I don't really like a lot of these call in shows. They're cool and I've learned a lot from them. But I don't have that desire to go on there and argue with somebody who's never going to change their position.

Kevin Crowe [01:32:52] Like they're calling in with the intention of convincing you that you're wrong. And like, I just, I don't have much interest in that. I would rather, like you said, kind of connect with the people who have similar stories or that, you know, maybe they're kind of along the same path or they're asking questions and they're being genuine in their questions. I, I've done a call in show before or maybe a couple. I can't remember at least one. It's just not my jam. And I think people are, have different skill sets and different interests too, you know, because some people will be great like, like what Dan McClellan does.

Kevin Crowe [01:33:26] I could never do what you do. I could never do what Matt Dillahunty or any, anybody who hosts a call in show or like these debates. I, I can't do that. That's not my strong suit. That's not what I'm good at. I'm good at being silly, making people laugh to forget about the religious trauma or whatever. That's what I. Yeah, you're very good at that too.

Todd Phillips [01:33:44] Yeah.

Kevin Crowe [01:33:45] Well, thank you. Thank you. I try, but it's. I think people have different strengths. But yeah, to answer your question, I've. I felt like I should be doing that. I should be going on like doing these debates. I should be doing call in shows because that's just kind of what you do if you make content in this space. But I've, I've very happy that I'VE settled on the same thing that you have of. I'm just not gonna do it. I'm just, I'm not gonna do those. It. I just don't think that it's right for me. It's not good for me. It's probably just gonna rile me up more than anything else. And like, I would rather just stay in my particular lane and my, my strength.

Todd Phillips [01:34:24] Yeah, I totally agree. Like, what happens to you? This is curiosity on my part. What happens to you with, you know, you've been doing this for, you know, several years. What happens to you when part of your job is becomes reading Christians attacking you every day? Because I mean, that's a, that's a, that's an everyday part of our lives.

John Dehlin [01:34:43] What.

Todd Phillips [01:34:43] How do you deal with that?

Kevin Crowe [01:34:45] A lot of times I will try to use it for content. So I'll take what they say. I'll do a, like my own little clap back, screenshot it, post it and like it helped. That kind of stuff helps me to find my people. You know, when I'm like, people are like, why are you spending so much time talking about a God that you don't believe in? And stuff? And it's like, well, God, I don't think that God is real, but religion is very real, right? And so then by making posts like that, then it's like other people who are like me are gonna find that and find me.

Kevin Crowe [01:35:17] So I try to do it, like use humor to sort of deflect or I'll tell them, hey, if you really want an answer to this question, buy me a coffee. I'll send, I'll drop a link for them to send me money. I'm like, I'll send you a personalized video response or. But sometimes the comments or even DMs can get be so bad that it does affect me. And so like one time this guy asked if he could do like, can I sexually assault your mom? And stuff. And just like this whole like writing paragraphs about what he's going to do to my mom and stuff.

Kevin Crowe [01:35:47] And that is something that's hard to kind of get past. And at that point is when I was like, okay, I think I'm gonna pull back a little bit on engaging with the haters. And I don't do it nearly as much anymore for that reason because they're not worth my time. It just, I would rather focus on the good things. And like, so I created this folder on my phone where every time somebody dm's me something positive or comments like this, your page helps me so much to laugh about this, all this religion and stuff. Or I get a DM that says my mom, you know, is making me go to church and says that I'm wrong for being queer and all this stuff.

Kevin Crowe [01:36:27] Like, I'll screenshot those and I'll put them in a comment, like a folder in my phone that's just called Good comments. And so I just try to remember to like, if I'm ever feeling, if I get a hate message or something, I'm like, man, I'm going to go to the good comments folder and just sort of look through those for a few minutes and remind myself of why I do it. I even have made a few posts in the past that just say why I do this. And it'll be a screenshot, all the names are removed and everything. But it'll be like a screenshot of a DM that I get and I'll like make a carousel post.

Kevin Crowe [01:36:58] And it's like 20 of those. You know, why this is why I do this? Like, and then so if I get the questions of like, why do you do that? Like, why do you spend so much time? I'll just send them a link to that post and it's like, if you really want to know why I do this, it's that. And so I think if you're a content creator, if you're making content in the space or even if you just talk about this stuff online, I think having a good comments folder on your phone is a good idea. I don't, I don't know where I came up with that, but I was like, I have to have something to remind me why I do this.

Todd Phillips [01:37:33] I love it. You know, I, I have not done that. I'm going to do it. I think it's a brilliant idea and it's, it's necessary, it's a necessary counteraction to the constant barrage of negativity that I think both of us are experiencing on a daily basis. And it's, look, listen, we signed up for it, right? And I, and I get that. But still, doesn't, doesn't make it less, you know, emotionally challenging to read through some of the stuff that obviously you and I both have received some pretty, pretty tough stuff to read. So real quick, what would you say to somebody who said, you know, this anti religious kind of content you're creating, you know, it's just another way of allowing religion to dominate your life. What would you say to that?

Using Comedy to Challenge Christian Nationalism

Kevin Crowe [01:38:15] I think I literally got that comment a couple hours ago.

Todd Phillips [01:38:18] Oh, really?

Kevin Crowe [01:38:19] This morning. This morning, somebody said something like that. And I will just say, like, I think it's important to talk about this. Like, you. You're saying that. Oh, even. Especially when my handle was Jesus Unfollower. It would be like, look, he's even part of your handle. Like, he's like, Jesus is on your mind all the time.

Kevin Crowe [01:38:36] But I'll just say, like, it's important that we talk about this stuff. We have people out there weaponizing the Bible. We have people harming others in religion's name. We can't let Christian nationalism, evangelicalism, like the radical Christians, just steamroll us. Like, we have to be voices of opposition. And so they're never going to get it. Some people are just never going to understand it. And I'm okay with that. You have to be okay with that. Like, the people who get it, get it and they'll find you and they'll, like, join forces with you or whatever. And some people are just never going to understand it, and that's okay.

Kevin Crowe [01:39:11] And I still think a lot of it is rooted in defensiveness or fear. You know, like, they imagine being one of them and just like, seeing somebody who you thought was on fire for Jesus leave the religion, that would have to, like, spark something in you that's like, oh, you know, whoa, this person, I thought they were like. And so then instead of being like, I could leave too. They, like, heart get harder. Like, harden their heart, to use a Christian term. And like, they just want to be able to dismiss your story and just discard what you have to say and chalk it up to, oh, you're still obsessed with this thing.

Kevin Crowe [01:39:48] You're anti religion. Instead of getting curious themselves, instead of asking questions themselves and saying, you know, why? You see so many worship leaders, so many pastors have deconstructed, have left the faith. You're telling me these people think that none of those people were ever really Christians? None of them were ever living, like, the right way. They. They left because they. They left because they were never really one of us. Like, First John 2:18 or whatever it is. They went from us because they were never one of us. I get that comment a lot, too. But, yeah, it's just. I think they just want to be able to discard your experience.

Kevin Crowe [01:40:23] They want to be able to discredit everything you say. And they can do that by saying, oh, you're just this hater, or you're just obsessed with it. And when they do that, they can. They feel fine with being like, nothing he says matters at all.

Todd Phillips [01:40:35] Yeah, no, I get it a lot. I was just curious to see what you were going to say about that. I, I, I feel very, feel very much the same. So let's, in, in the minutes that we have left, let's talk about the whole, the, the topic of Christian nationalism and your new project. The thing that's kind of lighting you up right now and it you kind of have a passion for is the, this is a great title, the Frank Truth show, where you're, as I understand it, right? You're exploring just these ridiculous ideas, you know, and challenging some of these concepts through satire. So tell me about the show, and who is Frank?

Kevin Crowe [01:41:11] So Frank Truth is the pastor of Majestic Southern Eagle Church in Northwest Georgia. Fictional character, fictional church. He sees everything. So he's based on just like a lot of people that I've known in my life who, you know, Christianity, like God and country are the most, two most important things to him, and probably not necessarily in that order. It's more like United States first, white American Christians first, then God, you know, then everything else follows that. It's kind of that way of thinking. And so when I do satire like that, it's like I'll look at headlines that are in the news and like, react to them as they would.

Kevin Crowe [01:41:54] And so I'm just trying to, like, hold a mirror up to the radical Christians that we see today by kind of like mocking it, taking it a little too far. And it's especially fun for me when people share it unironically because they think I'm being serious, right? They'll share it. And then, like, I think it's funny because, like, then down the road, if they realize that I'm joking, like, how far has it gone?

Kevin Crowe [01:42:17] A lot of people will warn me and say, like, well, people are going to think that you're serious when you do this. I'm like, good, good, let them. Because then when they share it, then when it gets shared like three times down the road, and then somebody's like, wait, this guy's kidding. Then it can maybe make them like, wait a minute. A lot of times it probably won't because they're so steeped in this belief. But maybe my hope is that it'll start to unravel something a little bit, that they'll be like, you know, oh, that, that was an absurd video.

Kevin Crowe [01:42:46] Maybe I sort of share those beliefs, or a person I know is just like that and this, you know, and so then, like, the half the comments will be people telling me how dumb and stupid I am because they think I'm serious. Half the people will be those who get it, and they're just laughing and stuff. And that's a real passion of mine, is just. I love satire. I love humor, and I love enacting pose law where people don't know if something is real or not.

Todd Phillips [01:43:10] That's.

Kevin Crowe [01:43:11] I could make it more obvious and that, you know, but I don't like to. I like to keep it subtle because I want people to be like, is he being for real? Like, that's the whole point for me. That's what makes it more.

Todd Phillips [01:43:21] You walk that line very well, I think.

Kevin Crowe [01:43:23] Thanks.

Todd Phillips [01:43:23] I really do. I. I mean, it's. It's a hard one to. It's a hard line to walk. What. So what makes comedy. What makes comedy the right response for you rather than rage?

Kevin Crowe [01:43:34] Comedy is the way that I consume the news myself. So I'll watch Last Week, Tonight with John Oliver, I'll watch the Daily show, stuff like that, because you're getting the same information, but you're getting it through humor, which makes it a little easier for me to digest. And so I'm. I'm trying to do that same thing, like, you know, where that. That's more like, more political, probably, like those shows and stuff. But, like, when it comes to religion and stuff, I'm kind of trying to do that same thing of, you know, maybe somebody is. Because this stuff can be super heavy. So a lot of times, if people are, like, consuming the news or getting their updates from something that's heavy and serious, then that can just like, be.

Kevin Crowe [01:44:16] Make their day more heavy, you know, and for me, I'm trying to like, be just like a little glimmer, just make them laugh. They might get some of the same information, but through comedy, which can kind of help them relax their shoulders a little bit. If I can make you relax your shoulders a little bit and do like a sharp nasal exhale when you scroll and see one of my posts and like, oh, that was. That was pretty funny. Then I've done my job well.

Todd Phillips [01:44:39] I found you online. I mean, that's how we connected. And we actually had a friend, a mutual friend that got us connected in real life. But I found you on social media. You were one of the first people I saw. So it was. It's quite cool to be able to hang out with you now and learn more about you. You know, you. If somebody's watching as we close this out, if somebody is watching this and has listened to your story and they're quietly, maybe Just realizing they don't believe anymore or they're a Christian and they've got questions and no one knows. What would you want them to hear from you?

Kevin Crowe [01:45:20] Oh man. I would say just be curious, Ask questions, Ask yourself questions. Ask other people questions. Take some time and, and like research the things that you might not be sure about. Because what's great about this day and age is you can look stuff up, you know, pre Internet, pre Google. People who had these questions had to like, go ask a pastor or try to, you know, find it some obscure way. And now it's like you can just sort of ask questions to people or to search engines or whatever, but, or get involved with a community like the one that you're starting. You know that that kind of stuff is huge.

Kevin Crowe [01:45:55] It's just, I like, I like watching those calling shows. I think for people who are having questions, that's a good, might, maybe a good place to start is just, just, just see other people's stories, watch some other deconversion stories, deconstruction stories. The point is not to end up atheist. The point is not to end up leaving Christianity. That's not the point. Although you would think by the comments that you and I get, that's what we're trying to do is we're trying to like, deconvert people. We're trying to lead people to hell or whatever, make them atheists. That's never been my intention at all.

John Dehlin [01:46:26] Nope.

Kevin Crowe [01:46:27] I just want people to ask questions. And wherever they arrive is wherever they arrive. If they ask themselves these questions and then they end up still being a Christian, that's fine. Or, or a different religion or an atheist or agnostic or whatever. Like the, the main, the main thing is just to, to be curious, to ask questions, to don't get so hung up in all the things that you've been told and stuff. And you know, it's healthy where, wherever you end up after that, if you go into something and you're curious and you just ask questions and you try to figure things out, you end up in a better place than if you never do that.

Todd Phillips [01:47:01] Yeah, I couldn't agree more. So I really appreciate you saying that. So now I know that they can find you in the decon recon community, but where else can they find you? Where, where, where. And we'll have all this in the description, Kevin, so just share it with them. We'll make sure it's in the description so they can find you. Where, where, where is that cool.

Kevin Crowe [01:47:18] The easiest thing is just go to kevincrow comedy.com it's got all my links and everything there. Or @KevinCrow Comedy on all the social platforms. That's the easiest way to find me.

Todd Phillips [01:47:28] That is awesome. Well, thank you so much for spending time with me today and with our audience. I was excited to learn more about your story. You and I have shared a lot of this offline and I just really felt like it was a great story to share with a broader audience. So I hope it was. It's been. I know it will be helpful to a lot of people. I hope it's been worth your time over the last couple hours to spend some time with me and hang out. So thank you so much. I really, really appreciate it. Kevin thanks again. Again, My name is Dr.

Closing Remarks and Series Information

Todd Phillips [01:47:56] Todd Phillips with Exvangelical Stories. This is in partnership with Mormon Stories and it's a miniseries podcast. We'll be posting these weekly, so please join us. If you have any questions, you can click on the links in the description below and contact me directly. Or Mormon Stories. If you'd like to contribute to this particular miniseries, we're considering doing this on a longer basis. We have five scheduled if we'd like to extend that. It's because of the support that you provide, so there'll be a link specifically in the description to support this project and I hope you'll consider doing so. Thanks again for joining us at exvangelical Stories. Have a great one.

Listen · Ep. 2218

A supporter is worth a thousand followers

Your generous donations ensure we can continue to provide support for those transitioning. Help us keep these essential discussions alive and accessible to all by making a donation today.

similar episodes

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *